The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Odyssey Discussion - There will be Spoilers (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=52862)

Mewzard 07-24-2015 10:35 PM

Odyssey Discussion - There will be Spoilers
 
Well, I read the digital copy. While I'm not as well read in TMNT to fully appreciate it as some, I found it a fascinating read. Definitely worth the price of admission.

Will be nice to place the physical copy on my shelf.

Was cool seeing some familiar faces during their Odyssey (including a few I didn't expect).

Rooish 07-25-2015 10:39 AM

I read the digital copy too.

Spoiler:
Er... okay, parts of it were fantastic, and very well written, and offered some closure. But seriously? Mike an evil demigod, more terrible than Null etc... in what way could any version of Mike anywhere ever become like that? He got no closure at all, nor much to do during the story until the end. For a book that was meant to incorporate pretty much the whole comic series's run, you forgot that in the Tales Vol. 1 reprint when Don brings his brothers back or whatever, he does so in what appears to be the reverse order of their deaths. Leo, then Mike, then Raph. Hence why Raph looks so much younger than the others--he died a lot younger. So that doesn't really fit what I feel is the implied canon.

But look, I'm trying to appreciate it for what it was; obviously I'm a Mike fan and I was just like no hell no. I wonder how I would react if it were any of the other Turtles. But Mike has always been portrayed as like the least emotionally disturbed Turtle, and I still can't imagine any of his brothers being an evil murderous insane demigod no matter what.

So, I'm going to just say it was an interesting story but certainly not possibly canonical, and I'm genuinely curious about what inspired you to choose this storyline of one of the Turtles being the shogun, and why it was Mike.

Also, I totally love that you put Venus in, and actually made her cool. Didn't see that ever coming!

mrmaczaps 07-25-2015 01:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rooish (Post 1486859)
I read the digital copy too.

Spoiler:
Er... okay, parts of it were fantastic, and very well written, and offered some closure. But seriously? Mike an evil demigod, more terrible than Null etc... in what way could any version of Mike anywhere ever become like that? He got no closure at all, nor much to do during the story until the end. For a book that was meant to incorporate pretty much the whole comic series's run, you forgot that in the Tales Vol. 1 reprint when Don brings his brothers back or whatever, he does so in what appears to be the reverse order of their deaths. Leo, then Mike, then Raph. Hence why Raph looks so much younger than the others--he died a lot younger. So that doesn't really fit what I feel is the implied canon.

But look, I'm trying to appreciate it for what it was; obviously I'm a Mike fan and I was just like no hell no. I wonder how I would react if it were any of the other Turtles. But Mike has always been portrayed as like the least emotionally disturbed Turtle, and I still can't imagine any of his brothers being an evil murderous insane demigod no matter what.

So, I'm going to just say it was an interesting story but certainly not possibly canonical, and I'm genuinely curious about what inspired you to choose this storyline of one of the Turtles being the shogun, and why it was Mike.

Also, I totally love that you put Venus in, and actually made her cool. Didn't see that ever coming!


I read the HC a month or three ago and I pretty much agree.

Andrew NDB 07-25-2015 03:18 PM

Spoiler:
I knew from the beginning Michelangelo would be a polarizing element in this. :)


Quote:

Originally Posted by Rooish (Post 1486859)
I read the digital copy too.

Spoiler:
Er... okay, parts of it were fantastic, and very well written, and offered some closure. But seriously? Mike an evil demigod, more terrible than Null etc... in what way could any version of Mike anywhere ever become like that? He got no closure at all, nor much to do during the story until the end. For a book that was meant to incorporate pretty much the whole comic series's run, you forgot that in the Tales Vol. 1 reprint when Don brings his brothers back or whatever, he does so in what appears to be the reverse order of their deaths. Leo, then Mike, then Raph. Hence why Raph looks so much younger than the others--he died a lot younger. So that doesn't really fit what I feel is the implied canon.

There's plenty of other stuff with Raph appearing much older in other material (Puma Blues, namely, possibly that Ghost of Christmas Future kind of story) to not make that one minor thing an absolute.

Quote:

Spoiler:
But look, I'm trying to appreciate it for what it was; obviously I'm a Mike fan and I was just like no hell no. I wonder how I would react if it were any of the other Turtles. But Mike has always been portrayed as like the least emotionally disturbed Turtle, and I still can't imagine any of his brothers being an evil murderous insane demigod no matter what.

Spoiler:
In the original "version" of "Odyssey," which was my fanfic written some 15 years ago called "TMNT: Transcension," the Shogun was Leonardo. On the surface it made sense to me... he was the surrogate leader figure, of course he'd be the one to take their dissolution the most personally and make it his duty to correct that. But as the years passed the less I could see that happening. His conditioning, his inner discipline hard-coded into him... he wouldn't like the dissolution of his brothers, but would he actively take the kind of steps the Shogun would have to in order to become the Shogun? Probably not. Not even if tempted.

Michelangelo, to me, is easily the most human of the Turtles. Ergo, the one most susceptible to being "emotionally disturbed" when the bottom fell out and the Turtles separated for good. And between his heartbreaks (Sara, to a lesser extent Klunk -- and he's the only Turtle who's ever taken on a pet, and I think that says something about him -- losing Splinter, then the Regenta... and while we don't know what's going to happen with the babies in Vol. 4 that may or may not be his, it's probably not too much of a reach to gander that one way or another it won't end pleasantly), he's already been there.

But you're right. This isn't enough to explain his becoming an "evil murderous insane demigod," not at all. Heartbroken about his family and being disillusioned with the world only set him on the path... actually wielding the Turnstone -- even if with the best of intentions -- is what drove him mad, exactly the same as it did to Donatello when he wielded the Turnstone in Archie's TMNT Adventures. He became crazed and mad with power.

Rooish 07-25-2015 06:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB
Spoiler:
In the original "version" of "Odyssey," which was my fanfic written some 15 years ago called "TMNT: Transcension," the Shogun was Leonardo. On the surface it made sense to me... he was the surrogate leader figure, of course he'd be the one to take their dissolution the most personally and make it his duty to correct that. But as the years passed the less I could see that happening. His conditioning, his inner discipline hard-coded into him... he wouldn't like the dissolution of his brothers, but would he actively take the kind of steps the Shogun would have to in order to become the Shogun? Probably not. Not even if tempted.

Michelangelo, to me, is easily the most human of the Turtles. Ergo, the one most susceptible to being "emotionally disturbed" when the bottom fell out and the Turtles separated for good. And between his heartbreaks (Sara, to a lesser extent Klunk -- and he's the only Turtle who's ever taken on a pet, and I think that says something about him -- losing Splinter, then the Regenta... and while we don't know what's going to happen with the babies in Vol. 4 that may or may not be his, it's probably not too much of a reach to gander that one way or another it won't end pleasantly), he's already been there.

But you're right. This isn't enough to explain his becoming an "evil murderous insane demigod," not at all. Heartbroken about his family and being disillusioned with the world only set him on the path... actually wielding the Turnstone -- even if with the best of intentions -- is what drove him mad, exactly the same as it did to Donatello when he wielded the Turnstone in Archie's TMNT Adventures. He became crazed and mad with power.

Spoiler:
I was mad and upset about Mike at first, but also I never read the turnstone storyline of Archie so I didn't realize that was the major factor in his madness. It helps to think that the Mikey we saw through most of "Odyssey" was still kind of the Mikey we knew, and not totally deviously misleading his brothers, as he had not encountered the turnstone yet. Am I correct in this?

Anyway, I was mad and upset, and then I thought about it for a while, and I decided to have faith in the fact that you are a very long time fan who knows the characters well, so I tried to imagine how you saw it getting to that point.

Yes Mikey has had many losses... Sara, Klunk, the Regenta, his possible children, Splinter, April and Casey must have died of whatever by 2058, whatever happened between Don and Shadow. And then Raph and Shadow. And Mikey is overall very softhearted, without strong resolve. I always imagined Mike's future being one of depression in a way, but I figured he would find a way to be peaceful and nurturing, if broken hearted.

And then I remembered him in Volume 4, coldly watching the Styracadons get massacred by the Triceratons, and joining in. I thought it was out of character, and chose to kind of ignore it like I ignored April being a drawing. I figured that Raph, Leo or Don might get involved in the war in a similar way, if they were there.

But maybe not--maybe it wasn't just Peter Laird writing Mikey out of character or being on a soapbox about something; maybe it was the beginning of Mike's derailment into being a much darker character. (Or I guess, not the beginning. He was kind of dark when Klunk died, too.)

I still viewed it as him, being not much of an enterprising type, being pulled into another war like he's been pulled into most everything with his brothers throughout his whole life. I couldn't imagine him going off with this mad scheme just because his brothers separated. But I can sort of see it and enjoy it even if I choose not to view it as my "canon" story.

But still. You made me sad Andrew! ;) Odyssey had Mikey die, in rather gruesome ways, three times! And his final death was pretty massively dishonourable.

One more thing. What made you decide to barely mention April and Casey in "Odyssey"?

Andrew NDB 07-25-2015 06:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rooish (Post 1486951)
Spoiler:
I was mad and upset about Mike at first, but also I never read the turnstone storyline of Archie so I didn't realize that was the major factor in his madness. It helps to think that the Mikey we saw through most of "Odyssey" was still kind of the Mikey we knew, and not totally deviously misleading his brothers, as he had not encountered the turnstone yet. Am I correct in this?



Spoiler:
Oh yes. The Mikey that is on the Odyssey with the other Turtles isn't being duplicitous or up to any kind of malicious subterfuge with his brothers. He's the Mikey we've always known, just older and a little more jaded. If anything, he was just embarrassed about his state of mind when the Turtles "rescued" him (but some of that slips out during the campfire bit anyway). He doesn't have any plans to become the Shogun and he didn't even know about the Turnstone yet, and it's inferred there are a number of journeys Mikey went on after faking his death on the Transmat that ultimately led him to consider Savanti and what Savanti was suggesting. We just get an abridged version in the story.

Just like Donatello picking up the Turnstone in the Archies and suddenly becoming mad, as soon as Mikey picked up the Turnstone it filtered and warped all of his good intentions in his mind into something far more nefarious and grandiose. He was still accomplishing the goal he set out to do, but he would have never even considered for a moment the kinds of things he did when he was actually wielding the Turnstone had he not been wielding it.

There's a throwaway line in the Shogun battle that suggests the madness may be due to the Turnstone, but without the actual Archie TMNT standing there present to give their on-the-spot accounting of things when their Don wielded it, there was no really good way to convey that to the reader. Beyond Mikey's over the top behavior.


Quote:

Spoiler:
And then I remembered him in Volume 4, coldly watching the Styracadons get massacred by the Triceratons, and joining in.

That's a good point too.

Quote:

Spoiler:
But maybe not--maybe it wasn't just Peter Laird writing Mikey out of character or being on a soapbox about something; maybe it was the beginning of Mike's derailment into being a much darker character. (Or I guess, not the beginning. He was kind of dark when Klunk died, too.)



Spoiler:
That's pretty much how I see it. Though I don't see that as the very beginning.


Quote:

Spoiler:
One more thing. What made you decide to barely mention April and Casey in "Odyssey"?

Spoiler:
It really came down to me not really wanting to speculate too much on what their final fates were. Where Peter left them in Vol. 4 are fairly unique places, so I'd rather that be left to either the imagination or future issues of Vol. 4. There will be plenty of April and Shadow in "Origin," though.

***First of Two Latin Kings*** 07-27-2015 03:35 PM

Do those of us who ordered physical copies have free access to the digital copy?

Lordmylar06 07-27-2015 04:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ***Doo Doo Acureds*** (Post 1487461)
Do those of us who ordered physical copies have free access to the digital copy?

I would check your spam folder of your email account if you were an indiegogo contributor. The only reason I saw the digital copy was because someone in the email chain replied to all and it went to my inbox instead of my spam folder.

mrmaczaps 07-27-2015 09:15 PM

I PayPal backed it and I got an email yesterday I believe.

Thank you.

CyberCubed 07-31-2015 11:39 PM

I have a few questions about "power levels" so to speak. Especially where Null and Savanti were concerned. For example:

Spoiler:
In the first encounter with Savanti and the Old Turtles, he pretty much mops the floor with them. They constantly get zapped and tossed to the side like they're nothing. Yet later on during the final battle, the Turtles take down Savanti incredibly easily almost like he was no threat before. We see him whimpering that, "This is not how it should be" and then gets sliced in half, etc.

Then there's Null, who from what I remember in Archie, was practically untouchable and nobody could land a hit on him. Yet here he was taken by surprise by one rock throw on his head, and then the Mutanimals tear threw him like he was nothing. I would have expected Null to put up a better fight, but he went down a little too easy for my tastes.

I dunno, its a minor gripe, but I think another page or two showing the fights not be so one-sided at the end would have helped especially since Savanti and Null were shown to be so powerful before. Anyhow, I definitely had a smile and "Hell YEAH!" moment when the Mutanimals got their revenge on Null. That was nearly 20 years in the making.

Andrew NDB 08-04-2015 05:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1489237)
I have a few questions about "power levels" so to speak. Especially where Null and Savanti were concerned. For example:

Spoiler:
In the first encounter with Savanti and the Old Turtles, he pretty much mops the floor with them. They constantly get zapped and tossed to the side like they're nothing. Yet later on during the final battle, the Turtles take down Savanti incredibly easily almost like he was no threat before. We see him whimpering that, "This is not how it should be" and then gets sliced in half, etc.

Then there's Null, who from what I remember in Archie, was practically untouchable and nobody could land a hit on him. Yet here he was taken by surprise by one rock throw on his head, and then the Mutanimals tear threw him like he was nothing. I would have expected Null to put up a better fight, but he went down a little too easy for my tastes.

Spoiler:
These were somewhat supernaturally-empowered Mutanimals. Venus wasn't sending them to the wolves.


Quote:

Spoiler:
I dunno, its a minor gripe, but I think another page or two showing the fights not be so one-sided at the end would have helped

Spoiler:
Under different (normal?) circumstances, I'd have given it a whole issue's worth of pages.

Flesh is food 08-14-2015 08:13 PM

I finished reading this about a week ago but I wanted to give the material some time to sink in. The story is pretty solid imo I really enjoyed reading the geriatric turtles on one last romp. It's cool to see them all as there most matured selves and there are just so many great moments in this book. My favorite of them all is Leonardo's dig and remakes/reimaginations (both in general and specifically to the tmnt) when he says to the shogun "was splinter not already father enough to us". Brilliant. What's this about "origin". Are you working on another project? If so I'm in

ctt4lfecw 10-03-2015 12:35 PM

I read my pdf version. I'll say this. I give it 4/5 stars.

Spoiler:
Let me just say that Andrew has a very creative mind and he took great care in putting together this comic for us to read. That is incredible ambition and dedication. The art was 5* even after I printed it out to read. Can't wait to see what it looks like when I get the actual hard copy book. Odyssey was just that, an Odyssey of the TMNT and its fans. There were so many parts that I enjoyed. But something that disappointed me was the decision to make Mikey the Shogun, sorry but I wasn't feeling that. It was very emotional stuff and in that regard it worked, I was genuinely disappointed that Mikey was the Turtle that sold the world, so to speak. The execution was good and it was a very creative way to make Mikey the Shogun but I just can't get on board with it. I know Mikey wanted to do whatever it took to keep the brothers together, and he felt like Leo failed and he could do better, but I can't see Mikey selling out like that. I also didn't like the shots taken at IDW TMNT. I really love IDW, so I didn't like that. But we are entitled to our opinions on what works for us and what doesn't. I remember the Image conclusion books endings, and when Raph killed Mikey I got flashbacks to that for some reason. But the writing and attention to detail in everything was great. Hats off to everyone involved. I'll definitely have to read it again. I enjoyed it very much. It is definitely a must-read for any fan of Mirage-era TMNT comics.


Rooish 11-01-2015 11:03 AM

I agree with you ctt4lfecw. I saw where he was coming from but the more time I give it, the more it feels like fan fiction (which it was). Mikey would never do what he did. I don't think any of the Turtles would.

Andrew NDB 11-18-2015 02:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ctt4lfecw (Post 1506711)
I read my pdf version. I'll say this. I give it 4/5 stars.

Spoiler:
I also didn't like the shots taken at IDW TMNT. I really love IDW, so I didn't like that.

Spoiler:
Definitely nothing in "Odyssey" is a dig at IDW TMNT. I just thought it'd be a fun thing that, in Michelangelo's delusions of creativity in making a "perfect TMNT world," he actually ends up making the IDW universe (which many consider to be sort of a hodgepodge "ultimate" TMNT universe anyway). And of course the other Turtles would react with prejudice to him making IDW Splinter their literal father as some means of better perfection in their family.

If anything, I think "Odyssey" serves to pass the baton from the Mirage TMNT to the IDW TMNT in a very real way.

Nortock Diab 11-25-2015 02:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1520265)
Spoiler:
Definitely nothing in "Odyssey" is a dig at IDW TMNT. I just thought it'd be a fun thing that, in Michelangelo's delusions of creativity in making a "perfect TMNT world," he actually ends up making the IDW universe (which many consider to be sort of a hodgepodge "ultimate" TMNT universe anyway). And of course the other Turtles would react with prejudice to him making IDW Splinter their literal father as some means of better perfection in their family.

If anything, I think "Odyssey" serves to pass the baton from the Mirage TMNT to the IDW TMNT in a very real way.

Spoiler:
That's exactly how I perceived it, it even got me into considering more widely the TMNT universe. First step was reading the first hardcover collection of IDW and starting watching the 2K3 cartoon.
I am looking forward to reading Odyssey again as soon as the softcover gets delivered to my place !

By the way Andrew, manu thanks for this book.
It perfectly fits next to my "official" TMNT books.

Danetello 12-08-2015 07:52 PM

I am late to the table with this one. Can someone please tell me how I can read this in any format? Digital or otherwise. I DID google but nothing came up, at least that I saw anyway.

***First of Two Latin Kings*** 12-09-2015 01:10 AM

How soon will the $37 copies start shipping?

Duke Nukem 12-09-2015 05:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Danetello (Post 1525815)
I am late to the table with this one. Can someone please tell me how I can read this in any format? Digital or otherwise. I DID google but nothing came up, at least that I saw anyway.

www.ebay.com/itm/291433363340

Peter Palmer 03-08-2016 12:41 PM

I just re-read this and figured I'd join in.

Spoiler:
Lawson's art was very well done. I enjoyed every page of his stuff. :tsmile:

Kudos for making a time-travel story that flows somewhat coherently...a tough feat sometimes. 1 particular question about the time travel, though. When the TMNT first encounter Savanti Romero (in 1970, I believe) outside the pet shop, the pet shop (and by extension, the prime turtles) gets destroyed, does it not? I think Juliet even says something about them being on "borrowed time" now. If the turtles hadn't time jumped, would they have been erased from existence? I figure that would have been an immediate effect, but perhaps they were all existing "outside of time" by that point. Even so, they wouldn't have gotten to exist outside of time if they never got mutated. This seemed like the only major paradox I noticed.

My TMNT knowledge doesn't extend to TMNT Adventures, so I'll have to take your word that it's ok. For me, the turnstone, Cuddly Cowlick, and Slash were all pretty new to me. I didn't mind most of it, but Slash was pretty distracting for me. He really did nothing for me and didn't add much to the plot...seemed like simple fan service that could have been absent and I wouldn't have noticed. Again, I'm not familiar with the source material, so maybe others loved him. To me, he diluted a bit the final adventure of the original turtles that I actually cared about. I may be alone in this.

I thought the turtles were characterized very well, though I found Raph's swearing pretty excessive. I know these guys aren't saints, but Raph swore so much that he just sounded like a third grader who just learned about bad words and wants to sound tough. It just got to be too much and by about the third "S#!*", I just started shaking my head each time. I did like that Mikey wore his shoulder strap that he sported on the cover of TMNT #1. I also thought Don was the right choice to give the Time powers to. And big props for not using Shredder as one of the "enemies of the past" that was brought back to battle the turtles. It seems that only the die-hard fans recognize that he wasn't a huge antagonist for most of their lives (ok, Bloodsucker wasn't either, but that whole experience could have done some damage to Raph's emotional well-being, so I understand his inclusion).

We see each of the turtles on their last day. From earlier comics, we knew a few details about Leo and Don's last day. We know that Mikey's fate is yet unknown. I know Raph loses an eye and does spend time in swamps in his later years. Has it ever been written that he does, in fact, die in a swamp? Genuine question...really don't know.

Was it ever stated that TMNT: TNM took place in the same universe as the live action films of the 90's? I've only caught a few episodes of TNM and I wasn't sure. I know the 2007 film is meant to be set in the same universe, but, Venus' mention of the scepter and how it sent the guys back to Feudal Japan made me wonder. If it is set, was there any explanation as to how the Shredder came back in the series, if only briefly?

In all, I'd say this is a really well-done fan fiction with high production value and you can tell that the writer is VERY familiar with TMNT lore.



Andrew NDB 03-09-2016 02:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Peter Palmer (Post 1556760)
Spoiler:
1 particular question about the time travel, though. When the TMNT first encounter Savanti Romero (in 1970, I believe) outside the pet shop, the pet shop (and by extension, the prime turtles) gets destroyed, does it not? I think Juliet even says something about them being on "borrowed time" now. If the turtles hadn't time jumped, would they have been erased from existence? I figure that would have been an immediate effect, but perhaps they were all existing "outside of time" by that point. Even so, they wouldn't have gotten to exist outside of time if they never got mutated. This seemed like the only major paradox I noticed.

Spoiler:
It's left a bit ambiguous but the general understanding I tried to convey at that point in the story is that as soon as that happened (the explosion), they could vanish at any moment (so they better make every moment count!). And there certainly wouldn't be any going back. Barring, like, if Donatello suddenly gained full control over the time traveling and took them back an hour into the past and stopped the Savantis. But man, that'd be pretty muddy... the versions of themselves from an hour ago there, plus the new ones.

Of course, when you've finished the story, it should be read into things that in the same manner that the Shogun redeposited his younger self, mind-wiped so as to leave the circle unbroken, as soon as the Savantis left and the Turtles departed in Cudley, the Shogun arrived and "cleaned up the scene," so to speak. Because if all of the baby Turtles were scorched... the Shogun would be in the same boat as all of them.


Quote:

Spoiler:

Was it ever stated that TMNT: TNM took place in the same universe as the live action films of the 90's? I've only caught a few episodes of TNM and I wasn't sure. I know the 2007 film is meant to be set in the same universe, but, Venus' mention of the scepter and how it sent the guys back to Feudal Japan made me wonder. If it is set, was there any explanation as to how the Shredder came back in the series, if only briefly?

There's plenty of references in interviews with Eastman and the Chiodo Brothers way back in the day making mention of, "Oh, these are the movie Turtles (in TNM) but they're older now, and grittier" (lies). And it's clearly intended to be the same subway lair from TMNT II and III, and Splinter is missing an ear (which only ever happened in one universe).

TMNT 4 is more ambiguous. There's plenty of interviews with the director openly saying it's a continuation of TMNT I and II, but then hey look, it's Walker's hat from TMNT III. And Triceraton crap even though they've never met them. It's best to look at TNM and TMNT 4 as a "Choose Your Own Sequel" to TMNT 3. You can have one, but not both. For the purposes of "Odyssey" I elected to have TMNT 4 sort of be its own universe, as it certainly feels like anyway.

No, TNM never explains how Shredder survived TMNT II. Though I don't know many people who ever bought that the heavily armored Shredder -- much less in his SuperShredder state -- would have died from a few pieces of wood falling on him.

TMNachoT 04-11-2016 09:10 PM

First i want to congrat all the people involved in the creation of this comics, and while I need to read the comics again, i have a question, did Mirage turtles need to die to have a new universe (idw) created? If so, why old toons turtles and 2K3 turtles co exist at the same time? Again, i need to read the comics again in case i didn't get things right. Cheers.

Andrew NDB 04-11-2016 09:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TMNachoT (Post 1568131)
First i want to congrat all the people involved in the creation of this comics, and while I need to read the comics again, i have a question, did Mirage turtles need to die to have a new universe (idw) created?

They didn't need to. But one of them is still around, as you can see in the coda.

Quote:

If so, why old toons turtles and 2K3 turtles co exist at the same time? Again, i need to read the comics again in case i didn't get things right. Cheers.
Spoiler:
The basic conclusion of Odyssey, all pre-2009 universes were wiped out, even Mirage. The Shogun created a new "perfect" one (IDW), which Leonardo may or may not have embellished, and two others rose up with it (Nick cartoon and new movieverse). Though if you look at the page where the 3 Earths are being created and splintering... there are others in the background. Could they be the last of the old ones vanishing forever? Could they be some of the old ones reforming? Could they be new ones we haven't seen yet? To answer definitively would seem to be shooting myself in the foot.

Chabrendeki 04-14-2016 09:25 AM

I just wanted to congratulate for all those who were involved in the birth of this wonderful comic!

Everything is there: meaningful philosophical and aesthetical thoughts, heartwarming scenes, action, humor and a lot of easter eggs/insider jokes...

There was a point I had to stop reading for minutes because of laughing:
"More playmates! Whoo-Hoo!"
:lol:

Toad64 04-15-2016 09:04 PM

Hey, just wanted to say that I finally got around to reading my copy of Odyssey and really enjoyed a lot of it.

Spoiler:
Not too sure how I felt about Mikey being the Shogun, but I can see his frustration at his family drifting apart. And really, ever since Splinter died or shortly before, this TMNT continuity had seemed a bit sadder and darker. I must say my favorite parts of the comic were the quieter moments when the turtles were enjoying seeing each other one last time. Seeing Cowlick was great, and I've got to say I was really surprised to see Bloodsucker show up for a moment! I really loved the "The River" 3-parter as a kid, for some reason it was always one of my favorite stories, but I've never really heard anyone else talking about it.

Anyway, just wanted to say thanks for making this, I'm really happy that I funded it so long ago!

Turtles 04-17-2016 05:30 AM

I waited for the paper version before reading this. It's been a long wait and I wanted to savor it properly - sitting in the sofa, wine glass in hand, enjoying every little detail. And it was well worth the wait. I am very impressed with this book, with what Andrew Modeen has achieved here. And thank you Rich for sending it to me. I own a piece of original artwork now - page 100, it's hanging on the wall where we will look at it every day. Most of all I want to THANK YOU for getting us new Jim Lawson TMNT comic book pages. And I went here to say a few words about the story, but then I read the TMNT Entity review first, and what was written there covers my feelings about the book so well. I will quote a bit, though:

"So you can see how being “fan fiction” actually played to this comic’s strengths as a final tale that acknowledges EVERYTHING that came before it, even the stuff not owned by Mirage/Viacom.

"(..) I think it is the most ambitious fan project in TMNT history and a very impressive achievement on Andrew’s part. I am proud to own a copy and have it on my shelf right alongside all my Mirage trade paperbacks and hopefully everyone else who received a copy will treat theirs as reverently.

"So congrats to Andrew on his hard work and thanks to all the creators, both pro and fan, who pooled their talents to make Odyssey happen. I think no matter who you are, if you like Mirage Ninja Turtles, there’ll be SOMETHING in this comic that will appeal to you."

...
Well said! Congratulations and thank you!

Andrew NDB 04-20-2016 01:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chabrendeki (Post 1569005)
I just wanted to congratulate for all those who were involved in the birth of this wonderful comic!

Everything is there: meaningful philosophical and aesthetical thoughts, heartwarming scenes, action, humor and a lot of easter eggs/insider jokes...

There was a point I had to stop reading for minutes because of laughing:
"More playmates! Whoo-Hoo!"
:lol:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Panda_Kahn_fan (Post 1569292)
Ok, finally read this thing, and... I have to admit, Odyssey is one of the best TMNT fan works I've ever had the pleasure of reading. Good writing, strong art, and a 'Crisis on infinite earths'-style story for the TMNT multiverse. We got satisfying endings for characters we cared about for the different universes, and nearly all the loose ends for previous TMNT universes were all tied up.

This was a good send-off for the original turtles, befitting the depressing and melancholy mood of their universe. As the original versions of the TMNT, they deserved this kind of grand finale, and it was probably more spectacular than anything they would've gotten officially. The fact my favorite TMNT universe was born out of the ashes of the old was a highlight for me. And I appreciated every TMNT incarnation was treated with respect here, even the worst among them.

I can appreciate the hard work and dedication that went into this book, so my compliments to all of those involved, good job.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Toad64 (Post 1569496)
Hey, just wanted to say that I finally got around to reading my copy of Odyssey and really enjoyed a lot of it.

Spoiler:
Not too sure how I felt about Mikey being the Shogun, but I can see his frustration at his family drifting apart. And really, ever since Splinter died or shortly before, this TMNT continuity had seemed a bit sadder and darker. I must say my favorite parts of the comic were the quieter moments when the turtles were enjoying seeing each other one last time. Seeing Cowlick was great, and I've got to say I was really surprised to see Bloodsucker show up for a moment! I really loved the "The River" 3-parter as a kid, for some reason it was always one of my favorite stories, but I've never really heard anyone else talking about it.

Anyway, just wanted to say thanks for making this, I'm really happy that I funded it so long ago!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Turtles (Post 1569879)
I waited for the paper version before reading this. It's been a long wait and I wanted to savor it properly - sitting in the sofa, wine glass in hand, enjoying every little detail. And it was well worth the wait. I am very impressed with this book, with what Andrew Modeen has achieved here. And thank you Rich for sending it to me. I own a piece of original artwork now - page 100, it's hanging on the wall where we will look at it every day.

Quote:

And I went here to say a few words about the story, but then I read the TMNT Entity review first, and what was written there covers my feelings about the book so well. I will quote a bit, though:

"So you can see how being “fan fiction” actually played to this comic’s strengths as a final tale that acknowledges EVERYTHING that came before it, even the stuff not owned by Mirage/Viacom.

"(..) I think it is the most ambitious fan project in TMNT history and a very impressive achievement on Andrew’s part. I am proud to own a copy and have it on my shelf right alongside all my Mirage trade paperbacks and hopefully everyone else who received a copy will treat theirs as reverently.

"So congrats to Andrew on his hard work and thanks to all the creators, both pro and fan, who pooled their talents to make Odyssey happen. I think no matter who you are, if you like Mirage Ninja Turtles, there’ll be SOMETHING in this comic that will appeal to you."

...
Well said! Congratulations and thank you!
Thank you, I'm glad you folks enjoyed it.

Quote:

Most of all I want to THANK YOU for getting us new Jim Lawson TMNT comic book pages.
Well, there's going to be a lot more to come. And "Origin" will be in full color (minus the B&W duotoned Obligado wrapup).

Andrew NDB 04-20-2016 01:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Panda_Kahn_fan (Post 1571021)
I'll be sticking to the IDW-verse

Of course you will.

bjaxx87 04-27-2016 08:13 AM

After reading every single story listed in TMNT Entity's Mirage timeline in chronological order (which was an exciting odyssey in itself) I finally rewarded myself and read Odyssey! Wow, this was a fun trip, lots of beautiful art, references and a great feeling of conclusion. The bittersweet ending somewhat sparked my interest to give a second chance to the IDW series (I already have both HC collections at the ready to get me (re-)started).

Spoiler:
I just wish spoiler tags would've been used as carefully in the main thread because I got spoiled about the Shogun's identity before I even started reading... ;)

I don't have much to complain. Mikey going nuts after all he's been through didn't seem too unnatural to me. We got glimpses of his dark side before when he was fighting alongside the triceratons and it seems a lot of heavy stuff happened after volume 4. The turnstone didn't help as well... I just wonder, what was that high price Mikey paid to gain Nulls help? What could he offer him? I know you won't reveal a definitive answer but I just can't imagine what it might have been.

Talking about Null... you still won't reveal what Murphy told you about him, right? I guess his phrase "You still don't know who I am" towards Slash was a little hint, though.

While I think I got all the Mirage and Image references, I didn't read the Archie series and Palladium books, so the future of earth (Earth Watch, males turning into monsters at the age of 19, Evermind, ...) often confused me. But it was still fun to turn the page and wonder what crazy stuff happens next.

I have to say that I really liked the campfire scene, except for that bit when his brothers were mocking Leo for his relationship with Radical. It felt pretty insensitive after Leo obviously had serious feelings for her and was more than devastated after losing her. He spent the rest of his life getting over that loss and swore never to kill again (except for the single moment he snapped and got his revenge on Carnage), so I don't know if his brothers would truly say "Haha, remember when we found out about you and Radical? Hilarious!". Didn't Leo admit his feelings for her towards Raph in V3 #25?

And by the way, what happened to Leo's vow? He didn't seem to have trouble killing in Odyssey and was much less even-tempered than in Swan Song.

However, Odyssey was a great read and I'm looking forward to your future projects! Thank you and everyone else involved for putting this together!

Andrew NDB 04-29-2016 03:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bjaxx87 (Post 1573081)
Spoiler:
I just wonder, what was that high price Mikey paid to gain Nulls help? What could he offer him? I know you won't reveal a definitive answer but I just can't imagine what it might have been.

I think the obvious conclusion someone could jump to would be "his soul," but I'd prefer to leave it ambiguous and let readers draw their own.

It wasn't "his soul" to me. Maybe it was a favor. Maybe there is a whole adventure worth telling behind the scenes with Michelangelo becoming the Shogun and what the favor was.

Quote:

Spoiler:
Talking about Null... you still won't reveal what Murphy told you about him, right? I guess his phrase "You still don't know who I am" towards Slash was a little hint, though.

It's someone from real life.

Quote:

Spoiler:
I have to say that I really liked the campfire scene, except for that bit when his brothers were mocking Leo for his relationship with Radical. It felt pretty insensitive after Leo obviously had serious feelings for her and was more than devastated after losing her. He spent the rest of his life getting over that loss and swore never to kill again (except for the single moment he snapped and got his revenge on Carnage), so I don't know if his brothers would truly say "Haha, remember when we found out about you and Radical? Hilarious!". Didn't Leo admit his feelings for her towards Raph in V3 #25?

It wasn't like a civil, social gathering. They were sitting around a campfire guzzling moonshine, not a thing known for making people very sensitive to one another.

Quote:

Spoiler:
And by the way, what happened to Leo's vow?

Kind of went out the window with the "all of creation being wiped out" thing going on. Might have warranted a nod in dialogue but I didn't feel like it did at the time.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:15 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.