The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   What do you think about different skin-colored TMNT? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=52866)

Andrew NDB 07-26-2015 03:31 PM

What do you think about different skin-colored TMNT?
 
Let's forget the bandanna color debate, that's a separate matter. But when I think about it, I think the different skin-colored TMNT that seems to be being pushed as the norm is even more ridiculous and insulting to one's intelligence than that whole matter.

Red-earred sliders don't have different skin colors. And even if there were, if these guys are supposed to be brothers, from the same Mama Turtle...? I think in IDW they're supposed to be sea turtles but even with those I'm pretty sure there's no disparity within a single batch of eggs.

It's like literally, even factoring out the always-asinine letters on the belts thing (and nothing is more insulting than having the letters on the belts AND different skin colors), TPTB are telling you, "We don't trust you to be able to recognize which Turtle is which because of the weapons they're carrying, or their body types, or even their individualized rainbow bandanna colors... we need to give them different skin colors so you can really, really tell them apart."

neatoman 07-26-2015 03:59 PM

Uh-huh, why do have such a problem with trying to make them seem less like clones of each other? Can't you accept that most people get confused by four visually identical characters? There's a reason Ben Reilly dyed his hair and Evil Spock had a beard.

As for the skin colors, they're mutants. Who cares if red-earred sliders don't have different skin colors in real-life, they don't really resemble that species after the mutation. They're not always red-earred sliders either, in the IDW series they're sea turtles and in the 4Kids cartoon it appears they were tortoises.

PangolinFeets 07-26-2015 04:01 PM

Or to give them more personality? I like the newer designs where they're pretty different-looking. I don't think it's hand-holding.

Duke Nukem 07-26-2015 04:31 PM

I doubt it was designed to make it easier to tell them apart in comics and film as much as making the toys look as different as possible so that people were more likely to buy all four of them.

Edit: Also:



At around 1:20 "Hey man take yo light green ass to the next room!"

Powder 07-26-2015 04:31 PM

I've always been a fan of it. I like the red-masked Playmates-skinned look. Best of both worlds IMO.

Leo656 07-26-2015 04:33 PM

It kinda is a little bit hand-holding. Like Andrew said, it is kind of pandering. There's logically no reason at all they'd be different colors. Whether people like it or not isn't the issue. The point he's making is that realistically, it makes no sense at all, especially IF they're supposed to all be related.

It kinda doesn't bother me, but it's definitely a little odd. Anything, ever, where it's like, "So, why'd they do that?" "Eh, no reason. Just Looks Cool." I kinda hate that. I get annoyed by anything that can't justify itself. "Why's Batman have a thousand piped seams all over his costume now, even in places there wouldn't logically be seams?" "Eh, just looks cool." "Why'd that one wrestler do like 6 flips when he jumped off the top rope onto the other guy, why didn't he just drop an elbow on his sternum?" "Eh, just looks cool." I hate that sh*t. Not always, like, violently, but it's like, at least have a reason for things beyond "Why not?"

In this case I kind of don't care and I can live with it, but it's not how I personally would have done it. I always picture them the same color by default as there's no reason at all that they wouldn't be.

spookycookies 07-26-2015 04:34 PM

The skin tones don't bother me, I mean they are mutants so I don't expect them to be 100% similar to any species of turtle. The initials on the their belt buckles was like a kiddy super hero thing that I don't expect to see outside of the original cartoon. I do like seeing them with individual gear but I wasn't a fan of the costumes they all had in the 2014 movie, it was too busy for me.

Andrew NDB 07-26-2015 05:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PangolinFeets (Post 1487153)
Or to give them more personality?

The color of one's skin denotes personality? That sounds pretty racist.

Leo656 07-26-2015 05:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1487186)
The color of one's skin denotes personality? That sounds pretty racist.


I had to. :lol: The chance was NEVER going to come again in this lifetime.

PangolinFeets 07-26-2015 05:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1487186)
The color of one's skin denotes personality? That sounds pretty racist.

:trolleye: We're talking about cartoon mutant turtles written by not-the-best writers*. It's not a new concept.



*To clarify, I thought this was the 2k3 cartoon thread. I do not think the comics are poorly written. Sorry Paul&IDW stafflurkers. :p

neatoman 07-26-2015 05:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1487194)

I had to. :lol: The chance was NEVER going to come again in this lifetime.

You know, Hulk Hogan has pretty dark skin himself...

Leo656 07-26-2015 05:39 PM

I think that's why George Foreman's still his friend and forgave him. :tgrin:

PangolinFeets 07-26-2015 06:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1487210)
I think that's why George Foreman's still his friend and forgave him. :tgrin:

Now that's racist. :-X

(I had to look that up, actually. HH dropped a racial slur in a podcast and now WWE cut their ties with him? I'm surprised I didn't hear more about it.)


Getting back on topic, the turtles don't really look much like any specific turtle species to begin with so that argument against color variations doesn't really hold water. I've heard some version are based on based on RES, but have none of their features, aside from the physical turtle-y ones (Not to mention that I'm pretty sure there is some color variation among RES). I still think the best canon rational is that the mutagen has all sorts of weird properties that would mess with how they look.

Redeemer 07-26-2015 06:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1487194)

I had to. :lol: The chance was NEVER going to come again in this lifetime.

lol so awesome !!!!!!! :lol:

Leo656 07-26-2015 06:05 PM

I usually excel at extremely dated jokes and references, so I figured I'd be topical for a change. :lol:

Candy Kappa 07-26-2015 06:45 PM

I like that the Turtles have different skin color, cause y'know what. Turtles do have different skin color, it may not be as apparent for someone who's not used to seeing turtles often, but they do. Markings, color, size, shape, it's all unique.

One of my favorite designs have different skin color and body build on the Turtles, and that's the OotS version off the Turtles, not only that, but they also have more proper turtle markings which I'm a huge fan off. As they are supposed to be Red-Eared Sliders, which are not a very "mundane" colored turtle, they can be quite colorful in their youth.

And the vintage Playmates skin color paired up with the red masks is a very solid look too. I'm a sucker for Don's dark olive, almost brown skin color.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 07-26-2015 07:01 PM

Personally, I don't like how each turtle has a drastically different skin tone than the other three. Or even when Mikey and Raph are darker green, and Leo and Don are lighter green.

I've always assumed four baby turtles from the same mother turtle, and these guys are TURTLES, not kittens. They should look pretty much the same.

And as a little kid, I was always confused by how Don was brown not green. I'd never seen any brown-skinned turtles. At least the other three were shades of green...

Jester 07-26-2015 07:03 PM

The thing I always wonder is do we really know that the Turtles were from the same clutch of eggs? I mean they're pet shop turtles. Born and breed on a turtle farm. Can we say with certainty they all came from the same mama slider?

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 07-26-2015 07:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jester (Post 1487231)
The thing I always wonder is do we really know that the Turtles were from the same clutch of eggs? I mean they're pet shop turtles. Born and breed on a turtle farm. Can we say with certainty they all came from the same mama slider?

Not really, because we do only first see them in a pet shop glass bowl.

But again, they are all the same breed of turtle. And turtles don't have the genetic diversity or cosmetic diversity or whatever the hell gives you a litter of kittens all black and white, calico, orange tabby, everything under the sun all from one mama.

qt.bangerang 07-26-2015 08:45 PM

It doesn't bother me. I have a different skin tone then my 3 siblings and the 4 of us come from the same 2 parents...so why can't 4 mutant turtles whose father is a mutant rat have different skin tones?

Metalhead 2.0 07-26-2015 09:25 PM

I haven't read all the other responses, but I don't remember reading anything in IDW to suggest that the 4 baby turtles all came from the same mother turtle. But I think the important thing to remember is that the mutagen is laced with human DNA, so between the injections being administered in the lab and the vial broken by the Foot they certainly could have come into contact with DNA of humans with varying skin tones leading to the differences in their own.

Rooish 07-26-2015 09:39 PM

It always seemed weird to me, but maybe it was an attempt to give parents even more justification for buying four nearly identical toys?

Or to teach kids about respecting everyone regardless of race? Although they made the dorky one the black guy.

I never liked it much. It's best in the 2003 series, I feel.

And if the Turtles really are red eared sliders (I feel like only Murphy said that), they should have greyish green and yellow stripes anyway.

Cipher 07-26-2015 10:23 PM

I have absolutely no problem with this, since they already fall pretty far from featuring the distinct features of any real-world turtles, which don't look identical to one another even if overall skin color isn't what separates them.

Personally, I've always thought this would be a fine compromise for keeping the red masks in a full-color comic, if another visual distinction must be had. Really doesn't bother me at all.

Mutant Ninja Anole 07-27-2015 08:57 AM

One of the biggest problems the turtles have had since day one is differentiating between each other. It's something I constantly here, especially from mainstream sources, i.e. parents, movie reviewers, etc. The more variety you can add, the better, in my opinion.

member_removed 07-27-2015 09:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jester (Post 1487231)
The thing I always wonder is do we really know that the Turtles were from the same clutch of eggs? I mean they're pet shop turtles. Born and breed on a turtle farm. Can we say with certainty they all came from the same mama slider?

Over the years, I had always been curious to whether they were ninja "brothers" or biological siblings. I think the closest we've come to a direct answer was in the 2007 movie. When Mikey says the monster looks like Donnie’s mom. To which Donnie replies that would make her your mom too. But that's just one of many interpretations of the TMNT.

Today it doesn't bother me, but back in 1990 when I was youngster and collecting the Playmates figures it did bug me. It seemed like a cynical ploy to sell identical figures to our parents.

Sophie Campbell 07-27-2015 10:29 AM

i like how there's no "i like/love it" poll option. oh, Andrew. ;)

personally i like the skin colors. i see a lot of talk about logic and realism (and aside from that real turtles actually DO have differing skin and markings, that's a real thing) i don't think there's any ILLOGICAL reason not to have the colors, either. the Turtles become more human when they mutate, they get teeth, they get human eyes, etc. they become humanoid to the point that the only really turtle trait they have is their shell. they're more human than turtle in my opinion, and all humans have visibly different skintones than one another, as opposed to the perhaps more subtle differentiations of real turtles, and even siblings and sometimes twins have complexions that differ from each other. if we're really bringing "science" and genetics into this rather than a purely artistic/design/style standpoint, then it seems more scientific and believable to me that they'd have different complexions.

neatoman 07-27-2015 11:37 AM

I find it somewhat disturbing that there are people (or at least one person) who is seriously bothered by the idea of the turtles having different skin colors. I can see the argument against the color coded masks or the belt buckles, since these can be seen as very childish changes, but the color coded masks do help make the turtles easier tell apart so I don't mind it (and the belt buckles have been ignored for about two decades now so who cares?).

The skin colors seems like way too much of a purist thing to complain about however. I mean seriously, making them different shades of green? Why would that bother anyone in their right mind? They're still frickin' green! I mean Jesus Christ, what's the next thing to complain about? The fact that people have started giving them different heights?

Need I point out that there has been far less subtle ways of differentiating the turtles?
http://miragelicensing.com/comics/archie/37/3.jpghttps://upload.wikimedia.org/wikiped...014_poster.jpghttp://g.cz/sites/default/files/g/2014/05/cyboer.jpghttp://www.tribalpages.com/tpphotos/...hul_246015.jpghttp://vignette3.wikia.nocookie.net/...20091205223941

Andrew NDB 07-27-2015 11:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 1487383)
Need I point out that there has been far less subtle ways of differentiating the turtles?

All of which unnecessary.

neatoman 07-27-2015 12:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1487388)
All of which unnecessary.

Right, ripping out Raph's eye or turning Don into a giant cyborg is of course overkill. But most people don't share your notion that four visually identical characters is perfectly fine, wheter you like it or not there will always be attempts at making them look different.

So with that considered, aren't you happy that skin colors and color coded masks are what stuck, instead of gamera mutations and chopped off arms?

plastroncafe 07-27-2015 12:40 PM

You want to go realistic?
Let's go realistic.

Slider markings are specific to an individual, with no two looking exactly the same. Saying that they should all look exactly the same is also akin to the racist:

All [blank] look alike to me.

Plasticplayhouse 07-27-2015 01:09 PM

doesnt bother me either way. i'm ok with a little color variation.

Lordmylar06 07-27-2015 01:33 PM

I've actually seen red eared sliders with differing skin tones. Darkness of the skin in sliders is caused by age. The older one is, usually the darker the tone. This isn't so true for sliders in captivity though. Also, the red ear markings can sometimes fade to an orange or more yellow tone over time.
That being said, differing skin tone due to age wouldn't apply to the TMNT as they were all around the same age.
I do however entertain the thought of red ear slider accurate skin on them. I think if done properly with a top notch colorist it could be beautiful.

neatoman 07-27-2015 02:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by plastroncafe (Post 1487396)
You want to go realistic?
Let's go realistic.

Slider markings are specific to an individual, with no two looking exactly the same. Saying that they should all look exactly the same is also akin to the racist:

All [blank] look alike to me.

You don't even need to argue that, realism flies out the window when you remember it's a story about baby turtles who touched alien goop and turned into humanoids.

plastroncafe 07-27-2015 02:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 1487420)
You don't even need to argue that, realism flies out the window when you remember it's a story about baby turtles who touched alien goop and turned into humanoids.

I felt I did in the face of the argument: Red-Eared Sliders have the same skin tone. Realism.

Commenter 42 07-27-2015 02:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1487140)
I think the different skin-colored TMNT that seems to be being pushed as the norm is even more ridiculous and insulting to one's intelligence than that whole matter.

Red-earred sliders don't have different skin colors. And even if there were, if these guys are supposed to be brothers, from the same Mama Turtle...?

I'm with you. It's true RES colors can vary a lot, but within a clutch, the variation is minimal. I'm a big fan of them looking almost identical. I'd be more comfortable with markings distinguishing them, if anything.

What really irritates me is when they are pushed as sea turtles. It makes absolutely no sense.

My biggest frustration is the "they're mutants" excuse, as in "they're mutants, who's to say they they wouldn't look like x,y,z?"

Bollocks.


Quote:

Originally Posted by Lordmylar06 (Post 1487410)
I do however entertain the thought of red ear slider accurate skin on them. I think if done properly with a top notch colorist it could be beautiful.

Agreed. I doubt that day will ever come. :(. It would be cool though.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 07-27-2015 03:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 1487389)
Right, ripping out Raph's eye or turning Don into a giant cyborg is of course overkill. But most people don't share your notion that four visually identical characters is perfectly fine, wheter you like it or not there will always be attempts at making them look different.

So with that considered, aren't you happy that skin colors and color coded masks are what stuck, instead of gamera mutations and chopped off arms?

I love the way you put that. :tlol: You have now won this debate, and I yield my former criticisms to this logic.

Bombshell 07-27-2015 03:21 PM

I think its completely plausible for the four turtles to have different skin tones. If you look at turtles in a petstore, they all have different markings on them, even in the same species. The yellow stripes are different, even the red markings are different (for RES). Their shells are different and yes, skin tone is different. Pigment is what the specialty breeders look for when picking out what male and female to mate to achieve what color for color mutations.

I always liked the different color skin tone. It gives them individuality outside of their weapons and headbands. They're not the same, just like the petstore turtles are not the same. So in essence, they shouldn't look the same. Even scientific genetic clones have differences from their host animal, and they have identical dna!

Along with the differences every turtle has, throw in some human dna and you've got a huge color pallet to work with. My skin tone is different from my sister's skin tone and we have the same parents. Hers is pinkish while mine is a hint yellow. Its not a far cry to see that four sibling turtles from the same parents (if thats what they are) can have different markings and shades of skin tone.

Joey Kamikaze 07-27-2015 03:42 PM

Obviously a serious about turtle mutants who battle Ninja clans and aliens should be as scientifically accurate as possible. As such, the four turtles should all look the same to us humans, not be able to hear or speak, and have gigantic penises.

plastroncafe 07-27-2015 03:45 PM

Turtles aren't deaf.
They have ears and everything.

Commenter 42 07-27-2015 04:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joey Kamikaze (Post 1487474)
Obviously a serious about turtle mutants who battle Ninja clans and aliens should be as scientifically accurate as possible. As such, the four turtles should all look the same to us humans, not be able to hear or speak, and have gigantic penises.

That video is at most 10% accurate. The penis size is true of some species, not all. Salmonella is an issue as well. That's about it. Snappers, not res, have a worm shaped tongue. RES live 20-30 years, (longer out of captivity) not 200. Their shells can bleed they don't spontaneously bleed.

Also, most city dwelling animals are vectors for disease, not just rats. Humans are pretty high up there too, as are most livestock from factory farms. Proximity is the real problem.

But sure, hahaha...yep, this video is full of hilarious misnomers. Yippee for stupid.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:54 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.