![]() |
Aside from Vol. 1, which TMNT incarnation of COMICS is the best??
That doesn't mean your "favorite" because that would conflict with what I'm trying to see.
What is the best stories etc? The best art? Covers? What do you guys think is the best stuff outside vol 1? |
IDW. IDW is even better than Mirage Volume 1, because it doesn't have a sh!tty "guest era" section in the middle.
|
Nice. Thanks for voting brother.
Yeah I left our Vol 1... cause it would conflict with people I think. Vol. 1's first like 11 issues are jsut killer, but yeah overall it might not be the best, but I didn't want people voting for it just because it was the origin, and the first several issues were great etc... |
Missing the short-lived Dreamweave series based on the 2k3 cartoon...which I really rather liked.
|
For me, Mirage/Image has always been a mixed grab-bag.
The bookends of Mirage Volume 1 are the epitome of TMNT, #1-11, a few canon Northampton stories, Return to New York, Masks, Tales Vol 1, and City at War (with the Shades of Gray prequel). But there is no forgiveness in my heart for the middle of Volume 1. Mirage Volume 2 started strong but got rushed at the end, through no fault of the actual content. Casey Jones was misused, and the interval with the giant turtle and fishwoman were utterly random, but Stockman and the Turtles splitting up was great. Thematically it's a perfect continuation of Volume 1; it just didn't get enough time to shine. Image Volume 3 is another mix of awesome and meh-some. The Image crossovers are tedious (except for Horridus, who is adorable with the Mikester) and Donny gets turned into an ongoing plot device / enforcer, but Shadow, Raph, Mikey, and the Foot Clan are all awesome. Mirage Volume 4 starts somewhat strong, #1-11 or thereabouts, and the plot developments of Utroms landing on Earth publicly and Splinter's death of old age are excellent. But as soon as Splinter dies, the plot threads unravel to a certain extent. Leo's drags on, Donnie's drags on, Raph's is utterly pointless, and Mikey's is great. But considering we'll never get an ending, eh. I don't think it's fair to lump Tales Volume 1 into it's own category; it's very much an essential part of Mirage Volume 1. Also, you forgot Tales Volume 2, which IS it's own thing. |
(splitting into two posts due to length)
Compared to Volumes 1-4 from Mirage/Image, IDW has had a far stronger track record. The other volumes are critically 50% awesome, 50% tedious. Whereas for its 75-85 issues (don't remember the exact number offhand), IDW and its accompanying tie-ins and mini-series are ALL excellent. The ONLY issues of IDW TMNT that have not been excellent are (most of us will agree) the Casey & April miniseries and the two Eastman annuals. |
IDW!
I find that the story and characters are far more investing. The turtles seem more like teenagers than any other incarnation, besides the Nick show, but it takes it seriously. Family conflict is more relevant and seems more real. Baxter Stockman's not a pushover or a boot kisser or a one-note mad scientist. Or constantly getting the short end of the the stick, but greatly deserving of it when he does. Most of all, he's terrifying in his own special way that Krang and Shredder do not have. April and Casey retain their usual roles of being clearly much older than the turtles, but I like that they're still incredibly young; young enough to be peers to the turtles. Reporter April and scientist/shop keeper April just seemed too old to be associating with the turtles at the level she does. Tech school April seems at just the right spot. Same with Casey. Other incarnations didn't quite hit the "good kid from a bad neighborhood" area quite as well for me. The Fugitoid has a lot more character, and I like the gold color better than silver; it shows how valuable he is. The feud between Splinter and Shredder is labeled as petty and pointless, as it should have been for decades. Applause to Donatello for seeing this. And, of course, the Utrom story having a lot more meat to their story than "we crashed because of a solar flare/psychopath", and the same goes for Krang. I have a lot more to say abut him and his psychology, but I'll get to that in another topic, if I can find it. |
I'm quite curious to see if anyone will vote against IDW. :tlol:
DON'T YOU DARE, WHOEVER YOU ARE! DON'T. YOU. DARE. |
Yeah I didn't include Vol 2 Tales because it was later, and if I had to include one of them it was be Vol 1. Which is just better overall... and has that old school famous Mirage vibe to it.
I didn't want to add in every single comic thing... I wanted to keep it chunky and headling. Which is what I did. All MAJOR comic lines are shown here. Tales Vol 2 didn't deserve to be in this. I know it is longer than Vol 1 and all that, but Vol 1 was during the classic era 87-89 right? THanks for the great inputs very fun. |
Oh, so the exclusions weren't oversights, they were intentionally left off to suit your own biases.
Good to know. |
Basically what CKDOhMY said. Each series has some really great content but they usually have an equal amount of not-so-great stuff within the same series. With very few exceptions, IDW has consistently produced quality stories, art and execution.
With that being said, IDW has advantages over the previous volume's teams and, I think, has taken somewhat of an easy way out by not creating an entirely new story. It seems they have learned from the other volumes mistakes by taking what worked in the past and regurgitating it but tweaking it slightly to make it their own. I'm not saying it doesn't work, because it does. IDW has succeeded in harnessing the awesome creative imaginings of the '80s cartoons/comics and I really think that's the reason for their popularity. I guess what I'm trying to say is, the main reason I like IDW so much is because I liked many of the previous stories so much. |
Quote:
That's like if I were to set up a poll asking "Which is the Greatest U.S. President of the 21st Century?" and gave you the options of Bill Clinton and Barack Obama only. Love him or hate him, George W. Bush should be in that poll. Tis a fact. |
Quote:
|
OMG
I was just trying to have some fun. I thought about including Tales Vol 2 but didn't because I was trying to keep the main ones in there. Plus I didn't think anyone would actually vote for tales vol 2. I wans't trying to be biased... so sorry. Just relax. I was simply trying to defend why I didn't include it. I just didn't think including every vol of every thing was that important. I stuck to adventures, the other official volumes the first tales because it is from that classical era and the idw I just thought vol 1 tales should get there and not vol 1 based on its prestige and timing. Sorry guys. Wasn't anything I was trying to do for myself. Just trying to have a friendly poll. If I could add it in I would. Good lord. |
I voted for Image... Mostly I haven't cared for the ongoing art from IDW. It's not bad, but the Turtles are ugly as all heck. Fawn all over the artist if you want but its definitely not my cup of tea. The stories from IDW have been great but TMNT wasn't even supposed to be an ongoing... Just a one shot and done... It's not really a fair comparison for V1 to IDW... IDW was planned out... Anyways. I'll take all the original material over the IDW as "best" any day.
:) |
People who post polls are supposed to keep those polls unbiased and equal opportunity. This isn't politics, man, it's TMNT. We all already know some of the material sucks.
Give us a chance to rant against Tales Vol 2, man. I hate the majority of it for wasting space and never finishing its good story arcs. Unbiased. Unprejudiced. Fair. Plastroncafe, would you do me a solid and post a Harvey Dent GIF? I can never get that crap to work right. :tlol: |
Well Tales 2 is the outlier, being an anthology and all. It bounces around and is part of each of the other eras, filling gaps and what not all over.
Anyways, kinda have to vote for IDW. Objectively speaking it's been highly consistent, and is accessible and organized enough that it's probably what I'd start someone on if they asked me where to start with TMNT. |
Quote:
This one? |
Quote:
I honestly didn't think anyone would vote for it anyways with the options at hand everything listed as options is MAJOR and classic things. a vol 2 of a series that went on way too long and is hit and miss just doesn't deserve it. Would you guys have voted for Dreamwave... no wait... |
I'd have voted for Dreamweave, which is why I made mention of it's exclusion.
|
Quote:
I'm not going to list the logic and facts, again. I think I'll just let PC's "Muffin" comment ride. (She and I have to do a superhero team-up more often, this has been GREAT FUN.) Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Seeing how CyberCubed isn't around (somebody turn on the Cubedsignal!), I'm gonna steal a sheet out of his script.
This thread needs to be locked. :twink: |
yeah just lock it or just delete it.
I just tried to make a fun poll and it went so sour. so sad |
Verily, life is but a pool of tears, its liquid sorrows clinging to us with every sodden step.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
A DARK KNIGHT. |
You merely adopted the 'drome... I was born in it.
|
Quote:
|
I kinda wish my face was inside that batman signal as it was being broken...
|
Dreamwave huh? I liked that the first time, then I looked at it again and it's honestly pretty bad. That art is awful, especially. I mean some of the writing was hinting at something good but all that copy/paste art was so hackish and lazy and over-stylized, to boot. Huh. Go figure, guess everything is someone's favorite. I guess it's kinda like how some people like black licorice and nobody can figure out why. :trazz:
I honestly would have to give a mention to Tales Vol. 2. It's definitely better than most things. I'unno about "best" but it's better than most. |
Quote:
|
I didn't say all that, they're not even the same thing. I know what I'm more apt to flip through but that doesn't say everything.
|
Quote:
Muffin, anyone? |
Well I mean there's more stuff in Tales that I'd like to re-read before I'd re-read Vol. 2 of Mirage, but that's just me. Seeing how one's an anthology and one's more like a mini-series, it's hard for me mentally to compare them.
Most of Mirage in general outside of Tales is like dry turkey, to me. It's fine but it's not my first pick of meats. I feel like some of the stuff in Tales Vol. 2 did a better job of telling TMNT stories that the readers would enjoy and was a little more aimed at fans than the rest of Mirage's stuff. But I'unno if you'd say "better", exactly. |
Quote:
But yeah, there is a lot of good stuff in there, too. And no Casey Jones doing an idiotic "Ahnuld" impression either. :tlol: |
Now, to say Mirage vol.1 is the best in comic from is an opinion. I alsp lump together the seven issues of Tales vol. 1 with the volume one books. At this point I cannot officially say IDW yet. It is not a completed volume like the rest. At this point it is Archie's Adventures series. When all is said and done it likely will be IDW. It is just hard to jusge something that is still going on.
|
Quote:
Volume 4 is, at best, tedious. IDW is, at worst, a well-written love letter to every prior incarnation of TMNT. |
I read IDW first and later went back and read other series. IDW is still my favorite (I'm probably just as biased as anyone else).
|
IDW, JUST... IDW.It has everything I wanted in a TMNT comic. I'd throw every other TMNT incarnation overboard to enjoy this one, without hesitation.
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:36 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.