![]() |
Pick one character that you could do without from TMNT.
Just imagine if one of these characters never existed, if you had to pick one, which would it be that you could live without?
|
This could be fun! I didn't include Shredder as an option because he is so vital to the Turtles. Out of these 4 who do you guys think you could live without?
|
Of those four?
Krang easily. |
Quote:
For me Baxter or Krang were the ones I'm not huge on but have a large part in the stories normally. I wonder if anyone picks Casey? |
ME!
Mostly because I didn't have any awareness of his existence before I got involved in TMNT. Then again, of the four, April was the only one I was *really* aware of. But when I did become aware of him, he didn't have much of an impact on me. Krang was the salve to my "why aren't Daleks out of their casings more?" madness, and then became so much more. Much, much more. Baxter Stockman is a close second, but I enjoyed him, even if he was a punching bag in 75% of his incarnations. Casey just couldn't appeal to me. He had/has a deplorable attitude in the Nick show, reminding me of the smart alecs in public school who would drag classes behind due to their bull****, and then the Fred Wolf Casey was just...no. But then that means going without IDW Casey, and that's where his absence would be missed. IDW Casey is pretty great. He fits the "good kid from a bad hood" niche better than most of the others so far. Maybe Mirage Casey too, but he was a little lackluster to me. I am a little surprised that April is on this list, considering what an integral part she has with the turtles. She's as important as Splinter, and maybe even Shredder. |
It isn't a "list". It is simply 4 major choices. I wanted to see what you guys thought from "these" choices... nothing is definitive... yikes
|
I was ruling out why I went with one of them over the others. Personally, I can't just say "I picked Casey" and leave it at that.
|
April. She's the hardest character to use, as eventually, she wears out her welcome. She's ALWAYS the first human the Turtles meet, and after that, her usefulness all too quickly wears out. All too often, she's just the "original human" and the token female.
That's the fault of the writers, of course, not the character. But consider all the different tactics writers have used: Early Mirage: Den mother, our POV to the Turtles... unhappy LA girl in City at War Fred Wolf: Reporter Archie: Kunochi in training 4Kids: Computer geek Imagi: Archaelogist Nick: Mary Sue alien/human hybrid love-triangle Mirage V4: Magic pencil drawing roach whore IDW: Pantheon hunter The ONLY other character in TMNT with this many different takes is The Rat King, who is nowhere near as important a character as April. |
It's a damn shame that so many writers struggle so much with writing a compelling female character. And it's not like there isn't stuff there for April.
Being the Zeppo is an important role, and she could bring so much nuance to the story. Alas. |
I really don't understand why so many people struggle; I think a big part of it is CEOs and upper management in toys and shows and books aimed at kids thinking "Only boys like Turtles! Why bother any effort into writing April beyond "token female"?"
|
If I had to choose between any of the four, it's certainly a toss up between April and Krang.
Barring my bias towards Baxter Stockman, I always felt the 2003 series did incredible with his characterization, especially with Insane in the Membrane. Sure, he's a laughingstock in the cartoons outside 2003, but I ultimately feel he did contribute quite a bit to the series and might be the often brought up villain not withstanding any of the mutants. If he were handled in a similar style to Mr. Freeze from Batman, I honestly feel Stockman would deserve a lot more credit as an antagonist that versions lack. Casey on the other hand does assist in the relationship with April, his friendship with Raphael, and even his rivalry with the Purple Dragons and Hun. Sure, he's often ridiculed with the Nick show with his continuous love triangle and goes through several differing characterizations, but he is memorable in his own right. The major problem with Casey is similar to April, he's often changed too often in characterization depending on incarnation; if anything I'd love for him to be the first human met for once instead of April. Outside his popularity at the time of Fred Wolf with his interactions with Shredder, Krang isn't exactly an excellent character. He did nearly nothing in Fred Wolf and doesn't stand strong personally. Despite possessing a standard character throughout the franchise, he was more of a product of his time personally. Even then, he is an entertaining character in his own right. April though seems to suffer too many radical changes over the years and exists as the introduction to the heroes to the human world. Even with connections to Baxter, her usefulness seems to go away with further introductions to more human characters that the novelty wears off. I'd go for her only due to her usefulness faltering unless someone changes up when she meets the Turtles. |
I'm finding it kind of funny that so far, no one has voted Baxter Stockman so far. More "haha" funny than "this is peculiar" funny.
|
I think a large part of the problem rests with April's Tokenism. When you've only got one of something, you have to be careful with how you handle them. She can't be a damsel, but she can't also be totally self sufficient.
April has to be as good as the male characters, but in no way better than them at anything, and that's a narrow field to work with. The easiest way to fix this would be to add another couple of regular female characters. That way April doesn't have to be everything. So she's not the token. Not only does that allow her to have more in the way of flaws, but it also gives her room to breath and grow into a third dimension. |
Yeah, like you've pointed out, Ciro and the rest of the Nick team have a "2 female characters only" policy. Unbelievable.
IDW, for my money, has done the best job of portraying female characters in the TMNT universe. April, Kitsune, Alopex, Angel, Koya, Lindsey, Karai... they all have very different personalities, motivations, and roles in the story. I think 4Kids also did pretty well, although there were practically no female characters of any import other than Karai and April. But I really did love their portrayal of April. I think it's the best she's been portrayed in animation. |
With this being in the comic section, it makes me think of Mirage. & in that, Krang has no role whatsoever. So if it's specific to that original universe, I vote for him, obviously. In general, though? April. She's never been particularly interesting.
|
Quote:
|
not sure i see the point to this poll?
but if i had to pick someone i could do without it's not someone on this list of four, it'd have to be Shadow Jones. in my eyes she started being used more as the entire Mirage line started slipping from it's former greatness. |
I picked Casey Jones. I like him, but to be totally honest, I just don't care for him in certain incarnations.
|
Oh haha! I expected this to be open choice but given the 4 characters in the top poll I absolutely decline making a decision as I could never go without any of those core story supportive characters regardless of which release line we talk about.
Admitted I haven't seen the 2012 animated series yet and won't be until I'm done with the full 90ies DVD box set I obtained. So that could take a while haha :tgrin: |
Quote:
Also its 4 main supporting characters in the books... through any incarnation in general. It is these 4 to choose from because they are all major parts of the lore and I thought it would be pretty tough choice. |
Quote:
now i see where you're going with this!!! well, now that you put it that way it's a pretty tough choice indeed!!! hmmmm! ....Krang, time for you to hit the bricks squishy! |
If you had put Kraaang there, i'don't vote those guys off... but I rather like Krang... Utroms are cool...
|
Honestly, I can't see doing without any of them, as they've all become fairly integral parts of the lore. If I HAD to choose, it's a toss up between Casey and Krang. Krang has had the fewest incarnations (unless you count Nick's Kraang Prime/sub-Prime), and Casey has had several that were rather lackluster.
|
I picked Krang because, frankly, he's a pretty replaceable supervillain. We've been without him before and been fine. He doesn't really bring an important narrative presence to the story the way the other characters (historically) have. I think the benevolent Utroms are a more interesting story option as well.
That said, I think we could easily do a version without either April or Casey, or replace them with alternate human characters. For that matter, Adventures never brought Casey in at all. |
Quote:
I think it says a lot that I skipped over Casey & April's mini almost entirely (sans checking in with the TMNT Entity blog from time to time to see if I was missing anything), and frankly didn't miss either character's presence at all in the lead up to #50. Especially in IDW, where much more interesting female personalities exist, what use does April serve? Even Lindsey Baker does a better job of being a more interesting "token human lady to a band of mutant misfits", at this point. |
Quote:
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:03 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.