The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Re-reading the entire IDW TMNT (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=54245)

myconius 01-14-2016 10:02 AM

Re-reading the entire IDW TMNT
 
as the single IDW TMNT issues have been coming out i'd usually read each issue 2 or 3 times on release.

but it's been a while since i've read some of the older issues, so i decided to re-read the entire series from the beginning according to Dr. Spengler's continuity timeline.

http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2013/...-timeline.html

as much as i enjoyed the series month to month i'm enjoying it a LOT more on this re-through.

and there's a LOT of points i missed as well.

one of the biggest ones was the differentiation between Mutagen and Ooze!
i can't believe i didn't realize they weren't the same thing!
but in the Hob Micro-series he says that Ooze was an ingredient in Mutagen.

so this better explained to me why Ooze has been used to heal certain characters, but they didn't get Mutated or Re-Mutated. :)

i'm sure other people probably caught onto this right away, but it had completely flew over my head. :D


btw... thank you again Dr. Spengler for posting that timeline! :D

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 01-14-2016 10:17 AM

Discussion re-reading time? Volume by volume? I'm game if anyone else is!

myconius 01-14-2016 10:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1537838)
Discussion re-reading time? Volume by volume? I'm game if anyone else is!

i've been re-reading the entire timeline, mini-series and all. :D

last one i JUST read up to and finished was City Fall. :)

after i read issues 1-4, i HAVE to immediately read 'a lot to learn' from the 30th Anniversary issue and then issue #5.

those are probably my most read issues from the entire run! ^__^

DrSpengler 01-14-2016 11:12 AM

I've been wanting to reread the first year recently; I recall being pretty harsh on it when it first came out and would like to reevaluate it.

My continuity timeline is chronological but isn't the ideal reading order, mind you; I wouldn't break up the minis like Utrom Empire, Mutanimals or Casey & April as I have them (rather, shuffle them to the end of the Ongoing arcs they correspond to).

Have fun!

CyberCubed 01-14-2016 12:42 PM

Its amazing how much the series has changed from the first year. What they've done with Old Hob alone since this is incredible, he received the most character development of the book.

PangolinFeets 01-14-2016 12:48 PM

I remember Bobby answered a Ninja note about the difference between ooze and mutagen. I didnt realize there was a difference until then.

I reread the series over my Christmas break. Its such a great story!

myconius 01-14-2016 12:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1537853)
I've been wanting to reread the first year recently; I recall being pretty harsh on it when it first came out and would like to reevaluate it.

My continuity timeline is chronological but isn't the ideal reading order, mind you; I wouldn't break up the minis like Utrom Empire, Mutanimals or Casey & April as I have them (rather, shuffle them to the end of the Ongoing arcs they correspond to).

Have fun!

yeah, it's definitely been a nice treat!!! :D
there were many things i missed, or misinterpreted since i was still so very stuck on the continuity of the Original Mirage TMNT Vol. 1.

but now that i'm more accustomed to the IDW universe i can appreciate certain things a LOT More!

AH thank you! it's a good thing you said that about reading order, as i've just finished with 'City Fall' and was unsure if i really wanted to mix reading 'Northampton' and 'Utrom Empire'?

thank you! it's definitely been a LOT of fun so far! :D

myconius 01-14-2016 12:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1537882)
Its amazing how much the series has changed from the first year. What they've done with Old Hob alone since this is incredible, he received the most character development of the book.

absolutely!!!!

Hob's micro-series especially was absolutely amazing at what it did for his character!!!

still though, it's really hard for me not to get misty-eyed when i read the first few pages of the Hob micro! :tcry:

Quote:

Originally Posted by PangolinFeets (Post 1537885)
I remember Bobby answered a Ninja note about the difference between ooze and mutagen. I didnt realize there was a difference until then.

I reread the series over my Christmas break. Its such a great story!

i vaguely recall seeing that in 'Ninja Notes' as well, but it must've slipped my mind just as easily as it entered it! :P

Joey Kamikaze 01-14-2016 03:28 PM

I think I did my last re-read around the time Northampton came out so I'm due too.

One thing that strikes me re-reading the first couple years is the amount of foreshadowing. Some hints you'll catch the first time through, but others only stick out once you have later stories in mind.

CyberCubed 01-14-2016 05:26 PM

The whole Savate Ninja stuff from the early issues seemed to get swept under the rug rather quickly. I remember people thinking they would be a bigger deal when this series first started.

MikeandRaph87 01-14-2016 05:29 PM

I am game if we can come up with a date range for reading the arcs/trades. I have been interested in doing so. I want to see if I like the first five issues I initially could care less about and if I still love #15-20 as much as I did which got me to love this title above any other.

Allio 01-14-2016 05:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1537996)
The whole Savate Ninja stuff from the early issues seemed to get swept under the rug rather quickly. I remember people thinking they would be a bigger deal when this series first started.

same thing could have been said about the police chick from Mikey's micro...which for all we know, that rock will be brought back.

PangolinFeets 01-14-2016 05:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Allio (Post 1537999)
same thing could have been said about the police chick from Mikey's micro...which for all we know, that rock will be brought back.

Yea but Kara came back and I feel like she is going to play an even larger role in the future.

myconius 01-14-2016 06:06 PM

one thing i find really amazing is all the little seeds planted in the series that later on built into major story points.

sure there are some loose threads that have gotten forgotten about, but overall this series is fantastic!!

my ONLY real gripe first time reading it and still doesn't sit right with me is issue #23 !!

Leo's turn to the Darkside wasn't very convincing!! :trolleye:

there was no real resistance or fight from Leo. no disbelief, NOTHING!!!

i just wish there was more development in that whole mind-warping, it just seemed rushed to me.

but that's my only real nit pick.
bringing back all the artists from previous arcs for the warped flashbacks was pretty awesome though!

turtlefan27 01-14-2016 06:24 PM

I've been wanting to do this for some time now..

Casey 01-14-2016 07:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by myconius (Post 1538015)
one thing i find really amazing is all the little seeds planted in the series that later on built into major story points.

sure there are some loose threads that have gotten forgotten about, but overall this series is fantastic!!

my ONLY real gripe first time reading it and still doesn't sit right with me is issue #23 !!

Leo's turn to the Darkside wasn't very convincing!! :trolleye:

there was no real resistance or fight from Leo. no disbelief, NOTHING!!!

i just wish there was more development in that whole mind-warping, it just seemed rushed to me.

but that's my only real nit pick.
bringing back all the artists from previous arcs for the warped flashbacks was pretty awesome though!

It always felt rushed to me too and it was hard for me to suspend my disbelief.

myconius 01-14-2016 07:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Casey (Post 1538035)
It always felt rushed to me too and it was hard for me to suspend my disbelief.

that's exactly my biggest thing with City Fall!

Leo is known for having such a strong resolve and being extremely disciplined!

and then it's just like -

Shredder - "Hey Leo, your Dad's really evil and i'm actually your bestest buddy!"

Leonardo - "OH! OK! say, can we stop and git sum Ice-Cream?" :P

well, maybe not AS bad as that? but yeah ...... WAY rushed!!!!

mikey22 01-14-2016 07:30 PM

hello

ive been getting into the batman tmnt comics and noticed this idw.

can someone please pm me a link as to where to read these comics to buy them all? they seem great!

thanks

mike

mikey22 01-14-2016 07:32 PM

i see something at barnes and noble the ultimate collection?

is this a good place to start?


http://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/teen...=9781631401114


thank you

Powder 01-14-2016 07:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mikey22 (Post 1538048)

In my opinion, yes, this is literally the best place to start. It's a great value for the price, & it's packed full of high quality content. It's got the benefit of being in chronological reading order, too, something you can't necessarily get in full with the standard 4 issue trades. Go for it!

mikey22 01-14-2016 09:39 PM

thanks a lot powder i believe i will get started!!!

myconius 01-14-2016 10:14 PM

so i re-read City Fall again over the last couple of days with the Micro-Series intermingled, and now i've just started re-reading City Fall again but this time without mixing in the Micros.

issue #22 was really good, and i did notice Leo's attitude towards Splinter seems shaken.
probably from the deception Splinter pulled on the Turtles in issue #21?

but still when i see Leonardo's hallucinations the Shredder come and rescue him from Splinter, and Leo doesn't question it in the least i really have to shake my head!

well i'll finish this re-read of City Fall yet again, but i REALLY have to look forward to getting to the Northampton arc!!!

that was so good that after issues 29-32 came out i had to re-read them over and over.
it's one of my most favorite arcs in the entire series.


one thing i will add about City Fall, the scenes of Mikey giving Slash candy bars are ABSOLUTELY Adorable!!!!!! ^__^

Joey Kamikaze 01-14-2016 10:53 PM

It's been a while since I read City Fall, but in retrospect (especially given later appearances by the Rat King) I take Leo's brainwashing as a mostly mystical event. If you approach it as a realistic story, it kind of falls apart. But we know Kitsune has the godlike power to get inside someone's head and rearrange their reality--she's done it to Leo, she's doing it to Alopex, and we've seen other Pantheon members play similar head games. Leo falling fast makes sense in-universe.

myconius 01-15-2016 12:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joey Kamikaze (Post 1538131)
It's been a while since I read City Fall, but in retrospect (especially given later appearances by the Rat King) I take Leo's brainwashing as a mostly mystical event. If you approach it as a realistic story, it kind of falls apart. But we know Kitsune has the godlike power to get inside someone's head and rearrange their reality--she's done it to Leo, she's doing it to Alopex, and we've seen other Pantheon members play similar head games. Leo falling fast makes sense in-universe.

yeah, i can see what you are saying.
and even though i JUST re-read the entire City Fall arc with the micro-series, i'm glad i've decided to do yet another read-through without them.
the pacing of the City Fall is much faster and exciting by just reading the main series.
and plus getting the full dose of Mateus Santolouco's art is just amazing!!!
it's SO dynamic and action packed! some of the panels really look like they were taken from a high-quality Anime! ^__^
and seeing Dark-Leo in action is pretty Bad @$$!!!!!

so i'm just about to finish re-reading City Fall for the second time this week, and i am appreciating it much more this time!

MikeandRaph87 01-16-2016 09:48 AM

Do we have an official date range to begin?

myconius 01-16-2016 11:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MikeandRaph87 (Post 1538479)
Do we have an official date range to begin?

sorry, i didn't realize the forum had an actual group re-read system in place. D:

but if anyone wants to join in with re-reading the IDW TMNT and have discussions about it, i welcome it completely. :)

i've been re-reading the series this whole last week, and am up to Northampton & Utrom Empire so far.


but if anyone who wants to join in this re-read and discussion they are most welcome! :)
and i don't mind going back to talk about previous arcs.

we don't have to be so formal as to scheduled dates and ranges.
read and discuss as you wish. :)

turtlefan27 01-17-2016 05:55 PM

I'm planning on starting the 1st 5 tomorrow

Casey 01-19-2016 11:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mikey22 (Post 1538048)
i see something at barnes and noble the ultimate collection?

is this a good place to start?


http://www.barnesandnoble.com/w/teen...=9781631401114


thank you

The Barnes and Noble website has Dan Duncan listed as the author!?

Etsyturtle2 01-19-2016 12:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Casey (Post 1539281)
The Barnes and Noble website has Dan Duncan listed as the author!?

Hahahhaha:lol:lolololololozzzz

myconius 01-19-2016 12:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Casey (Post 1539281)
The Barnes and Noble website has Dan Duncan listed as the author!?

at least they didn't do a mix up like i've seen on Amazon where they list someone who had absolutely NO involvement or relevance whatsoever. :/

myconius 01-19-2016 12:53 PM

finally up to Turtles in Time.

the read-through a second time is SO much richer of an experience!
there are so many little nuances i missed along the way the first time!

like in issue #37 when Krang and Shredder go back and forth about their previous "meeting", i really was unclear about them referring to later portions of 'Secret History of the Foot Clan'.

or other nice little layers they weave into the story here and there.

and i do have to say that having read 'Casey & April' (back when it came out) as i re-read issue #36 it makes a lot more sense to me now.

turtlefan27 01-19-2016 09:45 PM

I just re-read 1-5 yesterday and here's a few things that stood out to me that didn't the last time I read them..
Issue #1 page one guy appears to have a krang tshirt on. Page five the guy getting kicked by Leo has no face. Page 12 does krang have business partners with other companies other than stockgen and if so what do they do? Something is apparently going on due to the ships around the island.
Issue #2 only 3 things stick out to me. 1 is when splinter get thrown off the top of that building and the turtles are dropped off of it shouldn't that had killed them? Maybe I'm just nitpicking a tad. 2 is the cops arrived there super quick. And 3 if they are with April and heard yelling in a different room and then didn't see anyone there shouldn't they have known that someone was there and is now probably on the run??yet again probably just nitpicking..
Issue 4 page 16 why are the guys just leaving raph behind?

CyberCubed 01-20-2016 02:09 AM

Been rereading the series. The first 5 issues really bring back a lot of nostalgia (which is surprising cause this series is only 4 years old) from 2011. This pre-dates the Nick cartoon so I remember all the speculation back then.

Some people thought the Turtles were humans turned turtle (instead of reincarnated from ancient Japan), and everyone was wondering why the Turtles were teenagers, knew martial arts, and could speak already. The reincarnation origin is brilliant in retrospect.

I also really like April naming the Turtles, something I had forgotten about. Its also interesting to see Old Hob back when he was just a henchmen and tied into the Turtles origin.

Also love Dan Duncan's art.

myconius 01-20-2016 05:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1539612)
Been rereading the series. The first 5 issues really bring back a lot of nostalgia (which is surprising cause this series is only 4 years old) from 2011. This pre-dates the Nick cartoon so I remember all the speculation back then.

Some people thought the Turtles were humans turned turtle (instead of reincarnated from ancient Japan), and everyone was wondering why the Turtles were teenagers, knew martial arts, and could speak already. The reincarnation origin is brilliant in retrospect.

I also really like April naming the Turtles, something I had forgotten about. Its also interesting to see Old Hob back when he was just a henchmen and tied into the Turtles origin.

Also love Dan Duncan's art.

yeah right! for such a short period of 4 years so much has happened with the TMNT franchise, as well as comics in general.

i must admit when i heard TMNT was getting a reboot i was rather suspect of what we were getting especially since it was from a comic company i never really heard of before. but i'm SO glad i gave into my Ninja Turtle addiction and started reading the IDW series! one of the best decisions i've ever made as far as collecting new comics!!

yeah this comic series pre-dated the Nick series AND the Michael Bay movie, so there was a LOT of speculation!

the reincarnation was very jarring at first, but in hind-sight was one of the best decisions they made from a story stand point!
it definitely helped flesh out the characters backstory, and added SO many layers!
it's amazing how many times that execution scene of Yoshi and his Sons has been revisited, and it's always just as impactful!

that page of April telling Chet what she had named the Turtles was brilliant!
i loved how each Turtle even before Mutation was acting in character! :tlol:

most definitely!!! Duncan ROCKS!!!! :D

ProphetofGanja 01-20-2016 08:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by myconius (Post 1538143)
...and plus getting the full dose of Mateus Santolouco's art is just amazing!!!
it's SO dynamic and action packed! some of the panels really look like they were taken from a high-quality Anime! ^__^...

I have been dreaming about a Santolouco-style TMNT anime since he first took on art duties for the series

at least I can still dream

myconius 01-20-2016 08:39 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ProphetofGanja (Post 1539949)
I have been dreaming about a Santolouco-style TMNT anime since he first took on art duties for the series

at least I can still dream

i hear you on that!!!

as soon as i saw Santolouco's art in immediately reminded me of the Animation house that turned out Cowboy Bebop and Samurai Champloo!

i'd totally go Berserk if there was a Ninja Turtle anime put out by them!!!

CyberCubed 01-20-2016 08:55 PM

Its so funny to see how all the mutants went from lackies in the beginning of the book to what they are now:

Old Hob was Baxter's henchmutant. He spends the first 12 issues losing fights to Splinter/Turtles over and over and being bosses around and nearly killed. Now he's the leader of the Mutanimals.

Alopex was just a one-dimensional henchmutant of Shredder....now she's an actual character with likes/dislikes and a dynamic with Raphael.

Slash had no personality and was just a raging killing machine monster. Now he's an actual character and has a conscience.

Then there's Hun who started off just as Casey's abusive father, heh.

myconius 01-20-2016 09:04 PM

almost forgot to mention my re-read of Northampton over the weekend.

absolutely LOVE that arc!!!
it really made City Fall feel worth it to me, just to get to this point!
the interactions of the characters was so heartfelt!
plus i really enjoyed the spiritual visits from Tang Shen!
and not to mention just how MAGNIFICENT Sophie Campbell's art is!!!

that very last page of issue #31 :o

https://retconpunchdotcom.files.word...urns.jpg?w=593

when i first saw that panel the hairs stood on the back of my neck!!! :D

afterwards i got to re-indulge in Santalouco's awesome art in #33-40.
i swear that guy can make a single panel look like a splash page!!!

i was a bit confused with the placement of the 2014 annual and Turtles in Time?

it almost seems to me like Turtles in Time should follow directly AFTER the 2014 Annual, since Renet said the Turtles were bouncing through time after their last adventure when they were "accidentally oversaturated with Quantum Particles".

myconius 01-20-2016 09:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1539958)
Its so funny to see how all the mutants went from lackies in the beginning of the book to what they are now:

Old Hob was Baxter's henchmutant. He spends the first 12 issues losing fights to Splinter/Turtles over and over and being bosses around and nearly killed. Now he's the leader of the Mutanimals.

Alopex was just a one-dimensional henchmutant of Shredder....now she's an actual character with likes/dislikes and a dynamic with Raphael.

Slash had no personality and was just a raging killing machine monster. Now he's an actual character and has a conscience.

Then there's Hun who started off just as Casey's abusive father, heh.

i have to admit i DID NOT see that set up for Hun right under our noses!!!! :D

when they first did that reveal it was like :o

same with Chet/Honeycutt!!!

but Hob really did a complete turnaround!!!
i used to really hate his guts, but now i love that despicable furry critter!! :D

old_hob88 01-20-2016 09:10 PM

Just finished rereading the first 5 issues and "a lot to learn". It is fun seeing how much Hob changes from that era. He was really just a dim, one-dimensional character then, but he's become one of my favorite all-time TMNT characters.

I also really enjoy "Attack Lot to Learn". It really helps to flesh out the time right after Raph's return and show his adjustment.

I really wish the ongoing would throw some stories like this as back-ups to the ongoing. I honestly feel Casey & April could have been well executed as a back-up running along with vengeance.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:45 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.