The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Ace Duck, eventually being in the IDW comics (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=54754)

Zage 03-17-2016 12:26 PM

Ace Duck, eventually being in the IDW comics
 
I think that when Ace Duck does finally make an appearance, in the IDW series, it'd be cool if they combined both versions of him, & made him a pilot, with an amateur wrestling background. Possibly even have him be a jobber, premutation, but then when he mutates, he becomes a little bit more buffer, & defined, in muscle.

What do you guys think?

neatoman 03-17-2016 12:59 PM

Why the hell are you even assuming he will get in?

Zage 03-17-2016 01:55 PM

Cause Bobby Curnow likes the character.

Mew 03-17-2016 02:34 PM

I like this idea. Not gonna lie.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 03-17-2016 02:39 PM

I've never liked anything from Archie, so no, I would prefer either an all-new take on the character or 100% pilot (Fred Wolf action figure).

CyberCubed 03-17-2016 02:51 PM

Why did you never like anything from Archie? It had plenty of great arcs, characters, and utilized the old Playmates mutants better than the original cartoon did.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 03-17-2016 02:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1559300)
Why did you never like anything from Archie? It had plenty of great arcs, characters, and utilized the old Playmates mutants better than the original cartoon did.

Based in Fred Wolf, does a lot of random weird sci-fi environmental stuff. Never appealed to me.

Null, Maligna, Cudley, Hitler's Brain, Ninjara, Bellybomb... none of it for me. Comparing it to the more grounded (cough cough) Image Volume 3 that I discovered around the same time as a kid, which had ninjas, the Foot Clan, Raphael as Shredder, cyborg Donnie, etc, it was no contest.

Basically, none of the major original arcs or characters appeal to me.

CyberCubed 03-17-2016 03:06 PM

Yet all that stuff is in IDW too.

neatoman 03-17-2016 03:11 PM

I'd say the Archie series is basically a better version of the Fred Wolf cartoon but I still don't like it, the pacing is really bizarre and it contains some really bad artwork. That and it's a little too preachy.

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1559303)
Yet all that stuff is in IDW too.


Uh, Null is in it but Maligna, Cudley, Ninjara and BellyBomb are not. Very little of Archie's TMNT seems to have made it into the IDW series, all I noticed is that they reimagined Null and lifted the name Mutanimals for a similar group.

MikeandRaph87 03-17-2016 03:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1559301)
Based in Fred Wolf, does a lot of random weird sci-fi environmental stuff. Never appealed to me.

Null, Maligna, Cudley, Hitler's Brain, Ninjara, Bellybomb... none of it for me. Comparing it to the more grounded (cough cough) Image Volume 3 that I discovered around the same time as a kid, which had ninjas, the Foot Clan, Raphael as Shredder, cyborg Donnie, etc, it was no contest.

Basically, none of the major original arcs or characters appeal to me.

Hello, Bizarro MikeandRaph87.:tlol:

Yes, we do both love Netflix's Daredevil and old school Batman.

CyberCubed 03-17-2016 03:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 1559307)
I'd say the Archie series is basically a better version of the Fred Wolf cartoon but I still don't like it, the pacing is really bizarre and it contains some really bad artwork. That and it's a little too preachy.

What's wrong with the pacing? As for the art when Jim Lawson filled in the art was bad but Chris Allen and the rest of the artists were pretty good.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 03-17-2016 03:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 1559307)
I'd say the Archie series is basically a better version of the Fred Wolf cartoon but I still don't like it, the pacing is really bizarre and it contains some really bad artwork. That and it's a little too preachy.

Uh, Null is in it but Maligna, Cudley, Ninjara and BellyBomb are not. Very little of Archie's TMNT seems to have made it into the IDW series, all I noticed is that they reimagined Null and lifted the name Mutanimals for a similar group.

EXACTLY. This on all points. Well, except for the artwork... never even bothered looking that closely.

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1559303)
Yet all that stuff is in IDW too.

The difference being tone, setting, balance of elements, character development, and just about everything else.

Or to simplify it:

Archie BAD, IDW GOOD. :tlol:

neatoman 03-17-2016 03:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1559310)
What's wrong with the pacing? As for the art when Jim Lawson filled in the art was bad but Chris Allen and the rest of the artists were pretty good.

As and example, there's no gap between Leatherhead's "death" and comeback, the first Leatherhead story (the on in which he "dies") is immediately followed up in the next issue where he is an intergalactic wrestler. There was no time for his death to settle in or really any justification for this rather drastic change in characterisation. Not to mention the fact that the story goes from sewer battle to intergalactic wrestling in one issue, no foreshadowing or transition shown. Granted, it does get a little better after that but things still seemed to be disjointed and happening way too fast.

As for the art, it's often really weird looking, details on the same things keep changing, lack of detail and quite a few noticable coloring errors are present.

Ninjinister 03-17-2016 03:57 PM

I want Tristan Jones' Nazi-fighter

Shark_Blade 03-17-2016 04:18 PM

He's just gonna be exactly like Donald Duck but with a gay leather daddy twist.

Powder 03-17-2016 05:00 PM

My vote is a big "no". I like the toy, I can appreciate the Archie version for what it is, but he's inherently too goofy to come back in any new iteration, & to do a "serious" take would just defeat the purpose of the character anyway.

CyberCubed 03-17-2016 05:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1559314)
Or to simplify it:

Archie BAD, IDW GOOD. :tlol:

After the first 30ish issues or so, I'd say Archie had the best narrative, stories and characters of any TMNT comic.

It took the first 30 issues to set things up and grow out of the, "This is a kids comic" phase before it was able to go off the handle no holds barred.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 03-17-2016 06:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1559334)
After the first 30ish issues or so, I'd say Archie had the best narrative, stories and characters of any TMNT comic.

It took the first 30 issues to set things up and grow out of the, "This is a kids comic" phase before it was able to go off the handle no holds barred.

Nope. Absolutely wrong. You're picking, like, the worst major TMNT comic ever. Seriously, you have heard the words "Mirage", "Image", and "IDW", right? :trazz:

Only objectively worse TMNT comic that can be seriously considered is "Dreamwave", and nobody except Plastron remembers Dreamwave. And DrSpengler, but HE doesn't count because he reviews EVERYTHING. :twink:

MikeandRaph87 03-17-2016 07:11 PM

TMNTA taught me to read and had excellent arcs with Raw Power, Future Shark Trilogy, and The Black Hole Trilogy. The Forever War would make a solid fourth arc.

If we get a Future Shark Trilogy remake IDW will become the best comic series ever.

Sophie Campbell 03-17-2016 07:16 PM

He should start off as a regular duck, not a human. He could be a steamer duck, they have weird knobs on their wings that they use to punch other birds and animals, so Ace could be super aggressive and fly around just punching everyone.

Archie has Wyrm! He's pretty cool.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 03-17-2016 07:16 PM

I'll agree Armageddon (I'm not misspelling it) is an incredible character.

I would dearly LOVE to see a time-traveling cyborg shark show up in IDW. :tcool:

CyberCubed 03-17-2016 07:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1559342)
Nope. Absolutely wrong. You're picking, like, the worst major TMNT comic ever. Seriously, you have heard the words "Mirage", "Image", and "IDW", right? :trazz:

???

The writing in all the comics is exactly the same bar the tone. Outside of the best Mirage issues, it was just average. Image had some great moments, but was bogged down by the Image superhero crossover arcs. And while IDW is really good, its basically re-doing a lot of old arcs just with new twists.

The storylines in Archie were better than most TMNT stories, and moved at a great pace since most of them were only 3-4 issues long. And most importantly, the stuff was unique. Murphy didn't just rehash Mirage or Fred Wolf stories, he did all new stuff with Null, Malinga, Armaggon, Verminator X, the Future Turtles, Mutanimals, etc.

2K3 03-17-2016 07:25 PM

I was never a big fan of Ace Duck; he never stood out from the other cool mutants!

The only other Archie-Exclusive characters I'm up for seeing adapted into IDW are:

Belly Bomb (make him the "Jabba the Hutt"-style gangster of Dimension X)
Maligna (Making her the arch-rival of Krang and, just like her Archie-counterpart, working with Null... makes a nice comparison with Stockman and Krang)
Scumbug and Wyrm (Two really cool-looking mutants; I'd have it they were experiments of Null)
Stump and Slig (One of the "Utrom Empire" covers had a certain "tree" alien that's similar to these guys)

Apparently, Bludgeon was originally going to be Armaggon, but was changed at the last minute.

Zage 03-17-2016 07:39 PM

Bobby also said that he liked Maligna, and Cudley, when I asked him what his top 5 Archie characters are, that he'd want to bring into the book. He also named Ace Duck, which I already mentioned, and he likes Wingnut and Screwloose.

CyberCubed 03-17-2016 07:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Zage (Post 1559377)
Bobby also said that he liked Maligna, and Cudley, when I asked him what his top 5 Archie characters are, that he'd want to bring into the book. He also named Ace Duck, which I already mentioned, and he likes Wingnut and Screwloose.

Even so, there's not room to fit in everyone. There's only so many characters to use and they have to fit certain story arcs, or else there's not much of a reason to use them.

Utrommaniac 03-17-2016 08:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sophie Campbell (Post 1559356)
He should start off as a regular duck, not a human. He could be a steamer duck, they have weird knobs on their wings that they use to punch other birds and animals, so Ace could be super aggressive and fly around just punching everyone.

That would be amazing! Of course, between Ace, Koya, and Pete, it would call for some kind of bird squad. Or at the very least, a throw down between Ace and Koya with Pete caught in the middle.
No matter what happens, someone is going to be spitting feathers at the end of the day.

Joey Kamikaze 03-17-2016 10:56 PM

Re: all the TMNTA hate,

First, what the hell? TMNTA is a very different book from Mirage (and everything else that followed), but it's a great all-ages adventure story. Many of the characters get solid development across several years of canon, and the book embodies the whole "family that sticks together through all kinds of weirdness and tragedy" theme that TMNT has always been about.

And besides, TMNTA arguably had the best April. She experienced real character growth, she got out of the damsel in distress game fairly early in the run, she got her own sidekick, and she even had a pretty good miniseries that tied up Midnight Sun's loose ends. Chris Allan made her look fantastic too.

CyberCubed 03-17-2016 11:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joey Kamikaze (Post 1559429)
Re: all the TMNTA hate,

First, what the hell? TMNTA is a very different book from Mirage (and everything else that followed), but it's a great all-ages adventure story. Many of the characters get solid development across several years of canon, and the book embodies the whole "family that sticks together through all kinds of weirdness and tragedy" theme that TMNT has always been about.

And besides, TMNTA arguably had the best April. She experienced real character growth, she got out of the damsel in distress game fairly early in the run, she got her own sidekick, and she even had a pretty good miniseries that tied up Midnight Sun's loose ends. Chris Allan made her look fantastic too.

Its really only Cylon, and for some reason he dislikes sci-fi elements or things that remind him of the cartoons.

Anima Gemini 03-18-2016 03:36 AM

There's a picture of Ace Duck (along with pictures of Cudley and Cryin' Houn') on the wall in one issue of IDW. I believe it's in issue #53. It's a cool little Easter egg, but perhaps it could mean he already exists in that universe.

Or *maybe* once upon a time, Cudley traversed through the multiverse in order to abduct the IDW Mutanimals for a wrestling match or two, and they snapped some pictures of their opponents as a souvenir from their bout. Hey, that's my headcanon, at least! :D

On the subject of TMNT Adventures vs. Mirage, I always saw TMNTA as the Mirage crew's version of FW. Pretty much everyone from Mirage worked on TMNTA at one point or another, after all. Murphy, Brown, Lavigne, Lawson, Berger, Dooney, Talbot, Farley... even Eastman and Laird. Heck, when you consider the fact that those people ARE Mirage and they all worked it, Adventures IS Mirage. :lol:

FW took a bunch of characters created by the Mirage artists for the toyline and used them in its own way. Meanwhile, TMNTA was a chance for those creators to actually do what they wanted to do with their own characters. The end result was something very unique, yet still familiar to fans of both FW and Mirage. It was also REALLY damn good, in my humble opinion. Yes, the respect and admiration for TMNTA is real. Deal with it. :tcool:

Chabrendeki 03-18-2016 03:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1559310)
What's wrong with the pacing? As for the art when Jim Lawson filled in the art was bad but Chris Allen and the rest of the artists were pretty good.

I liked his take on Adventures. Okay ist a quite big difference between the cartoonish art of Mitchroney and the abstract and sketchy art of Lawson, but there is a lot of humor in it.

As a kid, I thought too, it were bad, because of the sketchyness, but now I can appreciate it.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 03-18-2016 09:15 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1559438)
Its really only Cylon, and for some reason he dislikes sci-fi elements or things that remind him of the cartoons.

I love sci-fi elements and things that remind me of the cartoons:

IDW's Bebop and Rocksteady and Krang, for one; Triceratons, Federation, Styracodons, Utroms, the Fugitoid, etc for another.

I just don't like Archie. But yeah, I freely admit I'm in the minority on this one.

DrSpengler 03-18-2016 09:19 AM

Not really Ace Duck's biggest fan, but he is something of a blank slate.

Personally, I really like Errol McCarthy's production art design for him, particularly this one and this one.

I'd kinda like to see THAT version in some fashion, more so than the grotesquely muscular pro wrestler from the Archie comics.

Joey Kamikaze 03-18-2016 04:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Anima Gemini (Post 1559459)
On the subject of TMNT Adventures vs. Mirage, I always saw TMNTA as the Mirage crew's version of FW. Pretty much everyone from Mirage worked on TMNTA at one point or another, after all. Murphy, Brown, Lavigne, Lawson, Berger, Dooney, Talbot, Farley... even Eastman and Laird. Heck, when you consider the fact that those people ARE Mirage and they all worked it, Adventures IS Mirage. :lol:

That's true too--Mirage took TMNTA in-house at #5, and Archie continued publishing it. Volume 1/Tales and TMNTA came from a lot of the same hands and minds.

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1559485)
Not really Ace Duck's biggest fan, but he is something of a blank slate.

Personally, I really like Errol McCarthy's production art design for him, particularly this one and this one.

I'd kinda like to see THAT version in some fashion, more so than the grotesquely muscular pro wrestler from the Archie comics.

Also gonna agree here, I always preferred Ace Duck's mutant WWII fighter pilot look to Archie's barrel-chested pro wrestler interpretation.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chabrendeki (Post 1559463)
I liked his take on Adventures. Okay ist a quite big difference between the cartoonish art of Mitchroney and the abstract and sketchy art of Lawson, but there is a lot of humor in it.

As a kid, I thought too, it were bad, because of the sketchyness, but now I can appreciate it.

Personally, I go back and forth on Lawson as an artist. It really depends on the project. For an example within TMNTA, I dig his pencils on #11 (the issue with the Rat King and the Foot Super Soldier), but then he shows up in #24 (the middle of the Slash & Bellybomb arc) and it's just... what the hell?

MikeandRaph87 03-18-2016 05:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1559483)
Styracodons.

What'cha talkin' 'bout, Willis?

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 03-18-2016 06:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MikeandRaph87 (Post 1559595)
What'cha talkin' 'bout, Willis?

Regenta Seri and her bodyguards from Mirage Volume 4; a sister race to the Triceratons, seemingly along the lines of Romulans and Vulcans with a bit more divergent evolutionary development. My personal take, anyway...

Kingoji 03-18-2016 06:35 PM

I think maybe the Ace Duck ship sailed after the introduction of Pigeon Pete. I could have seen the above-shared designs for Ace on the Mutanimals in a less overtly comedic way than Pete is portrayed.
Actually, if not for Pete and Herman, Ace could have worked particularly well as a replacement for both with a personality more skewed towards Dead-Eye Duck.

Kingoji 03-18-2016 06:38 PM

Oh yeah, and I'm camp Archie as well. Growing up in the UK we just didn't get any of the other material, so it's pretty much my 'primary' TMNT universe. Call me blasphemous, but even after the other material became more readily available I still found the Archie run to be the highest quality and certainly most consistent of the comics from the time.

Zage 03-18-2016 06:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kingoji (Post 1559612)
I think maybe the Ace Duck ship sailed after the introduction of Pigeon Pete. I could have seen the above-shared designs for Ace on the Mutanimals in a less overtly comedic way than Pete is portrayed.
Actually, if not for Pete and Herman, Ace could have worked particularly well as a replacement for both with a personality more skewed towards Dead-Eye Duck.

But Pete the Pigeon was not only is n the newer cartoon series, but was in one episode of the original series. Albeit looked different, and wasn't humanoid, this time around. In the original series, he was Michelangelo's pet, and had a green bandana.

CyberCubed 03-18-2016 09:29 PM

Ace Duck should be reinvented as a urban gangster who talks in the 30's slang and says, "Its curtains for you...QUACK!" before he pulls the trigger. :lol:

He should also be an ex-World War 1 veteran who was experimented on by Utroms and kept in stasis so he's still alive in the modern year. He'd be like Captain America, only a duck version! :o

oldmanwinters 03-18-2016 11:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1559485)
Not really Ace Duck's biggest fan, but he is something of a blank slate.

Personally, I really like Errol McCarthy's production art design for him, particularly this one and this one.

I'd kinda like to see THAT version in some fashion, more so than the grotesquely muscular pro wrestler from the Archie comics.

I'm all for seeing something akin to this version of Ace Duck. It's amazing how nobody has taken a crack at re-interpreting the action figure besides the lame Archie wrasler take on him.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:53 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.