The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   A different Shredder? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=55006)

Panda_Kahn_fan 04-17-2016 03:58 PM

A different Shredder?
 
You know, I was thinking; everyone keeps talking about "when's the Shredder coming back, when's Saki coming back from the dead?" And I noticed in the editor thread Bobby stated they don't want to kill off anyone in this series unless they don't want to bring them back, so I wanted to ask;

What about a different Shredder?

What if a new guy took over as the shredder, someone who had a reason to want revenge on the turtles? No not Karai, she stands as her own character and doesn't hate Yoshi and his sons. No not Ch'rell, he doesn't even know who yoshi is, and the 4kids shredder was not universally well received. No, just a simple member of the foot who was fanatically loyal to shredder, and now wants revenge for his death, just as Yoshi wanted revenge for Tang Shen's. Continuing the cycle of mindless vengeance in the foot.

Then I remembered that nameless foot soldier Splinter scratched way back at the beginning of the series during the stockgen heist. Who may have been the same scarred foot soldier who appeared in the Rapheal Micro (the IDW staff said that wasn't meant to be shredder in disguise, but it could have been interpereted to be him. And also might have been that nameless foot solider who scolded Rocksteady and bebop again in their micro issue; "The master is no one's friend!"

Just saying, just a thought, probably nothing....

CyberCubed 04-17-2016 04:05 PM

I expect Kitsune to revive Shredder as part of the Pantheon and make him a Dragon God. I think that was the whole point of Kitsune's plan with him, although I might be mistaken.

Either that or Ch'rell will masquerade as Shredder for a while, who knows. I also wouldn't mind seeing Raphael take over the Shredder mantle like in the Image comics, which would work since Splinter controls the Foot Clan now.

Blossombrooks 04-17-2016 04:25 PM

A different Shredder would be interesting but I can't see it being someone as far removed as an annoymous foot soldier, no matter the devotion. I agree with Cubed, I think Kitsune has another ace up her sleeve, she is a powerful lady and her true power still feels like it hasn't been fully unleashed.
What about Jennika? Splinter just sent her off to guard Shredder's tomb, what if she succumbs to some outside influence, perhaps Kitsune, and takes on the guise of the Shredder?

Utrommaniac 04-17-2016 05:37 PM

From the way things are being built up, Kitsune is most definitely resurrecting Saki. From the fact that she's had big plans for him for ages, and Splinter setting up a guard for his tomb.

I'm not setting up big hopes for Ch'rell yet, since we've only been given the absolute barest of information about him. If he is to be the next Shredder, then he'd be another viability for Kitsune's Ace. She had operated with Krang for a while, so she very much knows that Utroms exist. Whether she knows if they're actually interdimensional and not 'demons' is up to debate. She might have just called them that for Saki's sake.

ChosenOne 04-17-2016 05:45 PM

Well, if Jennika were to become posessed by Saki somehow, I have a hunch that Splinter would soon be adding a second head to his collection of decapitated Shredders.

As for Saki himself being resurrected, it's only a matter of when. While it would be nice to have him back in time for #100, I still feel there's so much ground to explore before his inevitable return that it would almost be better to wait until #150 (yes, I'm that optimistic but there's no reason to believe this comic can't last that long) and go with other big bads in the meantime.

Like I said elsewhere not too long ago, I'm partial to the idea of a "Shredder War" myself, involving Karai, Ch'rell and Raph, and whoever else IDW decides to bring into the mix, as pretenders to the title and armor that was once Saki's. And that can only happen while he's gone. Nature abhors a vacuum, and all.

Not to mention, I would dearly like to see some more exploration of the stance Yoshi and Saki had towards each other at the time of the latter's death. That was poignant, to say the least, and I feel like most, if not all, of their enmity would now be gone.

That never happened before in any TMNT continuity, and there are plenty of stories there well worth telling. IMHO, at least.

psychturtle 04-17-2016 08:18 PM

They could do a Kylo Ren lol. But seriously, this might be a cool idea. It could be someone who does not respect the culture or art of war. Someone ruthless who even makes the foot feel guilty. Someone who reminds me of Negan. That type of villain would ROCK!

Joey Kamikaze 04-17-2016 08:35 PM

I feel like the idea of someone else taking up the Shredder role has been done before... probably because it has. I suppose IDW might be able to breathe new life into those old bones, but I'd rather the book was free of the focus it had on Shredder the past couple years. Those were great stories, but now I'm ready for some great non-Shredder stories.

To echo common sentiment, the build-up seems to be that Oroku Saki will someday return, in some form. I'm guessing it will happen when the Pantheon story gets to a hot moment. But I hope it's a way off from now.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 04-17-2016 08:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by psychturtle (Post 1570114)
They could do a Kylo Ren lol. But seriously, this might be a cool idea. It could be someone who does not respect the culture or art of war. Someone ruthless who even makes the foot feel guilty. Someone who reminds me of Negan. That type of villain would ROCK!

Negan is a face-melting skull-smashing maniac who drops fifty f-bombs an issue. How exactly do you think IDW is supposed to create a Negan-like character in a T-rated comic? :trolleye:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Joey Kamikaze (Post 1570120)
I feel like the idea of someone else taking up the Shredder role has been done before... probably because it has. I suppose IDW might be able to breathe new life into those old bones, but I'd rather the book was free of the focus it had on Shredder the past couple years. Those were great stories, but now I'm ready for some great non-Shredder stories.

To echo common sentiment, the build-up seems to be that Oroku Saki will someday return, in some form. I'm guessing it will happen when the Pantheon story gets to a hot moment. But I hope it's a way off from now.

I agree with you. As much as I love Raph taking up Shredder's mantle, it's just not gonna work in IDW. Mirage did the "Shredder legacy" story the best, and honestly, I feel like it wouldn't work as well in the IDW stories.

ChosenOne 04-17-2016 09:14 PM

The fact of the matter is, with so many great big bads already in play and a bunch of others possibly cropping up in the very near future, there shouldn't be any rush to bring back Oroku Saki as the Shredder. Ch'rell? Sure, why not. For an arc or two, more as an homage to the 2003 cartoon than anything else.

But with Bishop and the EPF, Stockman, Null, Dunn and the Street Phantoms, Hun on the loose, Hob possibly seeking payback on the Turtles, the Pantheon and whoever else... It's an embarrassment of riches. Heck, I feel like Bishop alone could sustain almost 50 issues of the comic. Didn't he pick up the slack as the big bad for the better part of two seasons in the 2003 cartoon after Ch'rell was finally defeated? No reason he couldn't do the same here.

When I get to thinking about this, I feel like #100 is almost too soon to get closure on the Pantheon arc and a return of Shredder (as the Dragon Warrior or otherwise). But ultimately... In IDW I trust!

psychturtle 04-17-2016 09:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1570121)
Negan is a face-melting skull-smashing maniac who drops fifty f-bombs an issue. How exactly do you think IDW is supposed to create a Negan-like character in a T-rated comic? :trolleye:
.

If you put some mental energy to it, I'm sure you'll figure it out.:twink:

Utrommaniac 04-17-2016 09:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChosenOne (Post 1570126)
Heck, I feel like Bishop alone could sustain almost 50 issues of the comic. Didn't he pick up the slack as the big bad for the better part of two seasons in the 2003 cartoon after Ch'rell was finally defeated? No reason he couldn't do the same here.

Where is Bishop right now, anyway? Just...hanging around outside Burnow?

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1570121)
Negan is a face-melting skull-smashing maniac who drops fifty f-bombs an issue. How exactly do you think IDW is supposed to create a Negan-like character in a T-rated comic? :trolleye:

Grawlixes for the swearing part. I'm honestly a little surprised they didn't use those for Krang on occasion.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 04-17-2016 09:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChosenOne (Post 1570126)
The fact of the matter is, with so many great big bads already in play and a bunch of others possibly cropping up in the very near future, there shouldn't be any rush to bring back Oroku Saki as the Shredder. Ch'rell? Sure, why not. For an arc or two, more as an homage to the 2003 cartoon than anything else.

But with Bishop and the EPF, Stockman, Null, Dunn and the Street Phantoms, Hun on the loose, Hob possibly seeking payback on the Turtles, the Pantheon and whoever else... It's an embarrassment of riches. Heck, I feel like Bishop alone could sustain almost 50 issues of the comic. Didn't he pick up the slack as the big bad for the better part of two seasons in the 2003 cartoon after Ch'rell was finally defeated? No reason he couldn't do the same here.

When I get to thinking about this, I feel like #100 is almost too soon to get closure on the Pantheon arc and a return of Shredder (as the Dragon Warrior or otherwise). But ultimately... In IDW I trust!

I know, right? Bishop is probably the only villain in TMNT who could sustain an entire show; he's right up there with Shredder and Krang. He's got depth and longevity... I want that federal mofo to be a thorn in the Turtles' side for YEARS... :tlol:

Quote:

Originally Posted by psychturtle (Post 1570134)
If you put some mental energy to it, I'm sure you'll figure it out.:twink:

Not an answer, kiddo. YOU put some mental energy to it and tell me what aspects of a hard-R-rated character you want in a teen comic. Negan's an amazing character, but how exactly you do want IDW to water down 90-proof whiskey?

ChosenOne 04-17-2016 10:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Utrommaniac (Post 1570136)
Where is Bishop right now, anyway? Just...hanging around outside Burnow?

Biding his time, I'm sure. That prison jumpsuit of Leatherhead's and the scars all over his upper body surely have an explanation coming, and I bet you a Woody-delivered pizza that it has something to do with Bishop.

Utrommaniac 04-17-2016 10:25 PM

I'm sure the belt could have been from Bishop as well. It's most certainly alien in design, and might have been from Bishop's artifact collection.

The question becomes, though...why did he not get those off after escaping from Bishop - if he did indeed do so. Did he just...feel that he needed pants and kept them?

ChosenOne 04-17-2016 10:55 PM

Indeed, there's much more to Leatherhead than meets the eye. I can't wait for further revelations about his past and motivations in the next two issues.

As for a Negan-like character, well... I'm not too familiar with other incarnations of TMNT, but one character I feel would lend itself well to that sort of personality makeover would be an IDW version of Trap from TMNT Adventures. I can picture it already, and it's a glorious thing. 8)

Maybe without the F-bombs, though... Just some classic comic cursing would do!

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 04-17-2016 11:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChosenOne (Post 1570150)
Indeed, there's much more to Leatherhead than meets the eye. I can't wait for further revelations about his past and motivations in the next two issues.

As for a Negan-like character, well... I'm not too familiar with other incarnations of TMNT, but one character I feel would lend itself well to that sort of personality makeover would be an IDW version of Trap from TMNT Adventures. I can picture it already, and it's a glorious thing. 8)

Maybe without the F-bombs, though... Just some classic comic cursing would do!

I dunno, I really don't see it: Negan is memorable for extreme violence, something that IDW can only do in VERY limited amounts (Exhibit A, Donatello at the hands of Rocksteady and Bebop, Exhibit B, Splinter decapitating Shredder) and his outrageous vocabulary. Take both of those away, and it's not Negan... it might be a very well written shrewd opportunistic gang leader, but that's it.

ChosenOne 04-17-2016 11:20 PM

If memory serves, Trap was the very first character to use a gun in TMNT Adventures, to put down one of Maligna's henchmen, no less. It was a pretty startling moment when I first read it as a kid and it still stands out after all these years, especially considering how one of the Turtles in his immediate vicinity reacts to the gunshot. That's the hallmark of someone who employs extreme violence, even if he's fighting the good fight; no reason a guy can't be Negan-like and still be on the side of the angels. An anti-hero, really.

Utrommaniac 04-17-2016 11:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChosenOne (Post 1570150)
Maybe without the F-bombs, though... Just some classic comic cursing would do!

They've done some "normal" swearing. Your "damn/Hell/crap" typicalities, but Krang pushed the line to "bastard", and I don't think it's gone much further than that. He's...quite the swearing aficionado. "Damn" in some variety, three times in the spread of two pages, probably in the span of a minute or so. Something about that amuses me.

If they really, really have to push it beyond "bastard", it might have to take grawlixes, like I said before. #$%^!!!

ChosenOne 04-17-2016 11:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Utrommaniac (Post 1570154)
They've done some "normal" swearing. Your "damn/Hell/crap" typicalities, but Krang pushed the line to "bastard", and I don't think it's gone much further than that. He's...quite the swearing aficionado. "Damn" in some variety, three times in the spread of two pages, probably in the span of a minute or so. Something about that amuses me.

If they really, really have to push it beyond "bastard", it might have to take grawlixes, like I said before. #$%^!!!

I love Negan to death, but I do feel like F-bombs are mostly unnecessary to the telling of a good story. It fits the world of The Walking Dead but would be an absolute disaster on most other properties, and the same goes for more "extreme" curse words as well. None of the ones you mentioned are really that severe, at least in my opinion, and are more than enough and appropriate for what they're required to convey. Anything else is just overkill.

But yeah, no surprise there that a ruthless centuries-old general who routinely tears people's throats out with his teeth would be fond of swearing. :lol:

Utrommaniac 04-18-2016 12:06 AM

It wouldn't really fit the tone either; and then you have the fact that the series is basically PG-13 material, so they wouldn't be crossing that line, anyway.

Allio 04-18-2016 12:38 AM

I could imagine Ch'rell taking on the form of Shredder, pretending as if Saki was resurrected

to only have Saki be resurrected as the demon shredder.

ChosenOne 04-18-2016 08:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Utrommaniac (Post 1570164)
It wouldn't really fit the tone either; and then you have the fact that the series is basically PG-13 material, so they wouldn't be crossing that line, anyway.

Indeed it wouldn't. The only compromise I could ever imagine possible would be to take a more farcical character (such as Trap) and have him comic cursing. This would never work on Krang or any other "serious" character, though.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Allio (Post 1570173)
I could imagine Ch'rell taking on the form of Shredder, pretending as if Saki was resurrected

to only have Saki be resurrected as the demon shredder.

Yes, please! Can you imagine if Ch'rell plagues the Turtles as the Shredder for a couple of arcs, only to then have the real one pop back up and take him down with very little effort? What a glorious cliffhanger that would be!

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 04-18-2016 09:50 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Panda_Kahn_fan (Post 1570226)
Don't care about the off-topic cursing/trap stuff here, but I really, really hope they don't bring Saki back like everyone thinks they will. Bobby said dead means dead, and if the one meaningful death we've had is undone, well...this comic will really drop in my eyes. I'd even rather have C'hrell become shredder, than have 'Saki come back'. But we'll see what happens.

Considering all of the "I will see you again" between Saki and Kitsune, and the unfulfilled "Dragon Warrior" stuff that has been alluded to in Secret History of the Foot Clan, you know IDW is bringing Saki back.

They've got a plan and I trust them; this isn't just some cheap "NOW THEY'RE DEAD!" and then "NOW THEY'RE BACK!" trick from DC or Marvel.

Looking at YOU, Robo-Bats. :tlol:

Panda_Kahn_fan 04-18-2016 09:58 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1570234)
Considering all of the "I will see you again" between Saki and Kitsune, and the unfulfilled "Dragon Warrior" stuff that has been alluded to in Secret History of the Foot Clan, you know IDW is bringing Saki back.

They've got a plan and I trust them; this isn't just some cheap "NOW THEY'RE DEAD!" and then "NOW THEY'RE BACK!" trick from DC or Marvel.

Looking at YOU, Robo-Bats. :tlol:


Oh, I have no doubt it won't be a cheap trick if IDW brings him back. Heck, I half expect him to become the lord of Hades like we saw in his micro issue. But that isn't bringing him back to life. I don't want to see the emotional impact of issue 50 undone just to have Saki alive again just because fans want him as the main villian.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 04-18-2016 10:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Panda_Kahn_fan (Post 1570237)
Oh, I have no doubt it won't be a cheap trick if IDW brings him back. Heck, I half expect him to become the lord of Hades like we saw in his micro issue. But that isn't bringing him back to life. I don't want to see the emotional impact of issue 50 undone just to have Saki alive again just because fans want him as the main villian.

So... curious, to you, what's the difference between "bringing him back to life" and resurrecting him as the Dragon Warrior? A little confused.

And I'm fairly confident we'll see that Shredder micro-issue touched on again... it was just a little too off-the-wall to be a "this happened and now we shall never speak of it again" thing. :tlol:

Yeah, I'd much prefer Saki not be the big bad himself again in TMNT. He served his role, and now when he does come back, it will be as a greater part of the (by then much more prominent and dire) Pantheon situation.

Let's see Bishop, Null, and Krang get more spotlight now. And keep Krang in prison for quite awhile longer...

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 04-18-2016 10:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Panda_Kahn_fan (Post 1570250)
Ok, here's the thing... the dramatic moment in issue fifty-the seppaku, the farewell between childhood friends, that's the most powerful moment in the entire series (along with the execution scene of Yoshi and his family in issue 5). I don't want to see that undone. Reincarnate him a new body, bring him back as a souless undead corpse, or heck even make him a bodiless spirit. But don't bring him back as a living Saki/Shredder.

Well, this is how I see it. Saki was a pawn to the Pantheon even before he was born. He still doesn't know he was Kitsune's plaything.

Don't you want to see him finally come to that realization and turn his wrath against the Pantheon? To truly find redemption, and to side with Splinter and the Turtles against these would-be gods who have controlled him since before he was born?

THAT, my friend, will be just as awesome. And I'm 100% sure that's what we'll get.

Panda_Kahn_fan 04-18-2016 10:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1570254)
Well, this is how I see it. Saki was a pawn to the Pantheon even before he was born. He still doesn't know he was Kitsune's plaything.

Don't you want to see him finally come to that realization and turn his wrath against the Pantheon? To truly find redemption, and to side with Splinter and the Turtles against these would-be gods who have controlled him since before he was born?

THAT, my friend, will be just as awesome. And I'm 100% sure that's what we'll get.

All I can say is, I'll just have to sit back, wait, and see how things play out. Who knows? Maybe we''ll get a worm-clone again! XD

phillytmnt 04-18-2016 11:01 AM

I would like to see a redeemed Saki come back to life and fight the pantheon with the turtles. Saki was a pawn of Kitsune his whole life and it would be cool to seem him help the TMNT and get revenge.

Someone mentioned it before but I could see Saki getting resurrected in a new form like the Dragon Lord. I think one way or another, Saki is coming back.

psychturtle 04-19-2016 09:09 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1570254)
Well, this is how I see it. Saki was a pawn to the Pantheon even before he was born. He still doesn't know he was Kitsune's plaything.

Don't you want to see him finally come to that realization and turn his wrath against the Pantheon? To truly find redemption, and to side with Splinter and the Turtles against these would-be gods who have controlled him since before he was born?

THAT, my friend, will be just as awesome. And I'm 100% sure that's what we'll get.

That actually sounds predictable and shallow. I'd expect something a little more in depth than this. He isn't necessarily a guy out for redemption. That why he's a great villian. Why mess that up?

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan 04-21-2016 03:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChosenOne (Post 1570153)
If memory serves, Trap was the very first character to use a gun in TMNT Adventures, to put down one of Maligna's henchmen, no less. It was a pretty startling moment when I first read it as a kid and it still stands out after all these years, especially considering how one of the Turtles in his immediate vicinity reacts to the gunshot. That's the hallmark of someone who employs extreme violence, even if he's fighting the good fight; no reason a guy can't be Negan-like and still be on the side of the angels. An anti-hero, really.

The turtles themselves have no problems of using guns on their vehicles...

ChosenOne 04-21-2016 04:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Original TMNT Cartoon Fan (Post 1571374)
The turtles themselves have no problems of using guns on their vehicles...

That arguably depends on the specific incarnation of the comic/cartoon. The Archie Turtles had a notorious dislike for firearms.

Redeemer 04-21-2016 04:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Allio (Post 1570173)
I could imagine Ch'rell taking on the form of Shredder, pretending as if Saki was resurrected

to only have Saki be resurrected as the demon shredder.

That would be awesome! Then Ch'rell shredder would follow/team up with Krang.
A 87' style partnership.

I would love to see demon shredder, but not OP like he was in 2k3

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1570254)
Well, this is how I see it. Saki was a pawn to the Pantheon even before he was born. He still doesn't know he was Kitsune's plaything.

Don't you want to see him finally come to that realization and turn his wrath against the Pantheon? To truly find redemption, and to side with Splinter and the Turtles against these would-be gods who have controlled him since before he was born?

THAT, my friend, will be just as awesome. And I'm 100% sure that's what we'll get.

I would love to see that as well!!!

Utrommaniac 04-21-2016 04:48 PM

You know...that probably would be the best way to resurrect the Krang-Shredder partnership. Shredder would have to be another Utrom for it to work more sufficiently. Complete with Shredder trying to undermine Krang, even if it's not really the best idea in the long run.

Cryomancer 04-21-2016 06:58 PM

Reincarnate Saki as a newborn Shadow. Take the themes to their extremes.

No knowing right away or fast aging, either.

ChosenOne 04-21-2016 07:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cryomancer (Post 1571429)
Reincarnate Saki as a newborn Shadow. Take the themes to their extremes.

No knowing right away or fast aging, either.

How very Soma Cruz. 8) I dig it.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:56 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.