The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   4Kids TMNT Cartoon Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=11)
-   -   Is Shredder a Tengu? (A Japanese Goblin) (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=5596)

Aztec General 10-12-2003 10:44 AM

Is Shredder a Tengu? (A Japanese Goblin)
 
http://www.onmarkproductions.com/html/tengu.shtml

Check out the really cool webiste above. It says speaks about mythical Japanese goblins known as Tengu. They are describe essentially as evil monsters or trouble makers. Read the whole description, it's fascinating.

Now, why would Shredder in the new series be a Tengu? Well, he appears to be immortal/invulnerable (he's lived for hundreds of years apparently and he seems to be able to survive anything), he's monstrous (beyond human in some capacity), and he seems to be the original owner of THE SWORD OF TENGU!

Could 2K3 Shredder be a Japanese demon? This could explain the magical abilities of some of his highest ranking followers: the Mystic Ninja and the Elite Ninja. This is interesting indeed. I can't wait to find out more.

Jephael 10-12-2003 10:45 AM

Now there's an interesting theory!

Stefano 10-12-2003 10:50 AM

id rather have him a tengu than an utrom. In darkness on the edge of town he gets pissed at hun and baxter in the beginning and he like flies over to them and grabs them. also in the shredder strikes part 1 he disapears in the shaddow in front of leonardo.

Mecha Cow 10-12-2003 11:07 AM

Interesting theory. If Shredder were to be a demon it would make him even more of an ultimate villain. It would certainly make a lot more sense than him being an Utrom.

J Legault 10-12-2003 11:52 AM

So that's what Tengu means?

I have to agree with this threoy that Oroku Saki is some how a Japanese Demon in Human form.

I know there's ways that he can't be a Utrom. He has Material Arts that are too good to be a Largege Brain in a Humanoid Body.

So I guess He's a Tengu with out the long nose in some of those pictures.

This remeinds me of Kappas a Japenese Demon as well.

Dane E5R 10-12-2003 11:57 AM

I think tengu are mostly bird-like.. Uh.. I'd say oni would be a better choice. But nah, I think it was just the armor that kept him alive.

Shellfox 10-12-2003 11:58 AM

for a minute I thought this was about the big black birds from Power Rangers :lol:

Anyway, interesting theroy, but kid show and Demon, doesn't seem like teh best match in this day and age

Aztec General 10-12-2003 12:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shellfox
Anyway, interesting theroy, but kid show and Demon, doesn't seem like teh best match in this day and age

Oh? And kid show and decapitation is a good match? This show has clearly shown that it will not allow itself to be considered typical kid show garbage. So I see no problem with Shredder turning out to be a demon.

I like this theory. Shredder being a demon is a damn cool idea. If you consider the nature of the Foot (especially Elite and Mystic Ninjas) in this series it's quite possible. Besides his magic sword is called the SWORD OF TENGU. There's got to be a connection there.

Another plausible theory is that Shredder's armor is alive even though HE was killed. Perhaps the Sword of Tengu revitalized his Utrom armored suit? In that way Saki is no more, but his suit lives on? I'm not saying I buy it, but it is plausible.

And can we stop this Shredder is an Utrom business? That was one poster's opinion, who posted it as if it were a fact. That's implausible for many reasons. Not to mention I can't understand why so many people believed that poster.

As of now, I'm liking this Tengu theory. We'll see I suppose.

Kid Icarus 10-12-2003 12:14 PM

If thats the case, why do the Swords of Tengu (there were two of them) have Utroms on the handles?

Don't get me wrong, this is a cool theory, I just don't see this show getting so complicated that it ties in Japanese mythology to the story line. *shrug*.

Aztec General 10-12-2003 12:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gwgtrunks
Don't get me wrong, this is a cool theory, I just don't see this show getting so complicated that it ties in Japanese mythology to the story line. *shrug*.

Umm.... the mystic ninjas clearly involve mythology.

TheShredder 10-12-2003 12:56 PM

Umm.... how? When do mystic ninjas appear in mythology?

Aaron 10-12-2003 01:54 PM

Hmmmm...interesting.

PanMan 10-12-2003 02:16 PM

there is only one sword of tengu. the other one on the toy could just be a gimmick. i'm not completely ruling out the idea that there's another, but so far, it seems to be that there is only one.

and whoever said that saki disappeared infront of leo, i think it was just to show off his ninja skills, as being far superior to that of leo.

Shellfox 10-12-2003 02:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rat King
Quote:

Originally Posted by Shellfox
Anyway, interesting theroy, but kid show and Demon, doesn't seem like teh best match in this day and age

Oh? And kid show and decapitation is a good match? This show has clearly shown that it will not allow itself to be considered typical kid show garbage. So I see no problem with Shredder turning out to be a demon.

still its saturday morning cartoon, and the idea of using demons is going to be slim, in recent histroy the only sat show I can think of that did this was Batman. Honestly parents got pissed cause Darkwing duck had a pentagram in the opening, makinga demon a full on bad guy probly wouldn't cut it in todays PC world. If this were a prime time show maybe, but not a morning show, a ghost or other mystic creature maybe, but the word demon will probly never be used.

Parents scream satanic inflences at Harry Potter imagine what they'd say to a demon

Kid Icarus 10-12-2003 02:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PanMan
there is only one sword of tengu. the other one on the toy could just be a gimmick. i'm not completely ruling out the idea that there's another, but so far, it seems to be that there is only one.

and whoever said that saki disappeared infront of leo, i think it was just to show off his ninja skills, as being far superior to that of leo.

Actually, if you watch Darkness on the Edge of town again, there were two. One was destroyed I think.

Eye of Sarnath 10-12-2003 03:04 PM

That's a very interesting idea, one that I like. I think it's entirely plausible. They don't necesarrily have to call him a demon... he could just be an evil spirit creature or what have you...


Think about these:
Quote:

shape-shifting into human or animal forms
Quote:

magic of moving instantly from place to place without using their wings
Quote:

patron of martial arts
Quote:

a skilled warrior
Shredder CAN'T be a Utrom... they sit the stomach of robot suits, correct? Well, we've seen Shredder without his shirt, and guess what? No big hole in his stomach.

Cascadia 10-12-2003 03:18 PM

not quite sure what my say is in this theory.

King Kahn 10-12-2003 03:40 PM

i am still puzzled by the headless shredderman picking up his melon and walking off. i suppose that the worms are one theory but i just have to meditate on it for awhile. i did also think he could be a Utrom. i guess we'll have to wait. i do like the demon angle however.

Machias Banshee 10-12-2003 03:42 PM

Re: Is Shredder a Tengu? (A Japanese Goblin)
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Rat King
http://www.onmarkproductions.com/html/tengu.shtml

Check out the really cool webiste above. It says speaks about mythical Japanese goblins known as Tengu. They are describe essentially as evil monsters or trouble makers. Read the whole description, it's fascinating.

Now, why would Shredder in the new series be a Tengu? Well, he appears to be immortal/invulnerable (he's lived for hundreds of years apparently and he seems to be able to survive anything), he's monstrous (beyond human in some capacity), and he seems to be the original owner of THE SWORD OF TENGU!

Could 2K3 Shredder be a Japanese demon? This could explain the magical abilities of some of his highest ranking followers: the Mystic Ninja and the Elite Ninja. This is interesting indeed. I can't wait to find out more.

Wow, thats really interesting. I guess maybe the writers are trying to make things seem more historically 'accurate' among other things. I had thought Tengu was jsut a made up name. Guess we'll have to keep an eye out on more historical stuff in the future eps...!


And whoever said the Ninja Turtles weren't educational..? ;) :D

Shellfox 10-12-2003 04:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Eye of Sarnath
Shredder CAN'T be a Utrom... they sit the stomach of robot suits, correct? Well, we've seen Shredder without his shirt, and guess what? No big hole in his stomach.

that is unless you subscibe to teh beliefe of Synthetic skin coving the external form

Still evel spirt is an interesting concept

Eye of Sarnath 10-12-2003 04:53 PM

Quote:

that is unless you subscibe to teh beliefe of Synthetic skin coving the external form
Possible, yes. I don't particuarly like that idea though. I think the idea of a demon/evil spirit is great. Most likely though is it has something to do with aliens/extraterrestrial technologoy.

Stefano 10-12-2003 06:37 PM

shredder has red eyes and tengu are supposed to be bird like? What if the foot symbol is like a tengu claw. Perhaps

lhb412 10-12-2003 07:00 PM

Okay, heres the kicker that disproves the Shredder is an Utrom theory:

If Shredder is a brain-like alien in a robotic suit, then how can he have clones that are humanoid? Mutated, but most certainly humanoid, and besides Shredder doesn't seem to have any technological know-how.

BTW I love the Demon Shredder theory, although I just thing he's some sort of immortal human.

PanMan 10-12-2003 07:28 PM

i'm not too excited about this demon theory. i would like it much better if he was human but got powerful somehow.

however, i will reserve my judgement until they actually explain it.

and when did they show two swords of tengu? was it in the museum when they stole it, or somewhere else in the show? can you be more specific?

Stefano 10-12-2003 07:34 PM

i think there was only one. I dont remeber anyone saying or seeing the second sword besides the toys

TheShredder 10-12-2003 09:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lhb412
If Shredder is a brain-like alien in a robotic suit, then how can he have clones that are humanoid? Mutated, but most certainly humanoid, and besides Shredder doesn't seem to have any technological know-how.

Yes but I ask you why did the clones come out in full armor? They could be robots.

Eye of Sarnath 10-12-2003 09:30 PM

Or maybe they just had armor made for them... I don't know.

Kid Icarus 10-12-2003 09:33 PM

well, they couldent' have nudity on saturday morning cartoons really...

and i'm pretty sure they had armor in the comics too.

Valorxii 10-13-2003 12:17 AM

utroms are brain things right?

you know whatd be stupid. if krang was the utrom inside shredder. :sick:

Tetsu Deinonychus 10-13-2003 01:57 AM

First off they probably could say Demon because Tengu do not belong to a belief system that includes Satan, so there would be no satan connection. Also because they said demon in the old-cartoon's time-travel episode and all through the third movie. (And, Ghostbusters and 1960s episodes of Scooby-Doo also had no fear of the D-word!)

I'm rather fond of a supernatural-connection to Shredder, but some kind of Undead-Human (perhaps a flat-out ghost) is more my theory.

Also, alot of the focus seems to be shifting towards the supernatural, with the Mystic-Ninja and the Sword being described as a "potent combination of science and sorcery" they MUST be going SOMEWHERE with that.

Shellfox 10-13-2003 05:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lhb412
If Shredder is a brain-like alien in a robotic suit, then how can he have clones that are humanoid? Mutated, but most certainly humanoid, and besides Shredder doesn't seem to have any technological know-how.

maybe I just forgot, but I don't recall them ever saying the clones were of shredder, I don't recall them ever being called CLONES by anyone save the turtles, and they don't really count since they had no proff other than teh armor. Its possible they where made from hun

Quiller-Bee 10-13-2003 05:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shellfox
Quote:

Originally Posted by lhb412
If Shredder is a brain-like alien in a robotic suit, then how can he have clones that are humanoid? Mutated, but most certainly humanoid, and besides Shredder doesn't seem to have any technological know-how.

maybe I just forgot, but I don't recall them ever saying the clones were of shredder, I don't recall them ever being called CLONES by anyone save the turtles, and they don't really count since they had no proff other than teh armor. Its possible they where made from hun

Nah, no disrespect, but they're most likely genetic clones of Shredder as we've been lead to believe. My reasons for thinking this are 1.) As we all know, the show is loosely based on the Mirage comics, where they were indeed clones of the Shredder; 2.) The official names for the action figures seem to include the terms "Shredder" and "Clone", and 3.) They resemble the Shredder—armor and all—so that they'll be readily identified by the audience as clones of him.

I'm not saying that any other possibility is impossible, but it most likely just "is what it is". Personally, I don't think the writers would overcomplicate the clone issue.

HorseTechie 10-13-2003 12:57 PM

I said it in the RTNY thread, and I'll say it again here. WOw... awesome theroy. Just when I thought I knew everything about TMNT, something knew comes up.

And this tengu concept is also giving me many more plot bunny ideas for this fanfic I'm working on too... :D

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gwgtrunks
well, they couldent' have nudity on saturday morning cartoons really...

and i'm pretty sure they had armor in the comics too.

Heh.. I find this funny, since I see quite a bit of partial nudity on Ultimate muscle and Cramp Twins. Running around in skivvies at the least!

gobo 10-13-2003 03:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Eye of Sarnath
Well, we've seen Shredder without his shirt, and guess what? No big hole in his stomach.

I happen to remember the ep where Saki removed his shirt, but his mid-section was all bandaged, right? On the very iffy theory that Shredder is an Utrom, I'm dreading the possibility that Laird somehow caved to SOME people's demand to see characters from the old show, and allowed the writers to make Saki actually be Krang, the rogue Utrom who created a more mobile android body. That'd make this a very short-lived series, wouldn't it? :ohwell:

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gwgtrunks
well, they couldent' have nudity on saturday morning cartoons really...

Ahem... Quarry's boobies weren't dangling in the wind? I sure thought that was what they were implying in that ep.
Besides that, loin cloths would have made more believable garb for creatures who are supposed to be freshly genetically engineered. Likely, the world may never know what they were actually supposed to be.
But, I'm digging that Tengu theory. I doubt it's quite so simple an explanation though. After all, even the GUARDIANS left the scene acting as if Saki had been defeated for good.

Quote:

Originally Posted by TetsuDeinonychus
First off they probably could say Demon because Tengu do not belong to a belief system that includes Satan, so there would be no satan connection.

Satan isn't involved with any of the Harry Potter beasts either. But, there's not much to worry about in as much as there has been shockingly mature content in the show for a while now, and I haven't heard of anyone complaining.

Last thing: wouldn't a demon at least spill some bile when getting its head sliced off? Deep thoughts...

jeff the cheff 10-13-2003 07:55 PM

There are so many theories about shredder!! I dont really know what i believe it is, but of course theres something going on with the whole "Im shredder and i can walk without my head" thing. At first i thought it was stupid that shredder picked up his head...but after really thinking its getting me so interested!

lhb412 10-13-2003 08:15 PM

Just because he had the "bandages" (I put it in quotes because I know there must be some martial-arts term for those things) on his stomach doesn't mean he's hiding something.

Heck, in the original comics Foot Soldiers allways had those on, and now that I remember: Shredder did too! In costume and when he took off his Shredder suit in RTNY part 3!

jeff the cheff 10-13-2003 08:32 PM

he took off his uniform in rtny 3?

Stefano 10-13-2003 08:39 PM

yeah i think i saw it at ninjaturtles.com look at the illustation of that comic

tOkKa 10-14-2003 03:50 AM

-->> :P ..flappin' in the wind!!

http://www.x-entertainment.com/pics3/pr24.jpg
..Saki is kinda beaky.. just like a Tengu..


..come on.. lookit' his beaky shnozz..

.. that honker's gotta be that of a tengu!!
















.. :-? ok well..maybe not.. but still he's beaky.. i'd know.. cuz..i am..

heretic888 10-14-2003 11:39 AM

hmmm
 
A very interesting theory... and it may have some validity, also. Still, I don't know if I like the idea of an "unkillable" Shredder.

Interestingly enough, however, ninja are commonly associated as "controlling" and "defeating" tengu in Japanese mythology. Some say they are even descendents of tengu.

Oh, and yes, contrary to what someone said, most references to ninja in Japanese literature and legends portray them as warrior-sorcerers with demonic overtones. So, a 'mystic ninja' is indeed mythologically relevant.

The history they spurted about "laying waste to villages" to empower the Tokugawa family is also humorous. Not historically accurate at all. Ninja did not "lay waste to villages", they were mostly spies, bodyguards, and secret police for the Tokugawa shogunate.

The Guardians are cited as "yamabushi" on one of the cards. Shredder may be a "tengu". Leo even mentions Miyamato Mushasi. It appears some research went into this show....

Not enough, though, I'm afraid. I don't mind them going all mythical or alieny... but there's no real Ninpo here. That's what I'd like to see. Not tae-kwon-do with shuriken and a little bushido garbage thrown in.

Oh well, just my thoughts. Laterz.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:35 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.