The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Aspects that you like or dislike from both Mirage and IDW (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=57562)

LeotheLateBloomer 03-16-2017 07:20 AM

Aspects that you like or dislike from both Mirage and IDW
 
I know there are some who prefer one over the other but despite my love for Mirage, I've have read only some of IDW. I wish to read more of it. There are somethings that I like but also some stuff that I just cannot get passed. I'll eventually post what I think about both overall whenever I get around to reading more of the latter.

What are some of the aspects you like from both Mirage and IDW, aspects you dislike, stuff you wished they did more or less of. It doesn't have to be super detailed It can be something simple like the stories, the characters, anything. And then end it off with which one do you overall prefer and why?

ToTheNines 03-16-2017 07:31 AM

Volume 4 had its obvious problems. Plus Pete never finished the dang thing.

Tales Volume 2 produced some great stories, but I'd say they coulda toned down the constant Jim Lawson and Steve Murphy. I say that as a big fan of both of them, just always enjoyed when they showcased new/unique talent. Pretty annoying how they frigged around and never let Tristan Jones really get into his arc until it was too late.

Other than that Mirage was tops. Maybe coulda used more Farley and Zulli, less Hedden and McWeeney during the guest era.

As for IDW, it feels a little more organic now that we have 2 ongoing books, but I wish they'd be a little more avant-garde with their story telling and not be so enslaved to the TPB format. But hey, they have a model and it's their best selling book.

Oh, and they need to go back to all red bandanas. Especially now that pretty much everyone follows Santolouco's design and gives them all different height/build/facial features.

CyberCubed 03-16-2017 07:53 AM

Mirage guest era was a bit hit or miss, and Volume 2 was ok but rushed. Volume 4 is...well...Volume 4. I liked the better parts of it but Pete's writing is all over the place.

Most of Tales was pretty good. Each issue wasn't necessarily exciting, but it was nice to read one-shot stories and a few multiparters. It really fleshed out the Mirage universe since in Tales they went on all sorts of adventures they never went on in the main series.

Also Mirage has almost no rogues gallery outside Savanti. Almost every villain was one and done or got killed in their first or second appearances. Shredder, Rat King, Baxter, etc. were all short-lived, as was Karai as a villain and the Triceratons really. Leatherhead also was an uneasy ally in most issues besides the ones he went crazy in.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 03-16-2017 09:46 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 1668013)
Volume 4 had its obvious problems. Plus Pete never finished the dang thing.

Tales Volume 2 produced some great stories, but I'd say they coulda toned down the constant Jim Lawson and Steve Murphy. I say that as a big fan of both of them, just always enjoyed when they showcased new/unique talent. Pretty annoying how they frigged around and never let Tristan Jones really get into his arc until it was too late.

Other than that Mirage was tops. Maybe coulda used more Farley and Zulli, less Hedden and McWeeney during the guest era.

As for IDW, it feels a little more organic now that we have 2 ongoing books, but I wish they'd be a little more avant-garde with their story telling and not be so enslaved to the TPB format. But hey, they have a model and it's their best selling book.

Oh, and they need to go back to all red bandanas. Especially now that pretty much everyone follows Santolouco's design and gives them all different height/build/facial features.

Damn, TTN listed all my stuff.

Volume 4 needed serious rewriting, focus, and direction.

Tales Volume 2 needed to focus on their multi-part stories and actually finish them.

Volume 3 needed to not crossover with so many Image characters.

IDW is a slave to the trade paperback. Which is nice in some regards, but also a little irksome when a new story arc is just starting up.

Volume 1 needed to not take a year or three off for weird wacky nonsensical guest era issues. Some quality control, is what I'm saying.

Volume 2 needed to not have Casey brainwashed into thinking he was Arnie Schwartz.

Icegaze 03-16-2017 11:35 AM

I will start by saying I have an obvious bias for the IDW series over Mirage as I never had the opportunity (or will) to truly delve into the original (source material) comics.

Things I didn't like about the TMNT Mirage series:
1. The art style (not just the design, as I love the way the turtles were drawn in the first few chapters) but more about the ink work and other details (or lack thereof).
2. Most plots post Shredder/Foot clan. Didn't give them much of a chance to be honest.

Things I don't like about the TMNT IDW series:
1. Character design inconsistencies (I don't mind having different artists sharing the workload, but I still cannot get over how drastically different the turtles or Alopex look depending who draws them).
2. *Potential spoilers* I may change my mind on them, but for now, I'm not a huge fan of the Pantheon (supernatural beings such as Kitsune) or should I say, of their involvement with the plot.

Anything else would be extremely subjective and "petty". ;p

All in all, I'm so thrilled we get the best of all the "worlds" of TMNT with IDW.

CyberCubed 03-16-2017 01:43 PM

Turtles designs changed pretty drastically under Mirage artists as well, but I like seeing all the different artists takes on the Turtles. Each artists has their own unique style to make their TMNT stand out.

plastroncafe 03-16-2017 01:56 PM

Mirage:

I've always really disliked the lack of a firm timeline/story bible.
I mean, I get why there isn't one, but that doesn't mean I have to be entirely happy about it.

Not always happy with the portrayal of female characters, but as it was the 80s...again, so product of its time.

IDW:

I'm acknowledging right out of the gate that I'm several story-arcs behind.
Basically I've fallen off since Don got put into Metalhead.
I find IDW's greatest sin is that it relies a bit too much on Telling, rather than Showing.

Also that it's racing to get to the next plot point, and dragging me along with it. Because of that I haven't really connected with the characters.

Andrew NDB 03-16-2017 02:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by plastroncafe (Post 1668121)
Also that it's racing to get to the next plot point, and dragging me along with it. Because of that I haven't really connected with the characters.

That's kind of how I left off with it. Racing to get to the next plot, dragging me along while dangling carrots of Fred Wolf stuff in front of me.

You know, little tidbits like "Look, the Technodrome is coming soon!!! Hang in there!!" But I don't want to see the Technodrome. It all just sort of leaves me flat.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 03-16-2017 02:11 PM

Pacing usually hasn't been an issue for me with IDW, except for rushing through Donatello trapped inside Metalhead.

The no-killing issue bugs me, though, especially regarding City Fall and Dark Leo.

Andrew NDB 03-16-2017 02:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1668125)
The no-killing issue bugs me, though, especially regarding City Fall and Dark Leo.

Yeah, that undermined the whole story. "Look how DARK Leo has gone and how conflicted he is... ALMOST killing Slash!!" or whatever.

Obviously not IDW's fault, but it's still their tree.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 03-16-2017 02:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1668126)
Yeah, that undermined the whole story. "Look how DARK Leo has gone and how conflicted he is... ALMOST killing Slash!!" or whatever.

Obviously not IDW's fault, but it's still their tree.

... Tree?

Andrew NDB 03-16-2017 02:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1668130)
... Tree?


Jester 03-16-2017 02:40 PM

Is it all comics now days or just IDW's TMNT that does the whole start a quote on one page...

Jester 03-16-2017 02:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jester
...only to finish it on the next page.

Because that really bugs me...it's practically every page. And when you read multiple issues back to back after missing some, it's glaring.

ToTheNines 03-16-2017 03:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1668035)
Volume 2 needed to not have Casey brainwashed into thinking he was Arnie Schwartz.

Casey didn't bring anything to that story either way. I just ignore his word bubbles lol.

Quote:

Originally Posted by plastroncafe (Post 1668121)
IDW:

I'm acknowledging right out of the gate that I'm several story-arcs behind.
Basically I've fallen off since Don got put into Metalhead.
I find IDW's greatest sin is that it relies a bit too much on Telling, rather than Showing.

Also that it's racing to get to the next plot point, and dragging me along with it. Because of that I haven't really connected with the characters.

Ah man. That wasn't the best arc overall. But you're doing yourself a great disservice by not finishing that one. #50 was righteous.

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1668125)
especially regarding City Fall and Dark Leo.

That was bunk. They could have just not even addressed it and left it to our imaginations.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 03-16-2017 03:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 1668140)
Casey didn't bring anything to that story either way. I just ignore his word bubbles lol.

Ah man. That wasn't the best arc overall. But you're doing yourself a great disservice by not finishing that one. #50 was righteous.

That was bunk. They could have just not even addressed it and left it to our imaginations.

And Nobody was just there as cannon fodder. :tlol: Not that I cared... never liked that character.

CyberCubed 03-16-2017 03:20 PM

Seems to me that Viacom relaxed their hold on IDW since the Cityfall story arc, now that we're seeing things like Darius murdered right in front of the Turtles, or the violence with Slash attacking the Mutanimals.

If the Cityfall arc happened NOW for example instead of back in 2013 or when it originally came out, it probably would have had on-screen deaths.

Andrew NDB 03-16-2017 03:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1668147)
Seems to me that Viacom relaxed their hold on IDW since the Cityfall story arc, now that we're seeing things like Darius murdered right in front of the Turtles, or the violence with Slash attacking the Mutanimals.

If the Cityfall arc happened NOW for example instead of back in 2013 or when it originally came out, it probably would have had on-screen deaths.

Nah. Nickelodeon has always been OK with on-page blood and killing to some extent... as long as it's not the Turtles themselves doing it. That's where they draw the line, always have. The Turtles killing might hurt their ability to sell TMNT lunchboxes, or whatever, is probably the general mentality.

Although I wouldn't be surprised if -- hypothetically -- one month, IDW sends in a comic for approval from Nickelodeon, and it "passes" with no problems, then 3 months later they could send the exact same comic in for approval from Nickelodeon, and it suddenly gets "fix it" notes. Or vice versa.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 03-16-2017 03:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1668148)
Nah. Nickelodeon has always been OK with on-page blood and killing to some extent... as long as it's not the Turtles themselves doing it. That's where they draw the line, always have.

Yep. This. Which is weird when you consider that they seem to be okay with SPLINTER doing killings...

Eh, whatever. :trolleye::tgrumble:

We'll never see Turtles killing their enemies ever again. That was a Mirage exclusive.

Andrew NDB 03-16-2017 03:30 PM

The beginning of every Nickelodeon board meeting:

http://www.kpba.org/wp-content/uploa...ot-560x400.jpg

"Repeat after me, the Ninja Turtles like to eat pizza, they don't like to kill their enemies..."

***First of Two Latin Kings*** 03-16-2017 05:06 PM

The dark haired girl has a nice shape.

What was this thread about again?

spookycookies 03-16-2017 07:28 PM

My only complaint for IDW is the Casey & April mini-series that was the only bump I've felt in the road so far. Besides being really decompressed to the point where very little happened, it also took 2 important supporting characters away from Issue 50 that had both been around since #1.

But I'm over it.

I think every incarnation of the TMNT has had a problem keeping the supporting characters relevant... April during City At War was a pain to read for me.

My main complaints with Mirage is how it just sort of falls apart in the end and we get so many depressing stories about the Turtles not being together. I'm super interested in seeing them live out their lives and be in the future (how long exactly do mutated turtles live for?) but It kinda hurt the way Peter left Mikey seemingly gone forever.

CyberCubed 03-16-2017 07:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by spookycookies (Post 1668261)
My main complaints with Mirage is how it just sort of falls apart in the end and we get so many depressing stories about the Turtles not being together. I'm super interested in seeing them live out their lives and be in the future (how long exactly do mutated turtles live for?) but It kinda hurt the way Peter left Mikey seemingly gone forever.

That's actually what people like a lot about Mirage TMNT compared to any of the other series. The Turtles basically grow old, grow apart from each other, and then die.

Mirage TMNT were never there to be superheroes, save the world, or serve any real purpose. Sure they got into a lot of adventures along the way, but in the end of things they were just written as normal "people" living out their lives. Mirage never had any endgame planned in mind, or any major climax on the horizon...so it petering out in the end works well.

Andrew NDB 03-16-2017 08:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by spookycookies (Post 1668261)
I'm super interested in seeing them live out their lives and be in the future

While I'm sure there's potential for good stories in that... do you really want to read yearly stories of Old Leonardo tending to his birds in his treehouse? Or Old Donatello doing newspaper crosswords and talking to a computer all day?

Quote:

(how long exactly do mutated turtles live for?)
We see Donatello die (basically) of old age in the Tales treasury edition stuff around 2100. He would be about 130 then. So that.

Quote:

but It kinda hurt the way Peter left Mikey seemingly gone forever.
He came back in Odyssey. :)

Utrommaniac 03-16-2017 08:44 PM

We did see Raphael run around what's left of Japan with Karai's grandchild.

And while again question why the Utroms were working on cancer cures instead of global warming - with their primary reason for coming to Earth being to rescue humanity from flooding - I did like that even when the flooding came, life moved on. Just...guys, if that's what you're worried about, help with that and put cancer on the sidelines. Unless you're curing April of the ovarian disorder that would have been more functional to the story than the mess we really got.

plastroncafe 03-16-2017 10:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1668277)

We see Donatello die (basically) of old age in the Tales treasury edition stuff around 2100. He would be about 130 then. So that.

If we go by the extra content in the role playing games, I think Raph lives way longer than that. Long enough to see the end of humanity.

I know that's extra can and stuff, but I don't think it would have been in the RPG without approval.

Andrew NDB 03-16-2017 11:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by plastroncafe (Post 1668300)
If we go by the extra content in the role playing games, I think Raph lives way longer than that. Long enough to see the end of humanity.

I know that's extra can and stuff, but I don't think it would have been in the RPG without approval.

As much as I'd like it to be it doesn't work with the Mirage works that followed it. "After the Bomb" gives years, specific dates... the world would be bombed out at that time, total nuclear apocalypse, filled with mutant bunnies and bears and such with humans in the minority even by the time Raph had his adventure with Karai's grandchild, let alone the Leo and Radical stuff and everything else. Doesn't work, and I looked hard at the dates.

With "Odyssey" I did use the Palladium timeline as a template juuust beyond those troublesome years where it didn't jive with what everything Mirage post-2000 was doing.

DestronMirage22 03-16-2017 11:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ***First of Two Latin Kings*** (Post 1668185)
The dark haired girl has a nice shape.

What was this thread about again?

Seems to me like she's the only female in that picture that has a shape, but agreed. :P

Ninjinister 03-17-2017 12:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1668271)
so it petering out in the end works well.

That's quite the multi-laird statement.

myconius 03-17-2017 03:21 PM

i try not to nit pick.
but just a few minor grievances i have-

Mirage
-hit or miss Guest Era Tmnt Vol.1
-rushed ending to Tmnt Vol.2 (at least it concluded)
-hit or miss stories in 'Tales of Tmnt' Vol.2
-never concluded Vol.4
-unless a specific Turtle was the main focus of a panel or holding their weapon, sometimes when seen in the background they felt like they had no personality.


IDW
-can become too drama focused at times
-could really benefit from more action
-can't stand when IDW Michelangelo gets a bug up his shell
-the Turtles don't kill
-even without the Turtles killing enemies, they feel restrained when fighting with their weapons. they really need to cut loose more. . . . Literally!


other than that .... i love 'em both.

CyberCubed 03-17-2017 03:36 PM

A minor nitpick I have is revealing a character that still won't be used for months/years down the line. A recent example is Ch'rell, who got his reveal a while ago and we haven't seen him since for the next 15+ issues since he's still in stasis. I'd rather new characters not be revealed so far ahead of when they're actually ready to use them.

They did something similar with Leatherhead and his first cameo in Turtles in Time #3, but we didn't get his real debut until issue #56 or whatever it was. That was like a 2 year wait if I recall. You could say the same for human Bebop/Rocksteady who debuted in the Alopex micro but they weren't mutated for a good 2 years later.

I understand putting in teasers for things coming down the road, but some of these were done way too early.

Panda_Kahn_fan 03-17-2017 03:40 PM

Mirage... after another reread, my only complaints are the April-drawing-cockroach story, the filler in Volume I, and the a lack of a connected ongoing story line. Other than that Mirage is cool, just not my cup of tea.

IDW I love, but I will admit it has it's flaws; like cramming 500 story plots and characters in at once, or not using an existing character when the story calls for it, and making a new expy instead.

DestronMirage22 03-17-2017 03:43 PM

I really like IDW and all, but I feel like they could be doing better in some aspects. They could take more inspiration from Mirage and Image, and less of the usual tropes regarding the four guys: we don't always need to see Raph as an angry dude, or Mike as a dumb guy. If they did less of that kind of stuff I'd be more happy, but as it stands it's still really good.

Utrommaniac 03-17-2017 03:48 PM

Mike isn't all that dumb, though? He might not have a lot of critical thinking, but that doesn't mean he's stupid.

DestronMirage22 03-17-2017 03:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Utrommaniac (Post 1668434)
Mike isn't all that dumb, though? He might not have a lot of critical thinking, but that doesn't mean he's stupid.

Well, he does have his little moments to shine, like in #50, and he definitely has heart, but that kind of stuff in kind of undermined when he does things like tell poop jokes, like in the preview of the latest issue.

CyberCubed 03-17-2017 03:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Panda_Kahn_fan (Post 1668432)
or not using an existing character when the story calls for it, and making a new expy instead.

??? They don't do that though.

The only suspiciously similar character in IDW to an old character is of course Alopex compared to Ninjara. But if I recall Eastman created Alopex.

myconius 03-17-2017 03:57 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1668430)
A minor nitpick I have is revealing a character that still won't be used for months/years down the line. A recent example is Ch'rell, who got his reveal a while ago and we haven't seen him since for the next 15+ issues since he's still in stasis. I'd rather new characters not be revealed so far ahead of when they're actually ready to use them.

They did something similar with Leatherhead and his first cameo in Turtles in Time #3, but we didn't get his real debut until issue #56 or whatever it was. That was like a 2 year wait if I recall. You could say the same for human Bebop/Rocksteady who debuted in the Alopex micro but they weren't mutated for a good 2 years later.

I understand putting in teasers for things coming down the road, but some of these were done way too early.

yeah, the new character intros can be a tad bit too slow burn.
and other times like Leatherhead and Ch'rell WAY too delayed!!

Utrommaniac 03-17-2017 04:22 PM

Leatherhead, maybe, but Ch'rell is right on time.

MAYBE if he was in Utrom Empire, it would be a little better, but I think he's fine where he's at.

CyberCubed 03-17-2017 05:43 PM

I wonder if Ch'rell will be in the Trial of Krang arc, that would mean we'd see him in the 70's of the issues, or else it'll be a long wait after.

Utrommaniac 03-17-2017 06:24 PM

Likely so. It's the most appropriate place for him, and he's probably a Prime Witness to some of Krang's murders - especially with him carrying most of them out. Of course, he wouldn't testify, and would probably be focused on trying to free him while the turtles are rescuing the witnesses from assassination.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:03 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.