The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Do the IDW Comics need more Mirage influence? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=58135)

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 06-22-2017 11:10 AM

Do the IDW Comics need more Mirage influence?
 
IDW has been pretty cartoon heavy for awhile lately:

Bishop, Phantoms, Darius from 4Kids; Darkwater, Krang, Dimension X from OT; Mutanimals, Dreadmon, Null, Maligna from Archie.

It feels like IDW has always been light on incorporated Mirage elements. I think the last thing we had that we could definitely point to was Donatello's death and cyborg resurrection back at #45-50? Or Utroms on an island on Earth in #56-58... Oh, and the Turtles taking over the Foot Clan.

Okay, so there has been SOME Mirage/Image influence. But it definitely feels like the least present influence of the various TMNT incarnations. What do you guys think?

Panda_Kahn_fan 06-22-2017 11:23 AM

Not unless it suits the story, no. Mirage (I'm including image as a part of that in this entire post) was a very cerebral and compelling take on the TMNT, but at the end of the day, it is a different animal than IDW. One of the problems with the original comics, is that most of the iconic characters (including the main ones) have already appeared in other media. And most of them have appeared in IDW already. What's left behind- Gosei Hattori, Pimiko, radical, Dale Evens McGullicutty, Shadow, the vampires, complete carnage, etc.- should only be brought in if the story calls for them. And really... I don't want to see IDW redo or copy and of the mirage tales or story elements- we already have the originals, and any new comic retelling would just be a cheap imitation of the classics. So Mirage-only elements and characters should be like anything else they pull from TMNT history- only used if they have a specific story to tell with it.

neatoman 06-22-2017 11:25 AM

Technically speaking, Leo, Raph, Don, Mike, Splinter, April, Casey, Shredder, Karai, Baxter, Honeycutt, Renet, Savanti, Rat King, Leatherhead and Zog are all Mirage studios original characters and most of them are major players.

I can't really think of that many more characters anyone would actually care to see. What did you have in mind? Dale McGillicutty?

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 06-22-2017 11:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Panda_Kahn_fan (Post 1692716)
Not unless it suits the story, no. Mirage (I'm including image as a part of that in this entire post) was a very cerebral and compelling take on the TMNT, but at the end of the day, it is a different animal than IDW. One of the problems with the original comics, is that most of the iconic characters (including the main ones) have already appeared in other media. And most of them have appeared in IDW already. What's left behind- Gosei Hattori, Pimiko, radical, Sarah McGullicutty, Shadow, the vampires, complete carnage, etc.- should only be brought in if the story calls for them. And really... I don't want to see IDW redo or copy and of the mirage tales or story elements- we already have the originals, and any new comic retelling would just be a cheap imitation of the classics. So Mirage-only elements and characters should be like anything else they pull from TMNT history- only used if they have a specific story to tell with it.

I agree, and I guess it doesn't bother me THAT much because Mirage/Image comics were the best TMNT stories for my money. Those story elements don't NEED polishing and a second (better) telling... whereas Fred Wolf characters and ideas DEFINITELY need a second (better and more serious) telling. (I'm also not a fan of Archie, and have been greatly enjoying their characters and concepts being revamped.)

So basically, it boils down to "If it ain't broke, don't fix it." And Mirage is the least broke TMNT canon.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 06-22-2017 11:29 AM

Also, who is McGillicutty?

(And always say no to the Justice Force, my least favorite Mirage element!)

Panda_Kahn_fan 06-22-2017 11:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1692720)
Also, who is McGillicutty?

(And always say no to the Justice Force, my least favorite Mirage element!)

Dale Evans McGillicutty- freaky super-intelligent mutant who built a time machine, and with the TMNT's help traveled through time and prevented her own mutation. In the altered timeline she's simply just a little girl.

neatoman 06-22-2017 11:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1692720)
Also, who is McGillicutty?

A character from the Mark Martin issues, a horrifically mutated little girl who travels back in time to prevent her mutation.

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1692720)
(And always say no to the Justice Force, my least favorite Mirage element!)

I'm fine with them.

DestronMirage22 06-22-2017 11:34 AM

You can never have enough Mirage influence, can you? :D

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1692720)
Also, who is McGillicutty?

Dale Evans McGillicutty
http://turtlepedia.wikia.com/wiki/Da...s_McGillicutty
https://vignette3.wikia.nocookie.net...20130906205431
The little girl from Mirage 16, 22, and 23.
A very underrated character who definitely deserves some modern day interpretation. (A judging by these speedy responses, I'm not the only one who thinks so).

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 06-22-2017 11:36 AM

Oh hell no, NOT THAT STORY ARC!!!! :tlol:

DestronMirage22 06-22-2017 11:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1692728)
Oh hell no, NOT THAT STORY ARC!!!! :tlol:

Yeah, apart from the first issue, the rest of the story wasn't very good.
Dale pretty much was the only redeeming factor.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 06-22-2017 11:45 AM

I now regret creating this thread, for we have strayed into WTF Mirage territory. :tlol:

Candy Kappa 06-22-2017 11:51 AM

I'd love some more slice of life and existentialism.

neatoman 06-22-2017 11:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1692735)
I now regret creating this thread, for we have strayed into WTF Mirage territory. :tlol:

Ah yes, that reminds me, the midget skrulls.

DrSpengler 06-22-2017 12:01 PM

As has been pointed out, nearly every single fundamental TMNT character is Mirage-based to begin with. So just by virtue of having characters like Leatherhead, the Rat King and Nobody running around, we're getting doses of Mirage-inspired content. They're just so ingrained into the multimedia franchise that they feel less like a Mirage callback and more like a given.

There are certainly more obscure characters from the Mirage comics I wouldn't mind seeing, but there's no need to force them in. And many of them, quite frankly, only appearing in 1 issue here and there, are shallow-enough that they could be substituted with an original character and who'd either notice or give a crap?

I mean, Radical and Complete Carnage might be neat, but I'm not exactly chomping at the bit for, I dunno, Jack Marlin or the King of Thieves and Hadji.


I can tell you what I DON'T want to see, and that's anymore adaptations of Mirage storylines. We already got the whole "exile to Northampton, Return to New York" thing, and that's the big storyline that nearly every incarnation adapts, but I don't want to see anymore after that. I'd prefer original plots over endless adaptations of the same narratives we've seen across multiple incarnations of the brand.

Honestly, the "Northampton/return" story is getting so stale in its rehashes, it's becoming the TMNT's "Death of Gwen Stacy". And man, if I gotta watch that chick die one more time, I'm gonna flip a table.

ProphetofGanja 06-22-2017 12:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Candy Kappa (Post 1692737)
I'd love some more slice of life and existentialism.

. Seconded.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 06-22-2017 12:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1692744)
I can tell you what I DON'T want to see, and that's anymore adaptations of Mirage storylines. We already got the whole "exile to Northampton, Return to New York" thing, and that's the big storyline that nearly every incarnation adapts, but I don't want to see anymore after that. I'd prefer original plots over endless adaptations of the same narratives we've seen across multiple incarnations of the brand.

Honestly, the "Northampton/return" story is getting so stale in its rehashes, it's becoming the TMNT's "Death of Gwen Stacy". And man, if I gotta watch that chick die one more time, I'm gonna flip a table.

For the sake of discussion, what if it was pulling influence from Mirage storylines that haven't been Gwen-Stacy-neck-snapped to death?

Say, The River? Or... well, most of Mirage Volume 1 HAS been done to death, hasn't it? :tlol:

CyberCubed 06-22-2017 12:33 PM

Wyrm is basically Bloodsucker who already is in IDW.

As I said the only major thing IDW hasn't done much with is the Triceratons. We've seen brief snippets of them, but we never had a Triceraton arc. No Triceraton tournament arena. No Triceraton Vs. Federation/Utrom/Neutrino war. No Triceratons coming to Earth.

Since they're not as war driven in this series I guess it's hard to use them. Triceratons are basically the TMNT version of Klingon's, you just always want to see them go to war and fight people.

Panda_Kahn_fan 06-22-2017 12:40 PM

Again, I just don't know... by it's very nature, IDW is different than mirage, with a somewhat different audience. borrowed story lines and existentialist stuff might not work with this universe.

2K3 06-22-2017 03:33 PM

Most of the Mirage-verse has been incorporated into IDW already.

The only characters/ stories from the series left that I'd love to see appear:

Characters
Miyamoto Usagi, General Blanque, Prime Leader Zanramon, Commander Mozar, King of Thieves and Louis Braunzel

Stories
Shades of Grey - Casey needs a big character boast now he and April are split.

Utrommaniac 06-22-2017 03:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1692719)
So basically, it boils down to "If it ain't broke, don't fix it." And Mirage is the least broke TMNT canon.

...Volume 4???

But yeah, IDW is doing fine as its own thing, even when taking strides from other versions. Plus there's City Fall and Northampton, which are Mirage staples. Same as the TCRI fiasco, but it was a different situation for IDW entirely.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 06-22-2017 03:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Utrommaniac (Post 1692819)
...Volume 4???

But yeah, IDW is doing fine as its own thing, even when taking strides from other versions. Plus there's City Fall and Northampton, which are Mirage staples. Same as the TCRI fiasco, but it was a different situation for IDW entirely.

Volume 4 had some damn good stuff in it; Utrom First Contact, Splinter's death, Mikey and the Triceratons/Styracodons, Donatello and the other Utroms...

But there is, of course, also the April/Renet cockroach orgy. :tgrumble:

Utrommaniac 06-22-2017 04:03 PM

That is true, but those had their fair share of issues. It was honestly a little cluttered, even with the great stuff, and I can't forgive the reptile things in the Donatello arch talking like Gollum.

The Xihad storyline got left in the dirt big time, and that could have made a fantastic storyline by itself.

My personal issue with the "April and roaches" thing is more the fact that her infertility suddenly ended while she was in roach form? What a huge slap in the face to her and the readers.

Powder 06-22-2017 04:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Candy Kappa (Post 1692737)
I'd love some more slice of life and existentialism.

+ depressing stuff.

Not need, but needed. It needed to be more like Mirage, now, it's kinda too late.

You know what makes Mirage better than IDW for me? The TMNT don't feel like guest stars in their own series. This whole giant group thing is tired IMO. Extended/adoptive family is an important theme, but the turtles need more alone time. AND, on earth, they were unique. This universe is overloaded with mutants, though. The turtles are just 4 more pennies in the freak jar.

& like Speng's said, there's not much Mirage stuff they can do beyond adapting stories we've seen enough times already, or characters nobody cares about.

They've more or less found their groove, though, and there's been less punch-pulling in the last year or two. It's a good book that I rarely complain about. It's in ways not my ideal, but it's pretty satisfying.

CyberCubed 06-22-2017 05:00 PM

None of the rest of the Mirage characters were interesting because they were intended to be one-shot characters or throwaway catalysts for a plot.

General Blanque and the Federation have been replaced by the Neutrinos...who are essentially the same thing just "good" and not war mongers. Volume 4 had no real new characters besides mutated dinosaurs and Styracodons who are just another alien dino race. Or Cha Ocho who is filled in by Jennika in this series. etc. etc.

The only thing IDW needs to explore more are the Triceratons, other than that all Mirage bases are covered.

MikeandRaph87 06-22-2017 05:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1692848)
None of the rest of the Mirage characters were interesting because they were intended to be one-shot characters or throwaway catalysts for a plot.

General Blanque and the Federation have been replaced by the Neutrinos...who are essentially the same thing just "good" and not war mongers. Volume 4 had no real new characters besides mutated dinosaurs and Styracodons who are just another alien dino race. Or Cha Ocho who is filled in by Jennika in this series. etc. etc.

The only thing IDW needs to explore more are the Triceratons, other than that all Mirage bases are covered.

I think it depends on what version you prefer. It has lended heavily on both 2003 cartoon and Archie Comics of late. I could always use more of the 1987 cartoon influence personally because thst is my favorite version. I believe a fan wants a little more of their personal favorite version mixed in. Does it need 1987 cartoon influence? I don't know. It depends on if the narrative calls for it.

As far as The Federation is concerned,why can General Blanque nit be a renagade Neutrino?

Utrommaniac 06-22-2017 05:05 PM

I'm still dead certain the Neutrinos have some skeletons in their closet. While I doubt the King and Queen were involved in the Rebellion, maybe not even being involved at all, there's no way they're as peaceful as they seem to be.

CyberCubed 06-22-2017 05:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MikeandRaph87 (Post 1692852)

As far as The Federation is concerned,why can General Blanque nit be a renagade Neutrino?

I guess so, but he's a rather boring character. The Federation was never anything more than a generic race of human aliens to give the Triceratons someone to fight. Even in the 4kids version they were barely any more interesting.

The Neutrinos are essentially the same thing, only they're always considered good and moral and they have pointy elf ears, so we don't need another humanoid alien race.

Utrommaniac 06-22-2017 05:14 PM

There actually was a mention of the D'Hoonibs, who declared war on the Utroms and then later surrendered ( :lol: ). My best guess is that Traxus filled the Blanque place, but obviously that didn't end well for them (what military master gets killed by a marooned spoiled brat with a pointed stick and a lizard?)

MikeandRaph87 06-22-2017 05:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1692856)
I guess so, but he's a rather boring character. The Federation was never anything more than a generic race of human aliens to give the Triceratons someone to fight. Even in the 4kids version they were barely any more interesting.

The Neutrinos are essentially the same thing, only they're always considered good and moral and they have pointy elf ears, so we don't need another humanoid alien race.

My point is, I do believe there is room for them. The Federation can be a competiting ruler, a Zod-like character who is a neutrino and is disposed of. Hitler was evil and had his elite,but was Germany as a whole? No. So Blanque could be overthrown and exiled and attempt a comeback and attempt a coup of Zenter. If there is use IDW can find it!

Sophie Campbell 06-22-2017 08:50 PM

The aspect of Mirage I'd like to see more of isn't a content/character thing, it's a format thing. We have TMNT Universe now for shorter one-off stories but I'd still love to see more Mirage-style storytelling with one-and-done villains and random adventures that don't always tie into the big plot tapestry. I like Mirage's feeling of breathing room between stories.

The monthly comic market is much different now, though, and has different narrative constaints, people demand that stories "matter" and the one-offs that don't have any plot points are "filler" to be discarded, etc. so I don't think that kind of approach would be good for business.

myconius 06-22-2017 09:25 PM

i'd really enjoy some 'slice of life' story-telling and give the characters so breathing room. having Michelangelo finally adopting Klunk would be really nice.

i do enjoy some of the simpler one and done stories from the Mirage days. at least we finally have Tmnt:Universe which is probably the closest we'll ever get?

one thing i've been feeling for a while is sometimes the Turtles really do feel like guest stars in their own book, and that really upsets me.
i love the series, but at times the Turtles really do feel like they've been reduced to supporting cast.

Utrommaniac 06-22-2017 09:33 PM

I think Raph's adoption of Pepperoni has filled the Klunk role. With everything going on with Hob, Klunk might be awkward.

CyberCubed 06-22-2017 09:40 PM

The Wyrm issue in Universe is a perfect example of a one-shot story. It's self contained, and as far as we know, won't lead into anything else overall. Some random issues with one of the Turtles on a crazy adventure would be fine.

MikeandRaph87 06-22-2017 10:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Utrommaniac (Post 1692912)
I think Raph's adoption of Pepperoni has filled the Klunk role. With everything going on with Hob, Klunk might be awkward.

I agree. Pepperoni is the Klunk for this series. However, was it not odd for a rurtke to have a rurtke for a pet when Raohael jept Slash as a pet? Sure, Raphael was mutated and Slash not but no backstory and plain awkward. It made me think of a human keeping a more primitive human as a let and no one batting an eye.


As far as the Mirage story-style, I am all for one off adventures , but not characters. Look at how big Baxter was after just two appearances and Rat King with a single alive appearance. The true limited usage of characters as I said drastically limits my interest in Mirage.

myconius 06-22-2017 10:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Utrommaniac (Post 1692912)
I think Raph's adoption of Pepperoni has filled the Klunk role. With everything going on with Hob, Klunk might be awkward.

Pepperoni really doesn't help flesh out Michelangelo as a character, which is what i'd like to see.

Raph already has plenty of friends and relations in the series.
Michelangelo has Woody and Slash which the writers seem to like to put strains on his relationships with from time to time.
he didn't even really get much time with the Mutanimals before things headed south.

plus there are plenty of people that share their household with both cats and dogs.
heck if even bunnies and cats can get along then why not?

http://gifrific.com/wp-content/uploa...Cat-Cuddle.gif

Utrommaniac 06-22-2017 10:44 PM

Leo and Don are super in the "no friends town" as well. Don's been cut off from Harold and Leo...

myconius 06-22-2017 11:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Utrommaniac (Post 1692923)
Leo and Don are super in the "no friends town" as well. Don's been cut off from Harold and Leo...

at least we got to spend plenty of time with Don when he was hanging around Harold.
and now that Harold is out of the picture we can really feel the void on Don missing him.
plus Don has seemed to bond with Fugitoid.

Leonardo has always spent most of his down time training.
in the beginning of the series at least we'd get to see tending his swords, and practicing.
not so much lately though.
last time we go to spend any quality time with Leo in the Dojo i thing was when he was training Foot soldiers with Alopex.

CyberCubed 06-23-2017 01:25 AM

The less extra characters the better, they introduced a lot of human characters that don't really get much focus get written out after awhile. I completely forgot about Lindsey's girlfriend who works for Null until recently since I flipped through the old Mutanimals mini for example. It's the same reason I'm glad Winter and Knight were written out recently, it's too many extra characters.

There's also now Harold's wife, Lindsey is still around, Jennika, Woody, April's parents, in addition to Harold, Angel, etc. Sometimes it gets too cluttered.

***First of Two Latin Kings*** 06-23-2017 04:59 AM

I would love to see IDW's use of the organic exosuit motif from Vol. 4. The second mutation for Raphael also has a lot of merit.

The IDW series acknowledges that the Mirage universe exists in B & R Destroy Everything. There will probably be a crossover story at some point with black and white turtles with red bandanas.

Utrommaniac 06-23-2017 08:06 AM

I imagine organic exosuits would be a necessity on Burnow, since they don't really have a lot of resources and are cut off from the world, and their population is probably going to explode in the next few years for them.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:47 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.