The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   IDW net income down 91% in 2017 (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=58772)

DrSpengler 09-19-2017 01:45 PM

IDW net income down 91% in 2017
 
Direct IDW statement: "Publishing revenue decreased by ($751,000), principally due to industry cyclical downward pressure driven by market leaders, as well as the timing of significant major brand titles that are expected in the fourth quarter of fiscal 2017."

Ouch.

But I'm sure Aubrey Sitterson will turn it all around for them.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 09-19-2017 01:51 PM

Maybe I don't pay enough attention Marvel and DC, but what are the significant major brand titles in Q4 this year?

The DC Doomsday Clock and Batman Metal stuff?

plastroncafe 09-19-2017 01:56 PM

Maybe they're referring to the Nazi Cap thing Marvel was doing.
Most of the people I know who were upset about that don't go in for IDW stuff.

I've got to say though, I spent a couple days over at the IDW FB page, and that...that got wild there for a while.
In a fascinatingly hilarious way.

Andrew NDB 09-19-2017 02:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by plastroncafe (Post 1715681)
I've got to say though, I spent a couple days over at the IDW FB page, and that...that got wild there for a while.
In a fascinatingly hilarious way.

You're talking the Kevin, Bobby and Tom live chat? Or this:

"It has come to our attention that a freelance comic book writer, whose work includes IDW titles, has expressed opinions on his personal social media account that many find insensitive, divisive, and inflammatory.
IDW in no way condones or supports these personal opinions whatsoever, and recognizes the pain they may cause our readers.
Discussions regarding next steps are underway. We appreciate the patience and understanding of our many fans while these concerns are being addressed.
Thank you."


?

plastroncafe 09-19-2017 02:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1715682)
You're talking the Kevin, Bobby and Tom live chat? Or this:

"It has come to our attention that a freelance comic book writer, whose work includes IDW titles, has expressed opinions on his personal social media account that many find insensitive, divisive, and inflammatory.
IDW in no way condones or supports these personal opinions whatsoever, and recognizes the pain they may cause our readers.
Discussions regarding next steps are underway. We appreciate the patience and understanding of our many fans while these concerns are being addressed.
Thank you."


?

That. I didn't catch the livechat.
I had no idea who Sitterson was until the FB thread Streisanded him for me.
Kind of wish they'd done it sooner, because I wasted like 10 minutes of my life watching some random dude on youtube froth about something that had nothing to do with the current drama.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 09-19-2017 02:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by plastroncafe (Post 1715684)
That. I didn't catch the livechat.
I had no idea who Sitterson was until the FB thread Streisanded him for me.
Kind of wish they'd done it sooner, because I wasted like 10 minutes of my life watching some random dude on youtube froth about something that had nothing to do with the current drama.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1715682)
You're talking the Kevin, Bobby and Tom live chat? Or this:

"It has come to our attention that a freelance comic book writer, whose work includes IDW titles, has expressed opinions on his personal social media account that many find insensitive, divisive, and inflammatory.
IDW in no way condones or supports these personal opinions whatsoever, and recognizes the pain they may cause our readers.
Discussions regarding next steps are underway. We appreciate the patience and understanding of our many fans while these concerns are being addressed.
Thank you."


?

What was this all about?

MikeandRaph87 09-19-2017 02:15 PM

Wait...what? 91% loss? I thought it was a booming success!

plastroncafe 09-19-2017 02:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1715687)
What was this all about?

The guy who pens GI Joe was not delicate about his feeling that there's a lot of insincerity to be found in the Never Forget 9-11 commemoration.

And some readers of GI Joe didn't take a shine to his tone, and so they were trying very hard to call for him to be fired...all the while reassuring everyone they weren't against censorship in any way.

It was...an interesting afternoon.

CyberCubed 09-19-2017 02:19 PM

If you've been checking the IDW TMNT sales thread you would have seen the main ongoing and Universe have been declining in sales every month, even if they're still IDW's best selling comic franchise.

I hope this does not bode ill for the future of IDW TMNT though, we still need to make it to issue 100. :cry:

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 09-19-2017 02:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by plastroncafe (Post 1715690)
The guy who pens GI Joe was not delicate about his feeling that there's a lot of insincerity to be found in the Never Forget 9-11 commemoration.

And some readers of GI Joe didn't take a shine to his tone, and so they were trying very hard to call for him to be fired...all the while reassuring everyone they weren't against censorship in any way.

It was...an interesting afternoon.

Huh. I should try to find that guy's comments... sounds interesting. Also kinda sounds like the whole "this football player protests the national anthem rrrraaaaarrrrrrrrggggggghhh!" controversy...

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1715692)
If you've been checking the IDW TMNT sales thread you would have seen the main ongoing and Universe have been declining in sales every month, even if they're still IDW's best selling comic franchise.

I hope this does not bode ill for the future of IDW TMNT though, we still need to make it to issue 100. :cry:

It's not that IDW TMNT is failing, it's that comics as a whole and across the board (Marvel, DC, Dark Horse, IDW, Image, et al) are on a decline... mostly caused by Marvel and DC, thanks guys. :trazz:

plastroncafe 09-19-2017 02:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1715695)
Huh. I should try to find that guy's comments... sounds interesting. Also kinda sounds like the whole "this football player protests the national anthem rrrraaaaarrrrrrrrggggggghhh!" controversy...

It's exactly like that.
Though my favorite dude was the one who tried to impress upon me that politics has no place in GI Joe comics.

Personally?
The writer lives in Manhattan, and was there the day of. From where I'm sitting, that gives the guy access to a double-standard of behavior.
But what do I know?

oldmanwinters 09-19-2017 02:53 PM

Well, at least they've got the Sonic the Hedgehog license to look forward to next year... I hope. :teek:

snake 09-19-2017 02:59 PM

The hasbro universe IDW fans basically hate the company. Pretty sure TMNT is the only thing they're doing right.

oldmanwinters 09-19-2017 03:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by snake (Post 1715702)
The hasbro universe IDW fans basically hate the company. Pretty sure TMNT is the only thing they're doing right.

Well, I know their Ghostbusters output has been tremendous since about 2012. With all the reboots of their ongoing GB title (and the fact that the franchise peaked in popularity around 1989), I can't imagine it's a terrific seller.

plastroncafe 09-19-2017 03:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by oldmanwinters (Post 1715704)
Well, I know their Ghostbusters output has been tremendous since about 2012. With all the reboots of their ongoing GB title (and the fact that the franchise peaked in popularity around 1989), I can't imagine it's a terrific seller.

Which is a shame, because that's one hell of a good book.

CyberCubed 09-19-2017 03:17 PM

According to comichron sales for August, TMNT is still their best seller, and the latest issue only sold 13,449 copies, not counting digital:

http://www.comichron.com/monthlycomi...7/2017-08.html


Their next two best sellers was "First Strike" and "Star Trek."

Redeemer 09-19-2017 03:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by oldmanwinters (Post 1715701)
Well, at least they've got the Sonic the Hedgehog license to look forward to next year... I hope. :teek:

I think Sonic will definitely help IDW in terms of sales.

Its hard grasp how a company does not implode with a downfall like that. I wish the article listed some source for fact checking. I know IDW has mentioned a downturn in the industry, but I didn't think it was this severe.

CyberCubed 09-19-2017 03:24 PM

Bobby said before there is an industry wide downturn happening, and that IDW rejected projects or proposals from well established franchises or writers in the industry because things had gotten so bad.

But yeah, I think Sonic the Hedgehog franchise should help them a lot. The Archie Sonic comic went on for like for 20 years.

DrSpengler 09-19-2017 03:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by oldmanwinters (Post 1715701)
Well, at least they've got the Sonic the Hedgehog license to look forward to next year... I hope. :teek:

I'm sure out of hype and speculator interest alone, their Sonic relaunch will net them a short term profit boost, as most all-new number ones do. But eventually malaise will set in with profits; that's not so much a comment on quality, but just the inevitable reality.

Quote:

Originally Posted by oldmanwinters (Post 1715704)
Well, I know their Ghostbusters output has been tremendous since about 2012. With all the reboots of their ongoing GB title (and the fact that the franchise peaked in popularity around 1989), I can't imagine it's a terrific seller.

Ghostbusters sells pretty low; like TMNT Amazing Adventures numbers. But it IS a consistently good comic, at least when Burnham is on it (the one-shots and spin-offs by other writers haven't been so hot).

dl316bh 09-19-2017 03:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1715695)
It's not that IDW TMNT is failing, it's that comics as a whole and across the board (Marvel, DC, Dark Horse, IDW, Image, et al) are on a decline... mostly caused by Marvel and DC, thanks guys. :trazz:

I'd say it's mostly Marvel. Being the industry leader sounds nice and all, but when you screw up and tank yourself, you end up hurting the industry at large, because a lot of people who largely deal in those titles stop going. It seems like the constant relaunches and events finally caught up to them and they know it, which is why they're going in hard on the Generations thing and promised no events for at least a year and a half. Probably doesn't help that their last two events were not well received and the most recent was so uncomfortable in the wake of real life that Marvel saw the writing on the wall and rushed through it in, like, three months.

Quote:

But yeah, I think Sonic the Hedgehog franchise should help them a lot. The Archie Sonic comic went on for like for 20 years.
It'll be another decently selling comic once the sales even out, but I don't know about helping "a lot". The Archie title wasn't doing amazing numbers by the end.

ChosenOne 09-19-2017 03:28 PM

I read the title as meaning that the net income was down TO 91% at first, then had a closer look. Oh, man... :(

CyberCubed 09-19-2017 03:30 PM

After the Nick TMNT cartoon just recently ended, (in fact the final eps air Sept. 22nd), I'm getting worried for IDW's TMNT's future.

It seems like everything since the Viacom revival is being concluded. The movies bombed (although we're happy about that), the Nick TMNT cartoon is ending, of course Amazing Adventures is ending with it, and now IDW is experiencing a downturn.

We'll surely make it to issue #100, I have no fears there. But now I wonder how much longer we'll go after that.

DrSpengler 09-19-2017 03:33 PM

Well, if TMNT is indeed IDW's best seller, then I imagine it's the LAST title on the chopping block if budget cuts come down the line.

So TMNT fans probably have the least recourse to be concerned. It's just Ghostbusters fans who need to be worried...

ChosenOne 09-19-2017 03:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1715718)
Well, if TMNT is indeed IDW's best seller, then I imagine it's the LAST title on the chopping block if budget cuts come down the line.

The main ongoing, yes. But Universe (and possibly all the extra material like we got this year) will be sacrificed for sure.

myconius 09-19-2017 03:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1715695)
It's not that IDW TMNT is failing, it's that comics as a whole and across the board (Marvel, DC, Dark Horse, IDW, Image, et al) are on a decline... mostly caused by Marvel and DC, thanks guys. :trazz:

Quote:

Originally Posted by dl316bh (Post 1715714)
I'd say it's mostly Marvel. Being the industry leader sounds nice and all, but when you screw up and tank yourself, you end up hurting the industry at large, because a lot of people who largely deal in those titles stop going. It seems like the constant relaunches and events finally caught up to them and they know it, which is why they're going in hard on the Generations thing and promised no events for at least a year and a half. Probably doesn't help that their last two events were not well received and the most recent was so uncomfortable in the wake of real life that Marvel saw the writing on the wall and rushed through it in, like, three months.

i'd say it's both DC as well as Marvel.
on top of all the retcons and reboots, both companies are pushing the as many 'Events' as they can on their customers. long gone are the days when you can buy and enjoy just one comic title.
and now that most of DC's titles are bi-weekly that even more money to have to spend on the multitudes of cross-overs.

CyberCubed 09-19-2017 03:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChosenOne (Post 1715721)
The main ongoing, yes. But Universe (and possibly all the extra material like we got this year) will be sacrificed for sure.

I imagine if Universe ends they'd just replace with mini's and specials like we've gotten before it existed (or even now with the Dimension X 5-parter), just not as frequently.

myconius 09-19-2017 03:50 PM

i say if you aren't actually purchasing 'said comics', then you really shouldn't be concerned about what happens to them.

i'm not going to call out names, but you know who you are. :P

CyberCubed 09-19-2017 03:52 PM

Just curious, how is Dark Horse doing since they lost the Star Wars license to Marvel? I imagine that would have taken a heavy toll on them due to how popular Star Wars is?

Erik Burnham 09-19-2017 04:11 PM

Guys, I appreciate the concern.

And we always hope for more readers, Y'know? There is a downturn, no question.

Just beware of influencing further downturn from doom+gloom talk.

I say that because I know you don't have all the information. (I don't, either, but I know some of the other streams that are taken into account.)

Digital, reprints, collections (tpb, hc, and other), cost to profit, the license fees, convention sales, even. It all factors in. You see estimates of direct market sales. It's a great predictor, don't get me wrong, but don't let it influence too much, just buy what you dig and spread the word.

That said, I'd be happy if GB sales were higher, too. See you folks in November. 😘

PApagreg 09-19-2017 04:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by snake (Post 1715702)
The hasbro universe IDW fans basically hate the company. Pretty sure TMNT is the only thing they're doing right.

Actually IDW does really good Godzilla comics

dl316bh 09-19-2017 04:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by myconius (Post 1715722)
i'd say it's both DC as well as Marvel.
on top of all the retcons and reboots, both companies are pushing the as many 'Events' as they can on their customers. long gone are the days when you can buy and enjoy just one comic title.
and now that most of DC's titles are bi-weekly that even more money to have to spend on the multitudes of cross-overs.

I don't pay close attention to sales anymore, because it's stressful and does nothing to help enjoyment of comics, so I don't really know what DC's doing right now on that front. I mostly just know some retailer reports I've read that suggest they're mostly happy with how Rebirth has been performing even this far out. Other than that, I don't know much, though it's probably a good sign they've only had to cancel one ongoing a year and a half in. If you remember the New 52, they were forced to cancel, like, six of them eight months in, with a couple more following a few months later.

As for the events, though, eh, I really disagree on that. I've read DC for a long time, mainly in trade, and man, their event's are stupid easy to ignore these days. They seemed to figure out that excessive tie-ins pissed people off around when Countdown bombed, because from Final Crisis on, the vast majority of tie-ins were their own dedicated thing. Which is good, because I remember Infinite Crisis and how that went and screw that noise. That period of DC was a chore in singles or trade. I still haven't read Convergence. Skipped it entirely. Rarely remember it was a thing. Never felt forced into it.

I don't know why Marvel never aped that approach. Well, aped it entirely. They occasionally do a special "point one" issue as a tie-in, rather than swiping an actual issue of the comic, but they never seem to make it a linewide thing.

Quote:

Just beware of influencing further downturn from doom+gloom talk.
I noticed this was definitely a thing that happens back when I still kept up with sales and talked about them with others. Too much talk about how something is near dead, and people start to wonder why they bother.

TurtleWA 09-19-2017 04:35 PM

Are market leaders only acknowledged when revenue drops or are they also acknowledged when companies have a revenue increase. Seems like scapegoating. At least that was my first thought after reading the title. "IDW Blames “Market Leaders” (I.E. Marvel) For Revenue Drop In Financial Report." But then I read some more and it seems like several business decisions contributed to the revenue drop.

ChosenOne 09-19-2017 04:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Erik Burnham (Post 1715736)
Just beware of influencing further downturn from doom+gloom talk.

A little positivity always goes a long way!

Redeemer 09-19-2017 04:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1715711)
Bobby said before there is an industry wide downturn happening, and that IDW rejected projects or proposals from well established franchises or writers in the industry because things had gotten so bad.

But yeah, I think Sonic the Hedgehog franchise should help them a lot. The Archie Sonic comic went on for like for 20 years.

I literally just said that why did you quote me and say they same thing ? :lol: But Yeah I agree Sonic should definitely help sales. Hopefully the sales will start to tick back up.

Quote:

Originally Posted by dl316bh (Post 1715714)
I'd say it's mostly Marvel. Being the industry leader sounds nice and all, but when you screw up and tank yourself, you end up hurting the industry at large, because a lot of people who largely deal in those titles stop going. It seems like the constant relaunches and events finally caught up to them and they know it, which is why they're going in hard on the Generations thing and promised no events for at least a year and a half. Probably doesn't help that their last two events were not well received and the most recent was so uncomfortable in the wake of real life that Marvel saw the writing on the wall and rushed through it in, like, three months.


It'll be another decently selling comic once the sales even out, but I don't know about helping "a lot". The Archie title wasn't doing amazing numbers by the end.

I am wondering how consistently Sonic will sell at IDW, bc correct me if I am wrong, but I believe Sonic was one of Archies biggest sellers?

dl316bh 09-19-2017 05:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Redeemer (Post 1715768)
I am wondering how consistently Sonic will sell at IDW, bc correct me if I am wrong, but I believe Sonic was one of Archies biggest sellers?

It was a very consistent seller for them for decades and I'm pretty sure it was their best seller for a long time prior to the Archie lines modernization and relaunch, but by the last issue it barely pushed five and a half thousand in the direct market. Granted, at that point solicits had been sans Sonic for a bit, so people knew something was up and some probably dropped it, but even if you go back to before that point its best in the final year clocked in at six to seven thousand. Pretty much everything in the actual core Archie line had been outselling it.

That's not an indicator of how IDW will do, though. It's worth keeping in mind that with Archie we're talking about a comic that held on to characters and a world that hadn't been featured outside its pages in decades and was completely divorced from the main franchise. Nobody talked about it and it felt like it was never promoted, yet it held on for a long time despite all that, so who knows. I'm just saying, I wouldn't expect it to be a dynamo that props the whole company up.

CyberCubed 09-20-2017 12:35 PM

In the other thread a lot of people are saying their comic shops aren't even ordering Universe in anymore, and they have to ask to put it on their pull list.

plastroncafe 09-20-2017 01:09 PM

People should be doing this anyway, since pull lists are how the retailer knows how many books to order in the first place.

Candy Kappa 09-20-2017 01:33 PM

I can't do a pull list with my LCS, they don't import floppies. And especially since they've changed owner and Diamond is a bitch-ass to deal with when it comes to comics, when the old boss actually managed to get floppies I'd only get every second TMNT issue.

I'm all digital.

plastroncafe 09-20-2017 01:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Candy Kappa (Post 1716061)
I can't do a pull list with my LCS, they don't import floppies. And especially since they've changed owner and Diamond is a bitch-ass to deal with when it comes to comics, when the old boss actually managed to get floppies I'd only get every second TMNT issue.

I'm all digital.

Wow. Okay that sucks. Like, all of it.
Do you use a subscription to buy your online comics?
I'm curious if publishers are using those the way Diamond does pull lists..

Candy Kappa 09-20-2017 01:54 PM

I used to use Comixology, but after the app was changed I went on using the company specific apps for Marvel, IDW and DC which still uses the older Comixology setup. Of what I've read and heard, sales goes through Diamond's control and digital is not included since it's not through Diamond.

My LCS still got trades, but they're very pricey so it's more of a rare treat, especially when digital trades can be as 1/3rd of the price or lower.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:32 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.