The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   New "City at War" from IDW! (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=60578)

AlZarkovski 10-10-2018 12:19 PM

New "City at War" from IDW!
 
The Road to Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles’ Landmark #100 Issue Begins with Blockbuster City at War Storyline

Quote:

“City at War, which echoes the famous TMNTstoryline from the Mirage Publishing days, is our epic tale leading to our oversized issue #100,” says Group Editor Bobby Curnow. “This storyline will be the culmination of all the story points we’ve laid since issue #51, and in many ways, since the very beginning of our saga.”
New York City will be plunged chaos as four factions wrestle for control. At the center of it all, the Turtles face difficult decisions on how to be true to their individual selves and morals, while still keeping their family together against insurmountable odds.



http://brutalgamer.com/2018/10/09/ny...gi-joe-events/

CyberCubed 10-10-2018 12:21 PM

This is great, but I'm confused, is this just an arc in the main ongoing or another separate mini? From the way it sounds, this is just the new arc from issue 90 onward unless I'm mistaken.

Andrew NDB 10-10-2018 12:21 PM

Oh, I wish they wouldn't invite that comparison.

oldmanwinters 10-10-2018 12:22 PM

I always thought that "City Fall" was the IDW equivalent of "City at War" but I guess we'll see how this one plays out!

ChosenOne 10-10-2018 12:29 PM

Oh, great... I just had my pants zipper fixed after the 20/20 special was announced, and now this! :roll: :D

An "everyone vs everyone" kind of thing, huh? I dig it, gimme a good battle royale any day! :tcool:

Wonder who the four factions are? Splinter's Foot Clan, Karai's Foot Clan, the Mutanimals... and the EPF? Stockman? Null? The Mafia?

AlZarkovski 10-10-2018 12:32 PM

Now I think the ongoing will be reload and start again with #01.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 10-10-2018 12:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1779610)
Oh, I wish they wouldn't invite that comparison.

Same. Don't invite comparisons to the absolute pinnacle of all TMNT. Just don't. It's embarrassing.

Still looking forward to the arc, though... Foot under Splinter, EPF, Karai's crew, and Mutanimals, is my prediction. Although that fourth faction could be Null instead, I guess.

ChosenOne 10-10-2018 01:00 PM

I'd say the two Foot Clans and the Mutanimals are a lock, the question now is who the fourth and final faction is. Assuming, of course, there aren't a bunch of other smaller factions involved as well.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 10-10-2018 01:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChosenOne (Post 1779624)
I'd say the two Foot Clans and the Mutanimals are a lock, the question now is who the fourth and final faction is.

It'll absolutely be the EPF.

Exhibit A: Raphael Macro-Series.

miru 10-10-2018 01:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChosenOne (Post 1779612)
Oh, great... I just had my pants zipper fixed after the 20/20 special was announced, and now this! :roll: :D

An "everyone vs everyone" kind of thing, huh? I dig it, gimme a good battle royale any day! :tcool:

Wonder who the four factions are? Splinter's Foot Clan, Karai's Foot Clan, the Mutanimals... and the EPF? Stockman? Null? The Mafia?

Maybe some of the factions have made alliances with each other?

ChosenOne 10-10-2018 01:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AlZarkovski (Post 1779615)
Now I think the ongoing will be reload and start again with #01.

Oh, dear Stan Lee, please don't! :(

Quote:

Originally Posted by miru (Post 1779626)
Maybe some of the factions have made alliances with each other?

Good point! I went in guns blazing and didn't consider that. Assuming one of them is the EPF, Bishop will be allied with Stockman (insofar as Stockman allies with anyone until it doesn't suit his purposes anymore), and Splinter has Casey and Hun wrapped around his finger... Oooh boy, this is gonna be fun!

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1779625)
It'll absolutely be the EPF.

Exhibit A: Raphael Macro-Series.

Going from the concept above, could be the EPF/Stockman and Null.

Igglet 10-10-2018 01:15 PM

OH MAN, they're really setting the expectations high with this one, aren't they? Well take my money, IDW. Take ALL of it.

neatoman 10-10-2018 01:26 PM

Hm... Isn't this going to be confusing in the long run? If it's really called City at War that is, it reminds me of all those DC and Marvel events bleeding together.

"Yo, do want a trade of Secret Wars?"
"Secret Wars, Secret Wars II, Secret War or Secret Wars?"
"You said Secret Wars twice."
"I know."

ChosenOne 10-10-2018 01:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 1779631)
Hm... Isn't this going to be confusing in the long run? If it's really called City at War that is, it reminds me of all those DC and Marvel events bleeding together.

"Yo, do want a trade of Secret Wars?"
"Secret Wars, Secret Wars II, Secret War or Secret Wars?"
"You said Secret Wars twice."
"I know."

Overheard that same conversation at my local comic book store between two guys who kept confusing the original Secret Wars for Secret War. Had to step in and explain to them myself, and this was waaay before the newest Secret Wars...

One easy solution, though: City at War (Mirage) and City at War (IDW), boom!

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 10-10-2018 01:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 1779631)
Hm... Isn't this going to be confusing in the long run? If it's really called City at War that is, it reminds me of all those DC and Marvel events bleeding together.

"Yo, do want a trade of Secret Wars?"
"Secret Wars, Secret Wars II, Secret War or Secret Wars?"
"You said Secret Wars twice."
"I know."

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChosenOne (Post 1779632)
Overheard that same conversation at my local comic book store between two guys who kept confusing the original Secret Wars for Secret War. Had to step in and explain to them myself, and this was waaay before the newest Secret Wars...

One easy solution, though: City at War (Mirage) and City at War (IDW), boom!

Yeah, but IDW still shouldn't be copying the title. City at War wasn't just about a bunch of factions fighting for control of NYC, it was about moral uncertainty, a loss of direction, and a shattered family. About a cycle of violence.

IDW should pick a different title. This is like me using "A Catcher in the Rye" for my novel. Why invite such comparison to such a vaulted classic? There's no way I can live up to that. :tlol:

ChosenOne 10-10-2018 01:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1779634)
Yeah, but IDW still shouldn't be copying the title. City at War wasn't just about a bunch of factions fighting for control of NYC, it was about moral uncertainty, a loss of direction, and a shattered family. About a cycle of violence.

Who's to say the themes aren't exactly the same? Who's to say IDW's City at War won't be better than Mirage's City at War? Hey, it's a possibility. Everything in life is a possibility. I completely understand the other side but we should at least wait until the arc is out and complete. Gonna be a long-ass wait as it is.

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1779634)
IDW should pick a different title. This is like me using "A Catcher in the Rye" for my novel. Why invite such comparison to such a vaulted classic? There's no way I can live up to that. :tlol:

But you're not the person currently in charge of that book's IP and the subject of both works would probably differ wildly. I think IDW is entitled to at least use the same title as they're the ones currently heading the comic book side of the TMNT franchise. The 2003 cartoon also appropriated several Mirage story titles and no one complained. I know they were adaptations, but really... It's not that big of a difference.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 10-10-2018 01:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChosenOne (Post 1779637)
Who's to say the themes aren't exactly the same? Who's to say IDW's City at War won't be better than Mirage's City at War? Hey, it's a possibility. Everything in life is a possibility. I completely understand the other side but we should at least wait until the arc is out and complete. Gonna be a long-ass wait as it is.

Yeah...

But given how we can compare the tones and themes of Mirage and IDW TMNT, and see the history and precedent, it's fair to say the title is a hindrance.

Besides, you just KNOW Andrew hasn't said his fill on this yet. Do YOU want to give more fuel to his fire? :tlol:

Igglet 10-10-2018 01:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1779634)
Yeah, but IDW still shouldn't be copying the title. City at War wasn't just about a bunch of factions fighting for control of NYC, it was about moral uncertainty, a loss of direction, and a shattered family. About a cycle of violence.

IDW should pick a different title. This is like me using "A Catcher in the Rye" for my novel. Why invite such comparison to such a vaulted classic? There's no way I can live up to that. :tlol:

But that's the deal, this story isn't just going to be a bunch of factions fighting for control of NYC, because, frankly, what IDW's TMNT run has been about for so long now HAS been moral uncertainty, a loss of direction, and a shattered family. The name "City at War" is, all things considered, VERY fitting.

And, yes, they have a LOT to live up to. But these are the same people who've brought us such good TMNT stories so far and have created what many consider the best TMNT run ever. If anyone can do it, it's them.

ChosenOne 10-10-2018 01:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Igglet (Post 1779639)
But that's the deal, this story isn't just going to be a bunch of factions fighting for control of NYC, because, frankly, what IDW's TMNT run has been about for so long now HAS been moral uncertainty, a loss of direction, and a shattered family. The name "City at War" is, all things considered, VERY fitting.

And, yes, they have a LOT to live up to. But these are the same people who've brought us such good TMNT stories so far and have created what many consider the best TMNT run ever. If anyone can do it, it's them.

I like you! :)

miru 10-10-2018 01:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1779634)
Yeah, but IDW still shouldn't be copying the title. City at War wasn't just about a bunch of factions fighting for control of NYC, it was about moral uncertainty, a loss of direction, and a shattered family. About a cycle of violence.

IDW should pick a different title. This is like me using "A Catcher in the Rye" for my novel. Why invite such comparison to such a vaulted classic? There's no way I can live up to that. :tlol:

Nick and 2k3’s city at war were even more divergent than this. The basic idea is that there’s a bunch of conflicted factions.

Igglet 10-10-2018 01:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChosenOne (Post 1779640)
I like you! :)

I have never felt more appreciated in my life.

ChosenOne 10-10-2018 01:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Igglet (Post 1779643)
I have never felt more appreciated in my life.

Stick with being positive and you'll go far.

Weapons@theready 10-10-2018 01:59 PM

Where does the Pantheon fit in all of this? Are they the ones who are manipulating the four factions?

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 10-10-2018 01:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by miru (Post 1779642)
Nick and 2k3’s city at war were even more divergent than this. The basic idea is that there’s a bunch of conflicted factions.

That's why I'm so irritated by this. Every attempt to do this story again has been poor. And yes, IDW will absolutely win the silver medal with ease.

But... sigh. Oh well. I'm done complaining about it. I'll still enjoy the story. :tgrin:

Igglet 10-10-2018 01:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChosenOne (Post 1779644)
Stick with being positive and you'll go far.

Wise words.

On the topic of the story, though, I bet one of the factions in the story will be Karai's side of the Foot Clan. Or maybe we should call it the Shredder's, depending on whether he's getting resurrected or not.

AquaParade 10-10-2018 04:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1779610)
Oh, I wish they wouldn't invite that comparison.

Took the words out of my mouth.

What made City at War special was the introspection and nihilism of all that kept the turtles together. It was made up of that special Mirage sauce. It’s more than just a three/four-way battle across New York rooftops.

This could be great, but just do your own thing because this type of comparison only invites disappointment.

Kenwatanabesclone 10-10-2018 04:14 PM

I'm excited for the story but not too keen on the title, as others have already stated.

hypered1 10-10-2018 04:42 PM

In a way I feel like I may enjoy this more having not read the original 'City at War', and to be honest I thought IDW's City Fall was supposed to be the equivalent story arc.

Full disclosure, I've really only read the IDW ongoing continuity and few of the old UK Fleetway issues which I have come to learn are semi-based on the Fred Wolf cartoon and the Archie comics.

I have read the first couple of mirage issues but found the art style to be too messy for my tastes - same reason the IDW annuals are my least favourite issues of the their run - don't get me wrong, I have every respect for Messrs Eastman and Laird but I think I joined the party too late to properly appreciate the original work. :ohwell:

MikeandRaph87 10-10-2018 05:34 PM

I never got into City at War because Shredder was not involved just his absence being the cause of a gang war. I did enjoy the 2003 cartoon adaptation. It does not get much love in fandom, but its likely more appreciated by those like me who are not interested in the Mirage comics.

How long will this arc be and what will be the root cause? Sure, Shredder is absent, but the power vaccum is not neccessarily open right now. Karai returns and challenges Splinter? Will the Mutanimals fold under the Splinter lead foot clan or be their own faction? I can see Splinter reaching out to Hob. He has before, but would Hob work with Splinter if Splinter worked with Agent Bishop after what Agent Bishop did to Slash and the other Mutanimals?

That leaves two more factions, Null has opposed Agent Bishop as seen in the opening arc of TMNT Universe. That would be three. Earth Protection Force would make four. Stockman would likely be neutral like the Turtles and help them clean up what they cannot in public and it would likely help his push for the mayoral race. The Pantheon may take advantage of the aftermath so Kitsune or the siblings overall might be at the climax if at all. The Triceratons and Utroms will likely have a resolved storyline and be uninvolved. I dont see Chr'ell uniting the underworld as the new Shredder.

Utrommaniac 10-10-2018 05:46 PM

https://media.giphy.com/media/OCu7zWojqFA1W/giphy.gif

At least we have some idea of what's going on.


For sure, it would be Karai Vs Splinter for control of the city. Karai has clearly given up any chance of leadership within the Foot. I think Bishop is going to be pretty beaten down from the EPF and would be trying to lay low. I actually wouldn't put it past Stockman putting his nose in things and trying to have some kind of control over the Foot. Considering Don's Future Vision of him as President with some Foot soldiers.

I think Null could be the fourth contender, since she has some stuff going on that's pretty big.

CyberCubed 10-10-2018 05:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MikeandRaph87 (Post 1779686)
I never got into City at War because Shredder was not involved just his absence being the cause of a gang war. I

Shredder not being there/dead is why the City at War arc worked, it was what it was all about. The different factions of Foot all fighting each other for control of NYC. I don't understand how you can have a problem with that.

MikeandRaph87 10-10-2018 05:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1779692)
Shredder not being there/dead is why the City at War arc worked, it was what it was all about. The different factions of Foot all fighting each other for control of NYC. I don't understand how you can have a problem with that.

I did state Shredder leaving a void in the underworld was the cause. I did not say I had a problem with it. It just does not interest me. I would rather see whst we got in the 2003 cartoon or villains like Rat King or Krang or whoever vying for power in whatevwr iteration.

Utrommaniac 10-10-2018 06:02 PM

That's kind of been a very established thing?


It's probably not going to be Shredder returning as himself, given the Dragon Lord plot.

AquaParade 10-10-2018 06:11 PM

One of the great things about City at War is that although the Shredder is not physically there, his presence looms large over the story.
The turtles are left almost worse-off without him and can't seem to find direction in life, without the lust for revenge against The Shredder, that united them.

Plus you still get to see the stylish armor when Karai impersonates him.

Ah, such a great TMNT story.

Kenwatanabesclone 10-10-2018 06:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hypered1 (Post 1779678)
In a way I feel like I may enjoy this more having not read the original 'City at War', and to be honest I thought IDW's City Fall was supposed to be the equivalent story arc.

Full disclosure, I've really only read the IDW ongoing continuity and few of the old UK Fleetway issues which I have come to learn are semi-based on the Fred Ward cartoon and the Archie comics.

I have read the first couple of mirage issues but found the art style to be too messy for my tastes - same reason the IDW annuals are my least favourite issues of the their run - don't get me wrong, I have every respect for Messrs Eastman and Laird but I think I joined the party too late to properly appreciate the original work. :ohwell:

You should try and read more. The Mirage art evolved a lot and also had many guests artists. The first couple issues don't reflect the series as a whole. Plus, as jarring as the art may be, the stories told are really worth a shot.

Rooish 10-10-2018 09:24 PM

Wow, this is really exciting. Do we know who the artist will be?

It will be extremely hard to compete with the Mirage version. The 2003 version butchered it, and I didn't watch the Nick version. I think IDW will probably have great character development (they always do), but it won't be able to compete with the sheer bleakness and depressing-ness of Mirage, which is what I loved about it.

Redeemer 10-10-2018 09:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MikeandRaph87 (Post 1779686)
I never got into City at War because Shredder was not involved just his absence being the cause of a gang war. I did enjoy the 2003 cartoon adaptation. It does not get much love in fandom, but its likely more appreciated by those like me who are not interested in the Mirage comics.

How long will this arc be and what will be the root cause? Sure, Shredder is absent, but the power vaccum is not neccessarily open right now. Karai returns and challenges Splinter? Will the Mutanimals fold under the Splinter lead foot clan or be their own faction? I can see Splinter reaching out to Hob. He has before, but would Hob work with Splinter if Splinter worked with Agent Bishop after what Agent Bishop did to Slash and the other Mutanimals?

That leaves two more factions, Null has opposed Agent Bishop as seen in the opening arc of TMNT Universe. That would be three. Earth Protection Force would make four. Stockman would likely be neutral like the Turtles and help them clean up what they cannot in public and it would likely help his push for the mayoral race. The Pantheon may take advantage of the aftermath so Kitsune or the siblings overall might be at the climax if at all. The Triceratons and Utroms will likely have a resolved storyline and be uninvolved. I dont see Chr'ell uniting the underworld as the new Shredder.

I am with you. I read the "City at War" arc done by Mirage and thought it was overrated. I thought the side story with Casey was more entertaining. :lol: I don't know why bc that story wasn't that exciting at all...... I am pretty sure you and I are outliers among the fandoms in regards to the "City of War" arc.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Utrommaniac (Post 1779689)
https://media.giphy.com/media/OCu7zWojqFA1W/giphy.gif

At least we have some idea of what's going on.


For sure, it would be Karai Vs Splinter for control of the city. Karai has clearly given up any chance of leadership within the Foot. I think Bishop is going to be pretty beaten down from the EPF and would be trying to lay low. I actually wouldn't put it past Stockman putting his nose in things and trying to have some kind of control over the Foot. Considering Don's Future Vision of him as President with some Foot soldiers.

I think Null could be the fourth contender, since she has some stuff going on that's pretty big.

That is really good point. wow I am shocked you can remember something like that.... sounds like I need to start rereading the IDW series. :lol:

Utrommaniac 10-10-2018 11:01 PM

It's fairly recent stuff.

Karai's Path was just all about Karai coming to terms with not needing no Foot Clan and that if she wants to do things her way, be respected, and be in charge, then she needs to just...do that. Maybe even "fix" the mistake she made of reviving the Foot in the first place by eliminating them for good (and not them sink back into being a law firm)

Andrew NDB 10-11-2018 03:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1779634)
Yeah, but IDW still shouldn't be copying the title. City at War wasn't just about a bunch of factions fighting for control of NYC, it was about moral uncertainty, a loss of direction, and a shattered family. About a cycle of violence.

IDW should pick a different title. This is like me using "A Catcher in the Rye" for my novel. Why invite such comparison to such a vaulted classic? There's no way I can live up to that. :tlol:

It is possible, but wildly unlikely. My thing is... why invite that comparison at all? Because it's going to come now.

Quote:

Originally Posted by miru (Post 1779642)
Nick and 2k3’s city at war were even more divergent than this. The basic idea is that there’s a bunch of conflicted factions.

On the surface level. "Things fighting each other blah blah." But it's also about Splinter eating rats to survive, Casey learning to be a good man and a father after killing someone out of spite, the Turtles learning to move on after reconciling being bred into killing machines.

None of this lends itself to an IDW adaptation.

ChosenOne 10-11-2018 08:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1779724)
On the surface level. "Things fighting each other blah blah." But it's also about Splinter eating rats to survive, Casey learning to be a good man and a father after killing someone out of spite, the Turtles learning to move on after reconciling being bred into killing machines.

I don't know about rats, but I expect Splinter will be eating a crow or two. Does that work for you? :D


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:47 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.