The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   TMNT Macro-Series: Leonardo Preview and Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=60689)

AlZarkovski 11-17-2018 02:23 AM

TMNT Macro-Series: Leonardo Preview and Discussion
 
First Look:


Igglet 11-17-2018 03:15 AM

Man, that art looks good. These Macros just continue to impress.

***First of Two Latin Kings*** 11-18-2018 07:54 AM

I wish they would stick to artists with clean crisp styles like this.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 11-18-2018 11:35 AM

Whoa, I dig that Sophie isn't doing the usual "cute Turtles" art here! :teek: :tgrin:

Rooish 11-19-2018 09:41 AM

Agreed, the art is really lovely. Nice that Mikey has some interaction with Pepperoni; he has always been the pet guy to me.

bushido 11-19-2018 10:18 AM

I like the new style of Sophie Campbell. We can tell by her drawing that the turtles are older than at the time she was drawing Northampton.

Utrommaniac 11-19-2018 09:03 PM

The thing I love about Sophie's art is that you know what tone you're getting from the way she designs.

Round-shaped characters and bright colors? A fun time for all!
Squared-off characters with cold-palette with watercolor style? Seriousness and mysticism, high likelihood of angst.
Sharp-shaped characters with bright colors? Action time!


And yet even through all the changes in shape and color, you can always identify her style.

Joey Kamikaze 11-24-2018 10:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ***First of Two Latin Kings*** (Post 1783235)
I wish they would stick to artists with clean crisp styles like this.

Same. I hate getting issues that look like they colored someone's first draft sketches, like back when the Triceratons were in town a few issues back. This on the other hand looks great.

Redeemer 11-24-2018 11:41 AM

Best/favorite design I have seen in a while. Cant wait for this issue!

Igglet 11-24-2018 04:03 PM

Shouldn't the full preview be out by now? Isn't the issue out on Wednesday? Same for #88.

Utrommaniac 11-24-2018 06:19 PM

Yeah, I was just wondering about that.

daggio 11-24-2018 11:03 PM

I'm extremely curious about the synopsis. The solicitation talks about Leo taking refuge in Northampton, some sort of confrontation with Karai and Koya, and then some decision that will alter TMNT history. Between this and the synopsis for the Raphael Macro talking about a fight with Bishop, maybe the conclusion of Battle Lines is really gonna have a ripple affect on the TMNT.

bushido 11-27-2018 02:50 AM

Full preview here.

Igglet 11-27-2018 08:08 AM

Looks great so far. Seems somewhat quiet in a way, the fact that they're letting Leo reflect on the events that happened is pretty welcome, lots of stuff is going on so it's cool that they're using this Macro to address it.

AlZarkovski 11-27-2018 01:42 PM

Small spoiler. Looking at all, we'll see


Igglet 11-28-2018 01:04 PM

I'm really interested in what you guys think about this issue. I enjoyed it, but, there was something off about it and I just can't put my finger on it. There is some stuff I can say for sure I liked/disliked, but overall there's something to this issue that I'm not sure how I feel about.

Anyway, the art. I think most of it looks great... most of it. Two things I just can't get behind, though, and those two things I dislike immensely. How Turtles look so cutesy and how Karai's face makes her look like Babidi from Dragon Ball Z. The rest of it is pretty stellar, though. The part where they're going back to New York just blew me away, and the fights looked absolutely great. Those two things in particular were what I liked the best about this issue's art.

Now for the actual story elements.

Spoiler:
The spiritual/mystic part felt really off to me. Like, I genuinely don't get the purpose. It wasn't done in any sort of interesting way or whatever. "Look, Leo, we can feel you being in danger now!"...cool? It just feels so dull.

I pointed it out before but I did like that they took this issue as a sort of way to slow things down, let the characters look back to what happened and think about it, let it sink in and stuff. I still like that. I also enjoyed Leo talking about how he sort of wishes Splinter was flat out evil because it'd make things easier for him. It was interesting, though definitely on the nose.

Sort of tying into that, some BIG stuff happens in this issue but it just feels so dull. As I'm writing this, I figured out what's probably one of my main reason for "disliking" this issue and it can be summarized in three words(I don't necessarily dislike it, I just have some pretty big problems with it): show, don't tell. Karai just telling us all about her plans isn't that interesting to me personally. I get why they took this sort of approach and it's not necessarily the wrong way to do it, but, despite how they just dropped what could define the entire story going forward, it just made me think "Cool, I'll just wait to see it happen then." Until we do actually see it in action, I don't really care. Honestly, despite this being such a huge moment for TMNT, it just felt like filler to me. I don't know, I haven't thought this point through too much honestly and I might end up changing my mind.

Tying back into Leo's thoughts, and just overall the way he acted this issue... I'm not sure if I like it that much. It's hard to write Leo well, I can say that for sure. But the way he acted felt much more childish, so to say. He honestly felt like a more mature version of Mikey. The way he just jumped on board with Karai's plan immediately isn't exactly what I'd call the best idea. Donnie might be the turtle we all associate with intelligence because of his knack for science, but Leo is smart and I'd think he would handle this situation somewhat better. Honestly, the Mikey Macro did Leo better than the Leo Macro did, in my opinion.

The dialogue between Leo and Koya was very well written and I like how they low-key acknowledge that we completely forgot about the old Foot gang... which, wouldn't you guess it, leads into my next problem with it, go figure. The entire conversation kind of falls flat for me because I could genuinely not care less about Koya. If she got hit by a car randomly and just died there or got killed off-screen I wouldn't care. The series didn't give us a single reason to care about the Koya-Leo rivalry, so seeing it be 'resolved' to some degree makes me feel absolutely nothing.


Just to finish off, personally I didn't like this issue (which is something I rarely ever say about issues of TMNT) but I can't say I disliked it either. I feel like I ripped into it way too much with my rant, and there's definitely cool stuff, don't get me wrong. I'd put this at my personal bottom of the ranking list for the Macros so far, though, keep in mind, the Donnie Macro is one of my favorite issues to have been released recently and the Mikey one is outright one of my favorite issues of TMNT of all time. Then again, I might just be overly critical today.

Sorry about the massive wall of text, I know you probably don't want to hear my TED talk on here but there's just so much stuff regarding this that I wanted to talk about.

ChosenOne 11-28-2018 01:25 PM

Spoiler:
Oh, Leo, such naive optimism... Like Splinter would ever give up his position peacefully.


Campbell outdid herself here. The story, the fight choreographies, the new plot points relating to City at War, those last few pages that look like a spiritual successor to Calvin & Hobbes... This is frickin' amazing. At this rate, it'll be hard to single out the best Macro of the bunch, they're all that good!

CyberCubed 11-28-2018 02:50 PM

Nice art this issue too, especially the fighting between Leo/Koya which was well choreographed. I also appreciate where they went with the storytelling. But as said above, some things felt a bit odd:

1. Natsu (was that her name?), Ocho, and Bludgeon don't even talk, or say a single line. Even when they're all standing next to each other. Am I correct in saying this is the first time Natsu and Ocho have ever met the Turtles, and vice versa? Like..they don't even know who they are. Really strange Natsu didn't get a single line of dialogue.

2. Koya being bloodthirsty to take revenge on Leonardo, to backing down so quickly, felt kinda rushed. Also remember there was a back-up in Universe showing Koya seemingly go more insane with her lust to take revenge on Leonardo, and this didn't really seem to pick up from that plot point as well as it could have.

3. Karai was also a lot more friendly with the Turtles than she should of been, considering the last time they met was issue 50, where Splinter killed Shredder and Karai just seemingly split after Splinter asked if they could be allies. I mean have people forgotten Karai has not been in the main ongoing since issue 50? Her interactions with the Turtles seem far too friendly from their previous encounter, like there was some middle story arc we missed or something.

4. Although this is minor, Bebop/Rocksteady make no appearance even though Karai recruits them again after the end of their last mini. But again this is fine and they didn't have to appear here, we don't know how much time has passed and they're probably in NY still.


Besides that I enjoyed the issue. I mean I'm not sure what they did here will stick given we know the next arc is literally titled, "City at War," but it is nice to see Karai and her minions not want to kill the Turtles immediately.

Then again we have that new cover preview of issue 90+ that shows the Karai and her mutants in villainous poses...so I dunno, maybe there was some miscommunication between plot points...shrug. But otherwise I loved the art and storytelling. Very Mirage-like.

ChosenOne 11-28-2018 02:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1784027)
4. Although this is minor, Bebop/Rocksteady make no appearance even though Karai recruits them again after the end of their last mini. But again this is fine and they didn't have to appear here, we don't know how much time has passed and they're probably in NY still.

If Karai didn't go there looking for a fight, leaving those two behind (assuming she's already recruited them at this point in time) is the wisest thing she could do. Things have a tendency to escalate very easily when they're around.

Cloudrunner 11-28-2018 03:03 PM

I think both Koya and Bludgeon had decent character building during Karai's mini, but I still don't care that much about them. I think maybe they just need more interaction with the turtles and other characters to cement themselves. Hopefully we can see more of that in the coming arc. Though I hope they do a better job fleshing them out than they did Alopex, who gets occasional spurts of development before being completely forgotten about (even during plot points she would legitimately be invested in *cough* pantheon *cough*).

Igglet 11-28-2018 03:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cloudrunner (Post 1784031)
I think both Koya and Bludgeon had decent character building during Karai's mini, but I still don't care that much about them. I think maybe they just need more interaction with the turtles and other characters to cement themselves. Hopefully we can see more of that in the coming arc. Though I hope they do a better job fleshing them out than they did Alopex, who gets occasional spurts of development before being completely forgotten about (even during plot points she would legitimately be invested in *cough* pantheon *cough*).

Funnily enough, I was just reading through TMNTEntity's older reviews and one thing caught my attention- Bludgeon has been in the story since #37. Koya was introduced even before that, way back in #25, though the first time she appeared as a mutant was in #29. That was almost 50 issues ago. Honestly, people make fun of the Pantheon for being such a slow burner but this is on a whole other level (although there's obviously a difference between main antagonists and side characters like them). Of all the characters that've been around for this long, they've the least fleshed out personality/have done the least.

CyberCubed 11-28-2018 03:27 PM

Koya has gotten some very good characterisation I'd say, she's pretty well developed. Bludgeon is more or less there as her companion, and Ocho we literally were just introduced to the prior time he appeared, so...

Igglet 11-28-2018 03:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1784041)
Koya has gotten some very good characterisation I'd say, she's pretty well developed. Bludgeon is more or less there as her companion, and Ocho we literally were just introduced to the prior time he appeared, so...

I'd argue otherwise but honestly I literally for the life of me couldn't remember Karai's Path if you held me at gunpoint. Like, I literally didn't remember who Ocho was until someone reminded me. And I'm not saying this to mock the issue, it's genuinely just a blank spot in my brain.

Utrommaniac 11-28-2018 03:48 PM

They still haven't fixed the barn :lol: !

It was a nice issue though. It was good to get Leo centered and get Koya to get off her eternal "I hate Leonardo" schtic - it had been there long before Leo cut her wings. I'm especially happy that she seemed to take his apology.


But...

Does this mean Leo's going to have a cool scar under his mask???

neatoman 11-28-2018 03:55 PM

So I really enjoyed the paneling and the artwork in this one. It was really nice to read.

The only sort of con is that the plot can be summed up like this:
Karai: I'm here to take back the Foot clan!
Leo:... Good, I don't want it and I don't want my dad running it.
Karai: Oh... OK then. Bye.

It's strangely lacking in conflict. Or at least conflict Leo can't be bothered with. Even the fight with Koya ends because Leo just didn't give a ****.

Sophie Campbell 11-28-2018 06:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Utrommaniac (Post 1784045)
They still haven't fixed the barn :lol: !

Does this mean Leo's going to have a cool scar under his mask???

I ALMOST had a panel of the Turtles fixing the barn in the montage page toward the end but I decided not to do it, haha.

I've been trying to get them to let me give Leo a permanent scar for years now!! ;)

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 11-28-2018 06:57 PM

I loved this. I love how Sophie kept turning expectations on their heads--no huge fight, words over war, Leo finding a better way that brute force...

THAT was an amazing Leonardo tale, an amazing TMNT tale, and a very promising step towards the next big event! :tcool: It felt Mirage, even... where it was about something more than the action.

Congrats, Sophie. I think you wrote my favorite IDW TMNT issue to date!

But Leo's a naive nellie if he thinks Splinter is just gonna retire with his Foot pension and gold watch. :tlol: But it's perfectly in character and works. WE know it won't, but Leo does have enough reason to expect Splinter to make the smart choice.

...

Except Splinter aligned with Bishop 10 issues back. So maaaaaaaaaaaybe Leo's even more naive and dumb than I thought. :tlol: :tlol: :tlol: :tlol:

ChosenOne 11-28-2018 07:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1784072)
Except Splinter aligned with Bishop 10 issues back. So maaaaaaaaaaaybe Leo's even more naive and dumb than I thought. :tlol: :tlol: :tlol: :tlol:

I wonder how Splinter would react if he could see the real Bishop... He'd probably offer him fishsticks instead of fries, much healthier for a growing body. :D

daggio 11-28-2018 11:25 PM

Where this story takes place in the timeline is hard to figure out for me. Yes, I realize it's been said that this is probably meant to take place after "Battle Lines", but if it does it seems it has to take place much later. I know it would have been a spoiler if Slash had been mentioned, but I would've tended to believe that they were taking a break cuz of what had happened to him, but no mention of that. They mention needing a break from Splinter and the Foot Clan. If this does take place after "Battle Lines" then it would probably have to take place immediately prior to #90 or #91 (pure speculation on my end). Whenever Karai shows up in the ongoing again (90 or 91), we'll have to see if the events of this Macro are mentioned. If this takes place before "Battle Lines", maybe it takes place during "Bebop & Rocksteady Hit the Road" since we saw what happened in the epilogue.

Wentos 11-29-2018 02:28 AM

This issue was superb. The best single issue of the IDW run since issue 50 of the main series. Sophie's work (her writing AND her art!) has never been better.

I honestly can't think of anything else to say other than MORE PLEASE!

Utrommaniac 11-29-2018 02:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sophie Campbell (Post 1784066)
I ALMOST had a panel of the Turtles fixing the barn in the montage page toward the end but I decided not to do it, haha.

I've been trying to get them to let me give Leo a permanent scar for years now!! ;)

All things considered though, at least in my experience spending a summer in Ohio, people these days don't tend to fix their barns if they're not being truly used, so it does make some sense.


Great that it finally happened though. And with pretty good timing story-wise.
I do wonder though, for an illustration perspective, why these scars always seem to be on the right eye. Between Saki and Ch'rell (who has the biggest scar of the lot, in what I'm going to assume was a really big traumatic blow), and now Leo, all of them have scars on the right eye.

Hob doesn't count as having an eye scar, since he doesn't have an eye there at all anymore.

DrReagan 11-29-2018 04:12 AM

Okay but like, I was shipping Karai and, god I can't remember her name, back during Karai's Path, but I didn't actually think it would ever happen, and maybe it still won't, but OH MY GOD, do you all see Karai taking her hand when they were walking away from the turtles????

Like she has her hand in her own, she took her hand! There is absolutely no point to that unless my ship has somehow come true! :D

Oh PLEASE actually be giving me my long dreamed of gay Karai IDW, Please, PLEASE

Igglet 11-29-2018 06:09 AM

I re-read the issue and then read through my comment on it again and honestly, I was probably originally too critical of it. Most of my criticism still does stand, some of the art is not my cup of tea, the mystic stuff was utilized in a pretty meh way, the main conflict wasn't all that engaging and Leo's characterization was pretty bad. But, honestly, looking back at it all, I was probably too nitpicky on some aspects. Why'd I rip into this particular issue while just ignoring the problems with other issues of TMNT? Might be because the other Macros set the bar so high, but I'm not entirely sure, honestly.

I apologize for making this all sound like some blog post or whatever but I did feel like a dick for ripping into it so much.

Rooish 11-29-2018 09:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrReagan (Post 1784101)
Okay but like, I was shipping Karai and, god I can't remember her name, back during Karai's Path, but I didn't actually think it would ever happen, and maybe it still won't, but OH MY GOD, do you all see Karai taking her hand when they were walking away from the turtles????

Like she has her hand in her own, she took her hand! There is absolutely no point to that unless my ship has somehow come true! :D

Oh PLEASE actually be giving me my long dreamed of gay Karai IDW, Please, PLEASE

Yes I did notice that, and I was super confused and thought I had totally forgotten something about Karai’s path. But yeah, cool. Until that point I thought we were getting hints at a Leo-Karai tension, so I’d prefer this.

The art was amazing, I like that it was somewhat less cutesy than Campbell’s previous stuff, and I liked the colouring too except he Nick eye colours. I wish we could see this combo in the ongoing for an arc.

The writing could have used another draft or two. I agree there was not much conflict and that potential conflict with Karai and Koya was wrapped up way too easily—especially Koya!

And this is not Campbell’s fault, but I barely care about Karai, let alone her mutants, as they have hardly appeared in the ongoing in 50 issues.

However, it’s the first time I’ve felt hope that Splinter can come back to the side of good in a long time. And here I was kind of hoping he’d die. Of course he probably will, in 100, the minute he goes back to the Turtles.

ChosenOne 11-29-2018 09:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrReagan (Post 1784101)
Okay but like, I was shipping Karai and, god I can't remember her name, back during Karai's Path, but I didn't actually think it would ever happen, and maybe it still won't, but OH MY GOD, do you all see Karai taking her hand when they were walking away from the turtles????

Like she has her hand in her own, she took her hand! There is absolutely no point to that unless my ship has somehow come true! :D

Oh PLEASE actually be giving me my long dreamed of gay Karai IDW, Please, PLEASE

I did notice that! And also, maybe it's just my imagination, but there seemed to be something going on between Leo and Koya at the end there...

Igglet 11-29-2018 10:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rooish (Post 1784117)
Yes I did notice that, and I was super confused and thought I had totally forgotten something about Karai’s path. But yeah, cool. Until that point I thought we were getting hints at a Leo-Karai tension, so I’d prefer this.

The art was amazing, I like that it was somewhat less cutesy than Campbell’s previous stuff, and I liked the colouring too except he Nick eye colours. I wish we could see this combo in the ongoing for an arc.

The writing could have used another draft or two. I agree there was not much conflict and that potential conflict with Karai and Koya was wrapped up way too easily—especially Koya!

And this is not Campbell’s fault, but I barely care about Karai, let alone her mutants, as they have hardly appeared in the ongoing in 50 issues.

However, it’s the first time I’ve felt hope that Splinter can come back to the side of good in a long time. And here I was kind of hoping he’d die. Of course he probably will, in 100, the minute he goes back to the Turtles.

At this point, I'd reckon he'll actually die in like, #96 maybe. Right after coming back to the turtles, as you suggested. At this point, there doesn't seem to be much REALLY driving the conflict between the ole' Foot gang and the Turtles. If they were to kill Splinter just as he came back to his senses, however...

Sophie Campbell 11-29-2018 12:53 PM

Thanks so much, you guys!

Good to see some of you noticing things I snuck into this issue. :twink:

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1784072)
I loved this. I love how Sophie kept turning expectations on their heads--no huge fight, words over war, Leo finding a better way that brute force...

THAT was an amazing Leonardo tale, an amazing TMNT tale, and a very promising step towards the next big event! :tcool: It felt Mirage, even... where it was about something more than the action.

Congrats, Sophie. I think you wrote my favorite IDW TMNT issue to date!

Thank you SO much, Cylon, that means a lot!! :D I had a blast working on it and getting to do some Mirage-y type stuff finally.

Sophie Campbell 11-29-2018 12:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Utrommaniac (Post 1784100)
Great that it finally happened though. And with pretty good timing story-wise.
I do wonder though, for an illustration perspective, why these scars always seem to be on the right eye. Between Saki and Ch'rell (who has the biggest scar of the lot, in what I'm going to assume was a really big traumatic blow), and now Leo, all of them have scars on the right eye.

Oh, I don't know if the scar will actually be permanent, that depends entirely on the powers-that-be and the other artists working on the series. But I left the door open!! ;)

That's an interesting note about right eye scars, I never noticed! The main reason I did a right eye cut in this case is because of how the sequence was laid out: I wanted the characters pointing to the right because that's the direction the page is read, so Leo's right eye would have to be facing the viewer so that's the eye I slashed up for clarity's and storytelling's sake. If I'd picked the left eye you wouldn't have been able to see it in the profile shots. And now that you've brought it up, I really like Leo and Saki having a cut on the same eye.

martinitolove 11-29-2018 01:28 PM

Now we get a hint at Karai beeing lesbian, as in the 2012 show. It's fine by me, but how male, boring and ugly Natsu is! Compare her to Shinigami - a phantastic, beautiful and feminine character! I love Karai and hope she'll find a worthy partner ;)

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1784027)
1. Natsu (was that her name?), Ocho, and Bludgeon don't even talk, or say a single line. Even when they're all standing next to each other. Am I correct in saying this is the first time Natsu and Ocho have ever met the Turtles, and vice versa? Like..they don't even know who they are. Really strange Natsu didn't get a single line of dialogue.

2. Koya being bloodthirsty to take revenge on Leonardo, to backing down so quickly, felt kinda rushed. Also remember there was a back-up in Universe showing Koya seemingly go more insane with her lust to take revenge on Leonardo, and this didn't really seem to pick up from that plot point as well as it could have.

3. Karai was also a lot more friendly with the Turtles than she should of been, considering the last time they met was issue 50, where Splinter killed Shredder and Karai just seemingly split after Splinter asked if they could be allies. I mean have people forgotten Karai has not been in the main ongoing since issue 50? Her interactions with the Turtles seem far too friendly from their previous encounter, like there was some middle story arc we missed or something.

These are my issues with the story as well.

Rooish 11-29-2018 01:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by martinitolove (Post 1784148)
Now we get a hint at Karai beeing lesbian, as in the 2012 show. It's fine by me, but how male, boring and ugly Natsu is! Compare her to Shinigami - a phantastic, beautiful and feminine character! I love Karai and hope she'll find a worthy partner ;)

These are my issues with the story as well.

Yikes. You recognize not every woman wants to present as “feminine”, right? I don’t think Natsu is “ugly” or “male”, she just has a shaved head! Assuming Natsu identifies as a woman, I have always appreciated the variety in Campbell’s art of women, showing people who may be fatter or curvier, or less “feminine”, but still are women, too.

Also I’m pretty sure 2012 couldn’t say Karai was a lesbian, although I did totes ship her and Shinigami.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:03 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.