![]() |
Splinter's line in the first movie, "All fathers care for their sons" - problematic?
Obviously Splinter was talking about himself here, but we know in the real world, that line is not true. Some fathers never even meet their sons/kids, they impregnate some woman and then go off and never take responsibility or are absent fathers. Other fathers beat or abuse their sons. Or other fathers are just deadbeat dads who even if they stay with their sons barely do anything to take care of them.
Do you find that line problematic in today's day and age? Instead Splinter should say, "All fathers *should* care for their sons." |
Have you been drinking?
|
You're way overthinking this.
|
Cubed, you getting woke? :lol:
No, it's not a problematic line. |
Quote:
Quote:
|
I got to admit, I kind of missed it.
I love you Cubed. |
SJWcubed ? :lol:
|
I believe the line Splinter is meaning is "All good fathers care about their sons."
|
Quote:
"He may have been your father boy, but he wasn't your daddy" |
He menas Most fathers care for their sons.
|
All fathers, worth the pot they piss in, care for their sons.
|
Funny enough, I have no clue who my actual father is, but I never had any issue with that line. Guess I just always knew what he meant.
|
I have no issues, took it to mean generally or his own feelings. Not thought about it.
|
Splinter also tries to get out of the situation he's in (chained to a wall in Shredder's hideout). He had to realize instinctively that Danny had not run away from a family that was abusing him (he's rather the kind of typical lost/rebellious teenager), and he tries to awaken his empathy by showing him that they share a logic of "stable" people. And in the end, it works ... The use of psychology sounds rather ninja to me.
|
I don’t have a problem with Splinter’s line, but I can see why some people might.
|
Just an old guy speaking from his own perspective and maybe can't fathom how a father wouldn't.
edit: This Splinter was also always a rat and living life hidden away the reality of many human parent-child relationships may be a little foreign to him. (Lets face it, there was no Dr. Phil for him to watch back then. lol) Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Let's look at it this way. Splinter is obviously not the Turtles' biological father, but he was the one who found them abandoned, fed them, raised them, and trained them. Despite their differences, they all care for each other very much and he is very much their "father."
Remember that Shredder said in his grand speech "This is your family. I am your father," but he used the kids who he took in as pawns for money and power instead of acting like a real father to them. Splinter takes issue with this and tells the kids that the Foot Clan is not a family and Shredder is using them for his own desires. Danny's father, while not amazing by any stretch, isn't a terrible person and deep down he certainly does care for him. |
I must confess, as a kid it went right past me, but when I was a teen and later an adult, I've seen more people than you might think give that line the old Mrs. Krabappel "HAH!" whenever I've watched the movie in a small group.
Everybody just lets it slide, but yeah, ol' Splinter was definitely making a major ass-pull when he came up with that line. It's factually incorrect and easily disproven. All fathers should care for their sons, but a lot of them absolutely don't. But that wouldn't have achieved the same dramatic effect, obviously. |
I read this at lunch during a streasful workday. Thanks for bringing Cubism back.:lol:
What a nitpick. All SHOULD, but don't. Never would have tbought about it. |
Well, please consider that if anyone has been abused by their parent(s), it's a little bit more than just a nitpick.
I know plenty of people who wish their fathers were dead and they're rather justified in feeling that way. So yeah, whenever they watch that movie, that scene either gets an eye-roll or a massive disgusted groan. Just sayin'. Whether it annoys a person or not most likely depends on how they themselves were treated by their parental figure. |
Deja vu :lol:
|
Quote:
So Splinter could feel Danny as much as feels a sense of belonging with the Foot Clan, he does have his doubts about them. So Splinter is telling him that just because his father seems as though he doesn't have time for him, that doesn't mean he doesn't care about him. Because real fathers do care about their children. There are men who have children but don't want the responsibility so they up an abandon their families. Or if they stay they use the child as something else to take their anger out on, or they see the child just as a means of controlling the mother. So there are people who are biologically fathers, but they aren't real fathers. |
"All fathers should care for their sons" doesn't carry much weight, and would probably leave the audience pondering more than feeling. The line as-is works.
Sperm banks on legs aren't fathers. Abusive parents are hardly fatherly either. Splinter is a real father. He embodies what everyone wants in a dad. He loves them unconditionally, even though they are a completely different species from himself. As a kid who grew up with several step-parents in my life, that's an important message. Very important to consider the context between Splinter and Danny too, who's dad may seem controlling from his teenage perspective, but in reality is hardly abusive and is proven to be very loving and concerned, which he thankfully realizes. Splinter helped that along. Lastly, it's a movie for kids, speaking to them on their level. The intention behind the statement is more important than the pessimistic breakdown. Now, let's imagine a kid who's not loved (or worse, abused) by their father and is old enough to have this level of introspective thought sees the movie, hears the line, and reflects on what they heard. I don't think they are going to say to themselves, "no they don't! what a lie." The thought process is probably more along the lines of, "that sounds right, that is what a true father would say. it's too bad my father is not like that. this is an injustice." |
I understood what Splinter meant in that line and, I still have a Dad. My stepmother understood what Splinter meant and she actually shed a few tears because, she had a Dad.
For the two of us that have/ had fathers that we bonded with, Splinter's line from TMNT 1 definitely did pull a few heartstrings for us. |
Quote:
|
They should make a Splinter/Mr Miyagi skit :lol::P
|
Quote:
|
That line is just splinters own personal opinion like everything we say is our own and not someone elses, defined by their own relations with people and world around them.
I feel for some of You guys but You also cant be so naive, a lot of women prevent their kids to have normal contacts with fathers and justice system is so rigged that father has almost no chance against woman who accuses him of usual drinking, violence etc. even if there was no proof of that, only thing that matters for a lot of mothers is alimony and revenge through kids, just look around.I witnessed it and witness it day by day, women demand more money and threating fathers to never see kids again etc. What kind of human being does this, he has money or not he's still the father. Many fathers cut contact cause they dont want to be on this kind of terms raising their kids which are used as weapon against them. Its super easy to blame one person but life is not like this, every father had reasons which are not just "i dont care about the kid" My friend didnt even wanted to talk with father and ask him what was his reason they split etc. Because of money or hurt feelings, but what about his father's feelings, he obviously had it hard if he made this kind of decision, i doubt that he was super happy about it.In the end eveyrone preferes peace and order, complete family.At least thats what circle of life is about, if you dont want to play that game just do vasectomy and i dont blame any man for doing this, justice system is totally against men when it comes to custody of kids especially now with #metoo movement every argument between man and woman is violence against her and unless you have proof youre in trouble if you get yourself into argument with woman who loves to victimize herself and a lot of women do like that, because it pays off $$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ and theres no penalty for lying in court in this kind of cases cause its about the custody not abuse but still they believe her and wont check the facts. I totally understand fathers who wouldnt putup with vengeful woman using their child as weapon.They have no will and help to fight this kind of abuse , especially with all the women in courts as judges helping each other get kids and point fingers at bad fathers. This sounds like a joke but its reality of court system when it comes to having normal relations with kids if youre man or woman, women win in 90% of cases even if fathers have no history of proven abuse.I wish they would teach young boys about this at school. |
Quote:
|
I take more offence at the idea that nobody understands cricket.
|
Quote:
Are you saying abusive and neglectful fathers don't exist? Anyway, whenever I heard this line I would wince a bit in empathy for kids who watched it who didn't have caring fathers, but I guess they would understand that all fathers SHOULD care for their sons. Or children in general. Whatever. |
Clearly TMNT 1990 is a problematic movie in today's world, sure those things were acceptable back then but it was wrong then and it is wrong now. Best we can hope is that the movie is discontinued or at the very least that scene cut out from all future releases.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
It is quite impossible to talk about these things without drama, everyone has their own.Everyones way of thinking about these things is their own opinion, my father drank a lot but now when i look at it, it wasnt as bad for me, i didnt get beat up , when youre older some drama from the past becomes almost irrelevant.A lot of people strive for drama cause it makes their life interesting.They just love pulling victim card.I can do that too but how about no.Move on.
|
Quote:
|
First understand the phrase "the exception proves the rule", then you will understand what Splinter is talking about.
|
Quote:
Let's all watch this scene together shall we? Notice that Splinter says the "fathers" line at the end of the dialogue here. The way Danny says, "My father couldn't care less about me,' conveys that he isn't being abused, but rather he feels lorded over and ignored. Also, we can tell that Splinter has a way to read people from his first line about Danny's face wearing "so many burdens." Splinter knew what he was doing and played on Danny's sympathy to escape, but at the same time offer his hand in friendship. And yes, ultimately it does work, after their next scene together where we learn -- along with Danny -- the history between Splinter and Shredder. Danny quits the Foot, releases Splinter (with Casey's help), goes back to his father, and even gives April back the money he stole. I really don't think this particular line is all that problematic. |
How is this thread still open and how does it have two pages to it? This thread needs to die a slow death. Makes no sense.
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 05:04 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.