The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   Should TMNT 1990 be considered a Cult Classic? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=62062)

Cyndaquilfan123 11-19-2019 07:00 PM

Should TMNT 1990 be considered a Cult Classic?
 
So, a friend and I have a movie night every once in awhile and I show him films I really enjoy. So, last week I showed my friend TMNT 1990 for the first time. I don't think he had ever heard of the film. He really enjoyed it. Then I realized, so many people I know in my generation, (Gen Z) have never heard of this film, or flat out doesn't know it exists. I thought about it, and the Original film has a lot of the trademarks of a cult film.

1. it was based off a cult comic book, but while the 87 toon was huge, most people obviously don't know that book exists.

2. It's got the quotability of a cult film. Most people would not get it if I were to "Pizza Dude's got 30 seconds." or the Pork rind scene?

3. While not pushing it, it's got a little bit of that underground feel, like you don't see films with a secret club of underage guys smoking cigarettes all the time.

I don't know guys, do you agree with me here or am I completely off the mark? I'm just kinda frustrated that more people haven't seen this film.

Powder 11-19-2019 08:07 PM

It IS a cult classic. It was the most successful independent movie ever made, at it's time, & is still largely considered one of the best comic book adaptions in cinema. Doesn't surprise me that zoomers have missed out on it, but I'd be hard pressed to try & sell to them. You definitely don't seem to really get how big it is in the grand scheme of things, though. Maybe your fluoride peers don't get the references, but millions of other people would.

frank_one 11-19-2019 08:53 PM

I guess it's a cult, but it's not a classic.

Andrew NDB 11-19-2019 09:42 PM

I guess that's accurate.

CyberCubed 11-20-2019 08:51 AM

The first TMNT movie is the Citizen Cane of comic book movies. Also the first TMNT movie invented “Marvel humor” three decades before it became a thing. So funny to watch a movie from 1990 and see what would evolve into “Marvel humor.”

IndigoErth 11-20-2019 11:10 AM

Might be a little too niche, but it really aught to be one.

But people not knowing it exists... this does not compute. >.< Lack of showings on tv and elsewhere are depriving these kids!

Prowler 11-20-2019 11:34 AM

Should?! Isn't it one already? It is or at least was for a long time the highest grossing independent film ever. It's not like it's a movie that the world forgot or overlooked. It's very important to the TMNT legacy and generally liked by people. So who'd argue against it being a cult classic?

AquaParade 11-20-2019 12:13 PM

I think it gets a lot of respect from those who have re-watched it growing up, but, in my mind, it hasn't achieved that classic cult status in the mainstream. I think people need to be reminded how awesome this movie was, and they are when someone forces them to go back to it, but I think many people have forgotten this film and probably chalk it up as being on par with the Fred Wolf cartoon or something.

Wesley 11-20-2019 12:22 PM

I agree it should be considered a cult classic. Took me a while to get into it, though, as I didnt grow up with it and didn’t like it the first time I watched it for some reason. Probably wouldn’t have given the film a go if it wasn’t for this forum.

AquaParade 11-20-2019 12:41 PM

In my earliest memories of TMNT, I remember Secret of the Ooze being my favorite. It was probably around middle school when I finally realized the first film was way more suited to my tastes.

IMJ 11-20-2019 02:34 PM

The first (and arguably second) flicks are cult classics. There's no consideration to be had. There's no official governing bodies that assign this title.

They simply are by virtue of the core fanbase that still loves the movies, and the fact that they've maintained relevance in those circles all of this time.

I would have thought that this was obvious.

wpugh2424 11-20-2019 02:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by IMJ (Post 1826313)
The first (and arguably second) flicks are cult classics. There's no consideration to be had. There's no official governing bodies that assign this title.

They simply are by virtue of the core fanbase that still loves the movies, and the fact that they've maintained relevance in those circles all of this time.

I would have thought that this was obvious.

Agreed
There should be no question this a cult classic. We are still watching and talking about it to this day, and we have yet to see any other turtle movie come close to it’s charm and pure radness.

AquaParade 11-20-2019 04:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by IMJ (Post 1826313)
The first (and arguably second) flicks are cult classics. There's no consideration to be had. There's no official governing bodies that assign this title.

They simply are by virtue of the core fanbase that still loves the movies, and the fact that they've maintained relevance in those circles all of this time.

I would have thought that this was obvious.

I guess I never understood the term correctly.

Still seems like a sort of nebulous term to apply to something, but sure, it's a "cult classic".

d_osborn 11-20-2019 11:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by IMJ (Post 1826313)
The first (and arguably second) flicks are cult classics. There's no consideration to be had. There's no official governing bodies that assign this title.

They simply are by virtue of the core fanbase that still loves the movies, and the fact that they've maintained relevance in those circles all of this time.

I would have thought that this was obvious.

https://i.imgur.com/fWXct66.jpg

Coola Yagami 11-24-2019 12:55 PM

I'd say it is.

I have to say, re-watching it as an adult, the more serious themes resonate more. As a kid, all the 'turtles wallowing in their defeat' stuff bored me. As an adult I understood it was important to better pump up their grand return to New York, and all the stuff regarding the Turtles thinking their father was dead and all that made it go beyond just some silly kids movie.

ABrown 11-24-2019 06:38 PM

I would say that the first movie would fall into the category of "cult classic". It's what made me a TMNT fan to begin with. I remember I watched and enjoyed the original cartoon as a child, but I had always wanted it to be a little closer what the 1990 movie was. So I was really excited as a teenager when I first saw the OT had reinvented itself into the "red sky era".

Leo656 11-24-2019 06:45 PM

I think it has to be a "cult classic" for the simple fact of, 1. I still run into the occasional person who has neither seen or sometimes even heard of it, and 2. Most people who see it, including those aforementioned, inevitably think it's at least Really Good if not Great.

In a perfect world it would simply be "a classic", but I still run into too many people of all ages who've somehow never seen or heard of it. So obviously it didn't quite set the world on fire to the degree it deserved to, despite being very successful by a variety of metrics.

snake 11-25-2019 01:12 AM

It is. Helps that the film only gets better with age, too.

Andrew NDB 11-25-2019 01:22 AM

I don't think it gets better with age. It only gets increasingly better by comparison of anything new they put out.

Bottom line, they sold themselves way short with this even if this was the best possible movie they were allowed to make in 1990 with everything at play working against them.

Prowler 11-25-2019 02:32 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1826782)
I think it has to be a "cult classic" for the simple fact of, 1. I still run into the occasional person who has neither seen or sometimes even heard of it, and 2. Most people who see it, including those aforementioned, inevitably think it's at least Really Good if not Great.

In a perfect world it would simply be "a classic", but I still run into too many people of all ages who've somehow never seen or heard of it. So obviously it didn't quite set the world on fire to the degree it deserved to, despite being very successful by a variety of metrics.

No idea how many people on Earth have seen it, but quite a lot. When you mention a TMNT movie to your average Joe, that's always the one they first think of.

It might not be a movie NEARLY EVERYONE watched like Star Wars, The Lord of the Rings, The Godfather, Titanic(I feel like I'm the only one who hasn't), etc. But it's definitely a famous movie. It helps that it came out right during the peak of Turtlemania too.

For the record, in Portugal, we didn't get the cartoon until 1990 after the movie aired in the cinemas. Not sure if the same happened in other countries. But maybe that might have contributed to it not being even bigger. Americans already knew what the Turtles were and were ready to pay to watch it, while here people didn't know what the Turtles were at all and several people might simply not have been interested in going to watch it at the cinema. "What? Guys wearing Turtle suits? What a stupid idea!"

pferreira 11-27-2019 03:41 PM

Cult classic? Not sure. It was a very successful movie. I suppose it would be like saying that 1989s Batman is a cult classic. I normally reserve that title for movies that didn't do well at the Box Office and are not known by a large group of people.

Hamato Yoshi 11-30-2019 05:46 AM

Cult classic is like Horror Express , a flop in native Spain but appriciated much more today......imo TMNT is prolly not a cc

Leo656 11-30-2019 07:00 AM

I think it counts because most "normal" people, while they've probably heard of it, most likely never saw it (and that group of people grows larger every year; there's an entire generation that most likely never even heard of it by now, if we're being honest). And if you bring it up in conversation, they'll inevitably think it sounds incredibly stupid, BUT when they finally see it, they think it's better than it had any right to be.

TMNT 1990 absolutely hits multiple criteria for the admittedly-vague category of what a "cult classic" is. I don't think "TMNT fans all like it" and "It made a little money (because it didn't cost too much)" are enough to put it over.

Skimming Wikipedia's definition, while movies that bombed or are mostly unheard of tend to come to mind first, there's tons of things that allow a movie to fit the definition.

From Wikipedia:
A cult film or cult movie, also commonly referred to as a cult classic, is a film that has acquired a cult following. Cult films are known for their dedicated, passionate fanbase, an elaborate subculture that engage in repeated viewings, quoting dialogue, and audience participation.

Sounds pretty clear-cut to me.

mikey0 12-04-2019 10:21 AM

The 1990 TMNT movie is the highest-grossing independent film of all time. It deserves something for that alone. It’s not Tim Burton’s Batman from 1989 like another user in this thread point out already, but there were so many answers from other film directors and comic book producers to the 1990 TMNT film like the 1993 Super Mario Brothers film, The Crow from 1994, The Shadow from 1994, The Mask from 1994, The Phantom from 1996, Spawn from 1997, and Men In Black from 1997. The 1990 TMNT movie was a one of a kind gem that gives an movie viewer a good chance to look into what living in the very late 80s (1989 when the movie was filmed) was like. The 1990 TMNT movie falls a little short of being 1989 Batman, but it knocks out Howard the Duck from 1986 and Dick Tracy from 1990 in terms of being seen as a cult classic.

Hamato Yoshi 12-04-2019 10:28 AM

Phantom from '96 was lousy imo compared to the comic strip or the scandinavian comics

mikey0 12-04-2019 12:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Hamato Yoshi (Post 1827877)
Phantom from '96 was lousy imo compared to the comic strip or the scandinavian comics

None of the movies based off of comic strips or independent comic books that came after the 1990 TMNT in the 90s were as successful as the first ever TMNT film.

IMJ 12-04-2019 12:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1827464)
From Wikipedia:
A cult film or cult movie, also commonly referred to as a cult classic, is a film that has acquired a cult following. Cult films are known for their dedicated, passionate fanbase, an elaborate subculture that engage in repeated viewings, quoting dialogue, and audience participation.

Sounds pretty clear-cut to me.

Exactly.

Any other opinions about this are people interpolating information into what a cult classic is. This is such a strange conversation. TMNT '90 is a cult classic.

AquaParade 12-04-2019 02:57 PM

Well when trying to label something, you have to break down the meaning of the term. And I'm betting we could find definitions that contradict one another.

I mean, I'm fine being wrong, but my understanding was that a cult classic, was a film that wasn't appreciated upon release but garnered a dedicated following throughout the years, anyway. Wouldn't describe the first TMNT film, which was a smash success.

EDIT: Like this article seems to describe:

https://www.liveabout.com/what-is-a-cult-film-4156574
Quote:

The term “cult film” (and later “cult classic” as the film ages) is used to describe a movie that has developed a small, but significant and thoroughly dedicated, fanbase that grows over time. While hugely successful blockbuster franchises like "Star Wars" and "Harry Potter" have such enthusiastic fans that the movies seem to have cult-like influence, the term “cult film” specifically refers to movies that despite being much less successful financially nonetheless have passionate fans.
In a situation like this, who is the authority on the term? A simple Google search will find you many different interpretations. Not much of a consensus.

EDIt 2: Another definition that fits my understanding: https://www.yourdictionary.com/cult-classic
Quote:

A work of fiction that is extremely popular with a select audience but may or may not be successful at the time of the work's original publication.
With weekly viewings in movie theaters running continuously for over thirty years, The Rocky Horror Picture Show is a major cult classic despite having since become known to the general public.
I don't say this to prove I'm right, but maybe we should make sure to leave a little room for discussion here, and not get riled up if someone disagrees.

Leo656 12-04-2019 06:06 PM

Not riled up, just pointing out that 1. It made money and 2. "It's one of my favorite movies of allll tiiiiiiiime!" isn't enough to disqualify it, nor does "cult classic" status make it any less of a great movie or even "bad" in any way whatsoever.

"Cult classic" is not a bad thing; some people simply get annoyed when it's attached to a movie they personally love, because it makes them feel insecure. The fact is, even movies that were popular and made money can be "cult classics". It's a VERY broad term, as has been discussed already at length, but in this movie's case I definitely feel that it applies more than it doesn't.

It may have far outshined expectations for an independent film, but it didn't set the world on fire or have the long-term impact on the world the way, say, Batman '89 did, for example. Most non-TMNT fans have completely forgotten about it, and enough time has passed where an entire generation has barely heard of it. And that's another factor to consider.

Maybe it wouldn't fit the definition if we were talking about this in, say, 1993, but I'd say that in 2019, it's more of a "cult classic" than not. And that's fine! I don't get why people bristle so much at the suggestion, other than personal insecurity that their personal favorite thing might not actually be as popular with the rest of the world as it is with them. Calling something a "cult classic" doesn't automatically put it in "Howard The Duck" territory; it's a perfectly reasonable descriptor for ANY movie that had a much greater impact with a subsection of the population than it did with the masses at large.

I feel like the people who insist that it's not are the ones who may be "riled up" about it. It doesn't have to hit every qualifying box but it definitely hits some of the important ones. That's good enough for me.

IMJ 12-04-2019 08:51 PM

I love the 90's flick, The Crow. Have since High School. It was successful upon release. It's definitely a cult classic.
I love the 80's flick, Krull. It was a flop when it came out. It's still got a following today, and prop guys love making glaives and still talk about the movie. It's definitely a cult classic.

I would err on the side that a flick's initial success doesn't define this at all. It's more about whether or not a flick stays relevant across time through a dedicated fanbase that doesn't abandon it even when much of greater society has moved on.

Star Wars is not a cult classic because it has thrived in multi-media and is instead a cultural phenomena.

mikey0 12-04-2019 10:48 PM

TMNT 1990 made the TMNT become a household name, but it does not have a cult following like Donnie Darko, Mean Girls, or Hocus Pocus.

IMJ 12-04-2019 11:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mikey0 (Post 1828030)
TMNT 1990 made the TMNT become a household name, but it does not have a cult following like Donnie Darko, Mean Girls, or Hocus Pocus.

Huh?
It has us. Dude we are the cult following amidst a society that largely does not care about that movie anymore.

mikey0 12-05-2019 12:00 AM

I do not see a TMNT 1990 musical coming to Broadway any time soon like Beetlejuice, Mean Girls, and The Rocky Horror Picture Show. TMNT 1990 is not a cult classic.

TMNT 1990 kicked off the TMNT craze of the very early 1990s (Turtlemania of 1990) and became the highest-grossing independent comic book film of all time. That was it, though.

IMJ 12-05-2019 12:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mikey0 (Post 1828033)
I do not see a TMNT 1990 musical coming to Broadway any time soon like Beetlejuice, Mean Girls, and The Rocky Horror Picture Show. TMNT 1990 is not a cult classic.

TMNT 1990 kicked off the TMNT craze of the very early 1990s (Turtlemania of 1990) and became the highest-grossing independent comic book film of all time. That was it, though.

Does the greater society / movie-going public still care about TMNT '90? How and in what circles has the film remained in conversation?
It seems as if, by your logic TMNT '90 is now nothing more than an old movie that no one cares about because there isn't a musical in production.

yet there is a dedicated core following for the movie. Right here. Posting where you are reading it everyday on your computer screen. Cult. About an old movie, that by all rights should have been gone from the public eye completely by now. Classic.

mikey0 12-05-2019 08:32 AM

Perhaps, there needs to be a documentary on cult classic films like Mean Girls, Hocus Pocus, The Room, Donnie Darko, Heavy Metal, and The Rocky Horror Picture Show to explain what makes a film a cult classic.

TMNT 1990 was relevant at the time, but the TMNT fandom, a few Gen Xers, some Gen XYers, and a small number of Gen Yers are the only ones bringing the film up every now and then in this century. There is not a following outside of those groups, that I mentioned, devoted exclusively to TMNT 1990.

AquaParade 12-05-2019 10:53 AM

I'd love to consider the film a cult classic. Sounds badass.

I just don't think there is a definitive term. My case sort of rests at the fact that the first page of google turns up like 5 contradicting terms. But words are what we make them. So whatever. Interesting discussion, but doesn't matter much to me what the result is. Not something to get upset over.

Quote:

Originally Posted by mikey0 (Post 1828050)
Perhaps, there needs to be a documentary on cult classic films like Mean Girls, Hocus Pocus, The Room, Donnie Darko, Heavy Metal, and The Rocky Horror Picture Show to explain what makes a film a cult classic.

TMNT 1990 was relevant at the time, but the TMNT fandom, a few Gen Xers, some Gen XYers, and a small number of Gen Yers are the only ones bringing the film up every now and then in this century. There is not a following outside of those groups, that I mentioned, devoted exclusively to TMNT 1990.

See, this also sort of rings true with me, but I still defer to the fact that the term is nebulous.

MsMarvelDuckie 12-08-2019 07:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mikey0 (Post 1828050)
Perhaps, there needs to be a documentary on cult classic films like Mean Girls, Hocus Pocus, The Room, Donnie Darko, Heavy Metal, and The Rocky Horror Picture Show to explain what makes a film a cult classic.

TMNT 1990 was relevant at the time, but the TMNT fandom, a few Gen Xers, some Gen XYers, and a small number of Gen Yers are the only ones bringing the film up every now and then in this century. There is not a following outside of those groups, that I mentioned, devoted exclusively to TMNT 1990.

Isn't that pretty much the definition of a CULT classic, though? I mean, if we're being totally honest here, we ARE the cult. And, yes, it IS a classic at this point. More to the point, there have been two sequels, and then two seperate reboot/remake attempts, which has kept it relevant and discussed both within the "cult" itself, and by the media at large when those reboots are discussed. So- yeah, it IS a cult classic by any definition, as you just demonstrated yourself.

IMJ 12-08-2019 09:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by MsMarvelDuckie (Post 1828359)
Isn't that pretty much the definition of a CULT classic, though? I mean, if we're being totally honest here, we ARE the cult. And, yes, it IS a classic at this point. More to the point, there have been two sequels, and then two seperate reboot/remake attempts, which has kept it relevant and discussed both within the "cult" itself, and by the media at large when those reboots are discussed. So- yeah, it IS a cult classic by any definition, as you just demonstrated yourself.

This is exactly what I said to our guy here in post #32 above. No one reads anymore.

:P:P:lol::P

Masterpiece 01-01-2020 04:59 AM

It's more than a Cult Classic.

It's a Masterpiece.

Cyndaquilfan123 01-03-2020 06:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Masterpiece (Post 1830607)
It's more than a Cult Classic.

It's a Masterpiece.


You said it.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:34 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.