The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Fate of the Mirage TMNT (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=62600)

rs_jr 05-11-2020 04:05 PM

Fate of the Mirage TMNT
 
Hi

With Last Ronin coming out and I am not sure if they mentioned if it is in Mirage future of not?

Is it assumed that Turtle in Last Ronin is Don?

Did the Mirage comics ever mention or imply what happened to each Turtle?

I though Don was the last one around and did Mikey disappear into space or am I nit remembering things correctly?

Old Ralph ended up training new generation of Mutants but that was from the Palidum books i thinks.

Did Leo just die from old age, was it swan song?

Andrew NDB 05-11-2020 07:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rs_jr (Post 1845069)
With Last Ronin coming out and I am not sure if they mentioned if it is in Mirage future of not?

No. It's supposed to be a potential future for almost any TMNT universe.

Quote:

Did the Mirage comics ever mention or imply what happened to each Turtle?

I though Don was the last one around and did Mikey disappear into space or am I nit remembering things correctly?

Old Ralph ended up training new generation of Mutants but that was from the Palidum books i thinks.

Did Leo just die from old age, was it swan song?
Check out "TMNT: Odyssey."

DK2 05-11-2020 08:44 PM

Kevin has mainly implied Last Ronin is more Mirage than any other TMNT incarnations. Since the story outline was made during their Mirage days and Peter is getting credit I think that's safe to say. But he also says any readers or fans for Last Ronin can deem it for any TMNT incarnations' future too. We can't dwell on any of the dangling plots from Mirage volume 4 that I think your referring to rs_jr. We have no closure for that run. Last Ronin is really more of a "what if" or "elseworlds" for the turtles. Yes there were some Mirage shorts that had Don as the last turtle. Hard to say if it's Don for Last Ronin though.

Leo656 05-11-2020 09:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DK2 (Post 1845081)
We can't dwell on any of the dangling plots from Mirage volume 4 that I think your referring to rs_jr. We have no closure for that run.

Is it Too Soon to say "F*ck Mirage Vol. 4 right in the ear", or can we just go ahead and say that, officially? Because I pretty much always said that, but with time and hindsight as factors, especially... yeah, f*ck that mess.

Zog The Magnificent 05-11-2020 09:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1845083)
Is it Too Soon to say "F*ck Mirage Vol. 4 right in the ear", or can we just go ahead and say that, officially? Because I pretty much always said that, but with time and hindsight as factors, especially... yeah, f*ck that mess.

Are you meaning in terms of ever seeing a conclusion, or in terms of even wanting a conclusion?

As for me, yeah the story is kinda messy. There's a lot of good individual elements, and the overall story is fairly interesting, but it takes far too long for anything to actually happen, and a lot of what does happen never seems to go anywhere productive. I feel like it's sort of like the Prequel Trilogy, which had a good story overall but lost a bunch of points in the actual execution. Though despite that, I still hope somebody finishes it one day. I do SO hate loose ends. When it comes to anything, I'd rather have a bad ending than no ending.

Leo656 05-11-2020 10:49 PM

This is Mirage TMNT Vol. 4, summarized in 20 seconds.



BUT, I'll go into far greater depth because that's what I do. :trazz:

I stopped expecting or caring about any kind of satisfactory conclusion very quickly because it was a rambling, meandering mess from A-to-G. I say "A-to-G" because it was perfectly obvious that "Z" was never gonna f*cking happen! And they didn't even pretend to get close, either.

I could pull anything out of thin air, like "April The Time-Traveling, Roach-F*cking Magical Drawing", but that's a well-flogged horse. The whole Volume was just a gigantic exercise in wasted potential that went nowhere, circled back, then went even more "nowhere" than before.

I just said this to someone the other day, but most of Vol. 4 could have just been done as solo mini-series for various characters... which they later did, anyway. Here's a basic tip: If your story has become SO disconnected that you need four simultaneous solo mini's to actually move things even two measly inches forward, plot-wise, then you've completely lost sight of what's important. And charging four bucks a pop during a recession was absolutely brilliant considering that inside the book, nothing ever happened. And then when something did happen, like Splinter dying, it had all the dramatic weight of someone announcing they were gonna go take a leak. Just nothing. Totally didn't feel like a total waste of my time and money, seriously. Not at all.

For me, Vol. 4 was a mix between "the print version of Ambien" and "Chuck Austen writes better f*cking comics than this and he's CHUCK AUSTEN." I can't remember anything truly, sincerely good past the first issue; just "Meh" and "WOW, that's awful." Like, if you told me that Peter Laird was secretly an alien who had no understanding whatsoever about human emotions, and how to either display or manipulate them, I would totally, totally believe you. I'm sure he's a very nice guy and I'm grateful for what he initially helped create with the TMNT, but good Lord, his writing is as dry and flavorless as a Saltine-and-Rice Cracker sandwich. I know it was his passion and "his vision", but if you're gonna have the audacity to charge $4 a shot during an economic downturn, "your vision" better have some goddamn sizzle or else you're just jerking off.

And I don't especially enjoy paying to watch people jerk off, either literally or metaphorically. But that's what Vol. 4 was. "Peter Laird jerks off for 30-something issues, then gets bored, sells the property, and then goes to take a nap, thus rendering the entirety of Vol. 4 completely f*cking pointless."
-----------------------

All of that said, though, I too would love an ending, even though I didn't like the series. Because I, too, hate unfinished business and stories that don't get to conclude. And frankly, I'd settle for a bad ending. The series wasn't good, so nothing could really do much to significantly "damage" it retroactively. A good ending that ties the entire Mirage saga together in some satisfactory way would be ideal, but also unlikely and I'd settle for literally any ending. Because ANY ending would at least give Vol. 4 a reason to exist, whereas otherwise, it really has none. Outside of, "It allowed Tales of the TMNT Vol. 2 to exist, which was about 100x better than Vol. 4 in every single possible way."

In summation: Mirage TMNT Vol. 4 is definitely, absolutely not even close to being the worst comic I've ever followed. Not even close. It's not even "bad", per se. But it's definitely one of the ones that most made me feel like a total moron for ever caring about it, because I went into it wanting to love it and was given no reason to even care about it. I "did my part for The Franchise" and gave Pete my money; in return, ALL I got was a giant pile of paper, ink, and staples, and very little else.

Tales Vol. 2 was awesome, though.

DK2 05-11-2020 11:12 PM

Yeah to me the TMNT Vol.2 and Vol. 4 series were the slow paced stories. The good issues/main narrative of Vol. 1 and Vol. 3 from Image were the stories with better pace. I clearly think Kevin and Peter complimented each other working together. But on their own its really a mixed bag. Even the initial solo issues in the number 12,14,15,17,18 shows them in that light. Kevin was the action/choreography guy and Peter was the sci-fi/laid back guy. Them writing stories since they weren't really comics pros shows when they work solo. Together they compliment each other. No editor guiding or training them since they were Mirage themselves. Maybe they'd be better writers or storytellers if they had a guided hand in those days? Just my thoughts.

Leo656 05-11-2020 11:42 PM

That's all pretty spot-on. Especially the individual weaknesses of Kevin and Pete and how their collaboration served well to shore up each of their shortcomings. Individually, they're both pretty crummy from different angles. I don't think either of them is a particularly "good" writer. I just think they each have a lot of interesting and good ideas, but they, themselves, maybe aren't the best ones to execute those ideas.

Like, it's a commercial medium. You have to present people with a story worth paying money to read or else you're cheating them. I know Vol. 4 was Pete's personal and uncompromising vision, and I can respect that, but for what it ended up being... Geez, man, that could've been a free webcomic or something, theoretically. That book tread water like a drowning Labrador. Don't make people pay twice the contemporary rate of an average comic book unless you're gonna at least TRY to razzle-dazzle 'em.

Lots and lots of people are creative, and lots and lots of people are great writers, and lots and lots of people have good ideas. But not all people in any or all of those groups should necessarily be the one who decides what gets to make the Final Cut of the product you ship out the door. Like, they should have lots of input, yes, but editors exist for a reason; that reason generally being that most writers and other creatives become so attached to and invested in their work, they lose sight of the fact that their work maybe isn't going to sell for one reason or other, and if you're charging money for a product, you have to "sell" it, as in force people to care.

I mean, look at Grant Morrison, for example. He's a guy with a lot of talent and a ton of good-to-great ideas, but how "readable" and comprehensible his stories are generally comes down to who his editor is on any given project. And with NO editor? Holy SH*T, man, do not let this man run around unfiltered, because that way leads to madness. And he's great! He's one of the best writers to ever write for comic books. But he needs supervision, and probably medication.

Neither Eastman nor Laird is within a mile of being a "Grant Morrison"-caliber writer. So to say "They probably would've done a lot better if they'd A. Kept collaborating, and B. Had someone to tell them when their ideas either sucked or simply weren't reader-friendly," is pretty much a statement of absolute fact.

I mean, just for example... Okay, sure, you can say, objectively and factually, "April's Secret Origin is definitely something that NO TMNT fan ever could have guessed at or imagined!" And that's true. It's a unique idea. And no one WOULD ever have guessed at or imagined that story ever unfolding. Because it's a unique idea, but also a terrible and stupid one, especially the way it was presented. Like we REALLY needed to be told that April got to be a roach and eat bile and f*ck other bugs because, y'know, how else could she go back in time and witness her own creation as a magical drawing, right? I mean, in GOOD comic books, the character's usually just an intangible phantom, or something, but hey, I guess that's been done to death, so we get April The Time Traveling Roach. That's "better". And April being a magical sketch is totally a great idea that doesn't reek of "Too Much F*cking LSD In College, Pete" what-so-f*cking EVER.

Absolutely any editor at any "legitimate" comic book company would have sat Pete down and explained to him in about 37 words why that sh*t wasn't going to the printer, and that would have been the end of it. But y'know, when you're The Boss, nobody's gonna tell you that your ideas are terrible. That's why people should generally not be in charge of editing their own work, especially if they're the ones signing the paychecks.

Sophie Campbell 05-11-2020 11:43 PM

I love TMNT vol. 4!!! :tgrin:

rs_jr 05-12-2020 12:14 AM

Weren't we three issues away from concluding volume 4?

IDW brought back GI JOE though they got Hama.

Do you guys think if they launched a new monthly Tales volume 3 and a bimonthly TMNT mirage vol 5 making it 18 issues per year would do good as the GI JOE RAH did?

Especially if they bring back Lawson, Talbot, Dooney, Murphy and Eastman.
Though not the biggest fan of Morrison he can write street level grittiness and sci-fi.

side question:
Are the IDW color classics ( vol 3 coming out soon) collecting every Mirage issues including Fugatoid and any short stories in publishing release?

Also we need a Sophie Campbell Radical issue :)

Andrew NDB 05-12-2020 12:34 AM

Here's the digital version of the "regular" edition of "Odyssey":

https://www.dropbox.com/s/1otlfrl2tu...Small.pdf?dl=0

Leo656 05-12-2020 12:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sophie Campbell (Post 1845093)
I love TMNT vol. 4!!! :tgrin:

Sometimes I want to go back and read it again.

Instead, I touch myself for a while but go to bed without finishing, denying myself the satisfaction or closure of reaching climax. Then I toss and turn and fall asleep annoyed and unfulfilled.

Because it's more or less the exact same thing. Just, y'know, extremely literally. :tgrin:

This is fun. I am having a good time.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1845099)
Here's the digital version of the "regular" edition of "Odyssey":

https://www.dropbox.com/s/1otlfrl2tu...Small.pdf?dl=0

I love how strong your pimp hand is, brother. I love you. Y'know, within reason. :tgrin:

rs_jr 05-12-2020 02:54 AM

Yes, have Odyssey already in physical form.

I mainly want a regular Mirage TMNT series running monthly or bimonthly.

Ideally Peter and Kevin would be co supervisors but doesn't look like Peter is coming back to regular comic schedule any time soon.

AquaParade 05-12-2020 04:59 AM

I enjoy the fate of the Mirage characters being sort of ambiguous. I get such a thrill out of seeing those melancholy glimpses into the future. The little bit of info we have to go off of stokes the imagination. A lot of the "short stories" are good at this.

Leo656 05-12-2020 11:48 AM

Yeah, and that's well and fair. I myself don't much like it when they do Superman or Batman stories which present "Official Endings" to their journey, for example, because I feel like it limits storytelling by setting a predetermined endpoint that has to be built towards. I don't necessarily need to know how Bruce Wayne's gonna die and have that story be set in stone, or whether Superman's gonna be alive in the 30th Century, or whatever. There's some fun in not knowing and being able to just imagine all the different possibilities. Kingdom Come, for example. One of my favorite DC stories ever. Should it be canon? Oh, Lord no. And neither should "Dark Knight Returns", no matter how many Batman fans insist otherwise.

But I feel like Mirage Vol. 4 could have had ANY ending at all and it would have improved the entire series just by virtue of that. It didn't necessarily need to "close the book" on Mirage TMNT, and definitely didn't need to explicitly explain how the saga would end for everyone, but it at least could have done more than just gotten up and left in mid-sentence.

It's a like a guy running a marathon and deciding 2/3s of the way through it that he'd rather go play ping-pong. Why did you even show up, man? At least finish what you start.

Shred87 05-12-2020 12:14 PM

Very late to party but is there any way to get a hard copy of odyssey?

Diorm 05-12-2020 12:17 PM

https://www.ebay.com/itm/RARE-Ninja-...wAAOSwNXtcLBxg

Shred87 05-12-2020 12:45 PM

Guess online will have to do... wasn’t expecting it to be over 100 bucks

rs_jr 05-12-2020 12:57 PM

I guess I don’t really want s definite ending I just want the story to move forward.

Finish volume 4 and launch after it a volume 5 and a Tales volume 3 and continue the mirage universe on a regular schedule.

AquaParade 05-12-2020 01:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1845140)
Yeah, and that's well and fair. I myself don't much like it when they do Superman or Batman stories which present "Official Endings" to their journey, for example, because I feel like it limits storytelling by setting a predetermined endpoint that has to be built towards. I don't necessarily need to know how Bruce Wayne's gonna die and have that story be set in stone, or whether Superman's gonna be alive in the 30th Century, or whatever. There's some fun in not knowing and being able to just imagine all the different possibilities. Kingdom Come, for example. One of my favorite DC stories ever. Should it be canon? Oh, Lord no. And neither should "Dark Knight Returns", no matter how many Batman fans insist otherwise.

But I feel like Mirage Vol. 4 could have had ANY ending at all and it would have improved the entire series just by virtue of that. It didn't necessarily need to "close the book" on Mirage TMNT, and definitely didn't need to explicitly explain how the saga would end for everyone, but it at least could have done more than just gotten up and left in mid-sentence.

It's a like a guy running a marathon and deciding 2/3s of the way through it that he'd rather go play ping-pong. Why did you even show up, man? At least finish what you start.

Yeah, I'd agree with this. I think Volume 4 is sort of it's own story that deserves to be wrapped up, despite how far (or not) it reaches into the future of the Mirage timeline.

rs_jr 05-12-2020 01:35 PM

I do love to see Lawson come back on a new ongoing mirage TMNT but with some much TMNT coming out of IDW not sure it will sell well plus they probably have to collect volume 4 first so people are caught up

Leo656 05-12-2020 02:30 PM

Can someone actually "sell" me on Jim Lawson?

Like, seriously. I don't get it. He can't draw. Or at least, he can't draw humanoid figures or faces with anything less than the clumsy grace of a well-meaning first-grader. Most people who gush over him tell me openly that they don't read other comic books, which tells me that his art is "good" because they like TMNT and he draws it, but not for much other reason.

I can't think of a single artist on a popular or licensed book whose work was more "ugly". Okay, his dinosaurs are neat, but otherwise...

I mean I'm not trying to be mean, I just don't think the guy's stuff is even a little bit eye-pleasing and it baffles me that so many people love it. And when a lot of them tell me, "Well, I don't read other comics," it kinda makes me assume a lot.

I'unno. I probably won't change my opinion ever, but I'd love for someone to honestly try and explain what it is that makes him so special. He's the objective worst guy out of the entire Mirage crew to draw the main-story books, but he's the guy everyone wants. Why not, like, literally anyone else from Mirage? Consistency? That's dumb. Comics should be eye-pleasing.

Probably a nice guy. No hard feelings, no ill will towards him as a human being. I just really, truly find his art physically painful to look at, and I'd like to know what I'm supposedly missing.

((Shrug))

Zog The Magnificent 05-12-2020 02:40 PM

Yeah, I honestly don't get it. I actually think his art looked way better during City at War, but then he developed his "modern style," which at this point just doesn't look good. I mean, he can draw nature and creatures just fine, but he can't draw human beings. It's very stylized, to the point of being incredibly misshapen and off looking. The only reason he's still around for things is out of tradition's sake at this point. I won't say that it's ugly or the worst art ever, as there were some TMNT short stories that looked worse. That one where they talk about fear, for example. It's not even ugly, persay, it's just unappealing. I can build a resistance to this art, but truly ugly art I don't even want to look at. I've always believed that the story should come before the asthetics, and Jim Lawson is a great example of why. At the very least, having Jim Lawson does make it feel authentic, because like it or not that is what a lot of official TMNT comics looked like.

rs_jr 05-12-2020 02:48 PM

Ya
I agree not a fan of modern Lawson

But old Lawson when it seemed he was inspired by laird art was the best Lawson

Leo656 05-12-2020 03:00 PM

I'll agree he used to be "better" but I'll never say he was "good".

I think he got a job because his buddy ran the show, and he has a lot of loyal fans who never heard of Neal Adams. But that's my admittedly biased and very cynical take on it.

Zog The Magnificent 05-12-2020 03:05 PM

I dunno, it's weird. Like, I don't hate it, but I don't exactly like it either. I can stand it, but it feels more out of necesity than anything else. If I didn't read anything he drew, I'd miss out on half the Mirage TMNT library.

AquaParade 05-12-2020 03:50 PM

Jim's work isn't highly detailed nor are his layouts or perspectives very dynamic, so I understand how his art could come across as rather boring or ineffectual to some.

What I like about Jim Lawson is the surreal aspect to his art. There are a lot of visual moments in Volume 2, mostly involving Baxter Stockman that weird me out in a good way. His work also fits the "slice of life" type vibe of Mirage TMNT. Sort of mundane, yes, but it works at times.

Most of all, I love Jim's pencils on City at War, but I believe he had assistance on that, right?

I'm not a huge fan of Jim's work on volume 4, at least past the first several issues where it appears more detailed. I think his work typically benefits from color.

Leo656 05-12-2020 04:01 PM

A human face that's made up of two misshapen circles and a Spaghetti-O definitely is "surreal".

AquaParade 05-12-2020 04:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1845190)
A human face that's made up of two misshapen circles and a Spaghetti-O definitely is "surreal".

Maybe that's why Pete wanted so many aliens in Vol 4.

But really, certain panels just looked cool. I like some of these panels:

https://www.miragelicensing.com/comi...e02/01/01.html

https://www.miragelicensing.com/comi...e02/05/05.html

I'm sort of proving my former post wrong - some pretty cool perspectives being utilized in Jim's art. Again, I get it the criticisms though.

Volume 4 started off looking pretty good too:

https://www.miragelicensing.com/comi...e04/03/03.html

And then it eventually became this, which I'm less fond of:

https://www.miragelicensing.com/comi...e04/23/23.html

Edit: Volume 2 was dope and I want a hardcover bad.

Leo656 05-12-2020 04:28 PM

I think what bothers me the most is that every other major Mirage TMNT penciller was SO much better than him, but his style is the "Mirage standard" due to the volume of his work, not the quality of it. He drew the most issues by far but his work was poor compared to everyone else who drew the "canon storyline" issues.

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikiped..._vol_1_4-2.jpg

This. This is what I want. Lots and lots and LOTS of This.

I actually got this as a poster as a kid but I never knew what it was based on until many years later. :lol: I don't have it up anymore but it's one of my favorites!

Sharman 05-12-2020 04:30 PM

Laird stated several times on his blog that he had a conclusion planned out for volume 4 and even mentioned that he might just publish the synopsis rather than continue creating the comics.
But then he apparently lost interest in even doing that, so ...

A part of me still hopes that something will stir within PL and nudge him out of retirement just to finish volume 4.

But, in reality ...

AquaParade 05-12-2020 05:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1845192)
I think what bothers me the most is that every other major Mirage TMNT penciller was SO much better than him, but his style is the "Mirage standard" due to the volume of his work, not the quality of it. He drew the most issues by far but his work was poor compared to everyone else who drew the "canon storyline" issues.

https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikiped..._vol_1_4-2.jpg

This. This is what I want. Lots and lots and LOTS of This.

I actually got this as a poster as a kid but I never knew what it was based on until many years later. :lol: I don't have it up anymore but it's one of my favorites!

This is one of my very favorite images of the TMNT. I had this print of the issue when I was younger. It's gorgeous.

Jim is definitely hit or miss for me, but when he's on, there's no denying he is a talented artist. But yeah, the above piece is on another level.

Leo656 05-12-2020 05:22 PM

Yeah, definitely. It's one of my all-time favorite and most iconic images of them. I'm not even a "red bandanas" guy and as a kid it confused me, but it's SO damn clean it doesn't even matter.

Just a serious, serious piece of business, right there.

AquaParade 05-12-2020 05:26 PM

Lord, I love all those old painted Mirage covers. The ones done for the collected editions too. Farley, Dooney, Eastman & Laird as well, if I recall correctly, were all just putting out gorgeous TMNT artwork. Arguably some of the best content to come out of the franchise, really (if one could ever argue such a preposterous thing).

Leo656 05-12-2020 05:31 PM

Yeah, man. I get the exact same awkward half-chub when I look at 'em as when I see the Ecto-1A or the Mach 5.

I'unno if that's indicative of an underlying medical condition but I've learned to accept it and live with it.

Toxin45 05-13-2020 09:42 AM

Now with the covid-19 pandemic the comics are delayed and I fear mirage is gonna disband if it hasn’t already.

Galactus 05-13-2020 12:32 PM

I appreciate his current output isn't to their taste but I'm highly sceptical of people who say that Jim Lawson was never good. I mean Return To New York and the 1990 movie adaption still look ****ing awesome - some of the best TMNT art around as is his Tales Vol.1 art. I put this down to both deliberately aping Eastman and Laird's style and because he knew tonally the stories called for a more 'serious' art style than that found in say his Secret of the Ooze adaption a year later (which is still pretty nice albeit a bit more cartoony) he did a year later or his Adventures guest spots. City At War struck that 'right' balance between his then two differing styles and is still amongst his better art.

I actually thought the initial art of Vol.4 was very good when Laird was inking it and putting his own style over it which does show a lot of Lawson's current style lives and dies on who inks it and whether they put some of their own style over it. Personally while I appreciate Eric Talbot's art I don't think is a good 'fit' for Lawson's, I can't remember who inked Burning Man but it was much better. Lawson's art looks better when he inks it himself, it really brings out that what he draws well he draws ireally well such as non human characters, dinosaurs, motorcycles and environments etc.

His art may have evolved in a direction away from realistic approach he took on his best early work towards the jagged cartoony approach he has now but he has also seemingly grown as a storyteller. Vol. 4 in particular has a lot of cinematic touches and given that Laird isn't story boarding and is seemingly working more like the Marvel method that would mostly come from Lawson himself. Also it's best to remember other than when IDW throws him some work he's only really published in indie books and that audience has very different standards than the kind of audience who largely buys only the big two.

I'd argue the same argument applies to Vol. 4 as a whole. It's a big experiment on Laird's part and for anyone who happens to like it not meant to compete with Marvel or DC. Tales V.2 was the alternative but even then I'm not sure it was ever meant to be anything but Murphy's own tastes until Dan took over were he seemed to make a genuine effort to market the book to people who haven't bought TMNT books before but it's format was always a deterrent. I think what Tristan Jones was vying for for actual rotating creative teams doing arcs as opposed to one and done stories with a followup potentially five issues down the line was the way to go.

I've had the suspicion for a while that one of the reasons he set Vol.4 aside wasn't just that he was burned out but that he himself felt differently about it. He's openly said he regrets April's origin and that he originally was going for an apocalyptic ending but around the time of the Imagi movie changed his mind. He even floated the idea of a Vol.5 with more traditional TMNT stories. What exactly 'traditional' means for Peter Laird is probably up for debate. Would it require undoing a lot of the changes Vol.4 brought in? We know Don and Raph's transformations were always designed to be temporary but it even seems reversing Splinter's death (which is a shame as I thought that was very well done) I have a feeling he'd want to keep the Utroms and other alien's around in some form even if they wouldn't be omnipresent in this hypothetical Vol.5.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Toxin45 (Post 1845240)
Now with the covid-19 pandemic the comics are delayed and I fear mirage is gonna disband if it hasn’t already.

Mirage will continue to exist in the same capacity it has existed since the TMNT franchise was sold to Viacom. It's a website that sells their old stock of comics and merchandise and maybe the slimmest hope they'll publish something new again.

Leo656 05-13-2020 01:38 PM

There's no "Shrug" emoji here. :lol:

I concede his early stuff was better but I've never been thrilled by him.

Very first work of his I saw was in an issue of TMNTA, and I was incredibly disappointed in it.

I'm kind of a crab. In books based on popular or licensed characters, I prefer that things be as on-model as possible. To 7-year old me, Lawson's stuff comparatively looked like something out of a bootleg, off-brand coloring book or something. I didn't love the movie adaptation's art much at the time, either. :lol: I've always been rather critical, I guess.

I mean it is what it is. Perhaps there's a chance my opinion would be more kind if I'd come across his stuff much later in life or something instead of a bratty kid who just wanted his Turtles to look like the guys on TV, but I don't know. I just know that whenever I show his stuff to anyone who's never seen it before, they unanimously go, "Wow, that's horrible", so my gut feeling that you kind of have to be a TMNT fan with a strong affinity to Mirage to even appreciate his work still holds for me. Although I grant that, like me, most of the people who I've showed it to are people who grew up on "mainstream" comic books, so I guess that would also skew the data.

I'unno mang. As I said, I do agree that his early stuff was better and that a ton of it depends on who inks him. But if you need the right inker to make your stuff look great, then... well, that's not the strongest endorsement, y'know?

Like I said... no Shrug emoji. :lol:

TMNachoT 05-13-2020 05:25 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DK2 (Post 1845081)
Kevin has mainly implied Last Ronin is more Mirage than any other TMNT incarnations. Since the story outline was made during their Mirage days and Peter is getting credit I think that's safe to say. But he also says any readers or fans for Last Ronin can deem it for any TMNT incarnations' future too. We can't dwell on any of the dangling plots from Mirage volume 4 that I think your referring to rs_jr. We have no closure for that run. Last Ronin is really more of a "what if" or "elseworlds" for the turtles. Yes there were some Mirage shorts that had Don as the last turtle. Hard to say if it's Don for Last Ronin though.

But that was way before Peter wrote vol. 4, so i am pretty sure when Pete wrote the stories for such issue, he did not take that last runin story in consideration, at least he never mentioned the last ronin when creating vol. 4 so yes, we can say this is some kind of elseworlds thing or something not related to Mirage.

Galactus 05-13-2020 06:48 PM

I must admit his TMNT Adventures art I've always found severely lacking. As a kid I rarely took notice of the credits in the comics I read so you could have blowed me down with a feather when I realised it was the same guy that did that and the 1990 movie adaption. One was clearly so much better than the other.

I first clocked it was the same guy with the Secret Of The Ooze adaption. It was a weird hybrid of his Adventures and 1990 movie adaption style. Granted the drop in quality could be due to the lack of Peter and Kevin assisting him but he's done great looking work on his own like Sons Of The Silent Age and Tales V.1 without them so I would largely put it down to that the animated series in which Adventures was based and Secret Of The Ooze were 'silly' versions of the property so he adjusted his art accordingly.

It's strange that his art would develop down those lines but I also wonder if time was a factor too. As in he had to crank out a lot of stuff very quickly he developed a more abstract style that he he could knock out as fast like Jack Kirby ended up doing.

In regards to his quality being dependent on who inks him many a comic artist had had their work enhanced or ruined by inkers. When Lawson inks his own work or paired by someone who sticks very rigidly to his original pencils you at least get Lawson's strengths; as has been said before what he draws well he draws really well but most of the time he gets an inker that puts something of their own drawing style over the top of it and some like Laird fit well with him whereas Talbot does not.

I get you wanting things on model but there were plenty of unique looking depictions of the turtles out there back then. The action figure box art being an even more stylised version of the comic book art, video game box art etc It never really bugged me if licensed characters looked different as long as they were still recognisable.

Anyway I've lectured you enough on this (sorry I'm bored stuck inside all day) but ya like whatcha like but just offering you a different perspective.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:50 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.