The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Are mutants sterile? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=62835)

neatoman 07-18-2020 10:41 PM

Are mutants sterile?
 
Remember how the Utroms nuked all of their Triceratons when one Triceraton baby was born naturally, just so they could make sure it didn't happen again? Seems like they would tweak their furmula to be absolutely sure, wouldn't they? And seeing how most mutants (before Mutant Town at least) we see are lab experiments created for particular functions, it would make sense to be sure some "spillovers" outside of their control don't occur. Even if that is not the case, it is really hard to imagine that non-homogenous genetic freaks of various origins and results can ever produce viable offspring.

Now we do see potential futures in which Mutants and/or Utroms rule the world. Now some people here think that is indeed how the future will turn out in the main storyline and that Mutant Town is a sign towards that. I'm not sure why you'd seriously think those futures are the likely outcome for the prime timeline, these futures are obvious dystopias the heroes would not deliberately work towards making it happen or allow it to happen. Age of Apocalypse and Days of Future Past can't both be the actual outcome for the X-Men, nor can either be.

So if the signs of a broken, brutal dystopian future is not enough to motivate the characters to putting a stop to the spread of mutation, then maybe the implication that a world populated by mutants will face a swift extinction is?

TigerClaw 07-18-2020 10:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 1852979)
Remember how the Utroms nuked all of their Triceratons when one Triceraton baby was born naturally, just so they could make sure it didn't happen again? Seems like they would tweak their furmula to be absolutely sure, wouldn't they? And seeing how most mutants (before Mutant Town at least) we see are lab experiments created for particular functions, it would make sense to be sure some "spillovers" outside of their control don't occur. Even if that is not the case, it is really hard to imagine that non-homogenous genetic freaks of various origins and results can ever produce viable offspring.

Now we do see potential futures in which Mutants and/or Utroms rule the world. Now some people here think that is indeed how the future will turn out in the main storyline and that Mutant Town is a sign towards that. I'm not sure why you'd seriously think those futures are the likely outcome for the prime timeline, these futures are obvious dystopias the heroes would not deliberately work towards making it happen or allow it to happen. Age of Apocalypse and Days of Future Past can't both be the actual outcome for the X-Men, nor can either be.

So if the signs of a broken, brutal dystopian future is not enough to motivate the characters to putting a stop to the spread of mutation, then maybe the implication that a world populated by mutants will face a swift extinction is?

That's a good question. Also if they had the ability to procreate. Would they have human genitalia or animal genitalia? Since the mutation is 50% human 50% animal. That would also affect there biology as well.

neatoman 07-18-2020 11:33 PM

Well there's also the partial inspiration for this topic: The Super Mutants of Fallout.

They have extraordinary healing abilities (sound familiar?) which prevents disease resulting damaged DNA such as cancer. This healing factor is dependant on knowing what the core genetic code of the Mutant is and will thus repair any DNA damage. However, since the reproductive cells have to deviate from the base DNA to function, this healing factor prevents them from being able to produce useful reproductive cells and are therefore sterile. The very thing that prevent them from dying off in the radioactive wasteland is what prevents their population from growing.

I omitted it in the OP because these are not the same setting and I didn't want anyone to think my argument hinged on something unrelated. We don't know how the TMNT healing factor really works, it could be completely different for all we know.

Leo656 07-19-2020 12:50 AM

For April's sake, we all should hope they are! :lol: :lol: :lol:

....I'll show myself out.

Dejablue 07-19-2020 01:48 AM

As far as reproduction goes, i'd imagine a lot of this question can't be answered unless we know what the mutagen is made for.

But for a sweeping in general answer I might actually say yes? Yes they are most likely sterile if the mutagen is in the "super soldier" category. The folks in charge would want to keep close watch on the number of their experiments, it wouldn't be good if they could reproduce. Jurassic Park comes immediately to mind.

But also like Jurassic Park, mistakes can be made. Perhaps some mutants are fertile if they were made with an earlier version of the mutagen. But I feel like it would be a foolish oversight to not modify the mutagen to make the mutants sterile.

But AT THE SAME TIME. It's also stupid that the mutants created always have free will, autonomy, and the ability to turn against their creators in the first place but---

Leo656 07-19-2020 01:54 AM

I kinda feel the same way.

But I mean, even if it wasn't designed for a purpose, isn't the Ooze generally radioactive, or at least implied to be?

It's all fake, so Anything could be Anything, but I kinda feel like "pickled eggs and pickled sperm" doesn't even begin to cover the situation, honestly. :lol: They're probably all shooting blanks.

But then again, it's all fake so... eh? All really depends on how "logical" we wanna be.

Dejablue 07-19-2020 02:01 AM

I think whenever the ooze was made with a malicious purpose [super secret military soldiers] then the mutants are sterile. Or are at least supposed to be.

If Ooze is a bi-product of something else or a mistake then its up in the air and mutants probably are fertile.

And when it comes to the soldier mutants, they probably have to run tests for that kind of thing. So like I said, some fertile mutants may slip through the cracks. This is all my headcanon though so if someone wants to write fanfiction about freaky baby mutants there are no canon road blocks.

Leo656 07-19-2020 02:13 AM

I mean, it makes sense, though; if it was a controlled experiment, the only ones who could breed would probably be designed explicitly for that purpose, to see what would happen and study the results, and that's it. Letting these "abominations" breed openly without any controls in place would be a horrible idea. So yeah, if the Ooze was created on purpose, and the mutants in turn created on purpose, then them being able to reproduce probably wouldn't be a desired outcome for whoever was running the experiment. Way too much could go wrong.

If the Ooze is an accident, I guess whether the resultant mutants can reproduce or not can be whatever anyone wants it to be because you have a lot less to worry about. Anything and everything can be written off as "unforeseen side effects" if those are the rules in play. But I still kinda think it might be unlikely, given how little it seems to really take to make someone sterile or infertile or whatever. DNA-altering chemical waste probably ain't good for the pipes. :lol:

But that's also just spitballing.

newfan 07-19-2020 04:04 AM

We can speculate to a point but I guess as we are talking about fictional creatures which are created by a fictional ooze a writer could have room to go either way, if they wanted to address it.

hypered1 07-19-2020 08:01 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 1852989)
Well there's also the partial inspiration for this topic: The Super Mutants of Fallout.

They have extraordinary healing abilities (sound familiar?) which prevents disease resulting damaged DNA such as cancer. This healing factor is dependant on knowing what the core genetic code of the Mutant is and will thus repair any DNA damage. However, since the reproductive cells have to deviate from the base DNA to function, this healing factor prevents them from being able to produce useful reproductive cells and are therefore sterile. The very thing that prevent them from dying off in the radioactive wasteland is what prevents their population from growing.

I omitted it in the OP because these are not the same setting and I didn't want anyone to think my argument hinged on something unrelated. We don't know how the TMNT healing factor really works, it could be completely different for all we know.

Well we've seen a possible regenerative factor to the mutations if we count Rocksteady's ear regrowing between 'Hit the Road' and 'City at War'.

PizzaPower1985 07-19-2020 07:56 PM

To add a bit to this thread... I'll echo John Byrne from his own forum and ask the question he asked his own boards.

"What about non-human characters in superhero comics? Should they be celibate?"

Granted the 80's and 90's did happen in comic book history and it can add mature and dramatic flair to see Matt Murdock (the man-whore) in bed with all those ladies or Spidey and Mary Jane getting dressed after a roll in the hay... and Bruce W. had Silver St. Cloud and Selina Kyle and a number of others, but SHOULD WE DRAW THAT LINE at humans?

What exactly is entertaining about seeing animal characters or mutants like X-men's Beast or aliens or demons carrying on an adult/mature relationship?

Should we never explore it, ignore it and gloss over it OR should we perhaps treat these walking, talking humanoid characters like their human counterparts for added drama and maturity? Should TMNT, Hellboy, Bllacksad, non-human members of the X-men etc. never have THAT SIDE of their character explored?

neatoman 07-19-2020 08:00 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PizzaPower1985 (Post 1853117)
To add a bit to this thread... I'll echo John Byrne from his own forum and ask the question he asked his own boards.

"What about non-human characters in superhero comics? Should they be celibate?"

Granted the 80's and 90's did happen in comic book history and it can add mature and dramatic flair to see Matt Murdock (the man-whore) in bed with all those ladies or Spidey and Mary Jane getting dressed after a roll in the hay... and Bruce W. had Silver St. Cloud and Selina Kyle and a number of others, but SHOULD WE DRAW THAT LINE at humans?

What exactly is entertaining about seeing animal characters or mutants like X-men's Beast or aliens or demons carrying on an adult/mature relationship?

Should we never explore it, ignore it and gloss over it OR should we perhaps treat these walking, talking humanoid characters like their human counterparts for added drama and maturity? Should TMNT, Hellboy, Bllacksad, non-human members of the X-men etc. never have THAT SIDE of their character explored?

That's kind of a different subject from wheter or not they're able to reproduce.

lonewarrior20 07-19-2020 09:05 PM

i am actually picturing alopex looking at raph and saying "Raph, I want to have a baby."

PizzaPower1985 07-19-2020 09:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lonewarrior20 (Post 1853125)
i am actually picturing alopex looking at raph and saying "Raph, I want to have a baby."

Eeeewwwwww!

That's an image I didn't need in my head!

TigerClaw 07-19-2020 09:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PizzaPower1985 (Post 1853126)
Eeeewwwwww!

That's an image I didn't need in my head!

Considering that they are officially a pair. Im sure we can expect fan art of those two having an offspring.

PizzaPower1985 07-19-2020 10:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TigerClaw (Post 1853131)
Considering that they are officially a pair. Im sure we can expect fan art of those two having an offspring.

That would be one weird looking mutant. IDW wouldn't would they? I dunno... They brought back Venuka.

TigerClaw 07-19-2020 10:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PizzaPower1985 (Post 1853135)
That would be one weird looking mutant. IDW wouldn't would they? I dunno... They brought back Venuka.

There is fan art of Mona Lisa and Raph having an Offspring. a hybrid of a lizard and turtle.

Dejablue 07-19-2020 10:52 PM

I can only see the tmnt having viable offspring with other reptilian mutants, amphibian mutants or humans, and maybe birds. But mammals with fur? Please no. Do not want.


EDIT: We should also consider those future timelines. The one where mutants were common and humans were extinct or living underground, just because they were majority mutant doesn't mean the future has to be a dystopia. What if the future turns into a Fast Forward type thing? Or how it was in Mirage volume 4?

Leo656 07-20-2020 01:30 AM

There was actually a Fan Art contest here back in the day where the challenge was to draw a potential offspring of one of the Turtles and whoever. Pretty fun. People were a bit more creative and less judge-y back then. :trazz: At least in public. :lol:

Dejablue 07-20-2020 02:08 AM

That actually sounds fun. I would like to participate in an art contest.

Leo656 07-20-2020 02:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dejablue (Post 1853163)
That actually sounds fun. I would like to participate in an art contest.


There's probably no law against starting one!

I might not participate but I genuinely miss the days when Art and Writing Contests were all the rage around here. I only barely took part in them then, either, but a lot of people did and it was nice to see so much enthusiasm.

Then I was away for a long while, came back and everything was much more mean-spirited than before. Seemed like anyone who'd be enthusiastic for such projects was being derided as "furries and shipper trash" so nobody really put themselves out there anymore.

I'unno, I always thought it was fun seeing what people came up with. By all means, try and grease the wheels and get that kinda thing moving again. You have my support!

TigerClaw 07-21-2020 04:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dejablue (Post 1853140)
I can only see the tmnt having viable offspring with other reptilian mutants, amphibian mutants or humans, and maybe birds. But mammals with fur? Please no. Do not want.


EDIT: We should also consider those future timelines. The one where mutants were common and humans were extinct or living underground, just because they were majority mutant doesn't mean the future has to be a dystopia. What if the future turns into a Fast Forward type thing? Or how it was in Mirage volume 4?

There were those stories set 150 years in the future from the Archie Comics. It had humans and mutants. Future Raph was married to a mutant coyote.

PizzaPower1985 07-22-2020 10:17 AM

Why do humans insist on writing stories where humans and animals/mutants/aliens etc. mate and or fall in love?

It's disgusting!

Why do it? The appeal is lost on me... Are some people closet ophidiophiles? Zoophilia is disgusting and some folks truly need to have their mental health examined.

Leo656 07-22-2020 11:53 AM

If they were I doubt they'd tell you. :lol:

For my part, though, I do see a world of difference between, say, April banging one of the TMNT and say, her going to the zoo and getting freaky. :lol: Maybe that's a Me Issue and maybe I just watch too many cartoons. :trazz:

Point of fact, though, even though it never "got physical", April and Donnie teasing a relationship for the Nick show was a huge plot point, and so I have to feel like at least in theory, a lot of people have to kinda feel the way I do about it or else it wouldn't have even come up, let alone made it into the show and then made a big deal of. I don't think it helped anything (I'm on record that it's one of my most-hated things about the show, mostly for being a pointless waste of time), and I admit I'm shocked that there wasn't a big backlash to it, but it does illustrate that when it comes to sapient anthro characters, at least, it seems like there's not much of an "Ew" factor anymore for most people.

That's my take, anyways.

Of course, it could be that the people who made the Nick show are all just a bunch of perverts and wierdos! :lol: I have my own questions for them, on account of they went and made April a teenager for no good reason, and then made sure to stick the camera square on her ass constantly, often in zoom close-up. That's pretty "questionable" in and of itself. So who knows? Maybe they're all just crazy, over there!

PizzaPower1985 07-22-2020 12:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1853615)
If they were I doubt they'd tell you. :lol:

For my part, though, I do see a world of difference between, say, April banging one of the TMNT and say, her going to the zoo and getting freaky. :lol: Maybe that's a Me Issue and maybe I just watch too many cartoons. :trazz:

Point of fact, though, even though it never "got physical", April and Donnie teasing a relationship for the Nick show was a huge plot point, and so I have to feel like at least in theory, a lot of people have to kinda feel the way I do about it or else it wouldn't have even come up, let alone made it into the show and then made a big deal of. I don't think it helped anything (I'm on record that it's one of my most-hated things about the show, mostly for being a pointless waste of time), and I admit I'm shocked that there wasn't a big backlash to it, but it does illustrate that when it comes to sapient anthro characters, at least, it seems like there's not much of an "Ew" factor anymore for most people.

That's my take, anyways.

Of course, it could be that the people who made the Nick show are all just a bunch of perverts and wierdos! :lol: I have my own questions for them, on account of they went and made April a teenager for no good reason, and then made sure to stick the camera square on her ass constantly, often in zoom close-up. That's pretty "questionable" in and of itself. So who knows? Maybe they're all just crazy, over there!

DID YOU KNOW IN Hawaii, Kentucky, Nevada, New Mexico, Ohio, Texas, Vermont, West Virginia and Wyoming, and Washington D.C. IT IS COMPLETELY LEGAL TO HAVE SEX WITH ANIMALS? There are no laws on the books against gettin' freaky with Fido or tryin' to get frisky with felines. Animal welfare is seriously lacking in the U.S.

Well there ya go!

lonewarrior20 07-22-2020 12:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PizzaPower1985 (Post 1853623)
DID YOU KNOW IN Hawaii, Kentucky, Nevada, New Mexico, Ohio, Texas, Vermont, West Virginia and Wyoming, and Washington D.C. IT IS COMPLETELY LEGAL TO HAVE SEX WITH ANIMALS? There are no laws on the books against gettin' freaky with Fido or tryin' to get frisky with felines. Animal welfare is seriously lacking in the U.S.

Well there ya go!

Washington DC certainly makes things interesting and explains a few things.

oldmanwinters 07-22-2020 01:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1853615)
Of course, it could be that the people who made the Nick show are all just a bunch of perverts and wierdos! :lol: I have my own questions for them, on account of they went and made April a teenager for no good reason, and then made sure to stick the camera square on her ass constantly, often in zoom close-up. That's pretty "questionable" in and of itself. So who knows? Maybe they're all just crazy, over there!

I can believe that.

Leo656 07-22-2020 01:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PizzaPower1985 (Post 1853623)
DID YOU KNOW IN Hawaii, Kentucky, Nevada, New Mexico, Ohio, Texas, Vermont, West Virginia and Wyoming, and Washington D.C. IT IS COMPLETELY LEGAL TO HAVE SEX WITH ANIMALS? There are no laws on the books against gettin' freaky with Fido or tryin' to get frisky with felines. Animal welfare is seriously lacking in the U.S.

Well there ya go!

You could tell me absolutely anything about Kentucky and I would believe you.

neatoman 07-22-2020 02:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1853666)
You could tell me absolutely anything about Kentucky and I would believe you.

I heard the dead are rising from the grave to contact the aliens to prepare for when Odin returns to battle Zeus over the fate of humanity, it's all appearently going down in Kentucky.

Leo656 07-22-2020 02:52 PM

What's even better is if you take a celebrity who you could believe anything about, and stick them in a place where the same is equally true.

Example:

I once heard that Jared Leto dressed up like Barney Rubble, killed a hooker, ate her skin, and fed the bones to his dog while singing the forgotten Second Verse of "Ta-Ra-Ra-Boom-De-Yay".

In Kentucky.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 07-22-2020 02:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1853685)
What's even better is if you take a celebrity who you could believe anything about, and stick them in a place where the same is equally true.

Example:

I once heard that Jared Leto dressed up like Barney Rubble, killed a hooker, ate her skin, and fed the bones to his dog while singing the forgotten Second Verse of "Ta-Ra-Ra-Boom-De-Yay".

In Kentucky.

$hit, I'd believe that.

Leo656 07-22-2020 02:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1853686)
$hit, I'd believe that.

You could tell me absolutely anything about Jared Leto and I would believe you.

PizzaPower1985 07-22-2020 03:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1853689)
You could tell me absolutely anything about Jared Leto and I would believe you.

Did you know that he once dressed up like Kurt Cobain and sang songs about tea and rape?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dH8gDowIj6c

Leo656 07-22-2020 03:32 PM

Wow, now I have to take back a lot of not-nice things I may have said in the past about Jared Leto. :lol:

hypered1 07-22-2020 03:39 PM

Christ, this thread has jumped through about 10 different levels of weird.:teek:

Leo656 07-22-2020 03:43 PM

I make it my business to ruin everything. Sir.

https://media1.tenor.com/images/6b77...itemid=7207733

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 07-22-2020 03:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hypered1 (Post 1853707)
Christ, this thread has jumped through about 10 different levels of weird.:teek:

That's why I still love the 'Drome.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1853689)
You could tell me absolutely anything about Jared Leto and I would believe you.

Right? I wasn't even surprised to hear he has his own cult.

Leo656 07-22-2020 03:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1853712)
That's why I still love the 'Drome.



Right? I wasn't even surprised to hear he has his own cult.

Don't forget that time he hosted his own AMA and it was just 25 minutes of him eating a live kitten. That guy's a character.

Dejablue 07-24-2020 01:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PizzaPower1985 (Post 1853623)
DID YOU KNOW IN Hawaii, Kentucky, Nevada, New Mexico, Ohio, Texas, Vermont, West Virginia and Wyoming, and Washington D.C. IT IS COMPLETELY LEGAL TO HAVE SEX WITH ANIMALS? There are no laws on the books against gettin' freaky with Fido or tryin' to get frisky with felines. Animal welfare is seriously lacking in the U.S.

Well there ya go!

There should definitely be laws. Zoophilia is atrocious.

But wow that is off topic.

PizzaPower1985 07-24-2020 08:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dejablue (Post 1854126)
There should definitely be laws. Zoophilia is atrocious.

But wow that is off topic.

Well, it was I who brought it up many any posts ago by hinting that no one on the Drome should ever talk about sex with mutants, aliens, animals etc. because it's nasty, but then the convo shifted into zoophilia and I was just pointing out that it's not seen as such a bad thing in parts of the U.S.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:03 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.