The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Turns out the Escorzas completely replaced the art of Kuhn on Last Ronin (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=63214)

neatoman 10-31-2020 10:20 AM

Turns out the Escorzas completely replaced the art of Kuhn on Last Ronin
 
While I knew Kuhn was going to be replaced, I asssumed his artwork was still going to be used, with the Escorzas only filling in the pages he never got around to doing. But when I googled Last Ronin to find that old image Laird did of the Fugitoids severed head (I suspect there to be quite a lot liberties taken with the original concept), I came across a preview using Kuhn's artwork. As it turns out, the Escorzas didn't just fill in, they outright replaced what was already made. Not that I'm really complaining, I'm not exactly the biggest fan of how Kuhn draws and find the Escorzas art more appealing, it's just that I figured redoing it seemed to be a bit excessive. Which makes me wonder, how far did Kuhn get? If it was about 20% or less, then sure, I guess you'd want the series to look as artistically cohesive as possible. If it was 50-60% or more then that would seem like a lot of wasted work. I also wonder if the Kuhn pages will be included as extras in a trade? Might be interesting to see a full comparison.

Below are the versions of the same page by the different artists. Kuhn above, the Escorzas beneath.


Mayhem 10-31-2020 04:22 PM

As far as I’m aware, Andy didn’t get past issue #1 art

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 10-31-2020 04:48 PM

I really don't like Andy Kuhn's art, so this was a win for me. Feel bad for the guy, though.

Leo656 10-31-2020 04:52 PM

They both seem fitting for the tone and general aesthetic, but I do think that the Escorzas art is a bit more dynamic.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 10-31-2020 05:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1866556)
They both seem fitting for the tone and general aesthetic, but I do think that the Escorzas art is a bit more dynamic.

You know how you feel about Jim Lawson's art? That's how I feel about Kuhn's. :tlol:

frank_one 10-31-2020 05:32 PM

Looking at the pages above I see a lot of difference not just in the drawings but also in the colors. While I prefer Escorzas' art, I actually prefer the coloring in the Kuhn's version.

Leo656 10-31-2020 07:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1866557)
You know how you feel about Jim Lawson's art? That's how I feel about Kuhn's. :tlol:

Haven't seen a ton of his stuff, but frankly, anybody who draws worse than Jim Lawson would have to literally be trying to do that. Like "I'mma break all my fingers first and then try to hold a pencil." It would have to be a mission statement.

funatic 11-01-2020 01:16 AM

Does anyone know why Kuhn was replaced?

Andrew NDB 11-01-2020 04:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy (Post 1866554)
I really don't like Andy Kuhn's art, so this was a win for me. Feel bad for the guy, though.

I'm sure he still got paid his full page rates for the work completed.

Wentos 11-01-2020 07:13 AM

Imagine commissioning a TMNT miniseries based on an unused treatment from Kevin Eastman and Peter Laird, the first quasi-collaboration between the creators of TMNT in over 25 years, and hiring Andy Kuhn to draw it.

Maybe they'll release a true Eastman/Laird collaboration a few years from now and have it drawn by Brahm Revel. The fans love Brahm Revel.

neatoman 11-01-2020 08:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1866577)
Haven't seen a ton of his stuff, but frankly, anybody who draws worse than Jim Lawson would have to literally be trying to do that. Like "I'mma break all my fingers first and then try to hold a pencil." It would have to be a mission statement.

Go read the Mutanimals mini. It looks really inconsistant, the characters' features change quite a bit, to the point where you sometimes even question if you're seeing the same character anymore. Even basic detail, like Mondo's tail, shift in and out of existance. Kuhn isn't even all that detailed in the first place, so why he keeps forgetting to draw the crucial details is anyone's guess.

No tail


Tail


And for good measure, have a page that both does and doesn't depict the tail

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 11-01-2020 11:59 AM

My eyes, my eyes! Gah, make it stop!

For fvck's sake, I forgot how terrible the art in the Mutanimals mini-series was. Imagine how great Corey or Mateus would have drawn in.

funatic 11-01-2020 12:55 PM

My impression back then was that Kuhn was the guy they brought in to hit deadlines, and maybe the consistency errors reflect that. Not making excuses for them though. Anyone know if it was it his choice or IDWs to drop Last Ronin?

Leo656 11-01-2020 02:02 PM

Hah, yeah, alright, I see what you're saying. Ouch.

frank_one 11-01-2020 05:07 PM

I wonder why they hired him for The last Ronin in the first place. Also, I would be curious to know if they ever approach a Mirage artist for a project during all this years.

AquaParade 11-01-2020 05:16 PM

I love that they ended up with the Escorza brothers. It's such a great look for this book. I only wish they could pencil it all.

Mayhem 11-02-2020 03:36 AM

Just to quell any discussion on the fact, Andy was planning on the full run, something personal happened that's required most of his attention instead (I know what, don't ask, as we were emailing as he was working on a commission for me) and thus had to bow out due to time commitments.

Andrew NDB 11-02-2020 04:38 AM

I would've been interested to see what Kuhn's art would have looked like under Kevin's inks.

D Piddy 1982 11-02-2020 08:25 AM

I don't want to knock a guy when he's down, but I'm also pleased that the other guys got The Last Ronin job.

Andy's work reminds me of the quick layouts that storyboard artists do - it's all about output rather then quality or detail.

As someone else mentioned, makes you wonder if Andy is/was the go to guy when deadline pressures are mounting.

The Triceraton arc he did was a tough read for me, simply because the art was a massive step down from the Santoluoco stuff we had seen beforehand.

But, you know, I still have respect for anyone that is able to make a living from doing art.

frank_one 11-02-2020 09:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by D Piddy 1982 (Post 1866756)
But, you know, I still have respect for anyone that is able to make a living from doing art.

This is deeply important.

AquaParade 11-02-2020 11:34 AM

Oh, definitely. Critiquing art can be tricky, because we all have preferences, but there's no denying the talent, hard work, and skill that it takes to be even one of the less-popular artists. Not to say Kuhn should be labeled as such.

Powder 11-02-2020 08:35 PM

I like Andy's art. It's not a perfect fit for every arc, but he's definitely suited to the brand. His style on a whole reminds me a lot of Mirage's guest era & Tales Vol. 2. Nice guy, too.

I'd just like to know what happened with this project. Very sketchy, & hush-hush, his departure.

skylord 11-03-2020 10:36 AM

Andy's art grew on me and that partially happened after reading Mirage stuff. Conventionally aesthetically pleasing art like that of Santalouco or Campbell is what drew me in initially but given the right arc Kuhn's art fits fantastically. Rereading the series now I have a much better appreciation for his work.

Maruten 11-03-2020 09:30 PM

I like his art too, although after reading this thread I'll be watching Mondo's tail carefully from now on... :tlol:

His line work is quite rough and sketchy and I think that works well for a TMNT project that leans towards the more mature end of the property's spectrum. With TLR, I prefer what we've seen of his original pages over what we ended up getting, though the final book does look great.

Really though, with TMNT books - any era or publisher - it's "Eastman & Laird" and "everyone else". I'm accustomed to terrible art on TMNT books, or at least artists whose take on the Turtles I dislike a lot. After all these years, it doesn't bother me much. If I hate the art this month, it will probably be more to my liking by the time the next arc starts.

Sharman 11-12-2020 02:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 1866496)
I also wonder if the Kuhn pages will be included as extras in a trade? Might be interesting to see a full comparison.

Below are the versions of the same page by the different artists. Kuhn above, the Escorzas beneath.



I do think it's really interesting to be able to see different artists' take on the same project. For some reason I thought the layouts would be almost exactly the same, so to see how it actually turned out ...

I can see both pros and cons in both versions of the finished work but, as someone else pointed out, the Mirage era had its fair share of - shall we say - mediocre artists and it appears that both takes of The Last Ronin (regardless of any previous work by the artists) seem to me to be of a higher quality than some previous TMNT artwork.

frank_one 11-12-2020 04:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sharman (Post 1868403)
the Mirage era had its fair share of - shall we say - mediocre artists

I wouldn't call them mediocre. Their style was just less academic and more personal.

Sharman 11-14-2020 12:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by frank_one (Post 1868437)
I wouldn't call them mediocre. Their style was just less academic and more personal.

Fair enough. Personal taste.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:49 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.