The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   The Original Mirage Readers (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=63261)

PizzaPower1985 11-11-2020 05:03 PM

The Original Mirage Readers
 
I've always wondered...

Do you know anyone who was part of the original fan group who was reading and collecting Mirage in the earliest days? Late 1984 to say mid 85?

What happened to a lot of the original fans? Did they simply grow out of it or have they remained fans? Or is there any way to even know? Were any of you part of that group?

I talked to someone recently name Phillip who started collecting in 85, but said by the time the toon debuted in '87 he started getting out of it.

Any ideas about the OG fans? Any storied you'd like to share?

Leo656 11-11-2020 05:15 PM

I didn't even know anyone who'd heard of Mirage until I got the internet in 2000. Like I was aware of it because I'd seen issue #1 in a comic shop in like 1990 for over $100 (which seemed extravagant at the time :lol:) and I "won" one of the "City At War" issues at the Boardwalk playing the wheel game - I actually didn't win, but I'd played and lost so many turns that the vendor just felt sorry for me and gave it to me. And of course I read Wizard so I was aware of Mirage's existence but I'd never met anyone else who was familiar with it.

Nobody around here really carried the Mirage comics, whereas the Archie TMNTA books were everywhere. So while every kid I knew was aware that "TMNT was a comic book first", most of them mistakenly assumed that it was the Archie book. You know how kids are.

The very first time I'd ever had a conversation with a Mirage reader was on the internet sometime around 2001. Could've been Andrew, for all I know. :lol: He's like the only one I talked to back then that I still talk to now. And I regret that we weren't as close back then as we are now. :ohwell: Ah well, better late than never, I guess.

garsh 11-11-2020 06:37 PM

By the time I read any Mirage, I was already well into the toys, Archie, the cartoon and NES games. It was just by chance that a little comic booth had been set up in the midway of my local mall. Issues 22 and 23 were apparently current at the time, and I was very curious to get a look at where they had come from.

These turned out to be a two-part story about prepubescent super genius time traveler, Dale Evans McGuillicutty. I found them utterly baffling at the time. That was my only firsthand impression of the comics, and based on them I wasn't motivated to look for more.

Prior to that I had read the collector's edition mini-comic that was included with the fan club kit, but I was never sure what to make of it. It wasn't clear to me how "official" it was.

Mayhem 11-13-2020 03:01 AM

I started reading in about 88. Prior to the cartoon starting in the UK. Someone in my year had been on holiday to the US and bought a couple of the First Publishing graphic novels, so a few of us borrowed them to read after he said turtles were huge over there. I was mostly hooked but didn't follow it up until a few years later I was in the comic shop near to school and saw, I want to say issue #47, it was the two part Chote story done by Dooney. Remembered from the graphic novels, picked it up, loved it, and then slowly tried to get more back issues, but that didn't really happen until eBay started and I could purchase lots listed. Did the same with the back issues for Usagi as well in the late 90s. Cultiminating with getting a first print #1 in 2004 for the princely sum of $1000. I was saving up to move out so it ate a little in that but I didn't care hah hah.

MrPliggins 11-13-2020 07:53 AM

I haven't met anyone but I'm sure there is at least a member or two on this forum who were fans at the beginning. I discovered the Mirage comics at issue #16 at around age 10, and almost immediately started trying to find the back issues. I even tried at that time to order items from the ads in the original comics, but by that time it was too late and I received my money back.

funatic 11-13-2020 11:51 AM

My father owned a comic shop before I was born and put in orders for the first issue, but they were oversold at that point and they didn't ship him any. He read a few issues back then but never got too into it... was surprised when a few years later they took over the world and his little brat was bobbing along to the theme song every Saturday. :tlol:

CyberCubed 11-13-2020 12:36 PM

I'm pretty sure a good chunk of them are dead by now. If you were already in your 20's in 1984....which is now 35 years ago, you would have to be 55-60 by now.

IMJ 11-13-2020 01:01 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by garsh (Post 1868262)
By the time I read any Mirage, I was already well into the toys, Archie, the cartoon and NES games. It was just by chance that a little comic booth had been set up in the midway of my local mall. Issues 22 and 23 were apparently current at the time, and I was very curious to get a look at where they had come from.

These turned out to be a two-part story about prepubescent super genius time traveler, Dale Evans McGuillicutty. I found them utterly baffling at the time. That was my only firsthand impression of the comics, and based on them I wasn't motivated to look for more.

Prior to that I had read the collector's edition mini-comic that was included with the fan club kit, but I was never sure what to make of it. It wasn't clear to me how "official" it was.

Wow you got on board with Mirage early, man! I don't think I truly dabbled into a single Mirage book until City At War was on the LCS racks......

frank_one 11-13-2020 02:12 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1868555)
I'm pretty sure a good chunk of them are dead by now. If you were already in your 20's in 1984....which is now 35 years ago, you would have to be 55-60 by now.

It is not so common to die at 55-60... I guess :-?

CyberCubed 11-13-2020 02:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by frank_one (Post 1868564)
It is not so common to die at 55-60... I guess :-?

If they were in their 20's in the 1980's, that means they were born in the 60's. People had naturally shorter lifespans back then and people aged much faster. Remember this is basically ancient times.

PizzaPower1985 11-13-2020 03:20 PM

My Mom was born in 67 and Dad in 68. They were teenagers when TMNT came out... 17 and 16... the perfect age to read Mirage in 84 or 85. Today they are 53 and 52. Both in relatively decent health though, because of stress, mom has taken up smoking (still pisses me off.)

people don't typically die in 50's unless they have heart conditions, cancer ETC.

Andrew NDB 11-13-2020 03:40 PM

I mean, to be honest... I look at the lettercols of Vol. 1 and look at the names and wonder what became of everybody. They aren't here. They're not on the FB pages.

Leo656 11-13-2020 05:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1868587)
I mean, to be honest... I look at the lettercols of Vol. 1 and look at the names and wonder what became of everybody. They aren't here. They're not on the FB pages.

I have to imagine that when TMNT so quickly became something completely different and foreign from Mirage, the original Mirage TMNT fans from Issue #1-ish all gave up and found other things to do. I mean the toys and cartoon came next, and they're SO different that I can totally see a ton of purists just abandoning the ship. If they weren't already put off by the meandering "Guest Writer/Artist" stuff by that point, that is.

People are like that. Consider World Championship Wrestling being purchased by the WWF in 2001. Not only were the companies' presentation of pro wrestling totally different, the fans were totally different; MOST fans of one wouldn't be caught dead watching the other. It was assumed that when the WWF bought WCW, all the WCW fans would start watching the WWF instead, but that never happened. What happened instead was that about 20 million people all just quit watching wrestling forever because they liked WCW's style and hated the WWF. WWF/WWE never got those fans back, instead losing more and more people every year.

I have to imagine that it's the same issue with the old-school Day One Mirage fans. They may have liked what TMNT originally was, but seeing what it was turning into was probably enough to make them abandon ship forever. I can't imagine most of them having any interest at all in the cartoon show or the toys. Most of them probably haven't even thought of or paid attention to TMNT ever since. I can totally believe that.

PizzaPower1985 11-13-2020 05:58 PM

I can just imagine going into a Manhattan, Californian or Canadian comic book store and finding an early issue... or mailing away for one or whatever... those cats must have just read the first few issues and been attracted to it for its weirdness, more mature storyline or adult humor.

You guys make some good points... They do seem to just have disappeared.

IMJ 11-13-2020 06:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1868572)
If they were in their 20's in the 1980's, that means they were born in the 60's. People had naturally shorter lifespans back then and people aged much faster. Remember this is basically ancient times.

:lol::lol: -facepalms- WTF, man?!?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1868587)
I mean, to be honest... I look at the lettercols of Vol. 1 and look at the names and wonder what became of everybody. They aren't here. They're not on the FB pages.

There's a generational divide there were I think the our generation are the largest "older" cohort to have a continuous and adaptive internet presence. A lot of that older cohort (not all of it) have probably abandoned the hobby or just haven't followed the evolution of the internet away from forums.

Basically I think with most pop culture properties that we are at a phase where only the die hards are generally hanging on to any given IP at this point.

PizzaPower1985 11-13-2020 06:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1868600)
I have to imagine that when TMNT so quickly became something completely different and foreign from Mirage, the original Mirage TMNT fans from Issue #1-ish all gave up and found other things to do. I mean the toys and cartoon came next, and they're SO different that I can totally see a ton of purists just abandoning the ship. If they weren't already put off by the meandering "Guest Writer/Artist" stuff by that point, that is.

Yup. Probably... I met a man named Bill once, in a bar... and we were talking superheroes. Spider-man (the Ditko-Romita era) was his big thing... I mentioned TMNT and he was telling me how his sister bought issue 2 in 1985 and got him into it... They stayed with it until the cartoon came out. They read about it in Comics Scene or something and were excited because of the Kevin/Peter endorsement... but when it aired they were like "WTF is this?" and by the time the first film came out (which the liked) they were over TMNT.

frank_one 11-13-2020 06:40 PM

Original fans are probably still out there but they just don't hang out on message boards like us younger generations. Also, a lot of time has passed since 1984, they grew up, they got married, had kids and stopped reading comics. Modern generations tend to indulge in stuff like comics or videogames more than those older generations, even at 30 or 40.

CyberCubed 11-13-2020 08:15 PM

Yeah, that's basically a generation before most of us, our parents generation pretty much. How many of your parents still read comics, play videogames, watch cartoons and superhero movies? I imagine very few...since they didn't really grow up with this "lifestyle."

I feel like our generation is the first one to embrace still liking "kids stuff" as adults, because of the internet and the fact that everything is continuous. Our parents grew up in a different time where once you hit 18 they moved out and had to outgrow stuff from their youth. Then they just watched Jeopardy, Wheel of Fortune and 20/20 with Barbara Walters.

Andrew NDB 11-13-2020 08:26 PM

Yeah, it was probably a mix of the "original" Mirage comic fans becoming disinterested when Kevin and Laird had little to nothing to do with the book anymore and the rise of the cartoon/toys popularity (at a certain point when everyone thinks TMNT is just a thing for babies and morons, and all you've got to read at Mirage is the "guest writer/artist era" while Kevin and Peter are just busy selling toys... I get it). By "City at War" most were probably already long gone.

wpugh2424 11-13-2020 09:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1868572)
If they were in their 20's in the 1980's, that means they were born in the 60's. People had naturally shorter lifespans back then and people aged much faster. Remember this is basically ancient times.

Life expectancy was average of around 73 then

MrPliggins 11-14-2020 10:17 AM

Read the letters column of Mirage issue 15. That says it all. Many letter writers weren't happy with the way the direction of the comic was going. One letter even said "you're great together, but you suck apart," referring to issue 12 (Peter without Kevin) and 14 (Kevin without Peter). Of course the property was taking off at this point and they had so much licensing to deal with that they couldn't find time to work together anymore.

frank_one 11-14-2020 10:44 AM

Only a brave and bold fan could have kept his interest steady during the guest era. Let's say it, for the most part it sucked. A lot of readers were also not so keen to Jim Lawson' style, so after the first Eastman and Laird's issue of City at War they felt disappointed.
I wonder how well Image's Volume 3 did compared to Mirage's Volume 2.

CyberCubed 11-14-2020 10:51 AM

The guest era didn't really truly start till after Return to New York. Issues 12-18 while having one Mark Martin issue were all still pretty much Mirage comics.

Galactus 11-14-2020 11:33 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by frank_one (Post 1868726)
Only a brave and bold fan could have kept his interest steady during the guest era. Let's say it, for the most part it sucked. A lot of readers were also not so keen to Jim Lawson' style, so after the first Eastman and Laird's issue of City at War they felt disappointed.
I wonder how well Image's Volume 3 did compared to Mirage's Volume 2.

Lawson's Mirage Vol.1 art was great although reading through the letters pages it seemed a lot of readers were very married to the idea of Eastman & Laird together only. Weird now to read complaints of their solo art or the inclusion of Michael Dooney.

frank_one 11-14-2020 04:22 PM

One good thing back then was that they were not afraid of publishing all kinds of letters even the ones containing complaints.

CyberCubed 11-14-2020 04:55 PM

I don't know what those people expected out of the book. Not every issue was going to be Eastman/Laird. They sound like a bunch of greedy people who jumped ship rather quickly, I doubt they made it even to Return to New York if they didn't like issue's 12+.

They're probably all 55-60 year olds now, they're probably all suffering from diabetes.

PizzaPower1985 11-14-2020 05:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1868780)
I don't know what those people expected out of the book. Not every issue was going to be Eastman/Laird. They sound like a bunch of greedy people who jumped ship rather quickly, I doubt they made it even to Return to New York if they didn't like issue's 12+.

They're probably all 55-60 year olds now, they're probably all suffering from diabetes.

1) Cubed... remember that the first several issues were Kevin and Peter. And they were damn good... so, yes... after issue 7 and the micros, fans had a right to expect good stuff. They weren't greedy... And, if they jumped ship it was because the guest era didnt start brilliantly, like The River etc... it started proper with issue 16... and it wasn't great.

2) Why would you assume they have a major illness like diabetes? Why generalize?

Zulithe 11-14-2020 05:56 PM

I don't know anyone personally who was a fan of the comics before the Fred Wolf toon. I was too young, I didn't start reading comics until the very late 80s, same with all of my friends.

I picked up some Mirage reprints after the toon started getting huge. They were easy to find in most stores at the time.

ZedsDead 11-16-2020 01:09 AM

I didn’t start reading the Mirage comics until I was in high school. I didn’t even know what they were until I found #14 in a dollar bin. That kicked off the whole thing for me but I was already driving myself to the comic shop so late 90s.

Ive never met anyone that was an original reader from the early days. The only person that comes to mind is that YouTube channel ComicTropes. I’m pretty sure he said he was reading the Mirage books when they launched.

Hamato Yoshi 11-16-2020 07:05 PM

In Japan , if you write a negative fan letter to a celeb thats actually considered insulting in their culture

garsh 11-16-2020 07:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by IMJ (Post 1868559)
Wow you got on board with Mirage early, man! I don't think I truly dabbled into a single Mirage book until City At War was on the LCS racks......

Several times I also ogled some kind of compilation book at my local mall bookstore. If I recall correctly, the cover art depicted the turts wielding sci-fi guns, and hinted at xenomorphs just out of frame. I wanted it, but I was always very money conscious and tried not to bug my parents for too much. They already spoiled me anyway.

shawnoen 11-20-2020 09:05 PM

Was born in 1972 and I started collecting from issue #2 and never looked back. Loved the black and white comics, the larger format of the original several issues, the story, etc....it wasn't easy collecting back then. Sometimes it was MONTHS between issues. My dad used to take me to the comic shop religiously every Saturday though. Anticipation would always build...."Will there be a new issue this week/month"....nope. Most of the guest issues were good but not all. When the City at War started though, it really brought life back to the series for me.

And regarding the cartoon, Archie comics, etc....that was a bastardization of the comic to me and I never really cared for it.

I also collected Usagi Yojimbo, Lone Wolf and Cub, Cerebus, Green Arrow, Eagle Comics Judge Dredd, all the Batman graphic novels and mini series, Spiderman for a while, Xmen for a while, anything by McFarlane later (Batman, Hulk, Spiderman, Spawn, etc...).

Lots of good memories with my dad collecting these books (still have them all) and hope to pass them to my son eventually.

PizzaPower1985 11-20-2020 09:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by shawnoen (Post 1869514)
Was born in 1972 and I started collecting from issue #2 and never looked back. Loved the black and white comics, the larger format of the original several issues, the story, etc....it wasn't easy collecting back then. Sometimes it was MONTHS between issues. My dad used to take me to the comic shop religiously every Saturday though. Anticipation would always build...."Will there be a new issue this week/month"....nope. Most of the guest issues were good but not all. When the City at War started though, it really brought life back to the series for me.

And regarding the cartoon, Archie comics, etc....that was a bastardization of the comic to me and I never really cared for it.

I also collected Usagi Yojimbo, Green Arrow, all the Batman graphic novels and mini series, Spiderman, anything by McFarlane later (Batman, Hulk, Spiderman, Spawn, etc...).

Lots of good memories with my dad collecting these books (still have them all) and hope to pass them to my son eventually.

How do you feel about the TMNT movie from 1990?

frank_one 11-20-2020 09:27 PM

Were you still buying it during Volume 2, 3 (Image) and 4?

IndigoErth 11-20-2020 10:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by PizzaPower1985 (Post 1868243)
I've always wondered...

Do you know anyone who was part of the original fan group who was reading and collecting Mirage in the earliest days? Late 1984 to say mid 85?

What happened to a lot of the original fans? Did they simply grow out of it or have they remained fans? Or is there any way to even know? Were any of you part of that group?

I talked to someone recently name Phillip who started collecting in 85, but said by the time the toon debuted in '87 he started getting out of it.

Any ideas about the OG fans? Any storied you'd like to share?

No, but would be interesting to hear from them, since most of us were just little kids and much too young for it or didn't even exist yet. Little envious since I was only just turned 5 (less than two weeks before!) when it came out and would be many years before I'd even know of it, but... being part of the Turtlemania generation hooked me though, so it's not all bad.

shawnoen 11-20-2020 10:13 PM

I stopped buying TMNT when Mirage ended at issue 62.The only thing I've bought since then are the hardcover collected books for my son. I did watch the 1990 TMNT movie but it wasn't the TMNT I grew up with. It was entertaining, no doubt, but not the same.

Andrew NDB 11-20-2020 11:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by frank_one (Post 1868770)
One good thing back then was that they were not afraid of publishing all kinds of letters even the ones containing complaints.

You don't think Vol. 4's lettercol was loaded with complaints?

Powder 11-21-2020 07:56 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1869528)
You don't think Vol. 4's lettercol was loaded with complaints?

I think he's throwing shade at IDW, bruh.

CyberCubed 11-21-2020 10:28 AM

Why do comics even have letters pages these days? Back in the 80's and early/mid 90's there was no internet so there was no way to tell what readers were thinking back then besides the small handful of letters published. Like there was no way to discuss the events of the comic with anyone unless you knew people in-person.

By the time we moved into the early 2000's everyone had internet and online forums became a thing, so I have no idea why letters pages still existed. Especially ones where people physically mailed a hand-written letter in an envelope to Mirage (I remember Peter saying he got a few of those and he had to re-type the letter into word to put it in the comic), it's so bizarre.

frank_one 11-21-2020 11:19 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1869528)
You don't think Vol. 4's lettercol was loaded with complaints?

Was it? I guess it was. The only think I remember is people criticizing Laird for his Segway excursions. One of these days I need to reread them again. I am probably one of the few that appreciated Volume 4.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Powder (Post 1869568)
I think he's throwing shade at IDW, bruh.

No, not really. Actually I think I've never read fan mails published in those. The only IDW issues I have are translated versions of the first story arcs. I stopped reading IDW very early.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:36 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.