The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   New Interview with Sophie Campbell from Comicon.com (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=63570)

TigerClaw 01-27-2021 04:27 PM

New Interview with Sophie Campbell from Comicon.com
 
Comicon.com has posted a new interview with Sophie Campbell talking about TMNT. You can read it here.
https://www.comicon.com/2021/01/27/t...ninja-turtles/

This bit about Tokka and Rahzar was interesting. It kind of makes you feel bad for them.
Quote:

SR: The hearts of 90s Turtles fans were no doubt beating in excitement with the announcement of the arc that is set to re-introduce Tokka and Rahzar from Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles II: The Secret of the Ooze. What made you want to bring them into the book and what can you say about this arc as a whole?

SC: I’d been trying to get Tokka and Rahzar into the IDW series for a while, and for a bit early on it seemed like it might not happen. I didn’t really like them that much when I was a kid, I didn’t like the comedic silly Turtles stuff at the time, until one time I revisited the movie when I was older and the characters finally clicked with me, then I was a diehard Tokka and Rahzar fan. They’re interesting to me because since they’re children, they don’t really understand what they’re doing, they don’t understand that the Foot Clan is bad, they don’t understand that Shredder (or in IDW’s case, Karai) is the bad guy, all they know is that they want to make their mama proud of them. They aren’t yet capable of having their own morality, and IDW TMNT has had a lot of morality and ethics on the part of the villains so I thought it would be fun to change it up and have a couple of antagonists who are amoral. Also the fact that they’re babies makes them a bit tragic and you don’t really want to see the Turtles (or Bebop and Rocksteady) beat them up because they don’t understand why they’re getting beaten up! And finally, they’re just really fun to draw!

ChosenOne 01-27-2021 07:34 PM

So Tokka and Rahzar are the IDW TMNT equivalent of Majin Buu. I dig it.

Andrew NDB 01-27-2021 08:30 PM

"I think their charm is how baby-like they are!" <--- while not untrue, this is a terrible case for adding more mutants (to the pile, in the case of IDW) to the world of TMNT. For me.

Jephael 01-27-2021 10:49 PM

Gotta admit, I was pretty psyched about seeing these two show up, though like Andrew says, this series has been getting really overloaded already with mutants and mystic creatures. Half the time the TMNT themselves aren't even present, and when they are, they're just in the background.

Mutant Ninja Anole 01-27-2021 11:08 PM

Now that I think about it, “Giant baby animals that wreak havoc not knowing better” is pretty much a standard kaiju trope.

Wentos 01-29-2021 05:44 AM

Quote:

There are probably too many characters in the series at this point, haha.
Y-yeah, haha

slashpieturtlemix 01-29-2021 10:05 AM

I am very excited to see where she is going with this arc.

spookycookies 01-29-2021 01:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by slashpieturtlemix (Post 1878002)
I am very excited to see where she is going with this arc.

Spoilers Tokka & Rahzar are going to kiss

ChosenOne 01-29-2021 01:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by spookycookies (Post 1878020)
Spoilers Tokka & Rahzar are going to kiss

Spoiler: Only if they're both the same gender.

AquaParade 01-29-2021 02:48 PM

That is probably the best angle to take on them and it has potential.

Sophie Campbell 01-29-2021 05:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChosenOne (Post 1878024)
Spoiler: Only if they're both the same gender.

All right, settle down.

ChosenOne 01-29-2021 07:42 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sophie Campbell (Post 1878041)
All right, settle down.

Don't see why I should. I'm entitled to an opinion and perfectly free to discuss the comic, so long as I don't engage in any personal attacks or otherwise reproachful conduct (which I haven't). Just like everyone else. :)

Look, the 'Drome isn't a hive mind like Twitter. Not every single reader is going to like what you've done with the comic after the novelty wears off, and especially not for so long considering the quality content this comic gave us pre-#100 in the same two-year time span as your run. I was a fervent supporter and you know it, until I realized this is going nowhere. The second Jennika mini, which did so much with only three issues, made me realize that. Criticism comes with the territory of being a professional writer and you need to accept it. I'm not going to apologize for having an opinion. I'm not trying to be toxic, I just don't like this run anymore and choose to express myself in caustic terms because that's who I am. Yes, I will keep on reading it because that's also who I am, but only in the hopes of it ever returning to a better place. If I'm being brutally honest, and you deserve honesty after all the good things you've given us over the years instead of the exclusively pretty words you'll read on Twitter, you're a tremendous artist on par with Santolouco but not the best of writers in an ongoing format. Best when consumed in small amounts, and those I did enjoy very much. Slice of life material just doesn't lend itself well to a two-year run.

P.S. For what it's worth, you're the one who should have settled down before you got the ball rolling by attacking the forum on Twitter. Not cool.

CyberCubed 01-29-2021 07:56 PM

Missed the _____.

Andrew NDB 01-29-2021 09:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChosenOne (Post 1878050)
Slice of life material just doesn't lend itself well to a two-year run.

The Twitter thing aside... to play devil's advocate a little, is that really Sophie's fault in this particular case? If you look at her body of work, she tends to most enjoy doing certain kinds of stories from certain kinds of perspectives with a certain "look" and style. Like, looking back at Tales V2 and graphic novels like "Wet Moon" (which I've read). Point being, you kind of know what you're going to get in a Sophie Campbell story, no?

Like, if hypothetically Peter Laird had taken a break from Mirage Vol. 4 (you know, other than the one he's been on for 10 years), then hired Mark Martin to come and fill in and basically just do whatever for two years, and -- sure enough -- Mark ends up doing typically Mark Martin-type stories with cartoony wackiness and slapstick gags and all that stuff. If we're not into that stuff, should we really get mad at Mark Martin, then? No, that's absurd. He'd just have been doing what Mark Martin always does. Laird would've known what he was getting when he hired him. Like, there's people you can get mad at in this scenario... but not Mark Martin.

ChosenOne 01-29-2021 10:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1878062)
I mean... to play devil's advocate a little, is that really Sophie's fault in this particular case? If you look at her body of work, she tends to most enjoy doing certain kinds of stories from certain kinds of perspectives with a certain "look" and style. Like, looking back at Tales V2 and graphic novels like "Wet Moon." Point being, you kind of know what you're going to get in a Sophie Campbell story, no?

Like, if hypothetically Peter Laird had taken a break from Mirage Vol. 4 (you know, other than the one he's been on for 10 years), then hired Mark Martin to come and fill in and basically just do whatever for two years, and -- sure enough -- he ends up doing typically Mark Martin-type stories with wackiness and slapstick gags and all that stuff. Should we really get mad at Mark Martin? No, he's just doing what Mark Martin always does.

You misunderstand. I'm not mad that Sophie does what she does, because she can and has done it damn well. I'm "mad" (and not even that, more like disappointed) that she apparently can't take any criticism of her work as seen on Twitter and now here, and seems to get triggered very easily by flippant remarks about the recurring tropes in her writing. How would you have reacted if Laird or Martin had verbally attacked their detractors on social media and then confronted them directly at a forum where they gather to tell them to "settle down" as if trying to silence them just because they have a dissenting opinion? I'll say it again: not cool. And also not helping her case. I know I've done a 180, but right now I won't be sad when she leaves the ongoing.

Andrew NDB 01-29-2021 10:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChosenOne (Post 1878064)
How would you have reacted if Laird or Martin had verbally attacked their detractors on social media and then confronted them directly at a forum where they gather to tell them to "settle down" as if trying to silence them just because they have a dissenting opinion?

That's why I went back and added the "The Twitter thing aside."

I'd be... not too happy with Mr. Martin, I think. But it would depend.

ChosenOne 01-29-2021 10:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1878065)
That's why I went back and added the "The Twitter thing aside."

Sorry, didn't notice in time. But it's not just the Twitter thing, it's the general stagnant feel of the comic (especially when compared with the Jennika mini), the pushing of certain elements previously foreign to TMNT to the detriment of everything else that we care about, the announcement that this is slated to go on for several more months with no end in sight, this thing tonight... And yeah, the Twitter thing too. That's the elephant in the room that we can't ignore, much as we'd like to. Still, while I might not like this cup of tea, I'll keep sipping and deal with the aftertaste later. And I'll pretend she didn't say what she said.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1878065)
I'd be... not too happy with Mr. Martin, I think. lol...

But you'd be okay with Laird doing it. :D

Andrew NDB 01-29-2021 10:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChosenOne (Post 1878067)
But you'd be okay with Laird doing it. :D

Well... heh... it's complicated. IDW isn't Peter Laird and Peter Laird isn't anything close to IDW (or anybody at it). I look at them through different lenses.

IDW? I'm not saying they're just putting out TMNT™ product, but sales and profitability/viability are big concerns as they have to be with something like this. Nobody wants the book to tank but at the same time it's not, like, some focus-grouped thing designed to maximize interest and revenue in the demographics designated with the highest profitability potential (i.e., like everything else Nick/Viacom has done with TMNT since getting the license). Though IDW is also -- essentially -- a hired (or licensed, in this case) gun for Nickelodeon/Viacom, who come into things with their own set of rules and guidelines and red tape and, really, priorities. And that isn't a slight, it's just the way it is. Now that said, a random writer or artist over there rapping my knuckles about this or that? Like, my misbehaving or something? Depending, but yeah, I'd probably have some words.

Peter Laird? People were always getting mad at him for saying stuff like, "You don't like the book (Vol. 4)? Fine by me! Don't buy it. The book is losing money anyway -- I know, it has been for a while now and I don't care. I'm just doing it now because I enjoy doing it and I can afford to just keep on printing it," and I always respected that 200% while it drove a bunch of people batty. That's a boss move. I'm not saying I agree with everything or even most of what he'd say in the lettercol, but he got to do that, at least as long as he held the rights -- he co-created the damn thing and there he was, still rolling out new books even after Kevin cashed in all of his chips back in 2000. No, I wouldn't get mad at him if he told me to "settle down," though I'd probably never "poke the bear" with him to begin with to get such a response from him.

Leo656 01-29-2021 10:38 PM

I cannot help but notice that a lot of TMNT creatives don't take criticism very well. This is not a new phenomenon. Lest we forget, Laird was using his Vol. 4 letter's column soapbox to "clap back" at people who thought his plot was boring and Lawson's pencils were bad, and that was almost 20 years ago. Since then we've seen that people like Ciro and Ant Ward likewise ALSO don't take it well when people question, critique, or otherwise take the piss out of their work.

It stands out to me because over on the He-Man forum, the dude who wrote/co-created the "New Adventures of He-Man" animated series has been a very vocal and active member for about 15 years. And "New Adventures" is, to say the least, "highly divisive" amongst that fanbase. So it's not like he hasn't endured a ton of slings and arrows about his involvement in that show (along with some praise, of course; everything is SOMEone's favorite thing). But rather than get defensive about it, or retreat from it, he owns it and takes it with gentle good humor. Other people who've written for MOTU comics and otherwise are likewise very active and vocal on the forum and don't take EVERY instance of criticism as a direct personal attack.

So it begs the question: Why are TMNT creatives so thin-skinned as a general rule? Why is it that if 15 people in a room say, "I like this book", and two or three others say "I DON'T like it, and Here's Why", those two or three people then become "The Forum" as a whole and are also in turn fair game to be vilified publicly on social media for having a dissenting opinion?

Why can the guy who wrote "New Adventures of He-Man" stick around for 15 years on a He-Man forum, with people almost daily mentioning in some form or fashion how they thought that show "sucked" and was "The worst part of the franchise", and he can laugh about it... but TMNT Pros can't? This is what I don't get. So many TMNT Pros who have been here either quit outright, attack the fanbase for having dissenting opinions, OR both.

Frankly, and to be blunt, I have to believe that in some part, it's because the TMNT "Pros" - like much of the general TMNT fanbase - are rather immature.

If I'm wrong, I'm wrong, and I don't say this to attack anyone personally. But I can only call what I see. And what I always see from TMNT staff is, "You don't wanna collectively kiss my ass? FINE, I'll take my ball and go home, you big meanies!" And it's like... dude, it doesn't have to be like that.

I don't know. To be blunt, I think people who can't take a little constructive criticism shouldn't put themselves out there in the first place. And that's ALL I've seen from the so-called "Negatives": Constructive Criticism. "Here's What I Don't Like, and Here's What I'd Rather See." That's "hostile"? That's "negative"? That's "sexist/misogynist/whatever-ist"? WHY? Okay, some people crack jokes. That's allowed.

Paying customers have every right to speak their piece without being called names. That's what I think. And I don't know why the people who handle this specific franchise always have such a hard time being told that whatever the current flavor is doesn't sit well with some folks. Again, it's nothing new, and it's a shared trait among TMNT staff.

I just wish it wasn't.

ChosenOne 01-29-2021 10:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1878068)
Well... heh... it's complicated. IDW isn't Peter Laird and Peter Laird isn't anything close to IDW (or anybody at it). I look at them through different lenses.

IDW? I'm not saying they're just putting out TMNT™ product, but sales and profitability/viability are big concerns as they have to be with something like this. Nobody wants the book to tank but at the same time it's not, like, some focus-grouped thing designed to maximize interest and revenue in the demographics designated with the highest profitability potential (i.e., like everything else Nick/Viacom has done with TMNT since getting the license). Though IDW is also -- essentially -- a hired (or licensed, in this case) gun for Nickelodeon/Viacom, who come into things with their own set of rules and guidelines and red tape and, really, priorities. And that isn't a slight, it's just the way it is. Now, random writer or artist over there rapping my knuckles about this or that? Like, maybe I'm misbehaving? Yeah, I'd probably have some words.

Peter Laird? People were always getting mad at him for saying stuff like, "You don't like the book (Vol. 4)? Don't buy it. The book is losing money anyway -- I know, it has been for a while now and I don't care. I'm just doing it now because I enjoy doing it," and I always respected that while it drove a bunch of people batty. That's a boss move. He got to do that, at least as long as he held the rights. No, I wouldn't get mad at him if he told me to "settle down," though I'd probably never "poke the bear" with him to begin with to get such a response from him.

That was just a playful remark. See? That's how I roll. But I appreciate you taking the time to whip up a reply, and it's an interesting read to boot.

Hard to determine at this point who poked who first. I was always supportive of Sophie's run up until this past week, my post history and Sophie herself will attest to that. I know things were rough between her and some of the forum's denizens and I have no idea who started it but I always had her back. And then the Twitter thing soured me, and the Jennika mini came out and was so much better in much less issues than the ongoing has had so far while remaining stagnant and actually featured Null and feels like it's going somewhere as opposed to the ongoing, and now this... Not the most positive of attitudes from her. This is how one turns supporters/fans into detractors.

Speaking of tanking, I hate to make this ideological because my beef isn't about that at all but it's funny how usually any form of entertainment that turns full-blown PC starts to wither away and die sales- or ratings-wise... Food for thought.

I'll take a page out of Laird's book, then, and leave this out there to all those it may concern: You don't like my opinion? Keep walking.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1878069)
Paying customers have every right to speak their piece without being called names.

This too.

Leo656 01-29-2021 10:49 PM

I think the biggest lesson we can all take from this is that Nobody Needs To Be On Twitter.

It's just an echo chamber/sounding board for narcissism. No good comes from it, its only purpose is to sow discord. I personally don't have one because for all my long-windedness and braggadocio, in truth I'm under absolutely NO illusion that anyone anywhere on God's Green Earth gives a flying fiddler's f*ck what I think about a single goddamn thing. People tell me all the time to get Twitter, and I outright refuse, because in spite of all evidence, I Am Not A Narcissist.

I am a borderline Sociopath with high self-esteem, however, but that is COMPLETELY different, sir. :lol:

Anyways. Every single thing ever written on Twitter is nothing but cringe. If it didn't exist, the entire human race would be happier and there'd be a lot less ill-will. So if there's a lesson here, it's that Nobody Should Ever Be On Twitter.

That's not the lesson anybody's gonna take, but it's the one they SHOULD take.

CyberCubed 01-29-2021 10:54 PM

I think someone missed the joke of Rahzar/Tokka kissing.

ChosenOne 01-29-2021 11:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1878071)
I think the biggest lesson we can all take from this is that Nobody Needs To Be On Twitter.

It's just an echo chamber/sounding board for narcissism. No good comes from it, its only purpose is to sow discord. I personally don't have one because for all my long-windedness and braggadocio, in truth I'm under absolutely NO illusion that anyone anywhere on God's Green Earth gives a flying fiddler's f*ck what I think about a single goddamn thing. People tell me all the time to get Twitter, and I outright refuse, because in spite of all evidence, I Am Not A Narcissist.

I am a borderline Sociopath with high self-esteem, however, but that is COMPLETELY different, sir. :lol:

Anyways. Every single thing ever written on Twitter is nothing but cringe. If it didn't exist, the entire human race would be happier and there'd be a lot less ill-will. So if there's a lesson here, it's that Nobody Should Ever Be On Twitter.

That's not the lesson anybody's gonna take, but it's the one they SHOULD take.

Let's be honest, you're not on Twitter because there's a character limit. :lol:

(Yet another joke, please take it as such and nothing more.)

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1878072)
I think someone missed the joke of Rahzar/Tokka kissing.

Loads of jokes to be made there.

Speaking of Tokka, since she/he (what gender is Tokka? I genuinely don't know) is the same species as Slash, I wonder why they look so different in terms of size? Did Hob mutate the pair? Was he looking to use the same animal species? Did he do something to increase Tokka's might? So many questions.

Sophie Campbell 01-30-2021 02:18 AM

What is this Twitter attacking the Drome thing?? I think I missed that. It's kind of a running gag on my twitter at this point that I'm like "I gotta stop looking at the TMNT forum" whenever a new issue comes out, it's just a joke though. But people were actually attacking you here or something?

I've been visiting this forum for almost 10 years now, I know how it goes, it's fine. Fans not liking everything I do comes with the job, that's part of the job description. I've been doing comics professionally since 2002, I can take criticism just fine, I've heard it all, from death threats to people threatening to beat me up and that I'm a waste of space etc. etc. It's really fine, some days it wears on me for sure but it's not a big deal. It's just how it goes.

Early days of my series Wet Moon I used to get it pretty hard from readers and critics alike, but damn the worst was probably when I was working on Jem & the Holograms, those fans were BANANAS. Angry Jem fans make angry TMNT fans look like a walk in the park, like the meanest stuff I've ever heard said to me by anyone, haha. And hey I'm still here. :tcool:

In any case, you guys can talk about whatever the hell you want and have whatever opinion you want, and I'll keep doing Turtles.

Dejablue 01-30-2021 04:20 AM

Quote:

Speaking of tanking, I hate to make this ideological because my beef isn't about that at all but it's funny how usually any form of entertainment that turns full-blown PC starts to wither away and die sales- or ratings-wise... Food for thought.
In my personal opinion things can be as pc as it wants, that doesnt cause the tank. What causes a tank is if the story takes a back seat to a message being unsubtly sold.

hypered1 01-30-2021 06:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChosenOne (Post 1878073)
Speaking of Tokka, since she/he (what gender is Tokka? I genuinely don't know) is the same species as Slash, I wonder why they look so different in terms of size? Did Hob mutate the pair? Was he looking to use the same animal species? Did he do something to increase Tokka's might? So many questions.

I can't remember which thread it was but I did speculate a few weeks ago that Slash was a Common Snapping Turtle and Tokka is an Alligator Snapping Turtle which are larger and have spikier shells.

Leo656 01-30-2021 08:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ChosenOne (Post 1878073)
Let's be honest, you're not on Twitter because there's a character limit. :lol:

(Yet another joke, please take it as such and nothing more.)

That was awesome. A snug jab, perfectly placed. Good sh*t, pal. :lol:

TigerClaw 01-30-2021 09:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sophie Campbell (Post 1878074)
What is this Twitter attacking the Drome thing?? I think I missed that. It's kind of a running gag on my twitter at this point that I'm like "I gotta stop looking at the TMNT forum" whenever a new issue comes out, it's just a joke though. But people were actually attacking you here or something?

I've been visiting this forum for almost 10 years now, I know how it goes, it's fine. Fans not liking everything I do comes with the job, that's part of the job description. I've been doing comics professionally since 2002, I can take criticism just fine, I've heard it all, from death threats to people threatening to beat me up and that I'm a waste of space etc. etc. It's really fine, some days it wears on me for sure but it's not a big deal. It's just how it goes.

Early days of my series Wet Moon I used to get it pretty hard from readers and critics alike, but damn the worst was probably when I was working on Jem & the Holograms, those fans were BANANAS. Angry Jem fans make angry TMNT fans look like a walk in the park, like the meanest stuff I've ever heard said to me by anyone, haha. And hey I'm still here. :tcool:

In any case, you guys can talk about whatever the hell you want and have whatever opinion you want, and I'll keep doing Turtles.

You keep doing what your doing. I love the work you have done so far.

I don't like it when people who are critical of the work are trying to change how the work is written. As a writer you have a lot of creative freedom on the property and you are doing what you think is best. and honestly I love what you are doing because I needed something new and what I have seen you do so far was a breath of fresh air. and I hope it continues on in the foreseeable future. I love these characters and they are more human then any of us are. And that's why I love about it. They are relatable.

AquaParade 01-30-2021 09:50 AM

Spoken like a true android.

I think the book is pretty good right now. Just as good as it has been over the last few years, if not better. I'll admit I'm a few issues behind, but I like the slower pace and character work, even if it doesn't always fit my idea of how the tmnt should be done. Maybe I'm just a sucker for the art.

CylonsKlingonsDaleksOhMy 01-30-2021 11:39 AM

https://i.kym-cdn.com/photos/images/...937249093s.jpg

ChosenOne 01-30-2021 12:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sophie Campbell (Post 1878074)
I'll keep doing Turtles.

Ominous words... :o Well, then, bring on the next issue of Turtledale! The sooner we get this over with, the sooner we get the real comic back.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dejablue (Post 1878079)
In my personal opinion things can be as pc as it wants, that doesnt cause the tank. What causes a tank is if the story takes a back seat to a message being unsubtly sold.

It's possible we're just discussing semantics but to me, that is being PC. Some things are just self evident. They don't need to be championed or pushed on others. And as you said, when one does so, they cross the line into obnoxiousness and run a very serious risk of putting people off their intended message entirely, even of actively rebelling against it. Regarding the unsubtle messages, this comic seems to be treading those waters already. Let's hope it doesn't swim any further out and endanger the chances of getting back on track down the line.

Quote:

Originally Posted by hypered1 (Post 1878083)
I can't remember which thread it was but I did speculate a few weeks ago that Slash was a Common Snapping Turtle and Tokka is an Alligator Snapping Turtle which are larger and have spikier shells.

Good point, and a distinction I keep forgetting. Thank you.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1878087)
That was awesome. A snug jab, perfectly placed. Good sh*t, pal. :lol:

The highest praise in the land! :D

sdp 01-30-2021 02:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by spookycookies (Post 1878020)
Spoilers Tokka & Rahzar are going to kiss

https://i.pinimg.com/564x/fd/04/7e/f...0e00a1e38a.jpg
Quote:

Originally Posted by ChosenOne (Post 1878024)
Spoiler: Only if they're both the same gender.

https://i.ytimg.com/vi/z5q3XMzZe3U/hqdefault.jpg

frank_one 01-30-2021 05:43 PM

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EsC_6AEV...png&name=small
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/EsC_6AEV...png&name=small

superstaff 01-31-2021 07:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1878069)
Since then we've seen that people like Ciro and Ant Ward likewise ALSO don't take it well when people question, critique, or otherwise take the piss out of their work.

I'm curious (and was out of the loop during the 2012 tenure), what happened with Ciro and Ant?


Quote:

Originally Posted by TigerClaw (Post 1878089)
I don't like it when people who are critical of the work are trying to change how the work is written. As a writer you have a lot of creative freedom on the property and you are doing what you think is best.

I think many of us who critique works aren't trying to change them per say. I've been vocal about things I dislike in media (maybe not as much in this forum, but on other sites like Reddit), and a lot of it is venting about directions I didn't like the story taking, and hoping the criticisms can be taken to heart by writers so they avoid pitfalls in the future.

Problem is, a lot of creators do not like criticism. Of any kind. I remember writing a brief review of a major movie on /r/movies, and the director responded to me (to my shock) to basically insult me, and implied I only hated the movie because I was sexist, even though I never once said anything hateful towards the female characters (and I'm a female myself...). There is a difference between sexism and critiquing the way female characters are written (and believe me, I have many reservations with the way Jennika is characterized in IDW, which I won't get into here...).

The internet seems to conflate all criticism as inherently toxic, and coddle creators by saying their works are 100% perfect always, and should never be changed ever.

Mutant Ninja Anole 01-31-2021 11:50 AM

My general feeling is artists should be able to take criticism and generally understand people are going to be idiots sometimes, but the aggressive hatedom that can emerge from a work’s seeming best fans is something to behold. There’s a livejournal group that’s been posting detailed and vicious takedowns of the newspaper comic For Better or For Worse strip by strip, almost every single day, to the present, despite the strip having been out of publication for over 12 years. THAT’s dedication baby.

DragonSoul 01-31-2021 12:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by superstaff (Post 1878168)
Problem is, a lot of creators do not like criticism. Of any kind. I remember writing a brief review of a major movie on /r/movies, and the director responded to me (to my shock) to basically insult me, and implied I only hated the movie because I was sexist, even though I never once said anything hateful towards the female characters (and I'm a female myself...). There is a difference between sexism and critiquing the way female characters are written (and believe me, I have many reservations with the way Jennika is characterized in IDW, which I won't get into here...).

The internet seems to conflate all criticism as inherently toxic, and coddle creators by saying their works are 100% perfect always, and should never be changed ever.

Gosh that was unprofessional of that movie director. I would like to hear your criticisms on Jennika, I feel like maybe there should be more threads dedicated to critiques about a character. As another woman, I have a lot to say about Jennika as well and most are not in praise of the character.

I have to agree criticisms are wrongly viewed as toxic when instead they could be utilized as inspiration to refine their craft. I think how a creative responds to criticism ultimately defines their work for the better or worse. However, I do feel for Sophie Campbell in this case because it seems hard to pick out constructive criticism when most of her criticisms tend to insult her or threaten her.

MikeandRaph87 01-31-2021 01:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DragonSoul (Post 1878178)
Gosh that was unprofessional of that movie director. I would like to hear your criticisms on Jennika, I feel like maybe there should be more threads dedicated to critiques about a character. As another woman, I have a lot to say about Jennika as well and most are not in praise of the character.

I have to agree criticisms are wrongly viewed as toxic when instead they could be utilized as inspiration to refine their craft. I think how a creative responds to criticism ultimately defines their work for the better or worse. However, I do feel for Sophie Campbell in this case because it seems hard to pick out constructive criticism when most of her criticisms tend to insult her or threaten her.

As rough as the Techndrome Forums can be at times it is mostly cordial and constructive criticism. Admittingly just a few with a reputation can label a site for all-time and perhaps that is this forum's problem, however, please ladies I would like to read your critiques. I am not in favor of the direction and it goes beyond the current writer and prefer to tread lightly and express my concerns. I hope that you do the same. That is what makes fandom healthy.

Dejablue 01-31-2021 08:55 PM

I would feel really bad if anyone here insulted or threatened Campbell. I haven't read anything like that since reading other people's opinion on #113.

Leo656 01-31-2021 09:20 PM

Well I mean that would be a horse of a different color, yeah. But I definitely haven't seen anything like THAT spoken here about the book, just that some people don't care for the story or pacing, or that they like it in theory but that it's going on longer than they'd like. That all seems pretty constructive, especially for This Place.


Quote:

Originally Posted by superstaff (Post 1878168)
I'm curious (and was out of the loop during the 2012 tenure), what happened with Ciro and Ant?

I only caught the very tail end of the thing with Ciro, so I don't really know a ton. But apparently near the beginning of the Nick TMNT debut Cubed said some stuff that Ciro didn't like, so Ciro basically said "Screw you guys, I'm goin' home" and never came back. And for a while everybody was pissed at Cubed for "chasing off" one of the TNT creative Staff.

I was only dipping in and out at that time, so I missed most of the whole thing. But I did notice that Ciro was having a blast on the forum as long as everyone was being all positive and butt-kissy.

With Ant Ward, that was from when the first teasers for "Rise" came out and I made sure to voice by displeasure in my own usual inimitable style. :trazz: Something about wishing I had a time machine so I could make sure the creators of the show were never born, and something else about wanting to see everyone involved in the show get on the same bus and watch that bus go over a cliff. :lol: OKAY, it was dark. But it's nothing I haven't said before about other people and it was very clearly tongue-in-cheek.

So Ant allegedly saw that stuff, and took it as a specific threat against his person, and insisted that I get Temp-Banned and made an example of or else there'd be legal action. :roll:

Now, I know that "gallows humor" isn't to everyone's taste but I still think that was a pretty severe overreaction on his part. It was clearly just jokes. Poor-taste jokes, sure, but that's always been kind of my gimmick. Apparently jokes about dead babies piled up in my garage and dead hookers in my crawlspace is all fair game, but "I'd like to see that bus go over a cliff with all of them in it" was a bridge too far, somehow. :lol:

Part of me suspects that what it REALLY was, was that he's British and I'm Irish and thus we each have to think the other is a fookin' wanker and take things way too personally. :trazz:

I'd be pretty annoyed at seeing such comments about my work, too, but I'd also try and consider the source, were I him. I'm like, a Known Dick, so if he really expected me to just say "I don't like this" and NOT be all "colorful" about it, well, I dunno.

I mean, I don't drive and my time machine doesn't even work (can't make left turns). So a "threat" it most certainly was not. Just a bad joke that he took way too seriously.

ChosenOne 01-31-2021 09:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1878210)
I mean, I don't drive and my time machine doesn't even work (can't make left turns). So a "threat" it most certainly was not. Just a bad joke that he took way too seriously.

For a really nasty comeuppance, why not put the creators in the time machine and throw it off a cliff, only programmed to travel back to the moment it starts to fall right before it hits the ground below? :tcool::lol:


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:03 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.