The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   Do you think the 1990 film will ever be topped? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=63727)

jignat 03-09-2021 08:57 PM

Do you think the 1990 film will ever be topped?
 
The first live action film turned 30 last year and imo it is the best film by a mile.

After the films went into hiatus after 3, I was eager for the 2007 CGI film. While I thought it was good, it was not a big mainstream hit.

The 2014/2016 Bay-produced films were significantly worse and i hated their designs.

So, has the film franchise reached its peak?

Leo656 03-09-2021 09:13 PM

Nope. Not even mathematically possible. It's the best anyone's ever gonna do and people should make peace with that.

It owes everything to the fact that it was essentially an "independent" film. We've seen what Hollywood does when they make a TMNT film: They make a giant toy commercial.

There will never be another "indie" attempt at TMNT, aside from fan films. All Hollywood attempts are destined to be the same type of garbage. The 1990 film is the best we can ever expect and we should be grateful we even got that.

Prowler 03-09-2021 09:20 PM

No.

It was the first ever TMNT movie and, by far, the best one to date. And there's been several TMNT movies already. So I have zero hopes to ever see a TMNT movie as good as the 1990 one. Let alone a better one.

Jester 03-09-2021 09:32 PM

I'mma come out with a strong "Maybe..."

I love the Steve Barron film. It takes Mirage and Fred Wolf and blends them into a cohesive movie that has layers (I may be biased, but there's a lot of nuance in that movie.) It's a testament to Barron's care for the source material (The man used pages and panels of the comics as storyboards for crying out loud.) that that movie works even to this day.

IF (and it's a big IF) you can get a film maker who is willing to put that much care into the film, we could have a movie to equal the 1st....and MAYBE even top it.

I'm not sure who would be willing to do that kind of leg-work on such a niche property, but it could happen...maybe...

Leo656 03-09-2021 09:46 PM

"The filmmaker" is an irrelevant variable in the larger picture.

It's "The Studio". They control what we see, and they give "the filmmaker" his direction. And to "the studio", TMNT is just a kids' toy property. That's how it is now and how it's always going to stay.

Like sure, what Bay did to the brand was unforgivable, and he DID have more leeway than most other producer/director types would have had in his position... but let's be honest, what else was Paramount ever gonna give the green light to? "A super-hero movie aimed at selling toys" is all any movie studio is gonna throw $100 million+ at.

"Out of the Shadows" is realistically how everything is gonna look from now on, because it fits "the template" of what kind of movies Hollywood can "sell".

Andrew NDB 03-09-2021 09:49 PM

Any chance of that went out the door in 2009. If a movie came out now that was in any way better than 1990, it would be in spite of a flotilla of factors working against it.

Jester 03-09-2021 09:50 PM

That thought crossed my mind when I saw that another thread recently updated was the "Should Laird have sold to Viacom/Nick". I thought, "I bet the biggest hurdle to a good TMNT film anymore is Viacom."

Studio meddling is most definitely going to make this hard, but I just never like to be absolute about anything.

IMJ 03-09-2021 10:07 PM

Given the number actual "remakes" out there already they should give the story that was the 90's film another go around but with modern special effects and without that sort of cheap, urban stage set that always got with Platinum films of that era.

Don't get me wrong, I love the first movie. I'm only saying that it could be remade to follow those key beats from the Mirage Comic but with modern SFX. It wouldn't be entirely uncalled for. Hell, they were on their way to remaking Eric Draven's Crow story for God's sake.

Roseangelo 03-10-2021 12:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Leo656 (Post 1883850)
It owes everything to the fact that it was essentially an "independent" film. We've seen what Hollywood does when they make a TMNT film: They make a giant toy commercial.

This is the right answer.

The other part of being an indy movie is the fact that they made that move for $12 million. That's pennies in today's money, but it was still not a lot of money back then. They built costumes with brand new tech and pulled the whole damn thing together with $12 million. You can bet all of that was well spent, and they made it work because they had to. And they wanted to make that movie.

Powder 03-10-2021 02:15 AM

No. It was a work of art. Everything is else is product first, art second, if art even factors in at all.

But, I think it would be possible to make something that is equally impressive, for different reasons. Imagine a Guardians Of The Galaxy style Fugitoid/Triceraton arc movie with the right amount of action, spaceship chases, dimension hopping, legitimately good CGI, etc. Man...

Andrew NDB 03-10-2021 02:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roseangelo (Post 1883886)
This is the right answer.

The other part of being an indy movie is the fact that they made that move for $12 million. That's pennies in today's money, but it was still not a lot of money back then. They built costumes with brand new tech and pulled the whole damn thing together with $12 million. You can bet all of that was well spent, and they made it work because they had to. And they wanted to make that movie.

Lack of resources is always a good source of creativity/ingenuity.

The Star Wars prequels and sequels showed us both ends of the spectrum.

The OT: One guy with very little money having to rely on creative tricks to make big things happen with very little.

The prequels: The same guy calling the shots but who now has a ton of money. It has soul but wasn't nearly as good as it would have been had he/they been working under the same kind of conditions as the OT.

The sequels: No "guy" anymore, just suits and a whooooole lot of money now. Big surprise: completely soulless. Just like the 2014 and 2016 TMNT movies.

Lord Nightwalker 03-10-2021 08:16 AM

No. It seems like they don't really have a handle on TMNT.

IMJ 03-10-2021 11:55 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roseangelo (Post 1883886)
This is the right answer.

The other part of being an indy movie is the fact that they made that move for $12 million. That's pennies in today's money, but it was still not a lot of money back then. They built costumes with brand new tech and pulled the whole damn thing together with $12 million. You can bet all of that was well spent, and they made it work because they had to. And they wanted to make that movie.

This is true. At the time it really was a quality indie flick.

AquaParade 03-10-2021 01:54 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1883902)
Lack of resources is always a good source of creativity/ingenuity.

100%

Quote:

Originally Posted by Powder (Post 1883901)
No. It was a work of art. Everything is else is product first, art second, if art even factors in at all.

But, I think it would be possible to make something that is equally impressive, for different reasons. Imagine a Guardians Of The Galaxy style Fugitoid/Triceraton arc movie with the right amount of action, spaceship chases, dimension hopping, legitimately good CGI, etc. Man...

This is how I feel. There are certain aspects that can't be topped, and I absolutely love the 1990 film for. The indie flavor that fits Mirage so well, the confidence the film shows by maintaining a somber, calm tone, the character work.
But Hollywood could potentially make a kick ass TMNT movie that does things the 1990 film couldn't. Guardians of the Galaxy is the right idea, even if I don't particularly love that film, because I could appreciate that approach and treatment of the material.

I still think there is hope for another great TMNT movie. We've seen Nick try a few different things so far. They've had time to sit back and watch what sells and what doesn't. Rise and the feature films failed, while the Neca toy sales and Last Ronin have succeeded. They will take the time to evaluate and they will take something away from that. They have to if they want to make money.

Rabbit Kraken Zeo 03-10-2021 09:33 PM

III is my favorite and always will be, I appreciate 1 and 2 and to the displeasure of the fan base I maybe the only one who finds 3 more valuable then 1 and 2 combined. Look I love 1 and 2 but i prefer 3 specifically because of Walker's character and the time travel business. The entire plot felt very fun and enjoyable; the entire time I am feeling that moment from A to B.

Now for the topic in regards; the first film will always have a place in my heart to be remembered for being the first ever. It will stand the test of time for sure and i don't think many others can conquer it however considering my love for the 3rd I just prefer that film more but will any other really take over 1? No. To a degree--- the first film shapes the universe of our legendary turtles into live action so of course that feeling is over the top but again i still love all 3 but prefer the 3rd film as personal favorite.

Leo656 03-10-2021 09:56 PM

I'm gonna need more clarification on this.

What "character" of Walker? He's barely a character at all, he's "Stock Mustache-Twirling Movie Villain 32-C (Sans Mustache)." He's like he just stepped out of a book of Bad Guy Cliches and tried to do all of them at once. All he was missing was a big sign around his neck saying "I'm A Villain, Get It?" He's the most one-dimensional character in the entire trilogy, which says a lot when two of those characters happen to be a mutant baby wolf and a baby mutant snapping turtle, both of whom are barely capable of speech (yet still somehow manage to portray more depth than Walker does).

I don't know. No disrespect intended but it would help me greatly if you could show more of your work on this. So I could at least understand where you're coming from.

ABrown 03-11-2021 09:43 AM

I consider the 2007 CGI movie to be right there with it at the top on my list of favorite TMNT movies. The 1990 movie is my favorite, but 2007 TMNT is pretty damn close.

Zulithe 03-11-2021 10:18 AM

It was the perfect movie for 9yo me in the time that it came out, so for that kid version of myself it won't ever be topped. It's far from a perfect movie though and I do think it's possible to create a better TMNT film, I just don't think the right combination of talent, timing, budget, etc., will come together for it to actually happen. Particularly not under Nickelodeon who seems perfectly happy to put out product that clearly isn't being made for the passion of it, with some exception given to the 2012 series.

I love what they accomplished with the 1990 film. It is a treasure.

sdp 03-11-2021 10:58 AM

It's already been surpassed by TMNT 2014.

Zulithe 03-11-2021 11:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sdp (Post 1884236)
It's already been surpassed by TMNT 2014.

Well that's certainly a take! :teek:

Autbot_Benz 03-11-2021 12:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sdp (Post 1884236)
It's already been surpassed by TMNT 2014.

https://i.imgur.com/qd8Js12.gif

Adventuremaster18 03-11-2021 01:15 PM

I honestly feel it depends.

A big factor in my opinion is whether the film is either animated or live action. Viacom seems to play it a bit safe with live action films, as most studios do. However, animated TV movies or direct to video films are a different story.

Nick has made some incredible creator driven animated stuff, most notably Avatar the Last Airbender, which is some of the greatest storytelling I've seen in a series. TMNT 2012 and Rise did something similar, though not as good by comparison (sure, there were characters who would become toys which needed to be pushed in, but both, especially the former, had a focus on good storytelling as well). If they were able to produce either a direct to video feature film with a creator in charge who really cared, I think very much so that we could get a TMNT film that tops the original.

Galactus 03-11-2021 03:58 PM

Could the 1990 movie ever be topped? Sure. It's by far the best movie to ever be made of property but it's not exactly perfect. It could easily be improved on.

Is it likely to ever be topped. Nope. Not with the people we've got at the top making decisions.

I wouldn't go as far to say that being an indie movie was what made it great. After all the sequels were all indie flicks too and they were bad. As soon the first became an unexpected commercial success it ruined everyone's thinking about how the movies should be handled.

Jester 03-11-2021 04:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Adventuremaster18 (Post 1884255)
I honestly feel it depends.

A big factor in my opinion is whether the film is either animated or live action. Viacom seems to play it a bit safe with live action films, as most studios do. However, animated TV movies or direct to video films are a different story.

Nick has made some incredible creator driven animated stuff, most notably Avatar the Last Airbender, which is some of the greatest storytelling I've seen in a series. TMNT 2012 and Rise did something similar, though not as good by comparison (sure, there were characters who would become toys which needed to be pushed in, but both, especially the former, had a focus on good storytelling as well). If they were able to produce either a direct to video feature film with a creator in charge who really cared, I think very much so that we could get a TMNT film that tops the original.

I've always said I'd LOVE a movie that is a straight retelling on TMNT #1. Black and white and red (for bandanas, both Turtle and Foot, and BLOOD!). Simple. But then I wondered if Nick/Viacom could do like DC/Warner Bros. did with their animated movie series, take significant stories from the Eastman and Laird run of comics and make them into animated films...but than again that's essentially the first couple of 4kids seasons as it is.

Shark_Blade 03-11-2021 09:32 PM

Sure if you can get the right people to do it.

For now it still reigns supreme at the top of my TMNT movies list.


Prowler 03-11-2021 10:53 PM

I know that's your personal top, Shark Blade, but TMNT 1990 being number 1 is pretty much the only thing I can agree on in your list lol

Adventuremaster18 03-12-2021 12:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jester (Post 1884296)
I've always said I'd LOVE a movie that is a straight retelling on TMNT #1. Black and white and red (for bandanas, both Turtle and Foot, and BLOOD!). Simple. But then I wondered if Nick/Viacom could do like DC/Warner Bros. did with their animated movie series, take significant stories from the Eastman and Laird run of comics and make them into animated films...but than again that's essentially the first couple of 4kids seasons as it is.

I'm gonna be honest... I don't get why people want super accurate adaptations tbh. I'm very much in the minority on this, but I feel the best part of each version of TMNT is that it's so different.

My favorite writer, Douglas Adams, didn't understand the idea of telling the same story the exact same way in every version/adaptation. It's why the novels, books, audio dramas, and especially the film of his series "The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy" and "Dirk Gently" are all so different from each other. He liked the idea of experimenting and changing the story up with each version, because he didn't get the point of making each version the same.

And I agree with that. Even when they take inspiration from each version, Mirage, Archie, Fred Wolf, 2012, the 90's movie, Rise, IDW, etc. are all super unique and do their own takes on the TMNT. It helps keep things fresh and more interesting than just telling the same story again with no variation. The original story is there, no need to retell it the exact same way IMO.

Shark_Blade 03-12-2021 01:18 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Prowler (Post 1884391)
I know that's your personal top, Shark Blade, but TMNT 1990 being number 1 is pretty much the only thing I can agree on in your list lol

No sweat, different people different taste. For example, I know some people like Secret of the Ooze but it just doesn’t do it for me. *shrug*

But hey, we’re getting new Turtles (Rise on Netflix and the Platinum Dunes reboot) so that’s more movies to look forward to. :tgrin:

Andrew NDB 03-12-2021 02:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Shark_Blade (Post 1884414)
But hey, we’re getting new Turtles (Rise on Netflix and the Platinum Dunes reboot) so that’s more movies to look forward to. :tgrin:

Looking forward to them? Is that what we're doing?

Leo656 03-12-2021 10:55 AM

I'm not! I don't know what These People are doing. I don't claim them. :lol:

I'm not "looking forward" to anything with this f*cking franchise anymore, after the last ten years. "Awaiting with a clenched colon to see just how bad they're gonna f*ck it up THIS time" is the only appropriate response. Certainly not "looking forward to."

Musashi 03-12-2021 03:49 PM

We're looking forward to them, in the sense that they're in the future, so we can't yet look back at them.

Musashi 03-12-2021 03:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by sdp (Post 1884236)
It's already been surpassed by TMNT 2014.

Now, I don't really do memes and GIFs and all that, I'm old. But I have a hankering now for one that goes "Heh:)... Oh, you're serious...!!!" Is there such a one?

Jester 03-12-2021 11:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Musashi (Post 1884559)
Now, I don't really do memes and GIFs and all that, I'm old. But I have a hankering now for one that goes "Heh:)... Oh, you're serious...!!!" Is there such a one?

Like this:

DarkFell 03-13-2021 01:55 AM

I think that the 1990 TMNT movie should be left alone. Despite its flaws and imperfections with the animatronic suits, the actors and directors gave it their all and made TMNT '90 their own movie.

It's time to give the TMNT cast and crew another adventure to go on.

Musashi 03-13-2021 06:08 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jester (Post 1884644)
Like this...

That. :)

This is a sentence to take this over 10 characters so it can be posted.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 04:03 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.