![]() |
DC's Abandoned TMNT/Masters of the Universe Crossover
https://mlpnk72yciwc.i.optimole.com/...72705517_n.jpg
Freddie Williams: Quote:
|
I would have loved this crossover too :tcry:
|
Probably cause DC hates money and they couldn't find a way to put some sort of political spin on it. I mean the villains were a Japanese ninja and skull faced alien. They had no evil white business man to work with, lol
|
Cool design. This would have sold well.
|
Quote:
|
i actually had a few fusions done on a 4chan drawthread earlier this year.
Spoiler:
Spoiler:
might as well post the other one they were to combine with cobra commander. Spoiler:
|
I love that first one.
Honestly, I never want to see Shredder without a skull mask/face again. It just works. |
I wonder why DC pulled the plug on it when the Batman crossovers sold well. Guess we'll never know.
|
Can DC do stuff without Mattel's involvement?
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Since it's been canned, let's throw up some hypothetical synopsises.
I should prefic here by pointing out this first one is not what I would personally write, just what I think most writers would do:
And since that artwork implies there was going to plenty of mash-up concepts, here are a few I think they would do:
And here is one I would personally write, I barely know anything about He-Man, so forgive me if I screw something up:
|
You mean to tell me we have to miss out on Leo in furry men's hot pants? I'm not sure which way I feel abut that. lol Could have been a fun crossover.
|
I would've bought it, but I doubt it would've been "good". The two properties have a lot in common in the "meta" sense, as far as being 80s franchises that ended up succeeding beyond all initial expectations (and afterwards had a series of diminishing returns), but in a story and presentation sense you couldn't get much more different than those two brands.
This would inevitably just have been one of those "kid in the tub with his action figures" type of cross-overs. The MOTU/Thundercats cross-over made sense; the two brands had a lot in common, they were stylistically very similar, and going back to the 80s it was a cross-over lots of people were asking for. Conversely, MOTU and TMNT have almost nothing in common and nobody to my knowledge ever asked for this. There's not even a ton of cross-over between the fandoms; lots of MOTU fans also like TMNT, but most TMNT fans hate or don't care about MOTU. Could've been "interesting", but I think it would've been kind of dumb in its execution and I don't think it would've sold well. I say that "with love" as a fan of both (but a much bigger MOTU fan by a huge margin); not everything goes together like chocolate and peanut butter. On the positive side, Freddie Williams is terrific with these vintage characters and properties. Even if the plot was terrible it sure would've looked great, for sure. |
It would probably have read like ass but It would sell well.
All the tmnt crossovers have been big selllers. For one, it just helps to have two franchises to sell one book. It will always equal more base interest. And while there is less crossover between hardcore fans of each properties, there are many who are more casual fans of both. And yeah, Freddie’s designs are super cool. At least for the tmnt. I find his humans character sort of goofy looking, but I guess that’s just his style. |
If DC Eternia and DC Earth exist in the same universe, wouldn't that mean IDW mutants would revert on DC Eternia?
|
Quote:
Some of the DC MOTU stuff sold better than some of the IDW TMNT stuff, and I'm aware those terrible TMNT/Batman books sold well. All I can assume is that the MOTU/Thundercats and MOTU/Injustice cross-overs sold less than expected, otherwise they would've gone ahead with this. Those books were terrific, too; I have no idea what they sold but they were pretty much perfect. I'm only assuming they under-performed because this idea got scrapped. Quote:
All speculative, of course, but that's what I'd expect. |
Personally, I can hardly think of any crossovers of this nature I enjoy, beyond the art.
I think it's a combination of the fact that they usually have a very predictable structure, that can often be unsatisfying, and there also isn't always a lot of room to play between two franchises, because there is a lot of overhead/cooks in the kitchen. That said, even a basic premise can be executed beautifully with the right storyteller, so maybe there is no excuse. Robocop vs Termintor by Frank Miller & Walt Simonson proves it can be done. Batman vs Predator wasn't half bad either. I've always wanted to read the tmnt x flaming carrot stuff. That seems just stupid enough to work. |
I was not predicting Skeletor mixing Mumm-Ra's ashes into a potion and then drinking it, leading to Mumm-Ra taking partial control of Skeletor once his essence was inside his body, so if nothing else the MOTU/Thundercats cross-over proved that there are lots of ways to be "unpredictable" with these sort of things. :lol:
Regime Superman getting killed at the end of the MOTU/Injustice cross-over was pretty unexpected, as well (SPOILERS for a two+-year old comic, I guess?). He-Man wielding the Power of Shazam was epic. Both of those series were pretty much textbook examples on how to do these kinds of things properly. Lots of "Well of COURSE they would do that" type of fanservice moments with the Goofy Sh*t kept to the bare minimum (which as I understand it, was a huge problem in the TMNT/Batman books, which is why I haven't read them yet). All of my "Eh" about this potential idea comes from the TMNT side. Because while the Thundercats and Injustice books were mostly-serious (the fantastic Skeletor/Mumm-Ra banter notwithstanding), I can't see them resisting the urge to go full-on cornball with the TMNT stuff, because come cross-over time that's generally what happens. In any cross-over setting you have a bit of "Flanderization" on either side, but TMNT suffers more from that than most properties, simply because the worst aspects of TMNT are SO bad but at the same time it's the "iconic" stuff everyone remembers. The more I look at that sketch, though, the more I wish something had happened with this. Ah well. |
Yeah, I mostly skimmed Batman vs TMNT, after the first issue, but it did indeed end with the turtles and Batman eating pizza. I just can’t with that. I’m glad it makes some people smile, but it comes across as lazy, and worse, tired. It’s cliche. And it feels like a krutch for someone who doesn’t realize the turtles are more than pizza and Mikey saying something completely and utterly stupid.
And I guess those are the types of moments those books are about. I don’t think it has to be that way, but it usually is. And those books sold very well. So maybe sometimes it’s okay to let casual fans have those books if it props up sales and helps fund other, better books. |
With Williams providing the art it would have looked great if nothing else.
I've said this before but the first Batman/TMNT was surprisingly well done. It had it's goofy stuff like Michelangelo skateboarding in the Batcave and Batman being persuaded to eat pizza but it's largely kept in check. It even has some good character moments particularly Bruce taking Raphael to crime alley to show him his motivation to fight, The sequels...yeah they didn't aim to be anything other than Tynion mashing his Batman and Turtle figures together in comic form but the original is pretty solid. I imagine a TMNT/MOTU crossover wouldn't be all that different to any other story were the turtles go to an alien environment or barbarian-esque world. |
Skeletor could be very useful to me. A alien magician as powerful as him can kill all of my enenies! The turtles are not a threat for him because they are jsut mutant animals from earth. He will kill them in one second!
|
Freddie Williams gives an extensive explanation of the failed crossover on RagingBullets podcast:
https://ragingbullets.com/2021/07/12...ninja-turtles/ |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 08:50 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.