![]() |
In your opinion, what is the worst run on any TMNT comic?
With how bad IDW's run has been lately, I'm now curious. Do you think it's the worst run on a TMNT comic in general, or is it just bad in very specific ways? Is it worse than, say, TMNT Vol. 2? Any run is up for grabs. It's really just about which one you enjoyed the least in general, for whatever reason.
|
Oh, man, this is actually tough. I mean, both Mirage Vol. 4 (while being "pure" in the sense that at least it's the franchise creator's own personal vision) and the post-100 IDW run are about as far from what most TMNT fans would ever want to read as it gets, albeit from different directions. It's also tough to pick between them, since Vol. 4 will never have an ending and the current IDW run SEEMS like it's never going to end, so it's tough to grade either one of them "A-to-Z" since at present, neither of them has a "Z". They do both have a similar problem in that it takes dozens of issues for nothing of any importance to happen.
For me, they both scrape the bottom and are stuff I can't see myself looking at again. I also didn't care for the Image run back in the day, but I confess that it's been so long since I've looked at it my opinion may shift if I'm ever inclined to go back to it. Peoples' collective opinions on it seem to have softened; when I was new to the internet, the consensus seemed to be that it was among the worst TMNT material in existence, BUT to be fair at that time there wasn't a ton of TMNT media that was considered to be bad. So maybe people overreacted. I see a lot more people praising it Now than I ever did back Then. For my part, it seemed very, very "try-hard" back then, like it was going out of its way to be "edgy" and the antithesis of what TMNT had become. Which was perhaps necessary, but in reading it I could never shake the idea that the writers were rubbing their hands together and cackling with glee at the prospective reaction to things like the Turtles getting mutilated. Like shock value was the main drive behind it. Maybe it was, maybe it wasn't; I don't know, I'll give it another look one day now that it has an ending. I wouldn't call it a "run" but most of those guest artist issues of Mirage Vol. 1 were pretty damn brutal, too. I can't really cast a vote right now. I will say, I wish it was one of those polls that revealed who voted for what. I demand accountability so that I can continue to judge people based on their entertainment preferences. :trazz: Not at all shocked by what's currently in the "lead", though. :lol: |
For me, it's hard to choose. TMNT Vol. 2 is one of my least favorite comics in all of TMNT, but it's just a bad comic. Bad art, bad writing, and a nonsensical story that's rushed beyond belief. But at the end of the day, it's just a bad comic. The current IDW run has fine art, but it's bad in a very specific way that's representative of a definite push for a certain agenda, one that is incredibly pervasive in almost everything these days. So I hate the current IDW run more on principle, even if TMNT vol. 2 might be worse more on a more technical level. I suppose I have a more visceral reaction to IDW more on what it represents that what it is in this moment, but at the same time I've kind of built up an apathy to it and many other things, because I just don't have the energy to be pissed all the time. TMNT vol. 2 still really sucks, though.
Also, for the record, I know full well no one in their right mind would pick any of Mirage vol.1, beyond maybe the guest era, but I felt I had to include it in the name of fair play. |
I'm curious who picked the final "Other" option and what specifically they're referring to.
|
Interesting that IDW 101-present has the most votes. I haven't read it since like issue 50 but it was pretty good then. I voted Image Vol. 3 because at the time, I didn't care much for it. The art wasn't my cup of tea, and it seemed gimmicky. I could have a completely different opinion today though if I were to revisit.
|
Quote:
Alas, things have a habit of going south in a hurry. And historically-speaking, once a product (or company) enters a severe tailspin, it's nearly impossible to pull the nose up and save things. It just plain doesn't happen, most often. But yeah, IDW pre-100 and post-100 may as well not even be the same book, like 1997 WCW and 2000-2001 WCW may as well not have even been the same company. Aside from what it says on the header, there's like nothing in common between the "Pre-Crisis" and "Post-Crisis" versions of them. It's amazing how fast things can change. But, there it is. |
Well, the Sophie Campbell run annoys me, like a lot. It's perpetually stuck in a lame setting and doesn't even bother doing anything that would work within the setting. I can't say I liked the Image run or Volume 2 but at least things happened in those comics.
|
Strictly speaking for myself and my TMNT preferences which aren't necessarily popular across the board...
TMNT works best when the TMNT -- and the readers along with it -- are gobsmacked along a neverending taut rope of different experiences and genres. If it stays too long in any one -- even the urban ninja stuff that I love best -- then the wheels kind of come off. There is a certain whiplash of stuff in those first 11 issues of Mirage vol. 1 and even some of what came after that seemed like a great formula. It was always fresh, things never outstayed their welcome and it always eventually touched back on the ground for air. Yes, yes. "But where's Beebop and the Technodrome and tons of mutants, always?!" (in the early Vol. 4 days or even Vol. 3 it was a bunch of people demanding "why can't we get that stuff in Mirage?! It's so unfair!" with Peter swatting them away, not wrong) And then I just sort of tune out. Defeats the whole premise, IMHO. Different people like radically different things in TMNT. I can sit here and say that their isolation and uniqueness and tragedy is creatively the most interesting thing to me... and then guess what? 20 people will just say "nice story, bro," but that they're most looking forward to seeing the same 15 mutants from toys and the old cartoon coming back in some way. Who's wrong? I dunno. |
I have to admit I have voted for the recent run of IDW but that is based purely off the fact that half of the options I haven't read. So have no opinion. And the recent IDW is fresh in my head. Well I say fresh, I haven't actually read it, but I can see I don't need to from the previews and what others have said.
One thing I would say, for IDW to turn things around. I know they will have some road map laid out, but it would be nice for the TMNT to venture outside of the US, for some reason or another. First port of call would be Japan for me. A clash with the Japanese branch of the foot we hear so much about, yakuza etc. Perhaps it's happened in past iterations and I missed it. But would be cool. Europe would be nice, but recent history suggests those in charge of the franchise don't give a flip about anything or anyone outside the US. |
Bit of a pointless poll considering how biased this place is.
|
Soft core furries porn is got to be the lowest ANY series has ever sunk... Everyone needs to be fired post-haste.
I own all of the Mirage/Image stuff and have actually re-read a bunch of it as I pick up extra copies and whatnot. Vol 2 and vol 4 both have their downsides as well as the v1 guest era, but even the worst of that stands up better than IDW as a whole. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
How dare they. They ought'a just smile at that TMNT sticker and say "Yep, it's all good." Like good little consumerist sheep. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
It might be a bit more topical Right Now given how the reaction to IDW post-100 has gone, but there's never exactly been a bad time to discuss it. Quote:
|
The April 'O Neil spin-offs in the Archie comics felt kind of unnecessary to me. I mean what was the point of her going off on her own adventures? She does better as an ally of the Turtles. Now Casey Jones on the other hand, I could see him having his own spin-off but of course he never appeared in the Archie comics for whatever reason.
|
Haven’t gotten around to binging a re-read of post-100. Can’t really compare binging a series to one you read monthly. It’s two totally different styles. But out of the stuff I have bigger. Definitely 2k3 comics.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
And Mirage Vol. 2 doesn't really feel fair to judge as it got truncated before it was even able to go anywhere substantial. I consider it kind of "Vol. 4: the prologue" in a way. |
Yeah I don't know why people are bringing up short mini-series or comics canceled before their time. There's always short mini-series that are lackluster, that has nothing to do with a long ongoing run of a comic.
|
Quote:
Technically speaking, yes. In terms of just pure quality, some random Archie side-book, an incoherent guest story or Dreamwave's bizarre attempt to make a 4Kids tie-in book is probably worse overall than this current run. But they aren't really worth talking about here because they were never meant to be the primary book in the first place, or if they were then they didn't last long enough to be worth thinking of them as such. This run has lasted for for near damn two years, it sucked from day one and still sucks now. I don't think any other TMNT book has lasted this long while sucking this hard. |
If nothing else, it's interesting to see how many apologists for the current run have taken their ball and gone home, so to speak. Not altogether surprising, just interesting.
And yeah, that Dreamwave series was pretty awful. Although didn't the first couple issues do okay, sales-wise? I seem to remember the reaction to that book being much more positively received than Vol. 4 was, at least in the very beginning. Perhaps it's a bit unfair to rate various mini-series as "runs", but... eh. I don't see any harm in someone pointing out their badness. Some of them were so bad they deserve to be commented on. As I've said earlier... there's an unfortunately large number of bad TMNT comics. All for different reasons, too. I remember as a kid, I was almost always pretty sated by the ongoing TMNTA run, but I found most of the one-shots and Annuals to be pretty lousy, even then. |
I kind of like them all at different points. I suppose the early Archie books are pretty dry, but later on they were awesome.
|
Honestly? Dream wave is just boring. And that is really the biggest sin you can commit. I mean at least in something “bad” there is something there to latch onto. But dreamwave just doesn’t have that.
Also I forgot the comics based on the 2012 turtles… I yeah, those are bad. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Quote:
Sometimes I worry about you, Andrew. |
A week after this poll was created, I find it fascinating (in a good way) that Adventures seems to be the most consensual of all TMNT comics.
Or at least the one with fewer duds. |
Quote:
|
To be honest, it's not so much the stories themselves but the artwork which puts me off from some of the Mirage and Archies series.
https://static.comicvine.com/uploads...ch_sitting.jpg https://i.pinimg.com/originals/b3/6d...a6b8cf4c8e.jpg Jim Lawson's art is an acquired taste, the stories he illustrated are awesome but sometimes it looks like he just phoned it in. |
I don't think Mutant Town is the worst, but it doesn't really feel like TMNT. Or rather, it feels like a mix of TMNT and Omaha: The Cat Dancer.
I'd say the worst is some of the Mirage guest issues where the writers didn't know anything about the characters, or any of the reimaginings of the cartoons e.g. early Archie, Dreamwave (which had great art but WTF)... or Donatello in the jungle (Mirage 4) which just got boring. Peter Laird had a lot of integrity but couldn't keep his story moving. |
Quote:
I don't know, man. I've just never loved "stylized" art. And his is pretty stylized, too much for my tastes. People have different faces... he draws ONE face and uses it for everyone. April and Casey are often only discernible from each other from the neck-up by hairstyle. Mouths don't actually look like Spaghetti-Os, I'm not sure if anyone ever told him this. Muscles do not have sharp, pointy, right-angle edges on them. And so forth and so on. Some people love it. But I confess, I will never, ever, EVER understand it. He also completely no-sold and ignored me when I PM'ed him and offered an apology for some of the nastier things I've said over the years. So whatever, it's rescinded. :trazz: |
Not a fan of "I hate this the most polls", I think ranking would be better, but whatever, not my poll :)
I don't get why people are hating on Volume 2. That series had a really cool vibe to it, story wise it gets into everything I liked about V1. The art is really cool too. Lawson pencils with Talbot inks, and covers from E and L! Hell Yeah! I can't really say what series I didn't like, honestly, I bet there's something redeeming about all of them in some way. I still don't get the ripping on Lawson either. It always seems like people go out of their way to hate on artists they don't like. You're not going to like every artist that draws TMNT. This goes for all art too. So many people hate bands, and its like why even listen to them or talk about them. Imagine going to a restaurant, not liking it, but talking about it for the next 20 years. We get it, you don't like their food. With Lawson, clearly his art has an impact on you, and his style is immediately recognizable to you too. Would you rather a generic artist that doesn't have any style at all? |
Nah, I pretty much only ever rip on Lawson and Liefeld.
There's tons of comic book artists I don't like, for whatever reason. But those are the only two where I've ever been thrown for a loop that they actually get paid for what they do. Thus, why they're the only two I really ever bother to comment on. There's "This just isn't for me," but at some point, there's also, "I just can't even believe this is real." That's where I'm at with those two. Although Liefeld has shown SOME improvement over the years, whereas it can be argued (and has been, by many people who aren't me) that Lawson actually regressed quite a bit as time went on. As for what kind of art I'd prefer for TMNT... my answer to that would basically be, "Just about anyone else who ever worked on it." Just being honest. I mean, you can have a "style" and be "memorable" but still have your art look like... what it's supposed to look like. Freddie Williams II, for example, is fairly "stylized" in a manner of speaking, but it doesn't look like something a kid hastily scrawled on their notebook during study hall. He's done some TMNT stuff, and I'd gladly take that kind of thing every day forever. Ed McGuinness is another guy who does "Stylized" art that's still pretty good, and also "memorable" and "impactful". I certainly have been "impacted" by Lawson's TMNT art. But mostly in the sense of, every time I see it, I wish I was looking at something else. I'd rather be impacted in a positive way. I am aware that, within the TMNT fandom, this is a highly unpopular opinion. I am also aware, however, that outside of the "TMNT fandom", it IS a fairly popular opinion. There has always been a strong consensus among the various comic shop owners I've spoken to, for example, that the TMNT books he draws do not sell very well in part because they are not pleasing to look at. From their perspective, his artwork effects their bottom line because people would pick up the books, say "Damn, this is ugly," and put it down. What I have always, always heard, is that "People want to buy a TMNT comic, but not one that isn't pleasing to look at. If they don't like the art, they don't buy the book." To be fair, the fact that most of the TMNT comics he's drawn were black and white did not help, as that definitely ruined sales as well, over the years. And granted, this is all anecdotal. But it's always been a prevalent sentiment in my state, and I do not live in a vacuum, thus I am willing to assume that it has been the case elsewhere as well, probably exponentially. Anyway, the other dude brought him up. I just jumped on. :trazz: |
I'm actually surprised that no one has picked Volume 2. It's not that it started out bad, it's just that it ended up going nowhere due to outside elements, resulting in a story that wastes all of it's potential, throwing a brick onto the accelerator and then exploading against a brick wall at the end.
Regarding Jim Lawson, I pretty much feel the same way. His art is by no means the worst art I've ever seen, but it really does not look like what I would expect from professional art. I genuinely don't get it. I much prefer his art back in the earlier parts of Volume 1 and City at War, but then starting with Volume 2 he started drawing in his weird angular style. It actually looked fine at the beginning. Same with The first issues of Volume 4. His art is vastly improved by the right inking. But then the inking at the end really did it no favors. His style actually works very well when drawing nature and non-human creatures, but pretty much any humanoid always looks weird. I prefer basically every other artist in TMNT to him, but I've developed a callus to his more modern style because, like it or not, he has drawn the most issues out of anyone, and if I want to read those stories, I have to look at his art. And honestly, like I said, it's not the worst thing I've seen. I'm there for the story anyways, so eventually it just got to a point where it didn't even phase me anymore. But I do think it's strange. |
I think the issue with volume 2 is that it’s forgettable. I have to remind myself “oh yeah, that’s the story where Baxter is killed” which honestly is about the same fanfare as the turtles realize they killed him.
|
But again, pointing to Volume 2 as anything seems like weak sauce. You can't compare it to Vol. 1 or even 3 or 4 to any extent. It's 13 issues that were just beginning to go somewhere in a very decompressed storyline before they had to stop and truncate things very suddenly.
|
Quote:
I know I shouldn't call the kettle black as my own TMNT fancomic "The Full eighty Percent" has people calling me "Zoomer" and telling me "Learn to draw." Fact is that I enjoy doing the comic, which is why I keep working on it. https://images-wixmp-ed30a86b8c4ca88...TcxcUo98hrnw3k But much like Lawson, people DO know it's me when they see it. |
Quote:
|
Then explain to me how it has a beginning a middle and an end in any sort of true narrative manner. It began with the Turtles askew post-CAW and ended with... eh, a Louis Braunze subplot that sort of just ended with the discontinuation of the volume because of reasons outside of people's control?
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 08:18 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.