![]() |
Do you think IDW TMNT will reach issue 200?
We're 125 issues in right now, so I assume they have at least a plan to issue 150 which is another 25 issues. We already know Waltz has the Armaggeddon war planned with the major villains as the next big arc. Beyond that, what do you think?
|
Yes. I think they will make it to 200. Maybe well beyond that. TMNT will always have vast potential, it just needs to be properly harnessed. And that is possible.
Now, dose that mean every issue will speak to everyone? Of course not. Nothing dose. But that certainly doesn't mean it won't be enjoyable or have merit. Only time will tell. |
If it keeps going like the last 25 issues, I hope the hell not. More doesn't mean better...
|
If things stay the same as in 101-124, then no.
If future issues follow 125's lead, then yes. Definitely. This poll needs a "Maybe" option. |
Quote:
I agree with the sentiment though. 101-124 were pretty weak. I have not read beyond that yet. I’d love to see the series go on well past 200, but only if the story and art is as engaging as issues 1-100 were. I’d say no, it won’t make it to 200…but I’d love to be wrong. |
Another thing to consider is that IDW is losing their woke G.I. Joe and Transformers franchises. The TMNT book has a lot of woke $#!( in it, but TMNT fans might be more accepting of those themes. But patterns like that are something to consider.
Either way though, 200 contiguous issues of a series is a hell of a feet nowadays. Off the top of my head the only other I.P.'s doing it without relaunches or "fad #1's" have been Spawn and Savage Dragon and Savage Dragon is literally a money pit for Larsen - he pays to keep it going. Even if IDW TMNT "only" makes it to 150, that's a a respectable run. Although people need to realize that all sales on these books are way artificially inflated nowadays. For example, there's a big difference between selling 30,000 copies a month to 30,000 readers and selling 30,000 copies with variants a month to 13,500 die-hards who buy everything. TMNT #1 debuted in August 2011 in the top 50 (it was 48th) with 34,800 copies TMNT #50 from October 2015 placed 67th in the top 100 and that was an anniversary issue. It distributed 33,553 copies. For perspective, issue 90 in January 2019 saw 9,805 copies distributed and was at 189 on the sales lists for that month. Issue 100, an anniversary issue gave the title a small sales boost for a while. Anniversary issues tend to do that, so it's not a true readership victory, unfortunately. Issue 101 distributed 20,470 copies. But those bumps do help push a title forward for another year or whatnot. 102 saw 13,780 copies. That's 13,780 copies with cover and ratio variants, and that drop came a month after a 20,470 copy order of issue 101. Don't think for a second that 13,780 individual people are buying the IDW book monthly. It just doesn't work that way. 104 fluctuated back up closer to 15,000 copies. Keep in mind that those issues were riding the high of the whole woke push and the orchestrated Jennika thing which got YouTuber attention as hype too. So what it boils down to is that IDW is either making the smallest of profits from their woke TMNT book and clinging onto it for dear life, or more likely the ongoing is just another carrot in the greater soup of their TMNT publications (mini-series, one-shots, reprints, trades, etc) that as a whole they push the I.P. into profitability. My guess is that the monthly books don't make a lot of money, but the trades and reprints have kept IDW firmly in TMNT. And there's nothing wrong with using the whole meal to create the profitability if that's what is happening. I think though that it wouldn't be unfair to say that IDW has been definitely used "event content" for sales hype. I don't know that the book would've made it this far simply on firm storytelling as opposed to politicized "zeitgeist" hype-content. |
At the very least it will be cancelled and relaunched with a new #1 long before then. They haven't done that trick yet, but it's still in their back pocket if need be.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I think if the series ends it'll be either because Viacom/Nick seems they can get more sales with the license for another company, or IDW as a whole goes bankrupt. I don't see them ending the current run just to restart at #1...at that point Viacom might as well see what either Dark Horse or someone else can do with the license rather than sticking with IDW for another few years. It'll be a sure sign the IDW series had run its course.
|
Quote:
Even if IDW TMNT sells 50,000 copies every month, 50,000 viewers of a cartoon or 50,000 people buying a toy is nothing to Nick. They're not going to -- largely -- care about that. That's just a drop in a bucket. The kind of "moves" Nick makes with TMNT, they need millions of people to make a difference. And I don't mean that in a negative way, I mean that in a pragmatic way. |
I would hope that if the series can get much better and stay better for at least, let's say 10-15, issues without another drastic drop in quality afterward we would get to 200. But if no such improvement happens then it might as well end at around 140 with a hasty wrap up of all the major plot threads, which would be about the best thing to hope for. Though, hilariously the quickest wrap up I could think of would be a sudden reveal that the EPF had an anti-mutagen bomb ready to go, the Utroms/Triceratons are relocated to some other vacant planet, Null goes out of business due to a market crash so she can no longer prepare Earth for invasion and whatever focus left goes to whatever was going to happen with the Rat King. It wouldn't be elegant but it would at least wrap it up. Of course, if the series does get better, then just let it breathe. The only thing I just want to wrap up yesterday is Mutant Town, the inclusion of it was a giant mistake from the start and I'm just so tired of it.
As for whether or not it will get to 200 issues isn't dependent on me or any other single person liking the direction, it depends on how long IDW can justify an ongoing. Even if an ongoing stops being lucrative, IDW may still find reason to publish 4-5 issues every year just to keep the license. Quote:
That said of course, there are still many problems with 125, much of it feels rather sudden/random and much of what's going on actually seems rather awkward. But if I were to sum of up the improvements in one sentence it would be this: "It's not boring and I can see interesting stuff coming". The biggest problem with 101-124 is that almost nothing happened, there were other problems too and some of those are still present here, but least things are happening in 125. They could of course still be things that suck down the line but least it is something. And as for Campbell's pen... I have to admit that I suspect 125 was at least partially ghost written and that's why it's an improvement. Apart from the pages about the Dojo and the Punk Frogs, the writing style doesn't match Campbell at all and even those pages are much more compressed than what she usually makes. While this possible ghost writer might be someone who hasn't worked on a TMNT book before, I suspect it might be Waltz because he has "Story Consulting" credit (which admittedly he has had since 101), the fact that he is coming back for the FCBD issue, wrote the last two annuals and may actually be coming back to write the book fairly soon. If not Waltz, then maybe Allor or Burnham since they wrote many of the minis. The alternative to there being a ghost writer is that Campbell came to terms with her flaws as a writer, took a writing class and drastically changed her style immediately, which is technically possible but I doubt is the case because of how quickly it must have happened. And if it is true that 125 is indeed ghost written, then the next few issues credited to her may be as well, in which case her run is already over in all but the official sense. Quote:
Since they don't have to worry too much about something working out in that format, it's always good if IDW does end up hatching a gem of an idea they can put into movies/cartoons/toylines, duds can just be ignored. Admittedly, the IDW ideas that have made it into other media are elements of character design, the revised origin in which the Turtles are intentional lab experiments and an in-name-only version of Alopex, but that would still be something. |
Quote:
Naturally, IDW wouldn't throw her under the bus by admitting there's a ghost writer involved, but it appears that they finally noticed the writing (heh) on the wall (double heh) and went into damage control mode, trying to spin her run into something worthwhile at the very end. And it does seem to be the end for her. Whether the ghost writer is Tom or not, the next few issues should tie into the big event later this year which we all know will be handled by him, so there's no more room left for woke, furry fanfiction. As the song goes, "Ding, dong..." |
Hate to burst people's bubbles but I've spoken with Sophie and she not only confirmed that #125 was written by her but that she's staying onboard for the forseeable future. You can complain all you want but Sophie isn't leaving anytime soon.
|
Quote:
The reason we think this was ghost written is that it does not match her writing style, like at all. Issues 101-123 are very similar in the sense that they use very decompressed storytelling, heavy on dialogue without direct plot relevance, long montages and generally avoids subplots. After that we got 124 which intentionally leaves out word balloons and text boxes as a break between these two issues. Then we 125 which is drastically different in style, using at least three different plots and managing to get the point across much quicker. Technically, it is possible that Sophie wrote all of this herself, it could be true. The problem is that would require me to accept that a writer completely overhauled the style she had been going with for 23 issues over night. Telling me I should just stop being suspicious because she said she said she didn't use a ghost writer, something that you naturally would deny doing regardless of whether it's true or not... That is to insult my intelligence. |
Quote:
2. Professional writers are often capable of writing in a variety of styles and even other writers of this very series have done just that; compare the City Fall and Northampton arcs both of which were co-written by Kevin, Tom and Bobby. 3. You're insulting your own intelligence by behaving like conspiracy-theory nutjobs and believing in an idiotic unfounded assumption based upon zero factual evidence. |
Are we sure Potato Joe was referring to Peter Doocy? I mean, it fits Campbellistas so well...
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
As for professional writers being able to write in multiple different styles, this is true but the example you brought up is nowhere as noticeable of a change as this. The pacing throughout Waltz run is fairly consistent and there are several key features of his writing you could use to identify him as the writer even if you don't know for sure it's him. Not to mention that Northampton and City at War were part of the same larger story with the same writer and if you read all the way through, you can see how one slowly transitions into the other. Likewise, there are several features of Campbell's writing consistent throughout the first 23 issue of her run and 125 is a very sudden change. Are really not able to notice what a massive departure 125 is from the rest of Campbell's run? Technically yes, there is no factual proof that Campbell wasn't the sole writer on 125 as is the official credit, but if you have the slightest ability to analyse the content you'd notice the whiplash here. Why would the same exact writer do the same thing for two years straight and then completely change nearly all of her stylistic choices in a single issue? Of course I can't say for absolute certainty that was a ghost writer involved, it's the sort of thing we're not meant know but we can infer it. |
Quote:
Ghostwriting in fiction is usually done to the effect that multiple writers are used to create a bulk of content that is all largely in the same style, tone and patterns. Having it be in completely different style and tone would defeat the purpose having a ghostwriter. |
Quote:
|
I don't think IDW is going to exist in 6 years.
They've been selling (their entire tourism arm) and closing business units (they left the board game industry) non-stop the last few years just to stay afloat. There has been so much turnover in their leadership the last two years - too many people are leaving for it to be a good sign. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I hope so. I haven't read the book in ages, but I love that they are keeping the train going. Whether or not I hop back on, I love that it's one of the few comics that has kept it's numbering.
|
If it keeps going the way it's been going, along with IDW in general, probably not. I'd love it if it did, or it least I would have 2 years ago. Now, I'm kind of split between wanting it to just die already so we can stop dealing with all this woke crap, and not wanting it to end because it would annoy me if there was no ending, on top of the slim hope that it might recover. But I feel like I know better at this point than to hope for something like that.
|
Jesus. Every time one of the Tumblristas who make up the "brand new audience" for Campbell's TMNT run pipes up, it only reaffirms my position that this fanbase needs a LOT more elitism and gatekeeping, not less.
|
Quote:
and the 'woke/ sjw' nonsense everyone keeps peddling isn't going anywhere; all media follows the current trends of what is popular to get them the biggest audience to make them the most money and if it means being 'woke' or including 'sjw' stuff then that's what they'll do. |
Sophie Campbell does have a history of writing a certain way. I know that I have been able to pick out her issues that she was leading up before she took over on 100, and that she continued into 124. Its possible that she had a ghost writer or someone working with her to set things up in 125. Its also possible that there were barriers stopping her from writing certain things that have been moved out of the way because of staffing changes.
All of that is possible. Regardless of that, 125 is in her name. Its a solid issue, and probably the best one that we have had since 100. New plots here hatched, Casey Jones is acting like a badass again, a new plot that feels like it might belong in both the TMNT we want and Mutant Town is starting. Im not going to bitch about it. Thank you for a good issue, Sophie! |
Quote:
It was said long ago that Sophie was restricted in what she was allowed to write by those above her - she wanted Raph to take out Hob's good eye remember? Like Andrew said, people on here have got seriously short memories or permanent blinkers on and these same people need to accept that not everything right or wrong about the series lies at Sophie's feet. |
Campbell's also a notorious liar but I'm sure that's just incidental.
|
Quote:
But then you do have quite the reputation for spouting nonsense that has no basis in reality or factual backing so there's nothing new there then. |
How cute. It speaks at me. It thinks it's people. :lol:
|
Quote:
What the real f?!? :lol::lol::lol: |
I think messing with triggered1 is gonna be my new full-time forum position.
I can tell from the posting style they're either a woman OR a man-bun wearing soy-boy, and in either case those simply aren't people you speak to with respect. Just as a general rule. It will learn. It will learn the hard way, if necessary. |
Quote:
|
Nope. Real-life people recognize it as a marketing trend, same as any other. It's an unfortunate side-effect of the fact that nowadays you get tons more word-of-mouth from a Tweet than you would with a commercial. As such, companies think that it's "good business" to pander to the interests of people who spend all their time online... Which, as it turns out, are predominantly overweight, rainbow-haired, perpetually-offended, sexually-confused, easily-triggered, Gender Studies Majors and other (barely) high-functioning social misfits.
That's who's online all the time, sharing Tweets and memes and "making themselves heard", and so in turn, companies feel forced to pander to them. Because it SEEMS like there's a lot of them, but the thing is, they're just incredibly loud. As we see in Real Life by how most "woke"-infested movies fail hard, the growing number of lawsuits nationwide to stop letting schools indoctrinate impressionable kids with their nonsense, and the fact that people really, REALLY love Chick-Fil-A, MOST people are definitely NOT on the bandwagon. Companies are slowly coming around to this. By now they've figured out that most of these people don't have real jobs and are barely scraping by under the crushing debt of their Liberal Arts degrees, and so in turn it makes no sense to bend over for them. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:21 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.