![]() |
Why do theatrical/live-action Splinters always start out as rats?
So here is some concept art of the upcoming animated TMNT movie.
Spoiler:
As you can see, it clearly depicts a pre-mutated Splinter having started out as a rat. Because of the previously leaked concept art... Looked... I was worried Splinter was going to start out as a human being for this movie, so at least one of these pieces of concept art eased my worries, albeit in a minor way. But this did get me thinking, all the movie Splinters have started out as rats, haven't they? Not counting direct sequels (as they just naturally follow continuity), this means four out of four movie Splinters started out as rats, 100%. Why do you think that is? |
If we count 2007 tmnt as a sequel to the live action trilogy which I do, then that only makes three out of three Splinters start out as rats. Unless I'm missing something, and Splinter's origin is stated in Batman vs tmnt film.
The reason in the 1990 film is because they were trying to base it off Mirage, while with 2014, my best guess is that they wanted to make Splinter as April's pet, and a lab rat. As for this film, I'm thinking that it has something to with the nature of the ooze. Based on the cannister in the picture having Hazardous Waste and Radioactive Material labels, the ooze seems to be manufactured in a company that employs people, and has rules and regulations in place to keep the ooze from affecting them. This leads me to think that the Ooze is from the Utroms in TCRI (or a science experiment like the second Henson film), since the above versions treat the Oooze as a growth agent, and not as something that Utroms/scientists intentionally expose people to. This is unlike the uses of Mutagen by the villains in the 1987, 2012 and Rise cartoons, where they would have less reason to label the Mutagen as a hazard. |
Quote:
And after "because" you write the reason you think they had for making that decision. Remember, the 1990 movie still made April a reporter for some reason. Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Because that's always been his origin, for the most part/
Now if you're saying "Well, why don't they skip the origin?" then yeah, you can argue it's been done too much...but if they're going to do it, they should do it right and this version is the most widely accepted, as far as im aware. |
Quote:
Yeah, you see things like the giant whale in that concept art. The giant whale wasn't mixed with another animal or anything. |
Quote:
https://i.redd.it/5ljc9hfvv9i81.jpg |
Didn't pay much attention to the, uh, whale (why is there a whale?) in the background before... but does it have limbs made of kelp? If contact influenced mutation is somehow dumb, kelp limbs makes no more sense than the car in 2012.
Can't decide if the squid is part of it or just a companion...that doubles as "hair"? As far as the rat origin goes... I just assume it's 30% because that is the original and 70% because using an animal is easier and using a human Yoshi-turned-Splinter requires more legwork and thought to make the loss of humanity and a whole prior life matter. A rat is easier because a caged rat's backstory is limited and simple. There are the events that led to the rat ending up in NYC and mourning for his owner, but you don't have to deal with all the human stuff of a former human life and making the audience care about that and connect to him. For a movie... I guess it's understandable to go the simpler rat option given the time restraint. Though I personally prefer Yoshi being Splinter and would love to see a set of decent films someday that have the time to deal with that go that angle. |
Coulda been worse. Coulda been like in the Bayfilms where it mutate people based on whatever animal DNA they had in their body.... somehow? Cause we evolved from all sorts of different animals?
|
That part just kills me... but like in a laughing kind of way, because it sounds like it's written by someone who has absolutely ZERO knowledge about evolution. Like a creationist was given the task of tackling evolution for a screenplay. :tlol:
Baxter could have simply stated that they were going to use DNA from those animals and that would have been given a pass -- because at least you could try to tamper with DNA like that, even if real life would not produce those results -- but instead they had to come up with something weird that the mind dismisses immediately and breaks immersion. |
Quote:
The only way that makes any sense is if Bebop and Rocksteady's granny liked to get freaky when visiting the zoo. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
These guys look like they would get killed from slipping on a banana peel. Quote:
|
Donatello having glasses is so awful and feels like a dated 1980's stereotype. I can't believe in the 2020's they still think the "smart one" has to look like a nerd or wear glasses. This is like a 40+ year old stereotype and I can't even imagine why any modern writer/director would think this is a good thing.
Most smart characters in fiction these days don't even wear glasses. Like how is this still a thing in the modern world of 2020+? Did I time travel back to 1981? |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
I find it less insulting as a fan and more insulting as someone who wears them that Hollywood doesn't feel that the "cool" people can ever have them. Not that Donnie isn't cool, but since they keep digging deeper on the "nerd" stereotype with it...
If film makers feel they must give a Turtle glasses, I'd rather someone be original and have one of the other three briefly whip out a pair of reading glasses at the lair. (Though that makes more sense for Turtles who are allowed to be older and not stuck in having to focus on the "teenage" part of the title.) |
Quote:
|
I love how the New Guy claims to have lurked here forever, and yet comes right in the door asking us to express ourselves in a reasonable and non-hyperbolic fashion. :lol: "Do you even Technodrome, bro???" This place is like the f*cking Mos Eisley Cantina except everybody's way more surly (and some are way more drunk).
And giving Donnie glasses may not in and of itself be "a hate crime". But the BayTurtles design, which gave birth to the whole idea... yeah, those designs (and those movies) WERE in fact a hate crime. To disagree is to simply be wrong. That sh*t was assault and I'm still waiting on reparations. |
Has he asked us to express ourselves? I thought he was just trying to get us to embrace all things turtles regardless if they're good or bad. I wasn't paying much attention.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
Seth Rogen has had his hand in teenage films and most recently did that Good Boys movie before he was announced for this project and based on these designs, it's very apparent they're playing up that ONE aspect, which is stupid because they're not normal teenagers and never were. Just because real teenagers wear glasses, have braces, and look awkward doesn't mean MUTANT TURTLES who were trained to be NINJAS their whole lives would display the same characteristics as a normal human teenager raised in a normal society. The turtles are athletic by the very nature of their training and also disciplined. Yes, they can act a fool, but physically and mentally, they'd be way ahead of your average teenagers. |
Good Boys was hysterical. But that doesn't mean a TMNT anything should be that.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
The turtles don't coexist with other teenagers and have to worry about being popular or whatever. They've been trained since birth to be ninja masters to either kill shredder, self defense or whatever. They don't live a regular human life. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
The Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles are mutant turtles, they are fundamentally not human beings, the teenage part only refers to their chronological age being between 13 and 19. Expecting them to be like humans aged 13 to 19, when their biological maturation rate is inherently a mystery, is nonsense. |
"buT wE NeED tO SeE OuRSelVeS rEpREsEntEd iN tHe mATeriAl! hOw cAn wE EveR rELATe tO tHeSe FiCTioNal cHArActeRs uNlEss tHey aRe ExACtlY LiKe uS?!1!?!"
|
There is no logic for Yoshi to mutated into a rat as the same time as the turtles. The turtles mutant's origin is contrived when Splinter is Yoshi.
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:31 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.