The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   TMNT Compendium HC for Sept. but no #8? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=64914)

DK2 04-19-2022 08:53 PM

TMNT Compendium HC for Sept. but no #8?
 
Theres a TMNT Compendium hardcover thats listed for September now on the amazons and other book sites sources. Its the Mirage stuff: #1-7, 9-14, the 5 micro issues (includes Fugitoid) and Tales Vol. 1 #1-5. Its at 832 pages if I recall. But the obvious omission is issue 8. How can that be a problem as Dave Sim hasn't had any issues about it and last I knew IDW always gave him a small check for that issue. All I know is it never had one of those "color classics" issues reprints back then. But it is in the "ultimate collections" line. Confused has things changed on the TMNT #8 now? Always wondered if we'd ever see a big tome of any sort and I guess this is it. It it right to include Tales' 5 issues and Fugitiod and omit #8?

Roseangelo 04-19-2022 11:21 PM

I think it's always been a gray area, because while he never has had a problem with the book being reprinted, I think it can be a problem with getting him to explicitly say that "you have permission to reprint the book," and that is probably what IDW wants.

But I'm just guessing.

DK2 04-24-2022 11:44 PM

Well, I posted to IDW this question on their facebook page. Lets see what they say. To me its gonna be incomplete and I don't think it should come out without it. Its not really a compendium without TMNT #8 IMO.

mrmaczaps 04-25-2022 09:51 AM

Issue 8 is kind of irrelevant to the storyline contained in the other issues of this run... so its not super important and relatively cheap enough to pick up on its own. I can sell you a copy. I think I have 2 extras and one is signed by Steve Lavigne. I mean, it would be great to have all of the OG Mirage run reprinted in this format but I'm not going to lose sleep over the Guest Era stuff being skipped or issue 8.

Andrew NDB 04-25-2022 11:15 AM

The introduction of Renet and Savanti Romero is irrelevant to the run? Huh?

oldmanwinters 04-25-2022 11:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roseangelo (Post 1927345)
I think it's always been a gray area, because while he never has had a problem with the book being reprinted, I think it can be a problem with getting him to explicitly say that "you have permission to reprint the book," and that is probably what IDW wants.

But I'm just guessing.

Definitely sounds like covering their legal bases. It's one thing when Eastman and/or Laird has a verbal blessing to use the character, but that ain't how big corporations role. The spectre of Ken Penders vs. Archie/SEGA should teach everybody that lesson.

Sharman 04-27-2022 07:40 AM

Interesting to note that Dave Sim is listed on the cover, though. Of course, this is subject to change but I wonder if IDW thought they could reprint initially only to discover not?
https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon....1Ir-IiwRTL.jpg
I'm assuming also that these are B&W/Duo tone reprints?

Mewzard 04-27-2022 11:50 AM

Well, it would suck if Issue 8 wasn't included, but I do like the idea of larger hardcovers collection the whole of Mirage, including Tales and such.

CyberCubed 04-27-2022 04:47 PM

I don't even understand what the point of this is? They already released all these issues in black and white in the Ultimate collections. This is just the same thing again.

neatoman 04-27-2022 06:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1928024)
I don't even understand what the point of this is? They already released all these issues in black and white in the Ultimate collections. This is just the same thing again.

This one includes the Fugitoid one-shot (which IDW previously only printed in the Utrom Empire trade for some strange reason) and Tales was only reprinted in color.

DK2 04-27-2022 08:12 PM

Never got a response from idw's Facebook. Even seemed to have removed my posted inquiry.
Also to the previous poster, why do these huge omni books? It's been the norm for comics to get that huge book treatment. So I'm not surprised with this but to not have #8 isn't making it complete at all of the Eastman/Laird material.

DrSpengler 04-27-2022 08:21 PM

Dave Sim is planning on releasing his own remastered version of TMNT #8 in 2023 and is currently releasing those Pieces of Turtles 8 fanzines via Kickstarter as a lead-up to it. Maybe he didn't give permission (or couldn't give permission?) because doing so would interfere with his reprinting plans for the comic? Just a guess.

Coola Yagami 04-27-2022 08:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by drspengler (Post 1928050)
dave sim is planning on releasing his own remastered version of tmnt #8 in 2023 and is currently releasing those pieces of turtles 8 fanzines via kickstarter as a lead-up to it. Maybe he didn't give permission (or couldn't give permission?) because doing so would interfere with his reprinting plans for the comic? Just a guess.

SPENGLER LIVES!!!!!!!

caps

hypered1 04-27-2022 08:32 PM

As I mentioned in the release dates thread when this was first announced about six weeks ago the original solicitation stated the inclusion of Volume 1 issues 1 - 15 but within hours of the original post the listing changed to remove issues 8 and 15.
It is frustrating that a concise collection of the Mirage volumes still seems to be stuck behind the legal quagmires of the guest issues.

King Suck 04-27-2022 09:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1928050)
Dave Sim is planning on releasing his own remastered version of TMNT #8 in 2023 and is currently releasing those Pieces of Turtles 8 fanzines via Kickstarter as a lead-up to it. Maybe he didn't give permission (or couldn't give permission?) because doing so would interfere with his reprinting plans for the comic? Just a guess.

I wasnt aware of this. Do you happen to have a link for that kickstarter? My googlefu is weak.

DrSpengler 04-28-2022 09:57 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by King Suck (Post 1928059)
I wasnt aware of this. Do you happen to have a link for that kickstarter? My googlefu is weak.

The Kickstarter for Pieces of Turtles 8 ended a few weeks ago, unfortunately:

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects...s-of-turtles-8

But Sim said he was going to do a second and possibly a third installment in the Pieces series, so he may reprint issue 1 when he does the followups (or combine all of them into a Behind the Scenes compendium, perhaps).

Sharman 05-03-2022 12:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1928093)
The Kickstarter for Pieces of Turtles 8 ended a few weeks ago, unfortunately:

https://www.kickstarter.com/projects...s-of-turtles-8

But Sim said he was going to do a second and possibly a third installment in the Pieces series, so he may reprint issue 1 when he does the followups (or combine all of them into a Behind the Scenes compendium, perhaps).

Sad to have missed this but interested in the completed project ...

neatoman 05-14-2022 08:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by elgarlic (Post 1930223)
Are there any known rights issues for #15? If not, maybe they're just adjusting where the boundaries are between sets.

It would be nice if they could work something out with Sim for 8, but it seems like poor timing for that.

15 is the Justice Force one, so no.

rs_jr 05-29-2022 06:34 PM

Always wanted a nice oversized ( magazine sized) hardcovers in black and white collecting all the mirage stories ( including tales, short stories, turtle soup...) all in release date.

Taking out issue 8 makes me feel we will be missing all other creator period issues:( the river :(

DK2 06-10-2022 08:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by mrmaczaps (Post 1927796)
Issue 8 is kind of irrelevant to the storyline contained in the other issues of this run... so its not super important and relatively cheap enough to pick up on its own. I can sell you a copy. I think I have 2 extras and one is signed by Steve Lavigne. I mean, it would be great to have all of the OG Mirage run reprinted in this format but I'm not going to lose sleep over the Guest Era stuff being skipped or issue 8.

Well, if your gonna say that about issue #8 not being really the main narrative from the surrounding issues (besides Renet and Savanti Romero's first appearances) I feel issue #9 "The Passing" is the same thing. Sure Kevin and Pete wrote it, drew the cover, inked the art drawn by Mike Dooney. Overall it has nothing to do with the main narrative. The Turtles being a little younger and Splinters mystical journey helping a spirit and his family. It really is more or less the first "Tales of" story, besides all the short stories Kevin & Pete had done thru out that time. It always threw me off this story compared to #8. It really doesn't belong in the omnibus to an extant IMO in that sense. Thats just me.

Sharman 06-11-2022 04:18 PM

Well, it seems that the cover art has been changed (and Dave Sim's credit removed):
https://images-na.ssl-images-amazon....1a-VnsrQfL.jpg

elgarlic 10-04-2023 12:04 PM

I've just received my copy of the Compendium vol 2. And it was... almost successful. It's no surprise that it's missing the Veitch issues. I don't see that ever changing in reprints (we will see about Howarth in vol 3).

On the plus side, it's nice to see that so many issues are being reprinted in black and white for the first time in ages/ever. From what I've seen, these issues are generally looking great.

The downside is that Tales #6 seems to be missing its duotones/shading. It looks quite dull as a result. In fact, they even used one of these bland panels for the book's cover. I guess they felt proud or overly honest about that. If any issue had to lose its shading, this one was perhaps on the less impressive side to start (no issue had to lose its shading).

I had long been wondering how they would handle #33. They've been botching this issue in reprints for years. At some point they decided to remove Corben's color and use flat color with lazy photoshop gradients instead. Well, here we get neither. B&W inks only. This could have been the chance to get it right, but I suppose it's better than what they did last time

But hey, The Ring is printed in full color. So that's nice, but makes the decision for #33 even more baffling.

CyberCubed 10-04-2023 05:08 PM

So the only skipped issues are #8, and Rick Veitch's issues (Sky highway and the River trilogy?) so far?

elgarlic 10-04-2023 05:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1976842)
So the only skipped issues are #8, and Rick Veitch's issues (Sky highway and the River trilogy?) so far?

Yeah, so far, with #41 as the only other one that will likely get skipped.

#8 is of course the biggest bummer, being a regression from previous collections. I wonder if they had waited a little longer, maybe starting with vol 3 after Dave gave them the thumbs down for #8, it would have worked out once distanced from the Kickstarter.

I've noticed that Ultimate Collection vol 2 has sold out everywhere. Panic buying, or actually going out of print?

CyberCubed 10-04-2023 07:18 PM

I wonder how far this will go. The next one should finish Vol. 1, but I would like to see Vol. 2 and Image get this treatment. And eventually Vol. 4 if we're really lucky since that's never been collected.

elgarlic 10-04-2023 08:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1976859)
I wonder how far this will go. The next one should finish Vol. 1, but I would like to see Vol. 2 and Image get this treatment. And eventually Vol. 4 if we're really lucky since that's never been collected.

I'd like for it to continue, especially for vol 4 of course. But I don't think there is much chance of vol 2 having its original color, or to get the Image issues in their original b&w.

TurtleGurkle 01-04-2024 04:49 PM

https://www.penguinrandomhouse.com/b...rd-jim-lawson/

Compendium 3 announced - nice surprise it has #41 in there since I think that has been skipped before. Unfortunately it says "final" compendium, so not much hope of volume 2 in this format.
https://images3.penguinrandomhouse.c.../9798887241562

About Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles Compendium, Vol. 3

Complete your journey following the early exploits of the TMNT in this collection of stories from the original Mirage comics!

This third and final compendium completes Mirage’s first run of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles comics, collecting issues #38–62. Included are stories by contributors Rich Hedden, Tom McWeeney, Matt Howarth, Rick McCollum, Bill Anderson, Paul Jenkins, A.C. Farley, Rick Arthur, Dan Berger, and Michael Dooney.

The volume concludes with “Shades of Gray” and the 13-part epic “City at War” that concludes the series by co-creators Kevin Eastman and Peter Laird with Jim Lawson.

CyberCubed 01-04-2024 10:41 PM

Volume 2 could come out under a different name. It would feel weird to re-release Vol. 1 and just stop there.

Andrew NDB 01-05-2024 01:13 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1982396)
Volume 2 could come out under a different name. It would feel weird to re-release Vol. 1 and just stop there.

Unless sales bottomed out.

Chaotix12345 01-05-2024 07:50 AM

Judging by the TMNT Adventures Omnibus that's already been listed for March 2025, Archie might be IDW's next target for these large-scale collections.

TurtleGurkle 01-05-2024 11:01 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chaotix12345 (Post 1982409)
Judging by the TMNT Adventures Omnibus that's already been listed for March 2025, Archie might be IDW's next target for these large-scale collections.

That's my hope - Archie needs this type of collection!

CyberCubed 01-05-2024 04:30 PM

If they skip the whole middle eastern arc again then it won't be worth it. I don't see why they can't just cut that 1 page of Mohammed instead of you know, skipping 5 issues that they did with the normal TPB's.

TurtleGurkle 01-06-2024 12:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 1982432)
If they skip the whole middle eastern arc again then it won't be worth it. I don't see why they can't just cut that 1 page of Mohammed instead of you know, skipping 5 issues that they did with the normal TPB's.

It's better than nothing given how expensive the Archie TPBs and back issues are now. Skipped issues are just something we have to live with as TMNT fans I guess.

Although the description for the Adventures Omni did say it would collect everything!

Andrew NDB 01-06-2024 12:22 AM

Also, I'm assuming we can assume there will still be whole issues worth of pages missing the original duotones again?

Demon-Alukard 01-06-2024 01:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1982457)
Also, I'm assuming we can assume there will still be whole issues worth of pages missing the original duotones again?

As I have original Mirage files of Vol.1, I can say issues 49 and 53 are completely without duoshades. And until IDW decides to re-scan them from long published copies, nothing will change.

CyberCubed 04-24-2024 08:00 PM

I was considering picking this up but no issue #8 is a dealbreaker, especially since IDW already collected it before in both the ultimate collections and the colored collections. So they collected the issue twice before but not in this one, which is meant to be the definitive book?


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:20 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.