The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   TMNT vol. 1 #8 remastered edition? (Cerebus) (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=65724)

Andrew NDB 01-29-2023 05:08 PM

TMNT vol. 1 #8 remastered edition? (Cerebus)
 
What is this?

https://i.ibb.co/YQBgvzL/received-568535608470567.jpg

Monty Mole 01-29-2023 05:21 PM

I'd like to know also

LeotheLateBloomer 01-29-2023 05:22 PM

No clue but color me intrigued.

Andrew NDB 01-29-2023 05:33 PM

#1, is this "official"?

Andrew NDB 01-29-2023 05:46 PM

Seems it's official.

https://waverlycomics.com/home/p/tmnt-8

Zog The Magnificent 01-29-2023 05:47 PM

Yeah, it's official. Dave Sim's been doing this thing for the last year or so. Since he still has rights to #8 due to his original involvement, he decided to do a remaster of it and touch up the art. In anticipation of it, he's released two production logs/fanzines called "Pieces of Turtles 8," which detail a bunch of behind the scenes stuff from the creation of TMNT #8, notes, and old sketches. Both were funded through kickstarter. Following that, he just released an ashcan issue of TMNT #8, ahead of the Kickstarter for the final version of the remastered issue.

Roseangelo 01-29-2023 06:16 PM

I saw the Ashcan posted, but I'm not paying $100 for that...

If the Kickstarter is reasonably priced, I'll do that.

DrSpengler 01-30-2023 05:37 PM

I picked up both Pieces of Turtles 8 fanzines last year and they were pretty cool retrospectives, though I understand the appeal is pretty niche (you gotta be REAL into Mirage TMNT history).

As for the ashcan, I got in on it during the 24 hour preorder sale, when the basic edition was just $30. Likes others, I really wouldn't pay $100 for it now. Then again, these will probably wind up going for triple that on the ridiculous collector's market, so maybe it's worth it?

If all you really want is the remaster of TMNT #8, then just wait until March 1. It'll go live on Kickstarter then.

Coola Yagami 01-31-2023 12:09 PM

Is this that issue that had Cerebus in it and was redrawn to remove him?

oldmanwinters 01-31-2023 02:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Coola Yagami (Post 1954630)
Is this that issue that had Cerebus in it and was redrawn to remove him?

Yes, this one right here:
http://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2011/...hudnovsky.html

Only officially released in a Spanish-language TPB because it turned out Dave Sim was perfectly content to let Peter Laird/Mirage/et. al. reprint the issue after all. Years, later Arseniy and crew put together a fan-reprint with English re-lettering.

Sharman 02-18-2023 01:05 PM

My eyebrows are raised in anticipation

oldmanwinters 02-24-2023 02:51 PM

The remaster pre-order window is coming...
https://www.kickstarter.com/projects...tB9oxuJP-mRU2U

Andrew NDB 02-24-2023 03:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Coola Yagami (Post 1954630)
Is this that issue that had Cerebus in it and was redrawn to remove him?

It was redrawn to be a completely different story. The origin of Savanti Romero, basically.

oldmanwinters 03-01-2023 09:24 AM

Pre-Orders are open on Kickstarter and $5000 initial target is already funded.
https://www.kickstarter.com/projects...oject_launched

And the variant covers... OH, the variant covers! I am seriously impressed.

DrSpengler 03-01-2023 09:43 AM

I wasn't expecting so much choice, but a good problem to have, I guess. Went ahead and got the Dooney and Lawson covers along with Pieces of Turtles 8.3.

Nortock Diab 03-01-2023 10:19 AM

The only example of "resmastering" is not really promising in my opinion...
I expected some changes to justify printing a new version of this book.

But there is a Jim Lawson cover so I'll probably pull the trigger!

Roseangelo 03-01-2023 03:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Nortock Diab (Post 1956984)
[COLOR="Lime"]The only example of "resmastering" is not really promising in my opinion...
I expected some changes to justify printing a new version of this book.

Based on the background on the rights that was provided, I suspect the book was redrawn simply because Sim doesn't have the files to the original. But maintains the right to reprint/republish without permission from or compensation to the TMNT side.

In short, it's a money grab that will probably pay off pretty well for him.

I am tempted to go in at the $600 level and just resell the covers I don't like/want. Can probably get most of my money back the way these things go.

oldmanwinters 03-01-2023 03:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roseangelo (Post 1957011)

I am tempted to go in at the $600 level and just resell the covers I don't like/want. Can probably get most of my money back the way these things go.

"Fortune favors the bold!"

Andrew NDB 03-02-2023 11:40 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roseangelo (Post 1957011)
Based on the background on the rights that was provided, I suspect the book was redrawn simply because Sim doesn't have the files to the original.

There wouldn't have been files back then. I'm sure Kevin and Peter drew the pages and then they just let Dave Sim draw Cerebus wherever he showed up and then Kevin and Peter kept the original pages, which presumably Viacom/Nick has kicking around now in a vault somewhere.

DK2 03-08-2023 08:08 PM

I've seen the kickstarter and some of its just so pricey. I thought about the 3rd cover by Sim. I even thought the 2nd one but why get whats essentially a redo of the same cover to the original comic? I even thought the option for all three of Sims covers but it gets costly. I'm leaning to getting one cover, maybe the 15 trading card set. Then maybe Pieces of Turtles 8.3 since I didn't get the other ones that came out before. I thought about the covers from the Mirage artists but I'm also in line of thinking they didn't really have much to do with the original TMNT 8 if so, in a smaller capacity. Lawson wasn't involved but Dooney and Lavigne were in the inking and lettering respectively. I've even been thinking about Bisley's cover. But these kickstarters get so costly. I missed out on Sims ''Spawn #10 remaster''. Even thought about the Cerebus #1 and #2 remasters but at $15 each, geez. Thinking just making this spend less as possible I guess.

Roseangelo 03-08-2023 09:35 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DK2 (Post 1957920)
I've seen the kickstarter and some of its just so pricey. I thought about the 3rd cover by Sim. I even thought the 2nd one but why get whats essentially a redo of the same cover to the original comic? I even thought the option for all three of Sims covers but it gets costly. I'm leaning to getting one cover, maybe the 15 trading card set. Then maybe Pieces of Turtles 8.3 since I didn't get the other ones that came out before. I thought about the covers from the Mirage artists but I'm also in line of thinking they didn't really have much to do with the original TMNT 8 if so, in a smaller capacity. Lawson wasn't involved but Dooney and Lavigne were in the inking and lettering respectively. I've even been thinking about Bisley's cover. But these kickstarters get so costly. I missed out on Sims ''Spawn #10 remaster''. Even thought about the Cerebus #1 and #2 remasters but at $15 each, geez. Thinking just making this spend less as possible I guess.

I over-bought what I want and will sell what I don't want to make up for it. I've just accepted that's how the hobby rolls.

oldmanwinters 03-29-2023 02:02 PM

Reminder that the order window is down to the last 30 hours:
Thursday at 10:00 PM EDT

teacher fan 04-18-2023 05:41 PM

Since the initial sale apparently did well, the remastered Cerebus crossover is available again. The copies are cheaper than initially, and this window will close on April 28th; so NOW is the time to get it!

https://www.indiegogo.com/projects/t...ring-cerebus#/

Jeff 08-05-2023 03:10 PM

just got mine in the mail today! I got the jim lawson cover and it looks fantastic! haven't opened it yet, but when i do i'll take some pics and post them here.

DrSpengler 08-17-2023 09:54 PM

Got my copies today! Did a couple quick write ups on TMNT Entity:

https://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2023...-remaster.html

https://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2023...rtles-8-3.html

The Remaster looks great and I love the Michael Dooney and Lawson/Lavigne covers I got. But Pieces of Turtles 8 #3 is the real treasure in all this. Colossal interview with tons of photos and sketches and other things I'd never seen before. It can get maybe a little meandering (it is SO LOOOOOOONG) but it's very honest, candid and Sim and Eastman really seem to be enjoying the experience of reminiscing on things.

HotJuicyBurgers 08-17-2023 11:16 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1972837)
Got my copies today! Did a couple quick write ups on TMNT Entity:

https://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2023...-remaster.html

https://tmntentity.blogspot.com/2023...rtles-8-3.html

The Remaster looks great and I love the Michael Dooney and Lawson/Lavigne covers I got. But Pieces of Turtles 8 #3 is the real treasure in all this. Colossal interview with tons of photos and sketches and other things I'd never seen before. It can get maybe a little meandering (it is SO LOOOOOOONG) but it's very honest, candid and Sim and Eastman really seem to be enjoying the experience of reminiscing on things.

Anyway you could add the interview somewhere? Didn't even know the pieces of turtles 8 was a thing, let alone there are 3 of them.

I snagged the Dooney and Lawson cover for the remaster, I will say it looks better than I expected.

Mayhem 08-18-2023 01:25 AM

Hopefully my copies (ordered a few of the variants and the PoT8 #3) won’t be long in arriving then.

Andrew NDB 08-18-2023 01:58 AM

Eh. Does anyone have like an extra Lawson cover version they could part with? I missed the window for this.

Mayhem 08-18-2023 03:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1972848)
Eh. Does anyone have like an extra Lawson cover version they could part with? I missed the window for this.

They overprinted most of the variants to allow for damages, lost in mail etc and to round up to a nice figure. Available here:

https://waverlycomics.com/home/p/tmnt-8-wnlr7

bjaxx87 08-18-2023 07:55 AM

Did you guys receive any shipping information for your copies of the remaster? I didn't hear anything so far.

oldmanwinters 08-18-2023 08:01 AM

Yes, received mine this week with the Dooney cover and the impressive supplement "Visions of 8!"

DrSpengler 08-18-2023 09:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by bjaxx87 (Post 1972859)
Did you guys receive any shipping information for your copies of the remaster? I didn't hear anything so far.

I got the campaign updates that discussed the status of the books printing and shipping, but did not receive a unique tracking number.

IMJ 08-18-2023 09:18 AM

Geeze - 40 variant covers. Add that to your TMNT Mirage collection, omg. The Archie variant is pretty awesome.....

bjaxx87 08-18-2023 01:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by DrSpengler (Post 1972870)
I got the campaign updates that discussed the status of the books printing and shipping, but did not receive a unique tracking number.

I see, thanks. I backed at Indiegogo and there hasn't been a single update so far.

Jeff 08-18-2023 03:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1972848)
Eh. Does anyone have like an extra Lawson cover version they could part with? I missed the window for this.

i think they were selling extra as recently as last week, not sure if any lawson's were left, though.

Powder 08-18-2023 07:26 PM

At one point, I was going to have a piece of art involved in this book. Unfortunately, they had way too many folks involved & some of us got cut at the end. Oh well. Still an honor to have been thought of!

On another note, do the variants listed for sale include the supplementary content Pieces of 8?

https://i.ibb.co/KX5fcFW/222647975-4...90563805-n.png

Mayhem 08-19-2023 04:36 PM

No, all separate afaik

teacher fan 08-27-2023 06:25 AM

So I got my copy of this "remastered" comic yesterday. Cover and paper were decent enough quality. It was also sturdy thick "paper", and not that glossy stuff most modern comics use. The back of the comic only had 4 pages of "new" material. A letter Kevin Eastman wrote to Dave Sim back when they were working on this comic, some old sketches; and a never released piece of Cerebus and the Turtles made in 2012 between Kevin Eastman and Dave Sim. Everyone who ordered this comic also got Cerebus and TMNT "trading cards" and a TMNT/Cerebus postcard. They look cool... although for the cards: I doubt if anyone is really going to be actually trading these. I'll just keep them nestled with the comic in it's plastic case I'm putting it in.

As for how good the "remastered" quality is... it's just about as good as anything IDW did when they re-released the old Mirage comics (this very comic is also already in IDW's second ultimate TMNT collection). However, this is the first time this specific issue has been re-released as a "single floppy" in it's original black and white since it first came out; so that's something. To me, this is only something worth getting for the fun covers, and for the novelty.

Another interesting thing to note is that the copyright section says how this specific issue is jointly owned by Dave Sim and Viacom. Apparently Dave Sim and Mirage's old agreement was either of them could reprint this comic however they saw fit; so I guess Viacom has honored that agreement. However even that original agreement seems to have some grey area, as many people who co-created certain comics with Dave Sim didn't reprint their collaborations for many years... until around 2009 when Dave Sim suddenly publicly said it was cool. Although, creating new covers with NEW artwork featuring the Turtles seems to be stretching whatever that original agreement was... so maybe it's best to just view this reprinting as a "fan project" that just happens to have official people involved.

Andrew NDB 08-27-2023 11:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by teacher fan (Post 1973887)
As for how good the "remastered" quality is... it's just about as good as anything IDW did when they re-released the old Mirage comics

That bad, then?

teacher fan 08-28-2023 08:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 1973968)
That bad, then?

It didn't look bad to me. I held up my IDW "Ultimate Collection" and newly reprinted TMNT #8 comic right next to each other for comparison. From my perspective, both reprints look exactly the same (only the "Ultimate Collection" pages are obviously bigger). However the new reprint comic is printed on strong sturdy un-glossed paper, with a new thick cover. So it's definitely made to last. At the very least, it's definitely better quality than it's original printing.

As I dig deeper into the history of this reprint project, Kevin Eastman definitely appears to have been involved with it (or at least gave his official blessing). It's hard to say if the people in charge at Viacom were aware of this project, or if they even cared. But like I said in an earliest post... selling new covers with new artwork of the Turtles on it is where this comic enters the "grey zone" of legal territory. That being said, there truly are some amazing covers attached to this project.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 08:50 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.