The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   Is The Last Ronin worth building a film franchise around? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=67475)

ToTheNines 03-30-2025 05:08 AM

Is The Last Ronin worth building a film franchise around?
 
I guess what I’m really asking is: are the new generation of turtles from the sequel series (Moja and Yi, etc.) capable of carrying a film/multiple films? Because there’s really nowhere else to go if this TLR movie becomes a reality.

I have not read those books and never plan to.

neatoman 03-30-2025 07:07 PM

It's worth it in the sense that it might help break the public perception of TMNT as a "dumb comedy thing for kids".

IndigoErth 03-30-2025 08:24 PM

Personally, I wouldn't go forward as sequels, I'd jump back with some prequals.

These Turtles are older, so there is plenty of room to tell stories of their adult years leading up to the time period of TLR events.

Sure, by then we'd know how it ultimately ends, but some good original Ronin-related movies could be told that could still be enjoyed as complete stories on their own.

Andrew NDB 03-30-2025 11:36 PM

There are different ways to go about it. A Last Ronin movie as a sort of standalone thing, then new movies that show the "happier days" and the Last Ronin is like a future cautionary tale. Then maybe a Renet movie where Last Ronin is stopped from happening.

I dunno. There's options with something like this.

IndigoErth 03-31-2025 03:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 2006330)
Then maybe a Renet movie where Last Ronin is stopped from happening.

Huh, I could see that, and would be interesting to get her into a movie. She stops those events, the TMNT don't die, and open the door for sequels for the original Turtles.

neatoman 03-31-2025 03:46 PM

Renet movie? What would that be like? Doctor Who starring a busty chick who speak in slang?

Roseangelo 03-31-2025 03:53 PM

Honest answer is no. There are too many characters the regular public doesn't know/give an F about.

neatoman 03-31-2025 04:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Roseangelo (Post 2006357)
Honest answer is no. There are too many characters the regular public doesn't know/give an F about.

You mean like Mutant Mayhem?

sdp 03-31-2025 05:48 PM

They just desperately wanted a hit so they hastily announced a The Last Ronin movie and video game after they saw that it overwhelmingly popular in the comic and collectors sector. What they later realized is that niche is too small for any wide release so that's why this franchise is not going to happen and the movie will not be coming out, neither will the game.

Remember this from 2 years ago? lol


TylerD 04-15-2025 10:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 2006322)
It's worth it in the sense that it might help break the public perception of TMNT as a "dumb comedy thing for kids".

This!!

But... it has to be done right.... if they turned it into some stupid funny thing for kids (which i don't think they could, since everyone is dead other than Mikey, so would be tough to pull that off and turn it towards kids) it would completely ruin it. If they make this dark, and have it for the older TMNT fans, this could be an excellent series, or even just a stand alone movie!

Andrew NDB 04-15-2025 10:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TylerD (Post 2007075)
If they make this dark, and have it for the older TMNT fans

The fallacy here is the thought that only "older fans" could possibly interested in something dark, or something with a lot of dark in it.

IMJ 04-15-2025 11:05 AM

I'm beginning to realize that often times the way the Turtles look in an iteration has a huge impact on the acceptance of any given story. For example, it's entirely possible that the Michael Bay flicks could remain 100% unchanged from what they are, except replace the Turtle designs with CGi resembling the Platinum Dunes flick and suddenly it's a much more acceptable flick.

Spread that example across the board - if you get the designs correct then you are like 80% there to a movie that people will largely like.

ToTheNines 04-16-2025 03:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by IMJ (Post 2007077)
entirely possible that the Michael Bay flicks could remain 100% unchanged from what they are, except replace the Turtle designs with CGi resembling the Platinum Dunes flick and suddenly it's a much more acceptable flick.

I assume you meant to say something other than “Platinum Dunes” here, but yes I totally agree and have made a similar point in the past.

Still wouldn’t be my cup of tea, but I would hold the 2014 movie in higher regard if they got the designs right. And I’m willing to bet they would have performed better too.

IMJ 04-16-2025 09:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 2007117)
I assume you meant to say something other than “Platinum Dunes” here, but yes I totally agree and have made a similar point in the past.

Oops my mistake, you're right - I meant New Line.

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 2007117)
Still wouldn’t be my cup of tea, but I would hold the 2014 movie in higher regard if they got the designs right. And I’m willing to bet they would have performed better too.

Yup... exactly....

TylerD 04-16-2025 10:45 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 2007076)
The fallacy here is the thought that only "older fans" could possibly interested in something dark, or something with a lot of dark in it.

Younger fans too, but in todays generation a lot of the young crowd can't watch something too dark.... My 5 year old loves Ninja Turtles, but if it is rated R and involves heads getting cut off, and turtles dying... I would not allow him to watch it yet.

I just don't want them to do this with the intent to have it directed at all age groups... That is where it would go to hell... Put in goofy crap, and make it "funny" Direct this toward the older fans, and don't worry so much if the young fans have to miss out till they are a bit more grown up. Not everything has to apply to all age groups. Sometimes when you do that depending on a storyline it can suck real bad. Last Ronin is too dark to have it directed towards the younger audience in my opinion. If you start changing the storyline and have it more based around kids, it would fall apart drastically and not be worth doing in my opinion.

Andrew NDB 04-16-2025 11:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TylerD (Post 2007126)
Younger fans too, but in todays generation a lot of the young crowd can't watch something too dark.... My 5 year old loves Ninja Turtles, but if it is rated R and involves heads getting cut off, and turtles dying... I would not allow him to watch it yet.

I don't know that we need to make sure a TMNT movie is OK for 5 year-olds. 13 year-olds, sure, not 5 year-olds. Ultimately, if you're not able to portray ninjas in any way that isn't a sham... don't bother.

IndigoErth 04-16-2025 03:21 PM

Yeah, and we don't need to. People defend critical opinions of the kid friendly stuff with "It's not made for you!" but some of it doesn't need to be for the kiddies either. (And I mean content outside of comics.) Though some of those same people seem to get upset when something dares not be for their kid. Their kid can still have the fun of discovering it later if they remain fans.


Still hoping this movie happens, even just to get a mature film out there and give the world a clue that it isn't all kiddie stuff, but it's been a bit too quiet for too long. :ohwell:

TylerD 04-16-2025 08:29 PM

I agree with both of you. This world seems to be so sensitive. I just hope they don't do it period if it isn't going to be graphic and dark. Anything short of that and it would be horrific

ToTheNines 04-17-2025 06:22 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 2007129)
I don't know that we need to make sure a TMNT movie is OK for 5 year-olds. 13 year-olds, sure, not 5 year-olds. Ultimately, if you're not able to portray ninjas in any way that isn't a sham... don't bother.

That’s what really baffled me about the second PD movie. On one hand there clearly wanted to make a stupid Roger Rabbit ass cartoon for babies, but then they put a bunch of cussing and weird sexual sh*t in it. Strange.

LeotheLateBloomer 04-17-2025 08:39 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by IndigoErth (Post 2007143)
Yeah, and we don't need to. People defend critical opinions of the kid friendly stuff with "It's not made for you!" but some of it doesn't need to be for the kiddies either. (And I mean content outside of comics.) Though some of those same people seem to get upset when something dares not be for their kid. Their kid can still have the fun of discovering it later if they remain fans.

Those same people use that excuse (and their child, if they have one) as a defense to hide the fact that they like it. They're also the same people who dislike Secret of the Ooze for being watered down compared to the first. They hated the soccer mom impact it did for the movie and now they're being the soccer parents. If these are the same parents who take their child to see Deadpool movies, they're frauds!:lol:

TylerD 04-17-2025 09:59 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 2007170)
That’s what really baffled me about the second PD movie. On one hand there clearly wanted to make a stupid Roger Rabbit ass cartoon for babies, but then they put a bunch of cussing and weird sexual sh*t in it. Strange.

Exactly, which is completely stupid.... Either go all in, or don't... I hate that crap where a movie is designed for kids, but they still try and put enough in to entertain adults. It can work, but in Last Ronin case it just wouldn't in my opinion.... Nothing about it should be funny, or kid friendly... It's a very dark storyline. Michelangelo is alone in the world, and lost his entire family.... Would just make zero sense to me to try and make it funny, or anything in that ballpark. Keep it true to the comics, and keep it dark. It would be worth a watch

Of course like any comic, it's hard to get all the detail into a movie that is 1.5 hours long, but if done right it could be very good.

Andrew NDB 04-17-2025 10:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TylerD (Post 2007186)
It's a very dark storyline.

It's not really as dark as it's made out to be. But even within the bounds of a PG-13 movie they could push things even darker than the comic.

IndigoErth 04-17-2025 03:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LeotheLateBloomer (Post 2007178)
Those same people use that excuse (and their child, if they have one) as a defense to hide the fact that they like it.

True, and that's fine to like it, the "kid stuff" can be a fun watch too sometimes and it's okay to prefer that angle, so they can skip the insecurity over it and just like what they like.

The ones I don't get (and I've interacted with them on Reddit now and again) are the grown-ass people who will fight you over you actually wanting some more mature stuff occasionally. Emphasis on occasionally. Not replacing the family friendly stuff, nor make it take a back seat, but just throw older people who want a more mature movie/show a bone now and then. Like the idea that BOTH angles can exist at the same time and get screen time just doesn't compute for them, it's gotta be just one or the other and to want the OTHER is reacted to like a threat. :roll:

There was one guy... damn I wish I had screen shot it. :tlol: Went on at me that it's people like me who insist on dragging this stuff into adulthood who...somehow prevent other things from getting to exist? I mean, I wasn't aware that the arts and entertainment has only so many available spots in which new things are allowed to be made and exist. *shrug*

Greed might not be a good thing...unless it's TMNT, imo. :P Just give us ALL the possible good stuff for diff age groups. People don't like some older fan complaining, but he best way to shut them up is to stop ignoring that half of what TMNT is and can be.

TylerD 04-21-2025 01:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 2007191)
It's not really as dark as it's made out to be. But even within the bounds of a PG-13 movie they could push things even darker than the comic.

Could make it solid with a PG 14 rating

But making it into too kid friendly will ruin. It

Lord Nightwalker 04-22-2025 07:01 AM

Anything written well, with care and talent, could be worthy. But will we get that?
Likely not.

TylerD 04-22-2025 12:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Lord Nightwalker (Post 2007423)
Anything written well, with care and talent, could be worthy. But will we get that?
Likely not.

Oh agreed completely. Ifs just fun to think about. Haha.

TheLabRat 04-24-2025 04:50 AM

I hope movie change some of the plots, like Mikey massacre human Foot Soldier instead of robots, and Karai being killed by Mikey. If they want a sequel, Mikey should survive and become Splinter. Also, it's better to keep Hiroto's feeling for his mother, or even have him develop an him an oedipus complex, rather than be a boring jerk.

TylerD 04-24-2025 08:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheLabRat (Post 2007516)
I hope movie change some of the plots, like Mikey massacre human Foot Soldier instead of robots, and Karai being killed by Mikey. If they want a sequel, Mikey should survive and become Splinter. Also, it's better to keep Hiroto's feeling for his mother, or even have him develop an him an oedipus complex, rather than be a boring jerk.

I would be on board with that. Usually when they do a movie especially when DC does a movie based on a comic they change it up quite a bit depending on the story. One thing I will say is, they would probably keep it at a stand alone movie if they did one, and since Last Robin has so much material to cover they would likely have to cut a lot out (unless they did a sequel or 2) my guess is it would have to depend on how well the first one did.

Jeff 04-30-2025 06:27 PM

if its a good movie, then yes. no one outside of comics knew who miles morales was when into the spiderverse came out.

Andrew NDB 04-30-2025 06:43 PM

It's a complex argument, the whole "Well no one even KNOWS about such-and-such character, so how can they possibly consider using him?"

I remember in 1994-1996, people were saying, "Of COURSE they can't put Bane in a movie, nobody outside of comics even knows who he is!"

And then they put Bane in Batman & Robin in 1997 and everyone knows who he is... except now everyone knows him as a mentally deficient troglodyte underling of Poison Ivy. Two things here: #1, obviously, the not "anybody" knowing about Bane before Batman & Robin did not mean anything about why they could or couldn't include him. They did anyway and there wasn't like a barrier to putting him there. #2, now, the "people knowing about Bane" from Batman & Robin is now a hindrance to the character, NOT a benefit of any kind.

TylerD 05-06-2025 11:47 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 2007707)
It's a complex argument, the whole "Well no one even KNOWS about such-and-such character, so how can they possibly consider using him?"

I remember in 1994-1996, people were saying, "Of COURSE they can't put Bane in a movie, nobody outside of comics even knows who he is!"

And then they put Bane in Batman & Robin in 1997 and everyone knows who he is... except now everyone knows him as a mentally deficient troglodyte underling of Poison Ivy. Two things here: #1, obviously, the not "anybody" knowing about Bane before Batman & Robin did not mean anything about why they could or couldn't include him. They did anyway and there wasn't like a barrier to putting him there. #2, now, the "people knowing about Bane" from Batman & Robin is now a hindrance to the character, NOT a benefit of any kind.

Well said. As bad as Batman and Robin is especially what they did to Banes character, I still go back and watch it lol. It was criminal what they did to arguably one of the best villains in comic book history. Then again that entire movie just a complete wreck.

Spiderman 3 did the same thing to venom. Nothing even close to what Batman and Robin did to Banes, but it was pretty bad. Sadly the venom series out now hasn't done venom much justice either.

IMJ 05-06-2025 08:58 PM

Good points on Bane, but to be fair - most people didn't go in that cold.

Knightfall had some media attention similar to "The Death of Superman" in the early 90's.
And then, Batman TAS was a cultural breakout and Bane appeared there in 1994.

Schumacher's Batman and Robin was released in 1997.

I wouldn't say that changes the points that were made, but it's not like they put a widely unknown character on-film, even if they did screw him up.

Donnie 07-11-2025 07:52 PM

The fact that we may be getting a LR movie before a live action comic book Movie 1 style remake is ridiculous. I’ve never read LR either, but I read spoilers and saw the panels of Turtle deaths. Nah man. To hell with it. PL came out of the woodwork for THAT?

Andrew NDB 07-11-2025 09:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Donnie (Post 2010810)
PL came out of the woodwork for THAT?

PL didn't come out anything for it. He didn't do one iota of work on the IDW project. Who even knows how much they veered from that 1987 outline.

ToTheNines 07-12-2025 03:30 AM

Yeah that was all pure marketing nonsense.

Donnie 07-12-2025 10:30 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 2010820)
Yeah that was all pure marketing nonsense.

Ah, good to know then.:tlol:

Galactus 07-19-2025 05:19 PM

Making a The Last Ronin movie makes sense. It's been the best received (by regular people) TMNT piece of media in over a decade. There is a reason that when news hit it was being worked on it got more hype than Mutant Mayhem ever did. The very idea of a "dark" R rated movie about the last surviving ninja turtle fighting to avenge his brothers is interesting enough to pique the curiosity of people put off by the last few TMNT movies. It may be a swing for fences but it's possibly the smartest card they have left to play.

The ideal scenario would be they release The Last Ronin movie and it's successful enough for them to properly reboot the traditional TMNT live action movies to something a bit more serious and Mirage-esque.

Of course I'm sceptical The Last Ronin will ever happen. I have serious doubts there will ever be another live action TMNT movie of any kind again.

Mr. Entertainment 07-20-2025 05:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Galactus (Post 2011089)
Making a The Last Ronin movie makes sense. It's been the best received (by regular people) TMNT piece of media in over a decade. There is a reason that when news hit it was being worked on it got more hype than Mutant Mayhem ever did. The very idea of a "dark" R rated movie about the last surviving ninja turtle fighting to avenge his brothers is interesting enough to pique the curiosity of people put off by the last few TMNT movies. It may be a swing for fences but it's possibly the smartest card they have left to play.

The ideal scenario would be they release The Last Ronin movie and it's successful enough for them to properly reboot the traditional TMNT live action movies to something a bit more serious and Mirage-esque.

Of course I'm sceptical The Last Ronin will ever happen. I have serious doubts there will ever be another live action TMNT movie of any kind again.

If Paramount wanted to do a "Mirage-esque" movie, they would've done it 15 years ago. IF Last Ronin gets made, it'll at best get a sequel or two.

That's why I think The Last Ronin was created in the first place. To have a property Paramount can option for merchandising, games, movies, etc.

IndigoErth 07-20-2025 11:29 AM

Not even holding my breath anymore on it, it's been too quiet for too long and have started assuming it may not be happening after all. :ohwell: Which, even if imperfect, sucks (imo) as it's the boost the more mature side of TMNT needed to kick that door open to access to existing in media beyond comics.

I have seen casual people via Reddit who grew up with 87 (or 2003 but the shift in tone is not quite as jarring for them obviously) who haven't paid attention to the TMNT since then but took notice of TLR, surprised by it, and jump back on board. Do a live action movie (a good one) and get that trailer out there, it would surely be having more people doing a double take and get them curious enough to want to check it out.

I was hoping a movie would trigger some prequals set in the same universe (maybe a decade or two earlier?) so we can then see more of them all alive and tell other stories with those older Turtles. It would be a nice jumping on point to having some adult Turtles and not going all the way back to the start to remake the origin yet again.

But we can't have nice things via movies or shows these days (that isn't for the kiddies), so...

Daytona 07-20-2025 11:31 PM

I hope the movie gets made but I take its very announcement as the ultimate victory. TLR was literally the turtles DKR moment on both a fictional and meta level. The turtles are finally allowed to be serious again in the eyes of the property owners.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:11 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.