The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   IDW's The Shredder By Dan Watters (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=67500)

ZariusTwo 04-12-2025 07:17 AM

IDW's The Shredder By Dan Watters
 
Quote:

Dan Watters is writing a new Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles comic book series, a spin-off series for The Shredder, from IDW Entertainment in August 2025. There will be covers from Stjepan Sejic, Kael Ngu and Dike Ruan, and one of them may even be drawing the comic. I am sure we will learn more in a month or so… or maybe at this weekend's C2E2; you never know.
https://bleedingcool.com/comics/dan-...rtles-spinoff/

ToTheNines 04-12-2025 07:20 AM

They plagiarized Andrew.

hypered1 04-12-2025 07:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 2006949)
They plagiarized Andrew.

Doubtful considering that he's an ally to the turtles currently and I can't imagine Andrew has ever written him that way.

ToTheNines 04-12-2025 08:06 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by hypered1 (Post 2006950)
Doubtful considering that he's an ally to the turtles currently and I can't imagine Andrew has ever written him that way.

I was joking.

I am expecting this to actually be about Karai. But we’ll see.

TheLabRat 04-12-2025 09:14 AM

Pretty sure that he'll get more of what he want since he is actually the Chosen One in the IDW TMNT story.

CyberCubed 04-12-2025 12:41 PM

So is this canon? They show Kitsune there and she's currently "dead."

Also didn't Shredder go to Dimension X last we saw him?

Drose18 04-12-2025 11:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 2006958)
So is this canon? They show Kitsune there and she's currently "dead."

Also didn't Shredder go to Dimension X last we saw him?

That pic is one of the shredder in hell #1 covers.

Hopefully for this we just get to see Shredder doing hero stuff in Dimension X being a badass. Could be fun, maybe he somehow "turns" evil again in it or something to bring him back into the main story? Idkk I guess they could always go with the increasingly more inevitable "mutates/or otherwise into Super Shredder" outcome.

TheLabRat 04-13-2025 12:27 AM

It's no surprise that Shredder is the villain once again. Just like the writers still can't decide if Karai is possessed or naturally evil.

Andrew NDB 04-13-2025 01:36 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 2006949)
They plagiarized Andrew.

I mean, my eyes did perk up a second there. But I always thought it's kind of weird there has never been anything just called "The Shredder."

hypered1 04-13-2025 07:23 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheLabRat (Post 2006970)
It's no surprise that Shredder is the villain once again. Just like the writers still can't decide if Karai is possessed or naturally evil.

There's literally no details whatsoever in the article beyond who's writing and when it's planned to launch (a couple of possible cover artists).

Last we saw Shredder/ Saki was in Dimension X during the Armageddon event as an ally of the turtles.

Cloudrunner 04-13-2025 01:38 PM

Vain hope that this has a side plot about Alopex trying to hunt down and kill Shredder (obviously told from his POV). Maybe not as the main focus of the story, but as a persistent thorn in his side that he has to deal with.

ToTheNines 04-13-2025 01:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cloudrunner (Post 2006983)
Vain hope that this has a side plot about Alopex trying to hunt down and kill Shredder (obviously told from his POV). Maybe not as the main focus of the story, but as a persistent thorn in his side that he has to deal with.

She never got over that? Damn, that’s a 12 year old plot line at this point lol

TigerClaw 04-13-2025 02:23 PM

It could be a story about the Shredder trying to make amends, for all the terrible things he's done in the past.

What I like about IDW, Is how they are letting all these characters grow, So I could see this Shredder showing accountability for the things he's done.

GameCobra 04-13-2025 05:13 PM

Honestly, I would like for them to commit to Alopex being Shredder's highest ranking mutant next to Bebop and Rocksteady. The dynamic is there.

The thing that was very interesting about Shredder when I first read the Alopex 's micro series two years back was that even knowing her gave some insight into Shredder that i never seen before. Mainly that he holds high esteem for foxes. The problem though is he clearly sees Alopex as a tool. I would've liked to see Alopex knock some sense into Shredder overtime, but at the same time see Shredder's side of things. What gives him that logic.

CyberCubed 04-13-2025 06:19 PM

Pretty sure it'll just be about Shredder in Dimension X. Alopex won't appear at all.

Coola Yagami 04-13-2025 06:43 PM

It's kind of weird, while killing her family would be unforgivable, but if it weren't for Shredder, Alopex would still be just a regular animal.

TheLabRat 04-13-2025 08:50 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TigerClaw (Post 2006988)
It could be a story about the Shredder trying to make amends, for all the terrible things he's done in the past.

What I like about IDW, Is how they are letting all these characters grow, So I could see this Shredder showing accountability for the things he's done.

He just left the Foot Clan mess to Karai, it's hard to say that he's really faced up to his mistakes. He never admitted to Karai and other foot members that his past philosophy was wrong and tried to fix it. Now we see Karai just keeps making new mistakes.

neatoman 04-13-2025 10:46 PM

It's not even confirmed to be in the IDW continuity or any other previous continuity for that matter, for all we know it could just be reboot that divorces the character from TMNT entirely. Like how the Venom Movies circumvent Spider-Man entirely despite Spider-Man traditionally being very important for Venom's Origin.

Cloudrunner 04-14-2025 10:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 2006985)
She never got over that? Damn, that’s a 12 year old plot line at this point lol

A 12 year old plot point that was never addressed, until a very hasty and forced moment towards the end of Sophie's run that was a thinly veiled excuse to detach her from the turtles and write her out of the story.

GameCobra 04-14-2025 10:43 AM

Sadly, it starting to look like the angle they are going with this is she's going to be the mistreated foot soldier who turns traitor and dates the enemy in the long run.

I honestly wanted to see more about what lead to her loyalty with shredder. clearly she didn't like being transformed, but unlike Old Hob, she got attached to Shredder. Whether he lied to her or treated her respectfully until the murder of her family are interesting to me. Or maybe she saw Shredder's version of family as an upgrade and didn't want to admit it.

ToTheNines 04-14-2025 10:52 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cloudrunner (Post 2007023)
A 12 year old plot point that was never addressed, until a very hasty and forced moment towards the end of Sophie's run that was a thinly veiled excuse to detach her from the turtles and write her out of the story.

Yeah but even when the Alopex micro came out, as much as I liked that issue you just knew they wouldn’t deliver. They were compiling a huge list of characters who wanted to take Shredder out, and it was pretty obvious it was always going to be Splinter who got his revenge.

I don’t see the point now. He’s reincarnated and peaceful now. (I haven’t read anything after #125 yet, so perhaps I’m missing something here).

TheLabRat 04-14-2025 08:09 PM

This doesn't mean that everything he did before can be easily forgotten and forgiven. It would make sense for the victim or his old enemy to seek revenge from him. It's just that I also don't like how Alopex blames The Turtles for siding with Shredder while she chooses to help Karai, which made her behavior very hypocritical.

Aside from being the turtle's fairy godmother and guarding a demon as a jailer on Dimension X, Shredder did not try to bring honor to the Foot Clan like his father did. Instead, he just watch Karai go down the wrong path and never tried to correct it. As a result, the Oroku and Hamato families never truly reconciled. So I don't like that IDW resurrected Shredder but never let him do anything of major consequence.

At least in Andrew's "The Shredder" comic, Mirage Shredder killed Casey and April, and his actions indirectly led to Raph and Shadow become enemies.

ToTheNines 04-15-2025 03:47 AM

I haven’t read Shredder in Hell or #100 since they came out, and I’m only on #126 of Sophie’s run, so I’m missing some key pieces here. But!

My understanding was that he’s now completely separate from the Dragon warrior or whatever. Like the spirit of Takeshi Tatsuo is what made him an asshole and now he’s just his true own self.

ZariusTwo 04-29-2025 09:16 AM

Officially announced

https://www.ign.com/articles/shredde...spinoff-series

Coola Yagami 04-29-2025 12:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheLabRat (Post 2007054)
This doesn't mean that everything he did before can be easily forgotten and forgiven. It would make sense for the victim or his old enemy to seek revenge from him. It's just that I also don't like how Alopex blames The Turtles for siding with Shredder while she chooses to help Karai, which made her behavior very hypocritical.

Aside from being the turtle's fairy godmother and guarding a demon as a jailer on Dimension X, Shredder did not try to bring honor to the Foot Clan like his father did. Instead, he just watch Karai go down the wrong path and never tried to correct it. As a result, the Oroku and Hamato families never truly reconciled. So I don't like that IDW resurrected Shredder but never let him do anything of major consequence.

At least in Andrew's "The Shredder" comic, Mirage Shredder killed Casey and April, and his actions indirectly led to Raph and Shadow become enemies.

Did April die normally or did she suddenly vanish when she dropped, as if she was erased?

neatoman 04-29-2025 01:15 PM

So basically, this looks like his road back to full on villainy?

CyberCubed 04-29-2025 02:58 PM

Hopefully. The whole "good guy" Shredder never really sat well, it seemed like he was only at peace due to Kitsune but now that she's gone what does he have to do.

TheLabRat 04-29-2025 10:08 PM

In one of variant cover, he appears older than before. Does this mean that the ooze in his body has become less, or even disappeared?

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 2007659)
Hopefully. The whole "good guy" Shredder never really sat well, it seemed like he was only at peace due to Kitsune but now that she's gone what does he have to do.

Maybe Noi Tai Dar still has some power that can corrupt him, or maybe the Dragon isn't actually died. Now, Null has escaped maybe she will got to Dimension Z to save her brother.

Lord Nightwalker 04-30-2025 12:45 PM

Ugh.
I really liked the idea that Saki had found redemption.
He has some much potential as a darker hero.

CyberCubed 04-30-2025 08:06 PM

He may be half and half, not truly evil but not really a friend anymore. Honestly, "good guy Shredder" was just boring, but to be fair most of it was under Sophie's run.

TheLabRat 04-30-2025 10:12 PM

So they repeat the circle again, and the comic never actually got a soft reboot.

ToTheNines 05-01-2025 04:43 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheLabRat (Post 2007680)
In one of variant cover, he appears older than before.

I noticed that. It’s not really earned here, but I always liked the idea of Saki being a wise old master.

TheLabRat 05-04-2025 02:42 AM

If Shredder turn evil again, it will be very embarrassing for Tom Walz.

Bluelightsaber 05-04-2025 10:30 AM

If Shredder turns evil again, it’d totally undercut all the growth and redemption Waltz gave him. After tweets like that, it’d feel like a narrative betrayal just for drama’s sake.

TheLabRat 05-24-2025 08:18 AM

Shredder Creative Team Reveal Details on TMNT Spinoff Series and New Costume

What does that mean? Shredder was betrayed by his own clan? Now, some of the Foot soldiers have began to become disappointed with Karai's rule. If Shredder announces his return to take over Foot Clan, Karai could soon be a commander without any soldiers.

neatoman 05-24-2025 12:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheLabRat (Post 2007865)
If Shredder turn evil again, it will be very embarrassing for Tom Walz.

Not more than any other writer who had their ideas changed by successors, certainly not when it comes to villains going back to being villains. Did anyone not expect Doctor Octopus to return to villainy?

GameCobra 05-25-2025 07:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 2008879)
Not more than any other writer who had their ideas changed by successors, certainly not when it comes to villains going back to being villains. Did anyone not expect Doctor Octopus to return to villainy?

Having Shredder in my opinion come back as a villain would just cement in my mind that he's never going to get some proper growth as a character and a villain if he's going to just find another new reason to want vengeance against the turtles again.

Honestly, while having him return would be cool, I'm more inclined if Karai or someone else became the villain afterwards. Heck, even Koya would be a cool replacement for Shredder just off the notion that she's doing what she was taught to believe.

I would get a chuckle if Shredder turned out to be evil because he's just terrible at being a good guy (Say, for example, he had to kill Donatello because he realized there was something wrong with him, but came off as an asshole again), then maybe?

CyberCubed 05-25-2025 08:56 PM

He doesn't have to be completely evil, but nuanced. But yeah him turning on the Turtles again better have good writing behind it given he's more or less made peace with them existing.

TheLabRat 05-26-2025 02:38 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by GameCobra (Post 2008929)
Having Shredder in my opinion come back as a villain would just cement in my mind that he's never going to get some proper growth as a character and a villain if he's going to just find another new reason to want vengeance against the turtles again.

Honestly, while having him return would be cool, I'm more inclined if Karai or someone else became the villain afterwards. Heck, even Koya would be a cool replacement for Shredder just off the notion that she's doing what she was taught to believe.

I would get a chuckle if Shredder turned out to be evil because he's just terrible at being a good guy (Say, for example, he had to kill Donatello because he realized there was something wrong with him, but came off as an asshole again), then maybe?

Since Splinter gives Shredder a chance and he throw it away, I hope they don't write another preachy plots to try to make them sympathize with Shredder and even redeem him again. Let Shredder face his failure and the consequences. No one like to see any characters being erratic and indecisive, and too bad, this has happen to most of IDW TMNT characters.

Andrew NDB 05-26-2025 02:45 AM

I think in something like IDW TMNT, where I presume the general idea is that the TMNT do age, but slowly, and we don't talk ages, they are "evergreen." Like Marvel or DC. Not like Mirage at all. So with that in mind... of course Shredder will shift allegiances over the years. Think of him like Magneto in Marvel or something. I'm pretty sure I've read many times he's teamed with the X-Men and then become the Big Bad many times as well.

In Mirage, of course, very different.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:42 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.