![]() |
Shredder #1 preview and discussion
Spoiler:
|
Spoiler:
|
So Shredder is going the anti-hero route ?
This issue introduces a lot of mysteries, Saki went through a lot but we don't know what yet (but we have an idea of what haunts him), I am intrigued. Oh by the way, I love the new character design |
Also why is Shredder all gray now? Did he age a lot somehow? What happened when he was in space.
|
I really like this issue a lot and I’m excited for the future of this series. I am also confused why Shredder is all grey as well? Didn’t Kitsune enhance his body and made him kind of immortal from the ooze hibernation? Maybe something he dealt with reversed that?
|
Quote:
|
This issue felt pretty empty, a whole lot of things happened from Shredder being back on Earth, killing some random Foot soldiers, apparently having a black female student we've never seen before who is now stronger than him, and then getting recruited by Dark Water and the EPF? What on earth.
A whole lot of things happened but it all felt pretty random. IDW's mini's really need to stop stretching out stories over 4-5 issues, taking individually each single issue feels like nothing much until you read them all together. And not getting to see anything of Shredder in space is disappointing even if we might get flashbacks in the next few issues. I'd rather the story be set there. |
Quote:
What was the worm **** about? Were they trying to evoke Mirage? Because Shredder has died and been resurrected twice in IDW and neither time involved the worms of yore. I also typically don’t like it when the Foot has non-Japanese members, minus a few exclusions. And this new character didn’t do anything special enough to interest me anyway. I’ll probably pass on the rest of this mini. |
About their symbol, not sure if they want to make IDW version Ninja Tribunal or it's just coincide. But I agreed with the new character didn't impress me much right now. Why not have Karai be Shredder's rival?
|
I wouldn't describe this issue as empty, this a new Shredder we're facing. And yes, he aged.
Spoiler:
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
I hope we won't get to see character regression, but I don't mind to witness his character going through a tragic fate. Edit : Shredder going from his redemption arc to a dark path again could already be considered as character regression |
Quote:
|
Yes, have the IDW TMNT bring their rogue's gallery before side characters like Alopex and ask, "Excuse me... can you kill our villains for us? Nickelodeon won't let us, but you can."
|
Quote:
It could be a way to make Karai a bigger threat, that might work. |
Quote:
The IDW Turtles can't kill because of their code, but they can mutilate characters (Koya, Bludgeon, Bishop) which is kinda violent, and somehow weird. At least it made Splinter's antagonist arc interesting, even if it is controversial among the fanbase. |
Quote:
|
Even Splinter broke the code he taught his sons. Their powers and skill are nowhere near that of Batman, who at least beat the villains and send them to prison most of the times.
Quote:
Donnie still suffer the trauma of B&R, he didn't seek any means to improve his strength besides just changing to prosthetic shell, and his brothers never sought revenge on B&R for what they did to Donnie. |
Yeah, Batman has the skill, resources and necessary trauma to resort to non-lethal methods. He also needs to stay on the good side of the GCPD.
The turtles are NINJA engaging in hand to hand combat with deadly melee weapons. They can not afford to be captured and they would do anything to protect each other. There is absolutely no reason why they shouldn’t be willing and able to take a life, other than a corporate mandate. |
Well taking a life is no small thing.
In The Last Ronin, the turtles have no issue killing because it seems the Turtles are written as warriors. In IDW, killing is forbidden and it is a strong part of the Turtles' identities. Early on the run, Leonardo was feeling guilty for seemingly killing Slash. "No killing" was established as a core belief, so that's why Shredder couldn't make brainwashed Leo kill people. It makes sense in a story to make killing as a moral issue. The killers are menacing antagonists because they have no remorse killing (Shredder, Krang, B&R, Leatherhead, etc...) while the turtles are heroes protecting their sanity. Slash commiting suicide was meaningful because he felt guilty for all the horrors he did... |
If they actually let Dark Leo kill people, perhaps it would make their pursuit of no kill in later story more justified. At least Leo has become more averse to killing because this experience and PTSD.
|
I am still of the mind that for that story to have fully landed, it NEEDED to end with Dark Leo killing someone, and having that be the thing that finally snapped him out of it. Then the grief processing in IDW's Northampton arc would have had a lot more meaning behind it, and the City Fall story as a whole would have felt more consequential.
|
Yeah, that was literally the moment I tuned out. If Nick didn't want the TMNT to kill... eugh... that's stupid, but Leo being mind-warped should have been the one time they were allowed to. To then make some big story/character bit about now WHY they don't kill in Leo's subsequent redemption. I tend to believe that was absolutely the plan and maybe Waltz and company were led to believe they'd be able to do that... then at the 11th hour they were shut down. Or they finished the comic and got a note about, "Wait... Leonardo is going to kill people? ABSOLUTELY NOT!" and they had to revise everything.
It was all a big nothingburger. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
First of all, it was a complete accident, so why mope? Also, we the reader knew Slash survived, so it was a total eye roller. But the big question is… why weren’t they all trying to kill Slash? This massive brute is being totally out of control and violently trying to kill them, why not take him out? How would Leo have felt if Mikey got killed because he wasn’t willing to properly defend himself? |
Beside their different personalities, I think it's because, even in their past lives, they still lived like normal kids most of time. Splinter only trained his kids to use weapons for self-defense, but didn't teach them how to be prepared to kill. Another issue is that even in the modern timeline, I feel IDW Splinter is a bit self-deceiving. He told his children to help and protect others, but this actually puts his own children in danger, especially since they're mutants. Regardless, they're ultimately forced to confront violence and killing.
Like I said, once he's done with his revenge, he should take the turtles out of New York and start a new life anywhere away from the Foot Clan and other enemies, even to Dimension X. Let the villains kill each other for their own benefit until they may eventually destroy themselves. Mirage Turtles have no memories of human past lives, so they don't need to empathize with their enemies. Mirage Splinter used them as his tools of revenge from the beginning, although he also treated them as his own children. Mirage Turtles do kill criminal and help their friends, but they have no any obligation and were never intended to be the guardian angels. |
Quote:
I actually enjoyed how IDW Splinter was portrayed as a complex and gray character : he was always caring for his family but at the same time was ready to kill anyone who threatened it... But you have the right to prefer another type of story, that's okay. |
Quote:
A father at war with a ninja clan that killed his wife should be raising killers. To teach them not to is rather uncaring. But maybe he knows they have plot armor lol. |
Quote:
|
Yeah no one has ever been able to make any sense of Shredder in Hell/#100 for me.
|
It was Splinter who kill the evil dragon god. lol
Wouldn't it make more sense to have Shredder make a greater sacrifice to redeem himself just like Darth Vader? |
Quote:
It's kinda funny that in Shredder in Hell, Saki was helped by Splinter only to end up allowing the Dragon's resurection. "That's cool bro but I want to see my wife". At least he tried to make ammends to the Hamato |
|
Quote:
There is a chance Paul or Tristan approved of it if Paul's doing one of the "variant" covers, but this still seems repugnant to do with basically an unpolished character. |
Quote:
Sorry this thread has turned into such a player haters ball haha |
So far I’m not convinced they paired the book with the right artist. Obviously talented but I’d imagine something a little grittier for Shredder to try and hook that older TLR crowd.
This just feels a bit too clean, but we’re only one issue in so I could be convinced. |
Just curious what made him so angry, saying that technology, magic, honor, etc., are all false splendors. But honestly, it's a harsh to say this, but it's true that IDW Shredder would be nothing without Kitsune.
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:38 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.