The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   What does IDW have left to cover or adapt from existing TMNT lore? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=67848)

CyberCubed 11-11-2025 01:03 PM

What does IDW have left to cover or adapt from existing TMNT lore?
 
IDW has added a ton of new stuff to the universe but a lot of their characters and plotlines are loose adaptions of stuff done in previous series. What is left to cover? I've been thinking of all the major elements in past universes and IDW has covered nearly all of them:

City at War? Adapted.
Return to New York? Adapted
Turtles in Space? Adapted
Battle Nexus tournament? Adapted
Shredder coming back to life at least once? Adapted
Neutrinos vs. Rock Soldiers/Krang Dimension X war? Adapted
Triceraton invasion of Earth? Adapted
Turtles traveling through time with Renet? Adapted
Turtles meeting dinosaurs in the prehistoric? Adapted
Turtles traveling to a dystopian future? Adapted
Mutanimals and mutant allies? Adapted
Baxter working for Shredder? Adapted
Shredder creating mutant henchmen? Adapted
Karai taking over the Foot Clan and surpassing Shredder? Adapted
Turtles training mystic arts, magic powers, or the Astral plane? Adapted
EPF and Bishop hunting the Turtles or other mutants and aliens? Adapted
Area 51 with Mr. Braunze? Adapted
Northampton arc? Adapted
Baxter using fly or cyborg stuff? Adapted, although Baxter himself stayed human
Purple Dragons and other NY rival gangs fighting or with the Foot? Adapted
Leatherhead befriending the Turtles after going crazy? Adapted
Other humans forming mutant hate groups? Adapted
Metalhead both working with the Turtles and going rogue? Adapted.
Null and her group? Adapted
Cudley and Cherubae and other Archie exclusive Gods or Dimension X characters? Adapted
Stump Asteroid? Adapted
Turtles fighting monsters/skeletons/zombies? Loosely adapted
Don turning into a cyborg or getting a new shell? Loosely adapted
Raphael going off on his own? Adapted
Bebop and Rocksteady? Adapted
Hun and his connection to Casey and the Purple Dragons? Adapted
Turtles mutating into gamera forms? I don't believe this one was handled yet

And this is on top of like 90% of the important Mirage, Fred Wolf/Playmates, and Archie characters have now appeared in the series at some point or another. There are a few who still haven't (Chrome Dome has never been in IDW...lol), but I think they covered the bulk of the pre-2012 Nick characters.

Heyowakka 11-11-2025 01:06 PM

They haven’t formed a boy band, gone on tour and defeated Shredder with the power of music yet.

Zog The Magnificent 11-11-2025 01:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Heyowakka (Post 2017025)
They haven’t formed a boy band, gone on tour and defeated Shredder with the power of music yet.

No, but they DID form a band and defeat Bebop and Rocksteady with the power of music so hard that they didn't even compete :trolleye:. That might be close enough.

ToTheNines 11-11-2025 01:46 PM

First of all, I want to refute your first couple of points. RTNY wasn’t really adapted. They just unceremoniously come back to NYC after a 4-issue Northampton arc. The closest thing to RTNY is Vengeance. It was really good and they did have the balls to behead Shredder, but it’s still not RTNY.

And that’s a HARD NO on City at War from me, dawg. There was no reason to call that arc CaW and it shares nothing with the Mirage version outside of name and cast of characters.

Anyway:

1. Would be fun to see their take on the Image run. Raph takes on the Shredder mantle and leads some rogue Foot ninja against Karai? All while Saki is around this time, as well as Splinter (the other recent Jonin of the Foot).

Pimiko doesn’t exactly work as Shredder’s daughter in IDW, but she could be a descendant or some kind of relative to Karai.

2. The Shredder Clones don’t really have a reason to exist in IDW, but they’re such a TMNT staple that their absence feels weird.

3. They brought in Venus years ago, why not Dragonlord and The Rank?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Zog The Magnificent (Post 2017026)
No, but they DID form a band and defeat Bebop and Rocksteady with the power of music so hard that they didn't even compete :trolleye:. That might be close enough.

That was honestly cornier than CootS.

CyberCubed 11-11-2025 01:59 PM

Hm, I forgot the Shredder clones, I guess they could still appear. 4kids had the Shredder clones appear when Shredder was an Utrom, so it didn't even make sense in that series for Shredder to make clones of himself since he was still alive...and not even human, lol.

I'm surprised IDW hasn't found a way to throw them in.

Andrew NDB 11-11-2025 02:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 2017029)
3. They brought in Venus years ago, why not Dragonlord and The Rank?

Yeah, it's not that hard to imagine ways to make the Dragonlord and The Rank "cool." Although, if you're burning those kind of calories... why not make new characters?

In fact, what are the universally considered "Good" characters at IDW that are entirely original? Old Hob is one, of course (if you ignore Scratch and Hallocat I guess). What are some others?

ToTheNines 11-11-2025 02:39 PM

Other than Hob? Harold Lilja was a fun character for a while. Kitsune was cool back when the Pantheon was still a mystery.

That’s pretty much it though right? Jennika sucked before she got mutated. Hale sucked. Everyone else is an adapted character.

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 2017030)
Hm, I forgot the Shredder clones, I guess they could still appear. 4kids had the Shredder clones appear when Shredder was an Utrom, so it didn't even make sense in that series for Shredder to make clones of himself since he was still alive...and not even human, lol.

I'm surprised IDW hasn't found a way to throw them in.

They weren’t actually his clones in 4kids. The only time they were referred to as such in-universe was Donatello’s dialogue of “my guess is genetic clones of The Shredder”.

I always assumed they were a product of the Foot genetics division related to the Underground mutants and they decided to slap Shredder armor on them for some reason.

CyberCubed 11-11-2025 03:41 PM

Technically they did the Turtle/Don as a cyborg plot but with future Jennika in an alternate dystopian future as a cyborg instead. :lol: Also Don used a magic crystal pencil similar to Mirage's with Kirby's to "draw" his own Turtle children, one of which disappeared like the drawings usually do, but two Turtle children stayed for some reason. So I guess Don still has two fully grown "turtle kids" somewhere?

The end of Sophie's run was completely bonkers. :lol:

neatoman 11-11-2025 03:50 PM

Well, there are the Y'Lyntians, them and their relatively complicated form of mutation reversal would be perfect for IDW in terms of... You know... Setting things right without causing too many problems. So that would be on the top of the list I want to see that hasn't happened yet.

After that? Well, let's see what hasn't been mentioned in this thread yet, that would be:
  • Radical and Complete Carnage
  • Jhanna
  • Oroku Nagi
  • Robyn O'Neil
  • Kirby and his magic drawings (if I am not mistaken)
  • Amai (though obviously she'd have to be a baby)
  • Gabe and Shadow
  • C.R.A.P. or their 4Kids counterpart H.A.T.E.
  • Uncle Augie and his dimension box
  • The Justice Force
  • The Salamandrians
  • Nano
  • The Brotherhood
  • C.F. Volpehart
  • The Ninja Tribunal
And... Well, way too many Mirage one-off antagonists than is worth putting on the list but still deserve some more attention.

CyberCubed 11-11-2025 03:55 PM

Mr. Marlin from Tales/Leatherhead's debut in Mirage will be making his IDW debut soon. He's not going to be hunting Leatherhead though.

Nagi, Robyn O'Neil, Gabe, will all be pretty impossible to include in IDW at this point. I could see Shadow but only if they do a time-skip or they make her April/Casey's biological daughter. The Ninja Tribunal have been largely replaced with the Pantheon, which serve the same purpose mostly.

Andrew NDB 11-11-2025 04:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 2017034)
Other than Hob? Harold Lilja was a fun character for a while. Kitsune was cool back when the Pantheon was still a mystery.

That’s pretty much it though right? Jennika sucked before she got mutated. Hale sucked. Everyone else is an adapted character.

That's nuts to me.

sdp 11-11-2025 04:11 PM

The Yaotl 2007
Mr Ogg
Saint Turtles JP
I don't expect them to but I like these stries.

ToTheNines 11-11-2025 05:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 2017038)
That's nuts to me.

I mean, if you really dig there’s some more.

- ALOPEX, duh! Kind of a Ninjara expy, but technically original. I liked her better as a villain.
- Gothano, Toad Baron and Aka from the Pantheon.
- Professor Miller from Secret History of the Foot. I actually really liked him and was pissed when they killed him off.
- Oroku Maji, Master Masato and the other characters from ancient Japan. Takeshi Tatsuo was a cool concept.
- Zodi the scorpion bitch. Not that memorable but I really liked that opening TMNT Universe story.
- Fabrice and his French parkour ninja gang lol. Only existed to be jobbers.
- Koya and Bludgeon. They’re not bad. Oh and Natsu.
- Herman and Sally from the Mutanimals. And Lindsey.

Hypered will probably show up and drop 10-15 more that I’m forgetting lol

frank_one 11-11-2025 05:55 PM

IDW Turtles haven't met Flaming Carrot yet.

ToTheNines 11-11-2025 06:13 PM

IDW has used a few characters from the Red Sky era, but not many. Lord Dregg is a big one.

They also used Darius Dun from FF. They could still do Sho’Kanabo and Viral. The Inuwashi Gunjin. Torbin Zixx, etc.

Quote:

Originally Posted by frank_one (Post 2017043)
IDW Turtles haven't met Flaming Carrot yet.

Or Cerebus!

hypered1 11-11-2025 06:17 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 2017042)
I mean, if you really dig there’s some more.

- ALOPEX, duh! Kind of a Ninjara expy, but technically original. I liked her better as a villain.
- Gothano, Toad Baron and Aka from the Pantheon.
- Professor Miller from Secret History of the Foot. I actually really liked him and was pissed when they killed him off.
- Oroku Maji, Master Masato and the other characters from ancient Japan. Takeshi Tatsuo was a cool concept.
- Zodi the scorpion bitch. Not that memorable but I really liked that opening TMNT Universe story.
- Fabrice and his French parkour ninja gang lol. Only existed to be jobbers.
- Koya and Bludgeon. They’re not bad. Oh and Natsu.
- Herman and Sally from the Mutanimals. And Lindsey.

Hypered will probably show up and drop 10-15 more that I’m forgetting lol

I believe Natsu is proxy for Tatsu from the movies.

New characters, outside of the Mutant Town denizens, I can give you Ravenwood and Dr. barlow off the top of my head.

TheLabRat 11-11-2025 07:40 PM

- Super Turtles and Sliver
- The Great Turtle and Adversary
- Go-Komodo and King Komodo
- Mistress/Tang Amaya

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 2017023)
Karai taking over the Foot Clan and surpassing Shredder?

Unless we eventually see her beat and even kill Saki.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 2017032)
Yeah, it's not that hard to imagine ways to make the Dragonlord and The Rank "cool." Although, if you're burning those kind of calories... why not make new characters?

In fact, what are the universally considered "Good" characters at IDW that are entirely original? Old Hob is one, of course (if you ignore Scratch and Hallocat I guess). What are some others?

Bludgeon, Harold and Ravenwood.

I don't like Koya, especially that forced romance between her and Leo is gross. Make Leo fall in love with a femme fatale is character assassination.

Old Hob and Alopex once had good potential, until the writers stopped making them villains.

GameCobra 11-11-2025 09:27 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheLabRat (Post 2017048)
- Super Turtles and Sliver
- The Great Turtle and Adversary
- Go-Komodo and King Komodo
- Mistress/Tang Amaya


Unless we eventually see her beat and even kill Saki.


Bludgeon, Harold and Ravenwood.

I don't like Koya, especially that forced romance between her and Leo is gross. Make Leo fall in love with a femme fatale is character assassination.

Old Hob and Alopex once had good potential, until the writers stopped making them villains.

To be honest, Koya is a cool replacement for Alopex when she went good, but I feel like she could've been much better as Alopex's rival. I couldn't believe this wasn't a missed opportunity.

That being said, I do agree that Alopex works either way as both Shredder's mutant troop leader along with Karai and as another non-mutant side kick for the turtles. I really coudln't see anything wrong with Alopex and Venus being on the turtle's side at one point.

Also, didn't know that alot of IDW was a bunch of mash-ups from old series until this topic, but I do remember the dragonlord being a cap for the old 2012 TMNT? Felt like a good end to the IDW series if there ever will be one.

CyberCubed 11-11-2025 09:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 2017044)

They also used Darius Dun from FF. They could still do Sho’Kanabo and Viral. The Inuwashi Gunjin. Torbin Zixx, etc.

Torbin Zixx actually appeared. They even re-used his hologram gimmick where Raph fell for his hologram and missed kicking him while Torbin was somewhere else.

TheLabRat 11-12-2025 12:09 AM

They also brought Yoshi Chen(Archie) and King Cobra(Mirage) to IDW TMNT.

IDW Yoshi Chen is a descendants of Oroku family. He and his Dog Star Clan is focused on cybernetics and robotics. He is more like Karai's main rival.

IDW King Cobra appeared in Shredder #2. But he just a minor character and bad nostalgia bait.

ToTheNines 11-12-2025 05:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 2017036)
Well, there are the Y'Lyntians, them and their relatively complicated form of mutation reversal would be perfect for IDW in terms of... You know... Setting things right without causing too many problems. So that would be on the top of the list I want to see that hasn't happened yet.

Yeah, the Y’Lyntians are actually a huge part of 4kids lore and they don’t really get talked about much. They were connected to almost every aspect of the show, in some way.

Quote:

Originally Posted by GameCobra (Post 2017051)
but I do remember the dragonlord being a cap for the old 2012 TMNT? Felt like a good end to the IDW series if there ever will be one.

It was the first arc of season 5. Kavaxas doesn’t really have any relation to Dragonlord other than being a big mean dragon guy lol. And they loosely acknowledged that he was the 2012 version of Hothead.

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 2017056)
Torbin Zixx actually appeared. They even re-used his hologram gimmick where Raph fell for his hologram and missed kicking him while Torbin was somewhere else.

I still haven’t finished the Sophie era. Currently on #128.

SFMG 11-13-2025 01:37 AM

I always thought that Max Winters and the stone soldiers could make for a cool 4-5 issue (a single TPB pretty much) filler arc, if done well. Keep him ageless + tie him in to the foot/utroms etc somehow.

neatoman 11-13-2025 08:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SFMG (Post 2017160)
I always thought that Max Winters and the stone soldiers could make for a cool 4-5 issue (a single TPB pretty much) filler arc, if done well. Keep him ageless + tie him in to the foot/introns etc somehow.

Hah, yeah. When the "Winter" character showed up I thought it was going to be him, I didn't even consider the possibility that it was that supervillain from the late FW cartoon who randomly turned himself into a bug by absorbing energy. Max Winters was the apparent antagonist of a movie, maybe not the most popular one but I certainly thought that made him more well known at least than some one-off villain from the largely ignored FW seasons. Considering that all the IDW version of Alex Winter has in common with his FW counterpart is the name and him being a mercenary, it really did just come across like a random reference and not much like an interest in actually using the character. Max Winters, even though the movie didn't go into much detail, did seem like someone worth expanding upon.

Jephael 11-13-2025 08:43 PM

It's funny to me that they haven't utilized Cody Jones from Fast Forward, even though they used Darius Dun and placed him in present day New York. It would be interesting if they were to have April and Casey try to get back together and they end up concieving a child by accident or something. Then again, that's sorta daytime soap opera territory!

CyberCubed 11-13-2025 10:39 PM

I mean they just recently used the Nightwatcher concept from the movie for Jennika, so IDW mining the 2007 movie for ideas clearly isn't off the table.

neatoman 11-13-2025 11:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jephael (Post 2017229)
It's funny to me that they haven't utilized Cody Jones from Fast Forward, even though they used Darius Dun and placed him in present day New York. It would be interesting if they were to have April and Casey try to get back together and they end up concieving a child by accident or something. Then again, that's sorta daytime soap opera territory!

Yeah, the entire point of Cody is that he is the descendant of Casey and April which would require either time travel or the two of them actually have a kid in the main timeline. I can see them doing the former and the main consequence I see is that... a certain someone here... would complain that it would disconfirm the mutant wasteland future as the definitive timeline... As for the latter, I'm not seeing them doing that since it would be a commitment they may not be willing to make, time travel is one thing because what's depicted is just a possible timeline, not something they are forced to deal with indefinitely. I mean, why do you think Batman having a biological child of his own was left for possible futures or alternate realities, and out of the main timeline for 67 years?

SFMG 11-23-2025 01:48 AM

The Incredible Shrinking Turltes, or Eye of Sarnath in general, lends itself well to a mini or ongoing arc. It’s early enough in the 87 series they were at least trying to be serious. Again, could easily tie into broader Foot/space arcs.

Andrew NDB 11-23-2025 02:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 2017237)
I mean they just recently used the Nightwatcher concept from the movie for Jennika, so IDW mining the 2007 movie for ideas clearly isn't off the table.

It'll be interesting to see in the future what people born after the 2007 movie even came out will mine from that. They will have a completely different perspective on it than you or I. What seemed like such a minor footnote may become like a major wellspring.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:41 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.