![]() |
How well/poorly has the 4Kids series aged?
I made a thread like this for the FW cartoon recently, so might as well make one for the 2k3 series as well!
I think the 2k3 series aged well for the most part because it was a bit ahead of its time with its very strong continuity in an era where streaming was not a thing yet at all and you still had to get up every weekend morning to catch the latest episode of your favorite cartoon. The show came out a few years before youtube was even founded, remember. It also holds up well in terms of animation quality since it doesn't have the bad animation errors the FW series had. What elements from the 2k3 series didn't age well? I'd say the Guardians due to them being nods to the Matrix franchise. Matrix was a very popular series of movies around 1999-2003. Probably the hottest movie franchise of that time period alongside the Star Wars prequels, really. But someone who was either a baby or not born at the time yet might not "get it". I haven't seen the Matrix in years and in fact I've only seen the OG one 20+ years ago, so I have no idea if those movies hold up to this day or not. Or if they're still culturally relevant in 2025. You see and hear people making Die Hard and Terminator references, but the Matrix references? Well there's the blue pill and red pill meme which is quite popular I guess. |
Star Wars
The energy swords make the Guardians a Star Wars reference.
|
Quote:
|
Something I tend to give this show credit for, at least in comparison to the other TMNT, is that the overarching is actually well constructed. The order of episodes that adapted issues don't feel as random as the actual comic. It just makes more to have most of the pre-CaW Foot stories to happen before they go to space and the "let's hang out at the farm for leisure" stories after the looming threat of Shredder is taken care of. And even though it is a somewhat unnecessary change that rub people the wrong way, I can't really say the Utrom Shredder twist was bad. It's well foreshadowed and it makes more to reveal he's something more than a glorified gangster if he's going to remain the main villain after a series of villains who could easily crush a regular gangster emerge. It has also introduced a lot of elements that that have lasted after it ended and, at least in my opinion, are more welcome than much of what the subsequent 2012 tried to make a thing and such subsequent influence has helped diminish the idea that the FW cartoon should be seen as some "definitive" version all others need to emulate.
As for what hasn't really aged well? The otherwise well structured plot does mean some hiccups become especially noticeable, in particular the Shredder clones are a weird one, they were adapted from the comic but make absolutely no sense in context of this show. The later retconning of there having been a different Shredder doesn't raise too many questions because they did try to explain most of the weird implications there, but in doing so they established that Splinter already knew the Utrom one was an alien impostor, which is... Yeah... And the last two seasons really did just let the show devolve in generic kids' entertainment, I'm pretty sure "the annoying family comes to visit" and "siblings bicker over a cool thing" are ideas I've seen in other kids' cartoon plenty of times and I don't think using the Turtles to tell those stories is all that fitting. And this one needs it's own paragraph because I'd like to emphasise that is something all the TMNT cartoons do and it's inherently annoying: Whenever the show emphasises the need to market a toy, it's incredibly distracting. Insane in the Membrane is an otherwise dark and well made episode... Which is briefly undercut by Donatello feeling the need to advertise all the bells and whistles of the new car... Yeah, it's only 20 seconds long but remove those 20 seconds and remove the absolute worst part of that episode, it's that annoying. Again, all of these cartoons do this, it's not unique to this show but it is a flaw nonetheless. Then there are two potential problems going forward in terms of aging, not a problem now exactly but might be one day:
|
It’s aged pretty poorly if you ask me. Ham-fisted dialogue and voice acting, overused stock animation and music themes, mostly toothless combat, some pretty glaring plot holes and some ghastly Mirage adaptions.
I still have fond memories of those days. I thought it should have won every Emmy imaginable when it was coming out lol. I was always very frustrated that it didn’t get more attention, but it seems to be very well liked over on Reddit nowadays. I think it’s still accessible to kids, if they find it on Paramount+ or whatever. It currently seems to be my kid’s preferred version. |
Well, I definitely loved watching TMNT ‘03 when it first came out, though I am due for a rewatch. I feel like it probably hasn’t aged as well as ‘87 has due to its absurdist humor or the 2012 show will have when it’s time comes.
Out of the three it definitely has the worst voice acting and voice direction. The dialogue is also pretty cringy. ‘03 is also a strong contender for the having the absolute worst version of Michelangelo as well. Between ‘87 and ‘03, if I had to choose I’d always choose ‘87 without hesitation. Despite its shortcomings, ‘87 is just too close to my heart compared to ‘03, but thankfully I don’t have to choose and can rewatch both at my leisure. |
Quote:
|
I remember the first season being pretty well-outlined, with good momentum between Shredder episodes and street-level stuff. The continuity felt fluid without having a forced "theme" like FF or BttS. But this went out the window in season 2, which had a lot of one-offs which never interested me, and it never regained that up-and-down momentum which the first season had.
I'm sure if I watched an episode today I'd be irritated by all the bad dialogue I tuned out as a kid. I recently checked out the old music edits I'd done and was really put off by how cheesy the score was to that show. For every cool music cue in an episode there are probably five really mediocre-to-bad ones. |
There's no bad dialogue that we didn't know back when it aired. If you look at the old review threads from 2003-2005, people were already complaining about some of Mikey's lines or some of the lame "humor" in certain eps. All this was well known even when it aired. The old review threads were filled with this and remember most people posting back then were in their teens in the early 2000's so we were closer to the target audience of the show than we are now.
I don't recall stock animation outside City at War part 1 where they re-used the same Foot animation fights from a previous ep. But that was the only time I remember them doing it (when Leo blocks like 3 swords with his katana and does the round house kick). Despite the Turtles not being able to stab human enemies, the fight choreography is quite good for the majority of the show. The Turtles make use of the surroundings too depending where they're fighting. Bishop's fight scenes are still the best of the series. |
Quote:
Also, I enjoyed Mikey as a character for the most part. He didn’t get insufferable until season 2. |
Quote:
Not that much re-used stock footage iirc. I don't think some of the ghastly Mirage adaptations have anything to do with the show aging poorly, imo. It's not like a modern day TMNT cartoon would be unable to fumble some of those Mirage's adaptations either. Isn't that a running theme in comics? I am not into comics much outside of the Turtles, but I always see fans bemoaning how poorly adapted canon events and issues in superhero comics are in cartoons and movies. The voice acting is not as good as Fred Wolf's, I agree. As for the bad dialogue, saying "ah, shell!" and "what the shell!" sounded edgy to me when I was a kid but looking back it is a bit cringe. Quote:
|
Look, I like this show. I do. There's something to like about each of the first three TMNT cartoons. Even Rise, to some extent.
I'm a plot guy, and this show has a good plot. I will always enjoy it, and I'll even be generous and not hold the last two seasons against it. I don't ever rewatch them, and season 5 is a suitable ending for the show. https://i.ytimg.com/vi/351Aa5q_S98/maxresdefault.jpg HOWEVER, The dialogue, and the voice acting, is just... so cheesy. Cheesy at the best, kind of actually bad at the worst. I can look past it, because I'm here for the story, but it's really not very good. It's a large factor in why I think the 2012 show is the best one. I'd say that's the aspect of this show as a whole that's aged the worst. It's certainly the thing that makes sharing it with someone else who's uninitiated the hardest. |
I rewatched 2k3, (although people now just call it 2003, am I too much of a boomer for still calling it 2k3? :tlol:) like 10 years ago. And at least in 2015 it still seemed a very good show that had aged well, but I'm honestly afraid to check it out again and be disappointed.
|
Quote:
If you still massively enjoyed it in 2015 then I don't see why you'd be disappointed in watching it again in 2025/2026. Unless cartoons changed radically from 2016 on to the point of making cartoons like TMNT 2k3 completely obsolete. I don't watch cartoons anymore so I honestly have no idea. I only watch anime. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
And I don't see people typing 2k25 instead of 2025 when referring to the actual year itself. Only for games like WWE 2k25 and NBA 2k25, etc. 2K named them that way for the same reason SNES gamess often were preceded by "Super" and Nintendo 64 games were proceeded by "64" in their titles. No one thought Mega Man 64 or Super Mario 64 meant that they were the 64th games of their respective series. FIFA 64 could confuse some kids nowadays, though. Hell, back then I remember mentioning FIFA 64 in school and they'd laugh at me and say "FIFA 64? That doesn't exist!" and I'd have to remind them "No, idiots. 64 as in the Nintendo 64, not the year of 1964." |
I watched it the whole way through for the first time when it came out on dvd. I remember that I liked it quite a lot, but not quite as much as the 87 or 2012 Turtles. The plots were really cool and it seems like it had pretty good writing, good voice actors, and good villains. I need to watch it the whole way through again.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Something else about this show that I’ve had a near complete inversion on: when I was a kid, I desperately wanted every episode to be a Shredder/Foot episode, or at least a Mirage adaption. I would be pretty annoyed by “filler” or some of the original stories.
Now? The Shredder/Foot stuff is kinda boring and I’d rather watch the goofy stuff like Garbageman or even Fast Foward lol |
Eh, nah, the Shredder/Foot eps are the highlight of the show still. Only exception is the City at War eps, but I like all the others. The ones in Seasons 3 and 4 especially are all great, as well as the Foot adjacent eps that just had either Karai or Hun in them.
|
Yeah season 3 and 4 started getting a little more original with it. Exodus was especially fun. But all the season 1 and 2 stuff was “kinda like mirage but way worse”.
It was all very exhilarating as a young kid watching it all unfold, but now that I’m older I’d rather re-read Mirage than see the kiddie version of it. At least when 2012 went to the Mirage well, it was very visually interesting. |
Quote:
As an adult who read vol. 1... they really messed up on a lot of those. I think the ones in space in season 2 were the best adaptations. Ok, they changed that traitorous female Federation soldier's payment from drugs to jewelry, but that's perfectly understandable since it's a kids' cartoon. 4Kids created some cool characters like Hun and Bishop... but it also created lame ones like the Garbageman, Toh cand Go and that masculine woman from that filler episode in season 2. Fortunately, those were in 1-2 episodes at best. But Garbageman was going to get a 3rd episode lol Honestly, for a show that was well-known at the time for being much closer to the source material... it really wasn't all that close to it overall. Especially after season 2. And even by season 2 the show was starting to move away from Mirage, anyway. The Ultimate Ninja, Daimyo and Battle Nexus are 4Kids creations. |
Quote:
It's cool that you get those parts recreated visually and all, sure, but what's the point? To shoehorn in a moment from a practically unrelated story? Had the plot not involved the Kraang and just been the Foot tracking down the Turtles and them being forced to flee because of that alone, like in three other versions, then it would have actually made more sense to keep the fight. Honestly, the 2012 show does that kind of stuff a lot, I recently made a thread isolating the part about Baxter mutating and pointing out that it makes so little sense in context, that the FW version of it actually made more sense, so it all just felt like a hamfisted way of doing an homage: https://forums.thetechnodrome.com/sh...ad.php?t=67892 In fact, one of the reasons I'd consider these sorts of homages to a big reason for why the 2012 show tends to get a lot of undeserved praise. Yeah, you do get to see something that reminds you of something else and/or that you get to see something old show back up again, which then tickles your fancy and all that. But a lot of it seems to just be there to be there, not because it makes sense in context or because it was something anyone wanted to do long term. There are more problems that just these homages being shallow, but I shouldn't go into detail about those ones here. I know this isn't the "How well/poorly has the 2012 series aged?" thread and we're probably like 2.5 years away from it being appropriate to make that thread. It's just that I already noticed some serious problems in the second season that made watching the rest when it was still on to be rather frustrating, and looking back at it years later, those problems bug me even more. It's fine as a kids' cartoon but that's all it is to me, fine as children's entertainment and I don't find anything that's particularly impressive about it. I don't exactly think another 2.5 years is going to make me consider the 2012 to be much better. |
I think “The King” and “The Christmas Aliens” were two of the best adaptions. And part of me thinks that’s why 2012 never touched either of them, but that might be schizo to think.
The Baxter/Mouser stuff was pretty good, too. Quote:
EDIT: just saw neatoman’s post. Will reply later. |
Quote:
The King? Was that the one with The Rat King? Good episode, I agree. But The Christmas episode based on that Mikey issue? I disagree. The Mirage issue is more wholesome in it as is Mirage Mikey during that issue. 2k3 Mikey was always a bit obnoxious. |
“The King” was Donatello #1
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
Turtle Nexus
Turtle Nexus discussed these years a couple of days ago
|
Quote:
|
When I was lurking back in ‘03-‘04 the only anti 4kids show sentiment was from FW fans that thought it was “too different” from the old show. Which is such a weird thing to say about this show when no one ever complained about the 1990 movie in that way.
|
I remember a lot of, "Why is Baxter Stockman black?" or "Why is April not a reporter?" posts from when the show first starting airing. As said, it's bizarre since people already knew other versions of TMNT existed besides the original show by then.
Also people were mad Michelangelo wasn't bringing up pizza 24/7 or saying cowabunga in every episode. |
I remember having similar thoughts when the show first started airing, the only version of the turtles I knew about were the Fred Wolf, Movie, and Archie Turtles.
I think it wasn’t until a few years later I discovered the Mirage Turtles when we got a computer and internet access at home and it was like, “oh, hey! that explains why the 4kids cartoon is the way it is!” followed by, “oh $&@#! THAT explains the first game’s NES cover!” :lol: |
If you didn’t have internet, that makes sense. But if you had internet and were a big enough TMNT fan to be on here pre-2003, how the **** did you not know about Mirage?
I got back into TMNT probably early 2002 and was thrilled to see you could read Mirage #1 on the old official site. I immediately fell in love, but was only 10 and didn’t have a local comic shop anyways. So you know my bored ass was on the dial-up constantly reading all the comic synopses and squinting at the 4 sh*tty scans they did for each issue (most can still be found here: https://www.miragelicensing.com/html/comic-history.html) They were right there. What the hell else were you supposed to do from 1999-2002? |
The moment I found their website, I was doing the exact same thing, reading all the synopses and killing my eyes trying to make out every little detail on those tiny comic pages :lol:
|
Quote:
"Why don't their eyes have irises?!" "Why are they in space?! Ninja Turtles for me is New York!" "Why aren't they acknowledged by the public and considered heroes?!" :lol::roll: Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
Remember reading the daily comic strip? There were some fun ones! |
I tried my best to educate the casuals in the early 2000's about TMNT. I was already in High School when the 4kids series was airing, so I did my best to "hold down the fort" so to speak.
I considered myself, "the great TMNT educator" and try to educate all those casuals why the 2k3 series was different than the original cartoon. Some of them really needed to be educated. And many of them needed to be dealt with, swiftly and severely. |
Quote:
|
Quote:
|
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 07:32 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.