The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   General TMNT Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=7)
-   -   What character/plot aspects are “non-negotiable” for you between iterations? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=67917)

ToTheNines 12-20-2025 07:02 AM

What character/plot aspects are “non-negotiable” for you between iterations?
 
I was talking with a friend about fanboys/girls getting mad when major changes are made to characters in new takes. Ultimately, I think as long as the change is for the better, fans will be receptive. But sometimes when it’s a small detail, it makes it feel like the new creative team either doesn’t know the history, or they’re being malicious in disregarding it. The random example I thought of was Casey being a Chevy guy.

It’s really only Mirage canon. But in my head, Casey is a diehard Chevy guy no matter the version we’re talking about. It’s such a small detail, but I would be legitimately pissed if some movie came out and he was a Ford enthusiast or something lol. Anyway, here’s some ideas for the rest of the cast:

Shredder and Splinter: Must be Japanese. FUCK white Shredder! And the origin must center on the Oroku-Hamato feud. Even Rise understood this, no matter how rearranged it was.

April: Must be a normal human. And yes I still count Mirage despite her fantastical origin. 2012 and Rise got too out there.

Michelangelo: Must own a pet cat.

Donatello: Donnie is not a pussy! He’s just as deadly as the other 3. I hate when writers act like he’s soft.

Leonardo: I care less about Leo getting reinvented. As much as I liked the Space Heroes thing in 2012, in my head Donnie is the Trekkie and Leo is a Dune fan.

Raphael: Future Raph should lose his left eye at some point. FW and 2012 break the rule.

neatoman 12-20-2025 07:32 AM

Not sure what you mean with Rise April aside from her getting possessed by Karai in the final few episodes.

Anyway, I don't know about "non-negiotiable" but there are certainly aspects I find somewhat distasteful and would prefer to never see again, also there are things I feel should be there:
  • The Ooze should be created by the Utroms and not something any random human can make.
  • Any humanoid animal mutants that appear should start out as regular animals, that whole "humans turning into the last thing they touched" thing just opens up a can of worms.
  • The amount of characters that are these types of mutants should never be so large that you can just introduce new ones without explaining where they came from or fill a town with them, already at 20 aside from the main five is a stretch.
  • The Foot Clan should not be a bunch of robots or origami figures, make them human even if you can't kill them.
  • The Turtles should be actual characters and not some weird excuse to vomit pop culture references and pizza jokes.
  • Characters that were first and foremost created to be action figures should not be treated as integral to the series.
  • The fight scenes should not primarily be weird slapstick.
  • There are four Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, four exactly and their names are Leonardo, Donatello, Raphael and Michelangelo. Maybe a different group shows up in the future after they die, or maybe there are evil clones or something and perhaps even a warped mirror version of them, but the initial group consists of those four Ninja Turtles and no new Ninja Turtle joins them to be part of their group. EVER. Those four are those four, they don't find out they have another sibling, some friend of theirs does not somehow transform into into a ninja turtle, they don't come across a homeless child who is a mutant turtle, they don't find an experiment that is another mutant turtle in a lab and no other thing happens to introduce another Ninja Turtle to the group under any circumstance, GOT IT?

Heyowakka 12-20-2025 07:47 AM

Uh, one: Vernon needs to be louder, angrier and have access to a time machine. Two: Whenever Vernon’s not on screen, all the other characters should be asking, "Where's Vernon?”

Original TMNT Cartoon Fan 12-20-2025 10:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 2019894)
The Ooze should be created by the Utroms and not something any random human can make.

Sure, I wish you were around or older in the early 1990's to tell screenwriters and producers at New Line Cinema that!

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 2019894)
The Foot Clan should not be a bunch of robots or origami figures, make them human even if you can't kill them.

I have never even referred to robots or origami figures used by Shredder as members of the Foot Clan. I don't think henchmen of Shredder who don't follow the ninja code (like Bebop and Rocksteady or other non-ninja henchen in the 2012–2017 Nickelodeon cartoon) should be considered part of the Foot Clan. Just characters like Shredder, Karai and Tatsu.

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 2019894)
The Turtles should be actual characters and not some weird excuse to vomit pop culture references and pizza jokes.

Blame that on how Michelangelo is written, even while fighting, almost all the time.

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 2019894)
The fight scenes should not primarily be weird slapstick.

The exception is if the Turtles are mugged in an alley or have to save someone who is mugged. We don't need epic battles between the Turtles and average street thugs.

CyberCubed 12-20-2025 10:49 AM

April MUST be white. Black April's are so poorly written, they don't feel like April, but also is it just me or are they written with a lot of black stereotypes? Like the writers think making April black is for representation or whatever, but then they write the black April's with as many "black-isms" as they can? Like they're "loud and in charge" and "don't take no thang" from the Turtles or other characters.

If Bebop is used, he MUST be black prior to mutation. Weirdly the Mutant Mayhem Bebop/Rocksteady are the only incarnations that were just animals prior to mutation.

IndigoErth 12-20-2025 12:28 PM

The foundational stuff should be left alone for the most part.

Probably not unknown that I am vehemently against throwing away Leo's normal characterization in an effort to reinvent him...and for what reason? To make him more appealing to people who weren't into him before and have 3 others to choose from?

Same goes for the others, but I take it less personally. And no, cartoon Turtles shouldn't be taken personally, but when you have different architypes as one of basis of their dynamic as a franchise, doing what Rise did to Leo only results in rejecting and excluding those who normally relate to him elsewhere.

Adding to their personalities in ways that work for each of them and fill them out are perfectly fine. But the directions they are going with Leo (stop with the naive and haughty, humility-lacking BS) and Donnie (stop with the nerd stereotypes) lately need to pull back. Mikey, of course, has himself been a long-time victim of being dumbed down, but at least it was actually a plus of MM and Rise that they actually made him less of an idiot. I guess he'd already hit bottom and the only direction was back up.

"You just want the same thing every time!" No, stfu. Why is it hard to grasp wanting new stories, NOT screwing with the characterization and formula. More stores... less reinvention. Because the industry's need to reinvent it every time now is clearly starting to run out of steam and resulting in lame choices. (Really? High school?)


MM seemed like it understood the Turtles more than its direct predecessor at least, but this last season of its series... Eh. Don't get me wrong, it's still a fun watch and fine for what it is, I guess. But they made Leo too incompetent...and dumber. Leo may not be smart in the same ways Donnie is, but he's normally still a pretty bright guy from a different angle. MMTales Leo might be younger and more naive, but that doesn't need to translate to "dumb" in some instances it did in the second season.

ticktack 12-20-2025 01:06 PM

Leo was reinvented away from his original portrayal as an honor-bound, dutiful figure—someone whose near-pathological perfectionism could plausibly tip into obsession or breakdown. Instead, that complexity was flattened after the 2007 movie, which depicted him as haughty, disconnected, and frankly unlikable—an out-of-character take that poisoned later interpretations.

At the same time, Raph became stuck in an equally shallow mold: the perpetually confrontational, brute-force “problematic tough guy.” That distorted version is the one that ended up attracting the loudest, most toxic strain of fandom. And honestly, if those fans are only here for that fake-Raph power fantasy, they can do everyone a favor and leave the forums.

ticktack 12-20-2025 01:24 PM

I don’t mind some changes. What I do dislike are the ones that turn Raph into the “default” personality, because I find that version the least likable.

By contrast, many other changes to TMNT characters sparked little to no outrage—unlike the reaction to Raph in the 2012 TMNT series, when it was announced that his voice actor would be an actor who played a supporting role in The Lord of the Rings.

CyberCubed 12-20-2025 03:57 PM

I mean it's hard to say "keep the Turtles the same" when every series changed the origin over and over:

- Original cartoon had human Hamato Yoshi for the first time

- 4kids/2k3 had Hamato Yoshi working as a Guardian, Shredder is an Utrom, the ancient Feudal Shredder was the "real" Shredder.

- IDW went with the reincarnation origin

- Nick 2012 is mostly similar to before, although April is a teen and Splinter was human once again


Splinter's origin has already widely changed after Mirage every new incarnation too.

ToTheNines 12-21-2025 05:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by neatoman (Post 2019894)
Not sure what you mean with Rise April aside from her getting possessed by Karai in the final few episodes.

I guess she’s a normal human within the context of the Rise universe. I just meant her rabid animal fighting style and magic(?) bat. And her weird pet. She was just a bizarre character and not a regular high school kid.

Quote:

[*]The fight scenes should not primarily be weird slapstick
This is my only problem with the 1990 movie. The final fight with Shredder was good, but everything else is too goofy.

Quote:

[*]There are four Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles, four exactly and their names are Leonardo, Donatello, Raphael and Michelangelo. Maybe a different group shows up in the future after they die, or maybe there are evil clones or something and perhaps even a warped mirror version of them, but the initial group consists of those four Ninja Turtles and no new Ninja Turtle joins them to be part of their group. EVER. Those four are those four, they don't find out they have another sibling, some friend of theirs does not somehow transform into into a ninja turtle, they don't come across a homeless child who is a mutant turtle, they don't find an experiment that is another mutant turtle in a lab and no other thing happens to introduce another Ninja Turtle to the group under any circumstance, GOT IT?
Peter Laird take lol

Quote:

Originally Posted by IndigoErth (Post 2019906)
The foundational stuff should be left alone for the most part.

Probably not unknown that I am vehemently against throwing away Leo's normal characterization in an effort to reinvent him...and for what reason? To make him more appealing to people who weren't into him before and have 3 others to choose from?

In defense of Rise Leo, it was called Rise of the TMNT. They were going to let him grow into his traditional leader role and did so towards the end of season 2 and especially the movie. Would have loved to see more.

Quote:

Originally Posted by ticktack (Post 2019908)
Leo was reinvented away from his original portrayal as an honor-bound, dutiful figure—someone whose near-pathological perfectionism could plausibly tip into obsession or breakdown. Instead, that complexity was flattened after the 2007 movie, which depicted him as haughty, disconnected, and frankly unlikable—an out-of-character take that poisoned later interpretations.

At the same time, Raph became stuck in an equally shallow mold: the perpetually confrontational, brute-force “problematic tough guy.” That distorted version is the one that ended up attracting the loudest, most toxic strain of fandom. And honestly, if those fans are only here for that fake-Raph power fantasy, they can do everyone a favor and leave the forums.

2007 Leo was garbage, but I don’t think he did any harm to subsequent versions. 2012 Leo was great, PD was fine, Rise was a complete reinvention, etc.

Quote:

Originally Posted by ticktack (Post 2019910)
I don’t mind some changes. What I do dislike are the ones that turn Raph into the “default” personality, because I find that version the least likable.

By contrast, many other changes to TMNT characters sparked little to no outrage—unlike the reaction to Raph in the 2012 TMNT series, when it was announced that his voice actor would be an actor who played a supporting role in The Lord of the Rings.

I don’t remember anyone having a problem with Astin. I do remember some low IQ takes about Biggs not being able to voice Leonardo. Some people, myself included, weren’t sure about Paulsen as Donnie.

TheLabRat 12-21-2025 09:28 PM

New mutant turtles characters is not problem, but we don't need fifth and even sixth turtle as part of origin turtles. They should be side character or villain.

The turtles had no reason be guardians or pursuing the common good.

Losing a brother(especially Donnie) doesn't mean this is their doom, they can find other ways to overcome it, and sometimes this allows them to discover their untapped potential.

Karai was never the daughter of Shredder or Splinter. She should at least be on equal with Shredder. Most importantly, Leo never have a thing for her. He only respected her as a warrior, but remained wary of her at all times.

Foot Clan is not a super syndicate. They may have greater influence only in japan, but not enough to control all of japan. They will not recklessly fly helicopters to cause destruction, ignoring other governments and militaries.

Andrew NDB 12-21-2025 11:25 PM

* Yoshi and Oroku Saki have to both be Japanese with familial bad blood. Splinter has to be a direct extension of this.

* Oroku Saki needs to be Japanese.

* The Foot Clan needs to be of Japanese origin.

* The cycle of vengeance should be core. Between Hamato and Oroku. By extension to the Turtles.

* The Ninja Turtles need to be able to kill. Maybe it won't be their first impulse and maybe there can be some general reluctance to kill, but if they're fighting other ninjas trying to kill them then they absolutely will kill.

* The Turtles should be short. Barring that, "normal average human male height," at a maximim.

* No letters on the belts.

* No different skin colors.

* April should be in the den mother or at worst big sister capacity. NOT a love interest.

The rest I'm more or less negotiable with. Obviously I'd prefer no rainbow bandannas. But I know that's a losing battle at this point. Also Michelangelo being the "everyman" of the Turtles and not some kind of brain damaged party dude -- all I would say to this is that I would hope they would mitigate the party dude side and not go overboard. But they always do.

ticktack 12-22-2025 02:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 2019951)

2007 Leo was garbage, but I don’t think he did any harm to subsequent versions. 2012 Leo was great, PD was fine, Rise was a complete reinvention, etc.

Post-2007 producers might have really thought that the '07 version of garbage Leo was his true portrayal, so they got to completely reinvent him. Plus, some commenters in forums thought he was boring, yeah.

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 2019951)
I don’t remember anyone having a problem with Astin. I do remember some low IQ takes about Biggs not being able to voice Leonardo. Some people, myself included, weren’t sure about Paulsen as Donnie.

Sean Austin played "Samwise Gamgee" in LOTR. He was a soft, empathetic, supportive guy, a complete antithesis of anything related to toxic masculinity. Fans were really upfront and furious with the voice acting choice, saying he can't ever play a rude, tough, mad, angry, shhmExy, loud, overly confrontational, masculine, overbearing dude, withthtth a shofft shhhpot.

ticktack 12-22-2025 02:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ticktack (Post 2019961)
Sean Austin played "Samwise Gamgee" in LOTR. He was a soft, empathetic, supportive guy, a complete antithesis of anything related to toxic masculinity. Fans were really upfront and furious with the voice acting choice, saying he can't ever play a rude, tough, mad, angry, shhmExy, loud, overly confrontational, masculine, overbearing dude, withthtth a shofft shhhpot.


Imagine even the manosphere, incelious, tech-bro types* of the 2012 era so fed up with the concept of toxic masculinity that even they were gonna go for reinventing the bratty character dude. Like, if no way, that's a collaborative quality of sorts, for a main character.


Snake was goning to bite its own tail.

____________________________________________
*Proof:

Prowler 12-22-2025 03:12 AM

You know, ToTheNines; normally I'd say you'd not even need to mention that The Shredder/Oroku Saki should be a Japanese man, but the first Bayturtles film nearly tried to make him a White American dude named Eric ****ing Sachs. So I echo that sentiment of yours as well. There's no guarantee they won't try to pull off some stupid crap like that in the future again.

What else...

- April must be an attractive woman in her 20s and also White. Black April is pure history revisionism. And April as a teenager is just weird. Black teenage April is just horrible, in particular. That's not April.

- No romance in TMNT besides April and Casey. And especially NO romance between Turtles and humans like Donatello crushing on April in the Nick toon.

- No mutant Turtles besides the TMNT except MAYBEEEEEEEE for Slash but his inclusion must have a good and credible reason to justify his inclusion.

- Michelangelo should not be ****ing ret*rded.

ticktack 12-22-2025 03:42 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 2019960)

* April should be in the den mother or at worst big sister capacity.

That's a kitchen-nuturing stereotype for a woman.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Prowler (Post 2019963)

- April must be an attractive woman in her 20s and also White. Black April is pure history revisionism. And April as a teenager is just weird. Black teenage April is just horrible, in particular. That's not April.

- No romance in TMNT besides April and Casey.

In order to be appealing. For the male gaze.

https://i.kym-cdn.com/entries/icons/...3/RageFace.jpg

TheLabRat 12-22-2025 11:35 PM

Even if they don't allow the turtles to kill criminals, they should at least be allowed to do a lot harm to those who are irredeemable, and even causing them permanent disability.

Coola Yagami 12-24-2025 02:02 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ticktack (Post 2019966)
That's a kitchen-nuturing stereotype for a woman.


And there's nothing wrong with that.



Quote:

Originally Posted by ticktack (Post 2019966)



In order to be appealing. For the male gaze.

Not just yes, but hell yes. Don't bitter because you'll never look like 80's April.

ticktack 12-24-2025 05:31 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Coola Yagami (Post 2020119)
And there's nothing wrong with that.

Well, if you ever see a man become a househusband. Call me.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Coola Yagami (Post 2020119)
Not just yes, but hell yes. Don't bitter because you'll never look like 80's April.

Don't want to appeal to the male gaze. That's different stuff.

Coola Yagami 12-24-2025 10:12 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ticktack (Post 2020124)
Well, if you ever see a man become a househusband. Call me.


I mean they do exist. Often enough they aren't respected by their spouses, but househusbands do exist.

Quote:

Originally Posted by ticktack (Post 2020124)
Don't want to appeal to the male gaze. That's different stuff.

Most people complaining about the male gaze couldn't get male gaze upon them if they tried. It's usually not so much 'they choose not to appeal to it' it's more 'ain't no one checking for you'.

Andrew NDB 12-24-2025 10:34 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ticktack (Post 2020124)
Well, if you ever see a man become a househusband. Call me.

Something tells me you're not getting a lot of phone calls, period. And probably none at all from the opposite sex.

sdp 12-24-2025 10:47 AM

With each new incarnation of TMNT, they continue in raping my "non negotiable" ideas of what a character should be. But it's always been this way, I didn't read archie until the late 2000s and boy I hated everything they did there, so many non-negotiable takes there and that was in the beginning of the franchise.

Since I didnt watch much of the cartoon to me TMNT was just the TMNT playmates bios so my ideal take once I consumed more TMNT media is somewhere between a Mirage and Playmates hybrid

CyberCubed 12-24-2025 12:25 PM

In Archie I never liked that Leatherhead was a human man named Jess Harley before mutation. I don't know why Murphy did that when he was part of the Mirage staff and knows Leatherheads origin in Tales. To date its the only incarnation of Leatherhead that was human prior to mutation.

Even the Mutant Mayhem Leatherhead who is female for some strange reason was still a normal gator before mutation.

Andrew NDB 12-24-2025 12:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 2020159)
In Archie I never liked that Leatherhead was a human man named Jess Harley before mutation. I don't know why Murphy did that when he was part of the Mirage staff and knows Leatherheads origin in Tales.

I never had a problem with the Jess Harley stuff. His Mirage origin wouldn't even work in Archie.

Coola Yagami 12-24-2025 12:41 PM

It was odd, though unique, that technically Leatherhead wasn't a mutant since he was transformed through magic.

Then we had Jagwar born from a Jaguar spirit banging a human and I forgot Dreadmon's origin unless he was just... already there.

ticktack 12-24-2025 12:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Coola Yagami (Post 2020137)
I mean they do exist. Often enough they aren't respected by their spouses, but househusbands do exist.



Most people complaining about the male gaze couldn't get male gaze upon them if they tried. It's usually not so much 'they choose not to appeal to it' it's more 'ain't no one checking for you'.

Suure

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S48h...s3Xi9&index=56

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 2020144)
Something tells me you're not getting a lot of phone calls, period. And probably none at all from the opposite sex.


I don't really wanna call names, but some of you give a vibe of mean old people.

Coola Yagami 12-24-2025 12:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ticktack (Post 2020165)
Suure

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S48h...s3Xi9&index=56




I don't really wanna call names, but some of you give a vibe of mean old people.

Some just have common sense and don't put much stock on nonsense.

ticktack 12-24-2025 12:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Coola Yagami (Post 2020166)
Some just have common sense and don't put much stock on nonsense.

You say "common sense", I say "old people vibes". Yeah, I immediately felt that vibe. From responses, definitely.

Coola Yagami 12-24-2025 01:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ticktack (Post 2020168)
You say "common sense", I say "old people vibes". Yeah, I immediately felt that vibe. From responses, definitely.

Old people. With common sense.

This is a forum named after something from a cartoon of the 80's. Ain't no one here young.

ticktack 12-24-2025 01:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Coola Yagami (Post 2020170)
Old people. With common sense.

This is a forum named after something from a cartoon of the 80's. Ain't no one here young.

Yes, I was still correct, old people. Past 40-50 at best.

Stuck in the past.

Heyowakka 12-24-2025 01:28 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ticktack (Post 2020171)
Yes, I was still correct, old people. Past 40-50 at best.

Stuck in the past.

Oy. I may be a mean, hate-filled old man who lives in the past; but at least I’m not RUDE!

ticktack 12-24-2025 01:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Heyowakka (Post 2020176)
Oy. I may be a mean, hate-filled old man who lives in the past; but at least I’m not RUDE!

No one's rude, I just mapped people's mentality for myself that's all.

It's normal, having fixed mentality, I'm just not gonna mess around with that much. Like, it's ok, happens. I moved on.

Andrew NDB 12-24-2025 01:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ticktack (Post 2020177)
It's normal, having fixed mentality, I'm just not gonna mess around with that much. Like, it's ok, happens. I moved on.

You definitely haven't moved on.

ticktack 12-24-2025 01:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 2020178)
You definitely haven't moved on.

I acknowledge that different opinions exist and I am peaceful, forgiving with it. :tangel:

Plot twit: I'm a cool guy. :tsmile::roll:

Andrew NDB 12-24-2025 01:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ticktack (Post 2020179)
I acknowledge that different opinions exist and I am peaceful, forgiving with it.

Your posting style would suggest radically the opposite. Over and over again.

Coola Yagami 12-24-2025 01:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ticktack (Post 2020179)
I acknowledge that different opinions exist and I am peaceful, forgiving with it. :tangel:

Plot twit: I'm a cool guy. :tsmile::roll:

You're a guy???

ticktack 12-24-2025 02:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 2020180)
Your posting style would suggest radically the opposite. Over and over again.

- I share my own opinions, nothing bad in it.

- Why stay mad when I choose happiness. :tgrin::roll:

- What's wrong with acknowledging different vibes and opinions, and stay cool. What's the issue? I can't force anyone into thinking the same.


Quote:

Originally Posted by Coola Yagami (Post 2020181)
You're a guy???

It’s more like staying incognito under that label.

CyberCubed 12-24-2025 05:19 PM

https://www.tfw2005.com/boards/attac...-jpg.30067821/

Zog The Magnificent 12-24-2025 06:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 2020190)

There it is. Once ticktack starts in on something, I start waiting for this picture to appear.

ticktack 12-24-2025 11:10 PM

Fans here often prefer lighter nostalgia or traditional fandom banter over analytical tone. But that doesn’t make my perspective invalid — just somewhere out of sync with the prevailing vibe. :):tangel:


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:39 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.