The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   TMNT: Urban Legends Omnibus (black and white hardcover) (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=68089)

ToTheNines 03-02-2026 04:10 PM

TMNT: Urban Legends Omnibus (black and white hardcover)
 
Look at this cover!

https://tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/assets...gular_rich.jpg

Out this December. They’re even including #24-26 in black and white, which is cool.

Seems like 608 pages is a lot for these 26 issues. I’m wondering what else is in here:

- Big Bang Comics #10 Kid Gallahad short?
- Savage Dragon/TMNT crossover and Savage Dragon #2?
- TMNT/Savage Dragon crossover and Savage Dragon #22?
- Rest in Pieces from the IDW 30th Anniversary special?
- Down Time from the 40th Anniversary special?
- The elusive extra page from the original #1-5 TPB?

Am I missing anything?

CyberCubed 03-02-2026 05:18 PM

I was going to ask if this includes any of the extra material, I might have to double dip if it does. The colored collection is actually really good, unlike the old Mirage colored ones, they actually put effort into this one and the colors look great. Still having it in black and white would be good too.

They should definitely at least include the new stories from the 30th and 40th anniversaries in here given they were only like 6 pages each.

Andrew NDB 03-02-2026 05:19 PM

Frank "Frosco" rides again!

CyberCubed 03-02-2026 05:23 PM

This is why we have to pray IDW doesn't lose the TMNT license to DC given Paramount buying WB, I hate to see all these trades canceled before we get them. Hopefully TMNT stays with IDW for a while yet, at least till 2030...

rs_jr 03-02-2026 06:21 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 2025213)
Look at this cover!

https://tmnt-ninjaturtles.com/assets...gular_rich.jpg

Seems like 608 pages is a lot for these 26 issues. I’m wondering what else is in here:

- Big Bang Comics #10 Kid Gallahad short?
- Savage Dragon/TMNT crossover and Savage Dragon #2?
- TMNT/Savage Dragon crossover and Savage Dragon #22?
- Rest in Pieces from the IDW 30th Anniversary special?
- Down Time from the 40th Anniversary special?
- The elusive extra page from the original #1-5 TPB?

Am I missing anything?

Please someone show this to IDW. It would be amazing if they included those issues.

Daytona 03-02-2026 08:51 PM

Man I actually really appreciate the re-color they did for this series and wish it was collected that way.

Regardless, I’ll buy it.

CyberCubed 03-02-2026 10:40 PM

608 pages for the 26 issues, has anyone done a page count of those 26 issues to see what it adds up to? If it's less than 608 pages, we're probably getting extra content. Granted, does IDW count the pin-up cover pages as page count? Because there might just be 26 pages of the original covers for the issues in the cover gallery.

TurtleGurkle 03-03-2026 12:09 AM

Original covers, reprint covers, probably not a ton of other extra content after that.

ToTheNines 03-03-2026 10:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by rs_jr (Post 2025222)
Please someone show this to IDW. It would be amazing if they included those issues.

I think IDW and even NECA still lurk here and take our feedback to heart.

But yeah, at the very least I hope they include the extra page from #2 and Big Bang Comics' "Galahad" short.

Would also appreciate black and white versions of the two Anniversary shorts if they want to keep the whole thing b&w. Although losing Sabacooza's colors on "Rest in Pieces" would be a bit of a crime.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Daytona (Post 2025231)
Man I actually really appreciate the re-color they did for this series and wish it was collected that way.

Regardless, I’ll buy it.

I have all my Urban Legends floppies, I definitely appreciate the opportunity to own the series in black and white again. And it'll be interesting to see the new conclusion without colors.

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 2025234)
608 pages for the 26 issues, has anyone done a page count of those 26 issues to see what it adds up to? If it's less than 608 pages, we're probably getting extra content. Granted, does IDW count the pin-up cover pages as page count? Because there might just be 26 pages of the original covers for the issues in the cover gallery.

If they only do 1 cover per issue, I'm counting about 60 extra pages. I really hope they don't bother with any variant covers, as nice as some of them were. Hopefully it's just the original Fosco covers from the 90's, and the rest of the pages are extra stories.

CyberCubed 03-03-2026 05:19 PM

It's probably safe to assume the new stories from the 30th and 40th anniversary will be there over anything else, and they were about 5-6 pages each, weren't they? So you can take off about 12 pages.

That leaves roughly 42 pages free, which would be enough for about 2 issues. I could see it being the Savage Dragon crossovers if that's the case.

TurtleGurkle 03-03-2026 07:43 PM

The two trades combine to 628 pages, but again they had full page variant covers for each issue. I think they were all done by Kevin Eastman. I assume they will shrink the variants down to 4 a page and remove the duplicated title pages. I wouldn’t expect anything beyond the two short stories.

rs_jr 03-03-2026 08:15 PM

[QUOTE=ToTheNines;2025243]I think IDW and even NECA still lurk here and take our feedback to heart.

But yeah, at the very least I hope they include the extra page from #2 and Big Bang Comics' "Galahad" short.

Would also appreciate black and white versions of the two Anniversary shorts if they want to keep the whole thing b&w. Although losing Sabacooza's colors on "Rest in Pieces" would be a bit of a crime.


I feel they should include all those extra issues that might amount to over 100 pages because honestly 150 usd is too steep for a 600 page omnibus. If they bring in closer to 750 or 800 pages ( maybe bodycount also) would justify the 150 usd price tag.

ToTheNines 03-03-2026 08:23 PM

I don’t disagree. Just keep in mind that you’ll be able to get it for less than $100 if you wait a little bit. Luckily it comes out in December, so I’ll have some Christmas bonus money to blow on it.

Quote:

Originally Posted by TurtleGurkle (Post 2025266)
The two trades combine to 628 pages, but again they had full page variant covers for each issue. I think they were all done by Kevin Eastman. I assume they will shrink the variants down to 4 a page and remove the duplicated title pages. I wouldn’t expect anything beyond the two short stories.

I never got the trades, but Urban Legends all came with either an old Fosco cover, new Fosco cover, or new Eastman cover.

Personally I hope they don’t waste pages on the variants at all and just do the old Foscos. Since this is black and white, just keep it 90’s.

rs_jr 03-03-2026 08:43 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 2025270)
I don’t disagree. Just keep in mind that you’ll be able to get it for less than $100 if you wait a little bit. Luckily it comes out in December, so I’ll have some Christmas bonus money to blow on it.



I never got the trades, but Urban Legends all came with either an old Fosco cover, new Fosco cover, or new Eastman cover.

Personally I hope they don’t waste pages on the variants at all and just do the old Foscos. Since this is black and white, just keep it 90’s.

I will be buying it and supporting all these new mirage omnibus in hopes idw increases the pace, but id like all tmnt ancillary titles/crossover during the image years in one place.

ToTheNines 03-03-2026 09:18 PM

If they’re not in here, maybe they could do a “Crossover Omnibus” that covered all of Mirage and Image?

The first 4 Usagi stories
The aforementioned Savge Dragon stuff
Creed
Mars Attacks Image #1
Flaming Carrot
The parody stuff

It’s late and I’m tired, so I’m tapping out lol. But I think that could be a cool book.

Smithguy789 03-04-2026 07:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 2025275)
If they’re not in here, maybe they could do a “Crossover Omnibus” that covered all of Mirage and Image?

The first 4 Usagi stories
The aforementioned Savge Dragon stuff
Creed
Mars Attacks Image #1
Flaming Carrot
The parody stuff

It’s late and I’m tired, so I’m tapping out lol. But I think that could be a cool book.

They could throw in "Meet the Conservation Corps", Sonic #10 (IDW's got the rights, why not) and the Garfield crossover to pad out the page count.

I imagine the copyright wrangling on a book like that would be an absolute nightmare

ToTheNines 04-29-2026 01:47 PM

The Amazon listing clarifies that the only extra stories we’re getting are “Rest in Pieces” (which I don’t personally consider canon, and think Sabacooza’s colors are one of the main selling points) and “Downtime”. I guess those extra pages will just be the cover gallery.

I’m semi interested to see if those two shorts go at the end, or if they plug them in where they take place. And of course, if they include the elusive extra page from the 1997 TPB. I don’t think Urban Legends included it.

EDIT: I checked. Extra page is absent from Urban Legends #2.

Daytona 04-29-2026 04:41 PM

That’d be cool if they brought back “The Works” hardcover series and did this in color as well.

Andrew NDB 04-29-2026 04:47 PM

My opinion of this would generally be, "We finally got TMNT Vol. 3 in full and modern color (something I'd often say it always should have been in) for all issues, even some bonus ones and it took like 20 years... now, why would we ever, EVER want to go backwards from that?" Plus having Vol. 3 in color even thematically works better. This way, we go from Vol. 1 in B&W to an era of color in Vol. 2 and then Vol. 3... and then we have a many years gap as the Turtles get older than then pick things up in Vol. 4 back in B&W, like it was in Vol. 1. It suits the general "mood."

Now, if they were to leave it all B&W and then have a guy go through with some really nice digital duotones that would be a different story altogether! I wouldn't mind that as a companion piece to have.

Andrew NDB 04-29-2026 07:27 PM

Also, many might be unaware of: Frank and Jim and everybody involved in Image/Vol. 3... do you know who was paying them every month? It wasn't "Image" or Erik Larsen or anything.

It was Mirage. Only Mirage, ever, at any point.

ToTheNines 04-30-2026 06:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 2027444)
My opinion of this would generally be, "We finally got TMNT Vol. 3 in full and modern color (something I'd often say it always should have been in) for all issues, even some bonus ones and it took like 20 years... now, why would we ever, EVER want to go backwards from that?"

I’m of a similar mind. But the coloring on Urban Legends is just ok. Nothing special.

Quote:

Plus having Vol. 3 in color even thematically works better. This way, we go from Vol. 1 in B&W to an era of color in Vol. 2 and then Vol. 3... and then we have a many years gap as the Turtles get older than then pick things up in Vol. 4 back in B&W, like it was in Vol. 1. It suits the general "mood."
I agree. Although I’ll add that I think it’s a little strange that Journeys isn’t in color. Maybe that was at Peter’s request?

Quote:

Now, if they were to leave it all B&W and then have a guy go through with some really nice digital duotones that would be a different story altogether! I wouldn't mind that as a companion piece to have.
Now that could be cool.

I think this hardcover targeted at people who liked Urban Legends but didn’t own the original Image books. Which technically was me when this was announced, since I had sold my Image books years ago assuming the reprints would tank their value (wrong!).

So I was going to buy this, but ironically I stumbled upon a near complete run at a local con and just bought those instead. Now I only need #23. Can’t really justify this $100+ book when I just sank hundreds into the originals and still have one more expensive issue to track down.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 2027456)
Also, many might be unaware of: Frank and Jim and everybody involved in Image/Vol. 3... do you know who was paying them every month? It wasn't "Image" or Erik Larsen or anything.

It was Mirage. Only Mirage, ever, at any point.

Well that’s an interesting tidbit. Even Andrew Pepoy and all them? That must have been an odd licensing agreement. I guess Mirage must have split the sales profits with Image instead of your standard licensing fee collection.

Side note: looking up the credits for the Image run caused me to realize that Chris Elioupolous (letterer for #1-9) went on to write and draw children’s books. My kid and I love reading “A Little Emotional” and “The Yawns are Coming”. Pretty cool!

TurtleGurkle 04-30-2026 11:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 2027456)
Also, many might be unaware of: Frank and Jim and everybody involved in Image/Vol. 3... do you know who was paying them every month? It wasn't "Image" or Erik Larsen or anything.

It was Mirage. Only Mirage, ever, at any point.

Isn’t that just how Image works? The creators pay themselves and their team after Image takes the cut from publishing.

Andrew NDB 04-30-2026 12:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TurtleGurkle (Post 2027476)
Isn’t that just how Image works? The creators pay themselves and their team after Image takes the cut from publishing.

Not in this case. Like, they'd all get checks in the mail from Mirage from Gary Richardson, essentially.

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 2027471)
I agree. Although I’ll add that I think it’s a little strange that Journeys isn’t in color. Maybe that was at Peter’s request?

I don't think it's that strange. To do that they'd have to strip out all the duotones Peter Laird did somewhat sporadically throughout AND the more commonplace digital toning he started doing a ways into Vol. 4. And in a book that they've said is supposed to "Honor Peter" at IDW, stripping out large parts of his work probably wouldn't be the way to go about doing that.

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 2027471)
I guess Mirage must have split the sales profits with Image instead of your standard licensing fee collection.

I'm not for sure but from what I gather from my conversations (I was just doing a deep dive into old, ooold E-mails with Frank and Gary) if Mirage/Peter/Gary Richardson was paying any kind of "publication fee" to anyone at Image it wasn't much of anything, or nonexistant. It was just paychecks directly to Gary Carlson, Frank Fosco, and then paying the invoice of whatever it cost to print/distribute a given issue over there.

And sales profits? You mean when there was sales profits, only early on? I mean, possibly they would get shared with "Image." But "Image" wasn't really an entity in that way, at least then. It wasn't much more than a banner for folks to work under while doing their own thing.

TurtleGurkle 04-30-2026 12:51 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 2027477)
Not in this case. Like, they'd all get checks in the mail from Mirage from Gary Richardson, essentially.

That's how Image has always worked. Image takes their fee for publishing and the IP owners take the rest. In this case, Mirage took the rest and paid the creative team on the book.

frank_one 04-30-2026 01:31 PM

Let me understand, Mirage paid Image to make vol. 3 and took the profits the series was generating.

Andrew NDB 04-30-2026 02:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by frank_one (Post 2027481)
Let me understand, Mirage paid Image to make vol. 3 and took the profits the series was generating.

I can't imagine who else would. Mirage was paying "Image" (as in, just having Erik printing TMNT Vol. 3 issues the same way he'd print his own Savage Dragon issues) only superficially, with everyone at "Image" just being basically independent contractors for Mirage. With the Image banner on the covers.

For Erik, the only difference was he now had 2 comics to print a month instead of 1. And I'm sure Peter/Gary Richardson was paying Erik a nominal "Editor" fee to kind of oversee everything on an issue-by-issue basis. Though remember, it was Laird that had to approve each script from Carlson and would give sticky notes about it, not Erik.

So this notion that Mirage was hands-off on Vol. 3 is nonsense. Always has been.

frank_one 04-30-2026 02:36 PM

So, why didn't Mirage pay the writer and the artist directly and publish vol 3 through Mirage? Were they so busy with other things they didn't want to deal with the printer and with the distributor?

Andrew NDB 04-30-2026 02:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by frank_one (Post 2027489)
So, why didn't Mirage pay the writer and the artist directly

They did. That's what I'm saying.

Quote:

and publish vol 3 through Mirage?
That's EXACTLY what Frank was wondering at the time. But most likely the answer is that Peter didn't want to be as involved in the publishing as he'd have to be and sink all the time he'd need to do it as Vol. 2 had been done.

This was also during the "Peter is pissed at Kevin for doing NT:TNM with Venus" days. When that was cancelled and Kevin sold his half of the TMNT rights back to Peter in 2000 is when Peter had a change of heart about TMNT in general, not before.

ToTheNines 04-30-2026 03:27 PM

Well they tried something new by switching to color, which didn’t really take off. So I think part of it was shaking things up with a new publisher as another attempt to give TMNT a shot in the arm.

They also had a good rapport with Larsen. I think I remember reading that they wanted him to write it, but he didn’t have time so he hired Carlson. But I think Larsen did have a lot of creative input and worked closely with Carlson to establish the tone and direction they were going to take at the beginning.

Andrew NDB 04-30-2026 03:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 2027493)
Well they tried something new by switching to color, which didn’t really take off.

It probably sold about as well as the last few of Vol. 1. But I think when it comes to things like "The Great Mirage Flood" that was more equivalent to: "Peter Laird is very, very unhappy that Kevin is developing NT:TNM and a female Turtle and now doesn't really want to work on TMNT." So kind of whatever excuse could be used for why they couldn't keep on making Vol 2.

Quote:

They also had a good rapport with Larsen. I think I remember reading that they wanted him to write it, but he didn’t have time so he hired Carlson. But I think Larsen did have a lot of creative input and worked closely with Carlson to establish the tone and direction they were going to take at the beginning.
Yeah, like Peter telling Erik to kill Splinter with a bang at the beginning but Erik came up with the Bat-Splinter idea. I don't think Erik really offered many ideas beyond that beyond just a general sort of edict to Gary and Frank to differentiate the Turtles as soon as people, be it by injuries or whatever.

I remember not long into the Image series I caught him at a Seattle convention and peppered him with TMNT questions and he was like, "I don't know, dude! I've never really read any Mirage TMNT!"

ToTheNines 05-01-2026 05:36 AM

Very interesting.

Here’s a relevant interview Dooney did with Larsen. Printed in the back of Volume 2 #13:


DK2 05-04-2026 11:20 PM

When the Image TMNT comic was ailing in sales, I recall reading that Peter and Kevin offered to put in money to keep the book running to Image and Erik Larson. But Erik said there was no point in letting them do that with its sales numbers.

Red Robin 10-13-2026 01:05 PM

Do we already know if the extra material of #2 will be included in this one?

ToTheNines 10-13-2026 01:30 PM

We have no confirmation either way.

I seriously doubt it but would be happy to see it included.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:20 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.