The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   TMNT (IDW vol. 2) #17 preview/discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=68144)

ToTheNines 04-09-2026 02:44 AM

TMNT (IDW vol. 2) #17 preview/discussion
 
https://bleedingcool.com/comics/teen...stical-mayhem/

What did everyone think? I’m not sure I understand the twist at the end. I was fully expecting
Spoiler:
Venus

neatoman 04-09-2026 02:51 AM

I don't understand it either.
Spoiler:
Is it like spirit time travel or have we been mislead about what the past was like or something? Or are they trying to retcon it so that Splinter is a separate entity from Hamato Yoshi altogether?

Dancefloran 04-09-2026 12:04 PM

Well, I always welcome japanese folklore !

Spoiler:
Gashadokuro, Tengu, Kitsune, Yokais, Dan the Tanuki, Ujigami, Shinigami... are all inspired from the jap mythos. So what's next ? Yuki Onna ? Nue ? Deidarabochi ? Tsuchigumo ?


This issue would probably have been a better experience if they didn't spoil the return of this character.
Spoiler:
Tang Shen


As for the cliffhanger, well it's weird on purpose, I guess we'll see what this is about next issue. But it's confusing...
Spoiler:
They kinda hinted something about Splinter's soul. So maybe this Yoshi is also Splinter.

Venus should have the opportunity to come back one day, but they already have their hands full with a huge cast of characters lol. I expect the next mini series will be about Alopex/Leatherhead, Old Hob/Slash/Ludovic, Ninjara or April. As well as a new Dimension X arc. I guess Jennika and Angel could also be side characters in some mini series as well. Or some of those characters will play a part in the next main run arc.
I still expect Zog to return sometime as a side effect of the Battle Nexus.

Daytona 04-09-2026 01:38 PM

I just found this to be written poorly. I can’t stand when writers place comedy bits over tension. Mikey’s brothers are on the verge of death and he’s talking about pizza? It’s one thing to be distracted by your resurrected mother but this went beyond that.

And pizza itself feels like such a freakin krutch at this point when it comes to TMNT. Need some dialogue? Have Mikey mention pizza. Need a toy accessory? Here’s another slice of pizza. Need a brand tie-in? Have a pizza coupon! (Maybe this one I can actually get behind). It just feels so surface/entry-level, especially here. Yeah, we get it - pizza - “haha”.

Aside from that, the pacing and dialogue felt choppy in a way that’s difficult to articulate. Perhaps the writer and artist aren’t in sync, it’s hard to say.

The pre-release interviews for this series had me nervous but this confirms I’m out until the next creative team hops on the book. The writing style doesn’t interest me. It’s another Saturday morning cartoon, whereas I want my TMNT books more in the vein of Frank Miller’s Ronin, Daredevil, or even just The Last Ronin. I’m out.

Andrew NDB 04-09-2026 03:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Daytona (Post 2026754)
Yeah, we get it - pizza - “haha”.

Yeah, and we got it 30 years ago. It wasn't funny then, either.

GameCobra 04-09-2026 03:49 PM

The pizza thing i always loved, but mostly because it feels like this was the brand that pretty much established my love for pizza.

Bought the issue. One thing i really like is it looks like they are opening up some doors for Karai for a change. I been looking for some decent Karai lore.

Spoiler:
Definitely feels like Tang Shen isn't staying for long. Feels like the story is moreso trying to setup more spernatural enemies for the turtles, which i'm game for.

TheLabRat 04-09-2026 06:33 PM

Look like Karai's plan is failed, however, I tired of this character always blow hot and cold. She got the dragon power and try to open the portal to underworld to gain more, but now, they just reveal that she just want to free her soul from the dragon? Did they really have any plans for this character?

CyberCubed 04-09-2026 07:54 PM

This was quite the mystic issue, I feel a lot of this would have been more epic seeing it animated in a cartoon. Giant skeleton, mystic Japanese lore, it all feels like it should be an episode. So we know Shinigami wants to free Karai from the dragon spirit, but wouldn't that put Karai back at square one without any mystic power, or at least I assume.

It is confusing to know Splinter is merged with a giant skeleton and then a young Hamato Yoshi comes out of nowhere, but we'll see how that's handled next issue.

ToTheNines 04-09-2026 09:20 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 2026774)
This was quite the mystic issue, I feel a lot of this would have been more epic seeing it animated in a cartoon. Giant skeleton, mystic Japanese lore, it all feels like it should be an episode. So we know Shinigami wants to free Karai from the dragon spirit, but wouldn't that put Karai back at square one without any mystic power, or at least I assume.

It is confusing to know Splinter is merged with a giant skeleton and then a young Hamato Yoshi comes out of nowhere, but we'll see how that's handled next issue.

Aw man… you didn’t say it…

Heyowakka 04-09-2026 10:06 PM

Could it be CyberCubed is experiencing character development?

ToTheNines 04-10-2026 07:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Heyowakka (Post 2026777)
Could it be CyberCubed is experiencing character development?

After none for 20+ years here? I think it’s more likely that he’s going senile :lol:

TheLabRat 04-13-2026 06:59 AM

Strangely, even Tang Shen never mentioned their sons japanese name.

ToTheNines 04-13-2026 07:04 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheLabRat (Post 2026851)
Strangely, even Tang Shen never mentioned their sons japanese name.

Yeah we’ve talked about that being clunky throughout the series, but now that she’s back it’s pretty glaring. They’re all just going to be “my son” the whole time she’s around?

Heyowakka 04-13-2026 10:42 AM

She’ll call them Leonard, Ralph, Micheal and Donald.

ToTheNines 04-13-2026 10:52 AM

What did they do by in the Japanese dub and the OVA?

Heyowakka 04-13-2026 11:36 AM

Well, I know they changed Hamato Yoshi and Oroku Saki’s name to be actual, acceptable Japanese names; the Turtles probably retained their names, just under the pronunciation of Japanese dialect.

Dancefloran 04-13-2026 11:41 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheLabRat (Post 2026851)
Strangely, even Tang Shen never mentioned their sons japanese name.

Come on IDW team, give the turtles their japanese names already !!

ToTheNines 04-13-2026 01:06 PM

Tom Waltz once said in one of his Turtle Tracks appearances that they decided a long time ago that they would never reveal their original Japanese names. Granted, this is a new editorial team now, but I wouldn’t hold my breath.

Powder 04-13-2026 05:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Heyowakka (Post 2026865)
Well, I know they changed Hamato Yoshi and Oroku Saki’s name to be actual, acceptable Japanese names; the Turtles probably retained their names, just under the pronunciation of Japanese dialect.

That's correct. Oroku Saki became Oroku Sawaki, as Saki is typically a girl's name. It basically translates to blossom, haha. Growing up as a boy with a girl's name might actually be a fun point to account for his various complexes, but I guess it would sound pretty lame.

As for the turtles, still the same namesakes, just adjusted for the Japanese language, so Michelangelo for example is Mikeranjero (mee-keh-rahn-jeh-roh).

I don't think there was ever any instance, manga or otherwise, where they gave them completely unique names.

PrestonC 04-13-2026 09:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ToTheNines (Post 2026870)
Tom Waltz once said in one of his Turtle Tracks appearances that they decided a long time ago that they would never reveal their original Japanese names. Granted, this is a new editorial team now, but I wouldn’t hold my breath.

Yep, I asked that question and got a response in issue 17 lol. I remember because that was the only time I made it into Ninja Notes.

TheLabRat 04-14-2026 04:51 AM

I have a bad feeling that the next story arc will be another time travel crisis or "Turtles Forever 2".


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 09:49 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.