The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   4Kids TMNT Cartoon Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=11)
-   -   Who do you think will defeat the Shredder. (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=9791)

Jarrah White 06-14-2004 05:39 AM

Who do you think will defeat the Shredder.
 
Shredder will finally be beaten in the third season, we know that, but we are yet to know the details of his over throw. Suppose he does falls in battle, who do you think should have the honour of ridding the Utroms of their most dreaded enemy?

Demonfox38 06-14-2004 07:30 AM

I think it'll be more between if Splinter does it or Leonardo. Let's face it; both have vendetta issues. :P And both of them envolve revenge for their 'father', in a matter of speaking.

*Battle w/o love or honor begins to play* :evilgrin:

It'd be cool if Raph killed him, though. That is, if Shredder doesn't get royally bitch-slapped by the law of the Utroms. Raph makes messes when he kills. That's why we love him! :D

[email protected] 06-14-2004 07:54 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Demonfox38
I think it'll be more between if Splinter does it or Leonardo. Let's face it; both have vendetta issues. :P And both of them envolve revenge for their 'father', in a matter of speaking.

*Battle w/o love or honor begins to play* :evilgrin:

It'd be cool if Raph killed him, though. That is, if Shredder doesn't get royally bitch-slapped by the law of the Utroms. Raph makes messes when he kills. That's why we love him! :D

Shredder can't be defeated. Splinter tried to defeat shredder but he survived. Leo tried to destroy shredder but he surivved. I think his defeat will happen when the utroms capture him and take him to trial.

I agree with your idea of Raph killing him.

Mecha Cow 06-14-2004 09:11 AM

I don't think Shredder's going to die. He will most likely be captured by the Utroms, never to be seen again. Then again, the show might be able to get away with having Shredder die.

However, no-one is going to kill him. He might perish in an explosion or something like that, but they can't have one of the main characters kill someone in a children's cartoon. No way.

But let's say someone would kill him, I would say either Leonardo or Splinter. I could live with Splinter finishing Shredder off, but not Leonardo. Leonardo is always the one in the center. >: I'd like to see all four Turtles pull a team attack or something to finish him.

But like I said, won't happen.

Tigershard 06-14-2004 10:05 AM

Characters have died in children's cartoons before. Have you seen Gargoyles? Lots of gargoyles get smashed into pieces at the beginning of that series, and two bad guys fall off a cliff and die.

Or how about the Sat AM Sonic cartoon? Didn't they kill off Doctor Robotnik in that version?

And if they show the beheading of Shredder, and the Baxter slowly loosing his body parts, I don't see why they woudln't show the Shredder actually bitting it. Or how about the death of Hamato Yoshi?

Anyway, I vote Leo. He deserves to be able to take out the Shredder. With all the training he does, I think he is the only one other than Splinter that is even able to do it.

Raven 06-14-2004 11:08 AM

batman, yes batman will beat the shredder!


i have no idea......

[email protected] 06-14-2004 11:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mecha Cow
I don't think Shredder's going to die. He will most likely be captured by the Utroms, never to be seen again. Then again, the show might be able to get away with having Shredder die.

However, no-one is going to kill him. He might perish in an explosion or something like that, but they can't have one of the main characters kill someone in a children's cartoon. No way.

But let's say someone would kill him, I would say either Leonardo or Splinter. I could live with Splinter finishing Shredder off, but not Leonardo. Leonardo is always the one in the center. >: I'd like to see all four Turtles pull a team attack or something to finish him.

But like I said, won't happen.

I would not go for perish in explosion because he has survived explosions before, and can walk through fire.

Ninja Turtl3 : RaphaeL 06-14-2004 11:41 AM

its probably gonna be leonardo or splinter but im really hoping for raph to finish him of cuz he has the most power and he is the most viscious.. and he is my favorite, but yea how many time has he "died" before he just keeps comming back... maybe if his helmet fell off and they all kicked him in the head and crushed his skull? :lol:

Mecha Cow 06-14-2004 11:48 AM

Quote:

Characters have died in children's cartoons before. Have you seen Gargoyles? Lots of gargoyles get smashed into pieces at the beginning of that series, and two bad guys fall off a cliff and die.

Or how about the Sat AM Sonic cartoon? Didn't they kill off Doctor Robotnik in that version?

And if they show the beheading of Shredder, and the Baxter slowly loosing his body parts, I don't see why they woudln't show the Shredder actually bitting it. Or how about the death of Hamato Yoshi?

Anyway, I vote Leo. He deserves to be able to take out the Shredder. With all the training he does, I think he is the only one other than Splinter that is even able to do it.
Yes, you're right, cartoon characters have died before, and have been killed before, but not by the hero. I didn't say the Shredder couldn't die, but I said that I doubt anyone will actually kill him, especially not the TMNT. This is a children's cartoon, and the TMNT are the heroes. Heroes in children's cartoons don't kill, not even their enemies. :)

Quote:

I would not go for perish in explosion because he has survived explosions before, and can walk through fire.
Yeah, you're right, but it was just an example.

TheCloneRanger 06-14-2004 12:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mecha Cow

Yes, you're right, cartoon characters have died before, and have been killed before, but not by the hero. I didn't say the Shredder couldn't die, but I said that I doubt anyone will actually kill him, especially not the TMNT. This is a children's cartoon, and the TMNT are the heroes. Heroes in children's cartoons don't kill, not even their enemies. :)

Exactly. Heroes can't be murderers...it just won't happen.

I don't think anyone will kill the Shredder. I'm still on board with the Utrom recapture theory.

Ryona 06-14-2004 12:59 PM

I also vote for Leonardo or Splinter. Splinter has personal isues with Shredder and would most likely have to finnish off Shredder in some kind of situation.
Leonardo is the most powerful character in the series (along side Splinter and Shredder) so he's the only one who's capable of taking out Shredder. Heck, Leo already killed Shredder.... that is if Shredder was human; so Leo can do it again (now that he knows the weak point of Shredder's body).
Yup. Givin Leo's status in the series, he should be the one with the honour of killing Shredder permanently.

R-iZZy 06-14-2004 02:18 PM

I think Splinter deserves the honor of killing Shredder more than any character on the show; but knowing that Leo always has to shine, he'll most likely be given the honor.

Sakirules 06-14-2004 03:26 PM

Raph doesn't have any chance in the world to beat shredder. Shredder will simply give the Hot headed moron the beating of his life. It should be Splinter or leo.

if Leo gets lucky, he can claim victory. But Shredder could win against Leo 9 times out of 10.

Splinter and Shredder are evenly matched to me. both get get wins 5 times out of 10

Jarrah White 06-14-2004 04:15 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ninja Turtl3 : RaphaeL
its probably gonna be leonardo or splinter but im really hoping for raph to finish him of cuz he has the most power and he is the most viscious.. and he is my favorite, but yea how many time has he "died" before he just keeps comming back... maybe if his helmet fell off and they all kicked him in the head and crushed his skull? :lol:

He ain't got no skull.

hazlov2004 06-14-2004 04:19 PM

new tmnt discussion
 
i picked leonardo

Leonardo_Warrior_Turtle 06-14-2004 04:23 PM

I think this has a possibility of happening: Leonardo will fight Shredder again, to avenge what he will do to Splinter. (Almost tried to kill him.) In the big final epic battle between the Turtles and Shredder, Leo will be extremely pissed off and fight him to the death. Leo will be badly beaten and Shredder is about to lay the death move on him. Suddenly, Karai finally sees that her master has no honor and attacks him. She tears the Foot symbol off her shirt and is ready to quit the Foot and fight for Leo's life. That is when she defeats him, the the Ultroms come to take him away. From then on, the Foot are a totally different organization.

Aaron 06-14-2004 05:32 PM

Splinter, definetly.But id no Splinter I would want the gaurdians to.

Ninja Turtl3 : RaphaeL 06-14-2004 05:38 PM

i think if anyone was to fight him one on one raph would do the best he seems like he can take the most pain and he is the most agressive i dont think leo would be able to kill him but raph would just rip him apart but no one turtle can take him none of them are strong enuff or skilled enuff yet.

[email protected] 06-14-2004 05:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ninja Turtl3 : RaphaeL
its probably gonna be leonardo or splinter but im really hoping for raph to finish him of cuz he has the most power and he is the most viscious.. and he is my favorite, but yea how many time has he "died" before he just keeps comming back... maybe if his helmet fell off and they all kicked him in the head and crushed his skull? :lol:

I Agree with you all about raph. Raph is quite agresive and vengefull. IF he kills shredder, it will be because he injured splinter or his other bros and Raph may get so angry he will kill him or severly wound him just before the utroms capture him. THAT WOULD be a good way to kill SHREDDEr.

Raph does have the potentail of being shredder's killer. Remember when shredder was revealed as an utrom when coming out of shredder's armor and raph saying he an't so tough now, lets just squish him.
RAph even threatened to hun that if he harmed splinter, he would make him wish he was never born. Raph is more likley to do such a thing, due to his aggressive and angry nature.

[email protected] 06-14-2004 05:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheCloneRanger
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mecha Cow

Yes, you're right, cartoon characters have died before, and have been killed before, but not by the hero. I didn't say the Shredder couldn't die, but I said that I doubt anyone will actually kill him, especially not the TMNT. This is a children's cartoon, and the TMNT are the heroes. Heroes in children's cartoons don't kill, not even their enemies. :)

Exactly. Heroes can't be murderers...it just won't happen.

I don't think anyone will kill the Shredder. I'm still on board with the Utrom recapture theory.

I too am on board with the utrom recapture theory since they have been on this mission to recapture him for 100 years, but he escaped and elluded them and met them again 1000 years later and the utroms said they would meet again when they were transported out and shredder in rouge in the house said the utroms would come back for him.

as for heroes can't be murderers, i don't know with this day in age. Splinter tried to kill shredder to avenge yoshi by having shredder slice the metal holding the watertower up which fell on shredder and seemingly crushed him and leo cut off shredder's head and did not feel sorry but did have a look on his face.

[email protected] 06-14-2004 05:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TheCloneRanger
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mecha Cow

Yes, you're right, cartoon characters have died before, and have been killed before, but not by the hero. I didn't say the Shredder couldn't die, but I said that I doubt anyone will actually kill him, especially not the TMNT. This is a children's cartoon, and the TMNT are the heroes. Heroes in children's cartoons don't kill, not even their enemies. :)

Exactly. Heroes can't be murderers...it just won't happen.

I don't think anyone will kill the Shredder. I'm still on board with the Utrom recapture theory.

I too am on board with the utrom recapture theory since they have been on this mission to recapture him for 100 years, but he escaped and elluded them and met them again 1000 years later and the utroms said they would meet again when they were transported out and shredder in rouge in the house said the utroms would come back for him.

as for heroes can't be murderers, i don't know with this day in age. Splinter tried to kill shredder to avenge yoshi by having shredder slice the metal holding the watertower up which fell on shredder and seemingly crushed him and leo cut off shredder's head and did not feel sorry but did have a look on his face. And the turtles did what heroes would not do earlier, attack the villain before he attacks them (which is what they did in return to new york)

[email protected] 06-14-2004 05:50 PM

After submitting the first thing When it said my message was done, I went back(clicked back) and added the going after the villian thing and clicked submit. I DID NOT THINK I WOULD HAVE THE SAME THING POSTED TWICE. IT WAS AN ACCIDENT. COULD KRANG PLEASE DELETE the first one I put up and leave the 2nd one, which has the mesasge (--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by TheCloneRanger:

quote:
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Originally posted by Mecha Cow:


Yes, you're right, cartoon characters have died before, and have been killed before, but not by the hero. I didn't say the Shredder couldn't die, but I said that I doubt anyone will actually kill him, especially not the TMNT. This is a children's cartoon, and the TMNT are the heroes. Heroes in children's cartoons don't kill, not even their enemies.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



Exactly. Heroes can't be murderers...it just won't happen.

I don't think anyone will kill the Shredder. I'm still on board with the Utrom recapture theory.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------



I too am on board with the utrom recapture theory since they have been on this mission to recapture him for 100 years, but he escaped and elluded them and met them again 1000 years later and the utroms said they would meet again when they were transported out and shredder in rouge in the house said the utroms would come back for him.

as for heroes can't be murderers, i don't know with this day in age. Splinter tried to kill shredder to avenge yoshi by having shredder slice the metal holding the watertower up which fell on shredder and seemingly crushed him and leo cut off shredder's head and did not feel sorry but did have a look on his face. And the turtles did what heroes would not do earlier, attack the villain before he attacks them (which is what they did in return to new york) there. WHAT I MEAN LEAVE THE 2nd one there is, dont delete the 2nd one. I DID NOT MEAN TO POST THE SAME EXACT THING TWICE. PLEASE DELETE THE FIRST ONE (The one that did NOT say the going after shredder before he goes after him)

Ryona 06-14-2004 07:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ninja Turtl3 : RaphaeL
i think if anyone was to fight him one on one raph would do the best he seems like he can take the most pain and he is the most agressive i dont think leo would be able to kill him but raph would just rip him apart but no one turtle can take him none of them are strong enuff or skilled enuff yet.

I find it amusing that you say Leo wouldn't be able to kill Shredder when we all saw him cut Shredder's head off with no remorse. We've seen Leo out of the other turtles as the one who would finnish off Shredder. Way back in the first comic, Leonardo is the one who gave Shredder the mortal wound (thrusting his sword through Shredders chest) before Shredder was knocked off the roof by Donatello. Later in the comic series we see Leonardo battle Shredder alone and kill him permanently.
We've also seen plenty of times in the old animated series, Leonardo and Shredder having plenty showdowns. Yup, we've been shown time and time again that Leonardo is the only turtle with the fighting potential strong enough to dance with ol' Shred one on one.
Raphael may be physicaly the most resilient but Leonardo is mentaly the most resilient, and in a life and death battle, willpower and nerves of steel will always be way more helpfull than a high pain tolerance and blind rage.
Sorry to say this but to asume that Raphael, Donatello or Michaelangelo will be the one to kill Shredder is just wishful thinking.
Now if Raph, Don, and mikey were teamed up, then, yeah, the three of them would be able take out Shredder.

Ninja Turtl3 : RaphaeL 06-15-2004 11:05 AM

yea raph is the only one that i can think of that will be able to go threw with it maybe somthing like this would happen splinter fight shredder, shredder starts to win leo comes in some kind of crazy way he is like this is my fight
he is like outta the way TUTTLE (spelt like that for comedic purposes)
and then he says some speech of somthing then he is like i will destroy you then your brothers than your master then they begin to fight and leo is winning and shredder is down and leo is about to stab down into his gut where the utrom is but he stops and hes like i cant do it... then shrdder is like foolish turtle should have killed me when you had the chance and goes to plunge his claw into his gut and then raph blaocks it with his sci and leo is sitting there he is like in shock to think he almost killed a person and then shredder and raph are fighting he is like this is not your fight he is like you hurt my bro and my master now your gonna pay and like he tears his head off or somthing then his stomach opens and the utrom comes out then raph is about to thrust him dead then the utroms will come and stop him and say like no he must this and this well you get the point..

Ninja Turtl3 : RaphaeL 06-15-2004 11:09 AM

and also ryo if you watch the shows raph does alot of vicious stuff him self and this isnt the comic leo isnt as mercifull in this show but raph is and if you think that leo could take out raph like nothing your wrong!! infact that would be a pretty bad ass fight.. although cuz leo is captain he would win yet if raph was the captain he would win like vegta against goku vegeta just cant win the bad on good guy... its just not fair for the mean strong guy when you know he should win.

cqb101 06-15-2004 11:31 AM

I'd love to see Casey beat him, but that'll never happen.....I'm thinking it'll be either Leo or Karai.

Ryona 06-15-2004 11:37 AM

*Ninja Turtl3 : RaphaeL, please read the following...*


Again, like I said, Leonardo cut Shredder's head off! And this was when Leo thought Shredder was human. Why do you think Leo wouldn't be able to kill Shredder again? I understand that your favourite is Raphael, so naturaly you'll stick up for him and back him up. ... but there is no need to bring Leo down and say that he would chicken out on the oppertunity to finnish off Shredder. Please go by fact, and not fiction. Leonardo is just as dangerous (if not more so) as Raphael, but in a cool, calm way. Now, please don't take it all wrong. Raphael is a powerful warrior and can give Leonardo a good fight, but but Leo is just a better fighter... plain and simple. Although I do believe that Raphael is a better fighter than Donatello and Michaelangelo, so being second best isn't bad at all. Of coarse, all the turtles are great characters. :)

Oh, and yes, I agree that Leonardo is much like Goku, and Raphael is much like Vegeta (as warriors anyway). I would also say that Donatello is much like Gohan, and Michaelangelo is much like Goten.

Ryona 06-15-2004 11:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by cqb101
I'd love to see Casey beat him, but that'll never happen.....I'm thinking it'll be either Leo or Karai.

That would be interesting, but chances are Casey will be the one to kill Hun instead. Given there past history, I believe Casey should have the honor of finnishing off Hun.

heretic888 06-15-2004 12:35 PM

errrp
 
Although I do believe that Raphael is a better fighter than Donatello and Michaelangelo

Despite the fact that Mike completely wailed on him during sparring --- in both the comic and the new toon?? :P

Also, as a side note, Mike and Leo were the only two able to injure Shredder in one-on-one battle during issue 1 of the Mirage line. And, seeing as how this show is supposed to be based on Mirage, well...

Oh, and yes, I agree that Leonardo is much like Goku, and Raphael is much like Vegeta (as warriors anyway). I would also say that Donatello is much like Gohan, and Michaelangelo is much like Goten.

Leonardo is more like Goku than... Mike?? Leo stuffs his face, is carefree, adventurous, and likes playing with little kids?? Ummm... right.

I think Leo is more like Piccolo, personality-wise, once Piccolo becomes an established "good guy" in the series. Don, I'd say, is more like adult Gohan. And, Raph, of course, like Vegeta.


In any event, I don't think anyone is every going to "kill" the Shredder. That would involve destroying the little squishy guy in the stomach --- I think they'll just keep on demolishing the robot body until the writers get bored with the character.

Laterz.

Sakirules 06-15-2004 01:40 PM

Raph would not win against Shredder one on one. That's just wishful thinking. Sure Raph is a savage fighter and all but Shredder will surely clean his clocks. Then Raph will go into his hot head mode, which will only set himself for his downfall and it'd be the last thing he will regeret. Even Splinter said that raph's rashness will be the end of him.

Ryo? I agree with you all the way.

cqb101 06-15-2004 01:50 PM

Re: errrp
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by heretic888
Although I do believe that Raphael is a better fighter than Donatello and Michaelangelo

Despite the fact that Mike completely wailed on him during sparring --- in both the comic and the new toon?? :P

Also, as a side note, Mike and Leo were the only two able to injure Shredder in one-on-one battle during issue 1 of the Mirage line. And, seeing as how this show is supposed to be based on Mirage, well...

Oh, and yes, I agree that Leonardo is much like Goku, and Raphael is much like Vegeta (as warriors anyway). I would also say that Donatello is much like Gohan, and Michaelangelo is much like Goten.

Leonardo is more like Goku than... Mike?? Leo stuffs his face, is carefree, adventurous, and likes playing with little kids?? Ummm... right.

I think Leo is more like Piccolo, personality-wise, once Piccolo becomes an established "good guy" in the series. Don, I'd say, is more like adult Gohan. And, Raph, of course, like Vegeta.


In any event, I don't think anyone is every going to "kill" the Shredder. That would involve destroying the little squishy guy in the stomach --- I think they'll just keep on demolishing the robot body until the writers get bored with the character.

Laterz.

Very well said.

Ryona 06-15-2004 03:23 PM

Re: errrp
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by heretic888
Although I do believe that Raphael is a better fighter than Donatello and Michaelangelo

Despite the fact that Mike completely wailed on him during sparring --- in both the comic and the new toon?? :P

Also, as a side note, Mike and Leo were the only two able to injure Shredder in one-on-one battle during issue 1 of the Mirage line. And, seeing as how this show is supposed to be based on Mirage, well...

Oh, and yes, I agree that Leonardo is much like Goku, and Raphael is much like Vegeta (as warriors anyway). I would also say that Donatello is much like Gohan, and Michaelangelo is much like Goten.

Leonardo is more like Goku than... Mike?? Leo stuffs his face, is carefree, adventurous, and likes playing with little kids?? Ummm... right.

I think Leo is more like Piccolo, personality-wise, once Piccolo becomes an established "good guy" in the series. Don, I'd say, is more like adult Gohan. And, Raph, of course, like Vegeta.


In any event, I don't think anyone is every going to "kill" the Shredder. That would involve destroying the little squishy guy in the stomach --- I think they'll just keep on demolishing the robot body until the writers get bored with the character.

Laterz.

Heretic888, I don't know why you have to contradict every thing I say or twist it's true meaning to sound like I'm completely wrong.

Ok, first off I think Raphael is a better fighter than Michaelangelo only because he trains more than Mikey. The advantage that Michaelangelo has over Raphael is agillity, reflexes (natural advantages) and a cool head. Michaelangelo can easily beat Raphael if Raph goes into his hot-headed tendencies. If Raphael keeps calm and focused, than his training will come through.

As for Michaelangelo being the only one along side Leo to injure Shredder in the first comic isn't completely acurate. Raph went up first and failed. Don went up next and failed. Mikey got a surprise grab on Shredder but got quickly thrown off. Leo managed to get the first strike on Shredder. After that point, all the turtles were wailing on Shredder. So, they all got there chance to injure Shredder.

About the TMNT/ DBZ simularities in characters, well, if you read carefully you would have noticed that when I said "Leonardo is much like Goku, Raphael is Much like Vegeta", that next to that in brackets was: (as warriors anyway) meaning as in when they are in the battle field. Goku is completely cool and composed with nerves of steel and serious in a battle. I think that sounds much like Leo. I in no way said that they are alike in personality.

Please, if you're going to challange my comments, at the very least take a moment to analyze my comment, and please, don't twist it's meaning in your response. Thank You.

Hyper Metal Sonic 06-15-2004 03:24 PM

What's going to finish off the shredder?

4 Words:

Giant vat of Acid.

hazlov2004 06-15-2004 03:35 PM

new tmnt discussion
 
ok i still think it is leonardo but raphael i dont konw

Anarchistguy 06-15-2004 04:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ryo
*Ninja Turtl3 : RaphaeL, please read the following...*


Again, like I said, Leonardo cut Shredder's head off! And this was when Leo thought Shredder was human. Why do you think Leo wouldn't be able to kill Shredder again? I understand that your favourite is Raphael, so naturaly you'll stick up for him and back him up. ... but there is no need to bring Leo down and say that he would chicken out on the oppertunity to finnish off Shredder. Please go by fact, and not fiction. Leonardo is just as dangerous (if not more so) as Raphael, but in a cool, calm way. Now, please don't take it all wrong. Raphael is a powerful warrior and can give Leonardo a good fight, but but Leo is just a better fighter... plain and simple. Although I do believe that Raphael is a better fighter than Donatello and Michaelangelo, so being second best isn't bad at all. Of coarse, all the turtles are great characters. :)

I hate to intrude, but just like Ninja Turtl3 : RaphaeL backed up Raph because he's his favorite TMNT, you did the same with Leo. In RTNY (Comic version) Raph beat Leo in a REAL fight. (I KNOW Leo held back -so get off my back about it-, but still...). Sorry if I sounded rude...

heretic888 06-16-2004 09:24 AM

Heretic888, I don't know why you have to contradict every thing I say or twist it's true meaning to sound like I'm completely wrong.

I'm sorry that you're having trouble with someone disagreeing with you, and citing actual evidence (i.e., issue numbers) to back it up. If you perceive any of that as a personal attack, then the real world will be a shocker for you for sure --- particularly when the real personal attacks get tossed your way.

You don't know everything. I don't know everything. Nobody knows everything. So, don't act offended when someone knows something you don't.

Ok, first off I think Raphael is a better fighter than Michaelangelo only because he trains more than Mikey.

Two things:

1) "Training more" doesn't make you a "better fighter". It may help, or it may not.

2) Raph trains more, neh?? Prove it.

The advantage that Michaelangelo has over Raphael is agillity, reflexes (natural advantages) and a cool head. Michaelangelo can easily beat Raphael if Raph goes into his hot-headed tendencies. If Raphael keeps calm and focused, than his training will come through.

Well, it didn't. Mike already beat Raph in sparring. Once in the cartoon (episode 4), twice in the comic (issue 2 and Raphael special). And, if you weren't paying attention, it wasn't as if they were neck-in-neck the whole time either ---- Mike had a clear advantage, and he was enraging Raphael by bragging about it.

As for Michaelangelo being the only one along side Leo to injure Shredder in the first comic isn't completely acurate. Raph went up first and failed. Don went up next and failed. Mikey got a surprise grab on Shredder but got quickly thrown off. Leo managed to get the first strike on Shredder. After that point, all the turtles were wailing on Shredder. So, they all got there chance to injure Shredder.

Two things:

1) I find it interesting how you attribute Mike's attack as a "surprise grab", but the other three were not (including Leo). Especially since there is absolutely nothing in the issue itself to back up that assertion.

2) Despite your rather circular and roundabout explanation, the fact remains that only Leo and Mike injured Shredder one-on-one. You can explain it away or rationalize it however you wish, but the facts remain.

About the TMNT/ DBZ simularities in characters, well, if you read carefully you would have noticed that when I said "Leonardo is much like Goku, Raphael is Much like Vegeta", that next to that in brackets was: (as warriors anyway) meaning as in when they are in the battle field. Goku is completely cool and composed with nerves of steel and serious in a battle.

Guess you haven't watched too many episodes of DBZ, then. Goku constantly jokes around and makes a general ass of himself in battle --- apparently because fighting to him is fun. Sure doesn't sound like Leo t'me.

Piccolo (when he's a "good guy"), on the other hand, is Leo to the core (even does the whole leader/meditator thing).

Please, if you're going to challange my comments, at the very least take a moment to analyze my comment, and please, don't twist it's meaning in your response.

I didn't "twist" anything, if you're referring to the DBZ comment. I merely responded to what you said/typed. Perhaps you should articulate yourself more clearly in the future??

I KNOW Leo held back -so get off my back about it-, but still....

Sorry to "get on your back", but there is no but still here. Leo held back. A lot. This was readily apparent when Leo saved Raph from the Elite Guard in issue 21, and proceeded to challenge Shredder himself (with Raph conceding to Leo's "right" to do so). Leo also later defeated Raph repeatedly in sparring during the "Shades of Grey" story-arch.

Just my opinions, of course. Laterz.

raphael_is_cool 06-16-2004 09:42 AM

I'll add my two cents.

Firstly I'd imagine Leo would finish off the Shredder, he's always been the best fighter and the leader. In the comics he was the one that did so too

Now to address the Mikey beating Raph in sparring in issue #2, to me that's crap. All you see of their fight is Raph sends Mikey flying, crashing through furniture, then when Raph goes to attack while Mikey's on the floor he is sent flying too when Mikey puts a foot up. Now if you can construe that as to Mikey kicking his butt then I'm not with you on that

And the way I always saw the comics was that Raph and Leo are like 2 sides of the same coin. Raph can be the second best fighter but it is his temper that lets him down sometimes. This I feel is best represented in the RTNY issues where Raph does get the better of Leo (I didn't see any holding back) but then later on in the arc as he rashly runs off to face Saki he is punished

Also consider that whole pathetic 'he injured him' aspect. Read issue #10 and you'll notice Casey kicking the shredder backwards, no surprise attack or anything. Now do you think Casey is better than the turtles?

But you have to consider this is all down to personal opinion and what you take from it

Anarchistguy 06-16-2004 10:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by heretic888
I KNOW Leo held back -so get off my back about it-, but still....

Sorry to "get on your back", but there is no but still here. Leo held back. A lot. This was readily apparent when Leo saved Raph from the Elite Guard in issue 21, and proceeded to challenge Shredder himself (with Raph conceding to Leo's "right" to do so). Leo also later defeated Raph repeatedly in sparring during the "Shades of Grey" story-arch.

Sorry, but I already know all that.

Quote:

Originally Posted by raphael_is_cool
I'll add my two cents.

Firstly I'd imagine Leo would finish off the Shredder, he's always been the best fighter and the leader. In the comics he was the one that did so too

Now to address the Mikey beating Raph in sparring in issue #2, to me that's crap. All you see of their fight is Raph sends Mikey flying, crashing through furniture, then when Raph goes to attack while Mikey's on the floor he is sent flying too when Mikey puts a foot up. Now if you can construe that as to Mikey kicking his butt then I'm not with you on that

And the way I always saw the comics was that Raph and Leo are like 2 sides of the same coin. Raph can be the second best fighter but it is his temper that lets him down sometimes. This I feel is best represented in the RTNY issues where Raph does get the better of Leo (I didn't see any holding back) but then later on in the arc as he rashly runs off to face Saki he is punished

Also consider that whole pathetic 'he injured him' aspect. Read issue #10 and you'll notice Casey kicking the shredder backwards, no surprise attack or anything. Now do you think Casey is better than the turtles?

But you have to consider this is all down to personal opinion and what you take from it

I couldn't have said it better myself. Well said.

Ryona 06-16-2004 01:12 PM

Heretic888, please, don't add fuel to the fire.
I never claimed to know everything, and I infact do agree with your response to the Dragonball Z comment. I think you know that I don't have a problem with agreeing with responses if it seems to me that it's right and justified. Of coarse, we all have our different perspectives. If you want to shoot down everything I say (including this post) than thats fine. You have the right to do so, but please, don't insult me because we don't see eye to eye.

This thread was originaly created to discuss who would be the one to defeat Shredder. Now it's starting to turn into a "Who can beat who in a fight" thread. I fully admit that I helped this feud start up with my comments being in favour of Leonardo. I'm sorry.

With that being said, I've decided to leave and post no more.

Ninja Turtl3 : RaphaeL 06-16-2004 02:52 PM

i dont know why everyone looks at raphs anger as a down fall? yes he may not think as clearly and he does some pretty out of control things but if you think of it this way would you rather be fighting a person that knows how to fight and stays calm or this massive screaming turtle that wont stay doen unless you kill him and he just keeps comming and whatever doesnt kill him will just surly get him stronger thats in my opinion, cuz i like raph so ill stick up for him no matter how wrong i may be im hot headed as well :)
as for mike beating raph? i dont really think that would be much of a contest mike seems like the young little bro raph wouldnt hurt him or anything but i think mike knows he would whoop him in a fight.
and i forgot where i read it but laird was saying that mike is like the younger bro cant fight as well don can fight but chooses not to leo trys to keep from fighting that why raph is there to bring it up for everyone if noone else is fighting you can be sure that raph will be


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:39 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.