The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   4Kids TMNT Cartoon Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=11)
-   -   Trans-Chronological and Dimensional travel in the New TMNT (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=11938)

Kali 03-07-2005 02:59 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ninja Turtle Nincompoop
This episode was definitely high on the Weird-O-Meter. I dunno, it seemed so random how Ultimate Draco (HOW DID I KNOW THEY'D CALL HIM THAT... refer to the Time Travails thread) just came out of nowhere and caught the turtles in their exact location. I mean... how would they all of a sudden know how to use that time sceptar? Anyway, I guess that moment kind of came too fast, without much of a background.

You know, it's entirely possible that Ultimate Drako spent years, possibly centuries learning how to use the time scepter. But it was sudden. It could be explained later.

But then there's the question of why UD chose that moment in time. Makes me wonder exactly what set of time travel rules they're using in this show. Parallel time streams, certainly, since we obviously have different dimensions and alternate realities, but even the scepter doesn't seem to be able to actually change events of the “past”. Meaning that now that UD’s technically “outside” the linear time stream, nothing he could do would actually effect his current state. He could go back and change it so that the events of the Battle Nexus went exactly as he planned, and he’d still be like that.

Maybe. Or maybe he's prevented from doing things like that.

Yes, I know it’s a kids show at the base of it all, and nobody says that they have to have laws when time traveling. I just love the subject. :D

tmnt_forever_fangirl 03-07-2005 03:04 PM

So...if they're gonna show each of the turtles in a different dimension, that means there will be a Donny episode coming up? :D *slaps forehead* Well, duh! Of course...heheh...don't mind me. Can't wait to see what dimension Splinter will wind up in...

Kazari 03-07-2005 04:50 PM

Yeah he will :p they are ALL going to be somewhere LOL

TigerClaw 03-07-2005 04:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tmnt_forever_fangirl
So...if they're gonna show each of the turtles in a different dimension, that means there will be a Donny episode coming up? :D *slaps forehead* Well, duh! Of course...heheh...don't mind me. Can't wait to see what dimension Splinter will wind up in...

And quite possibly a Splinter episode as well since he too got zapped to another dimension.

Kazari 03-07-2005 04:54 PM

Nah no splinter. I think he won't appear to the Leonardo one, me thinks.

Mandi-chan 03-07-2005 05:25 PM

Maybe Splinter didn't wind up in a different reality or dimension....UD might have him. He did want to destroy daddy dearest first, he may be torturing him or something....

Kazari 03-07-2005 05:26 PM

True *laughs* YAY More UDness..but THEY need to split or not die or that will make me said *cries* LOL

Machias Banshee 03-07-2005 11:00 PM

Yeesh... its about time!

I just stopped by the 4Kids site, and saw two new things.

1. Preview comes up in separate LARGER window...

2. New Forum, but I"m sure half of you already live there by now... :P ;)

Whitewolf89 03-07-2005 11:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kazari
BTW the preview for the new ep is on the 4 Kids site :D

Cool, but what do you need to get the thing to work?! I tried I don't know HOW many times to play it in the new format that 4Kids.tv has, and it just would NOT work! I finally got frustrated and gave up for the day. As much as the smaller preview-thing was, at least IT worked...even if the picture WAS all sort of...well..."pixelated".

Someone help me? Please? I'll be your fan forever if you tell me what I need to PLAY the darned thing!!!

Peace.

Aska_Badoura 03-08-2005 02:00 AM

Hrm... I'm picking apart the HTML on the preview pop-up window to see what's in it, Wolf. It looks like a Windows Media Player ASF file. Do you have Windows? What version of Media Player do you have, do you know? It should work for the newer versions, but if you have a really old version or something, it may act weird. Um, you can try saving this to your disk and try to play it from there, that might help. I dunno, see what you get.

Quote:

But one thing I must say... Shellectro looked hella-gay (no offense). That costume was just a little too loud for me, like maybe an outfit you'd see in those plays with "strange" performers.
*squeaks* But... he's a superhero! I mean, how many normal-looking superheroes have you seen? :|

Quote:

Yes, I know it’s a kids show at the base of it all, and nobody says that they have to have laws when time traveling. I just love the subject. :D
Ooh, me too! :) Gargoyles had a view (bop me on the head if you guys are tired of me drawing parallels to that show all the time! :)) that you can go back in time and do something that will affect the present, but you can't change it to be different than it was when you left it. If you go into the past, it's already part of history, so whatever you did there is permanent. Most traditional time-travel stories have it so you can go back in time and do something that will change the present to be different than it was when you left, like if someone's dead now, and you go back in time to prevent the death, then come back to the present and they're alive again/still. The Acorna book series (don't know if anyone around here has read them, but I personally haven't found this kind of time travel anywhere else yet) has a system almost like the traditional one, but points out that you or someone else can jump back in time again and undo anything you did, so nothing is really permanent; you can do just about anything stupid you want and then go back and fix it later.

So far, they haven't really shown us what kind of system the new show's gonna have. Looks more like they're just going to have characters use the staff as a means of transportation through time, rather than a tool to change time.

Wow, deep thoughts. ;)

Kazari 03-08-2005 06:22 AM

Quote:

But one thing I must say... Shellectro looked hella-gay (no offense). That costume was just a little too loud for me, like maybe an outfit you'd see in those plays with "strange" performers.
You DID Not just say that!! *growls and baps you whoever said that* Shellektro rules!!!! :D

Doppleganger 03-08-2005 09:05 AM

Quote:

Ooh, me too! Gargoyles had a view (bop me on the head if you guys are tired of me drawing parallels to that show all the time! ) that you can go back in time and do something that will affect the present, but you can't change it to be different than it was when you left it. If you go into the past, it's already part of history, so whatever you did there is permanent. Most traditional time-travel stories have it so you can go back in time and do something that will change the present to be different than it was when you left, like if someone's dead now, and you go back in time to prevent the death, then come back to the present and they're alive again/still. The Acorna book series (don't know if anyone around here has read them, but I personally haven't found this kind of time travel anywhere else yet) has a system almost like the traditional one, but points out that you or someone else can jump back in time again and undo anything you did, so nothing is really permanent; you can do just about anything stupid you want and then go back and fix it later.
Umm...no not quite. In the Gargoyles universe history is immutable meaning you can't change events in the past. Gargoyles timeline was never malleable so whatever happened there happened and there was no way to fix. Remember when Demona (Vows) tricked Goliath to giving her the Phoenix gate? She went back in time to warn her younger self of the impending slaughter. But when she saw the shattered forms of her clansmen and the bitter attitude of Demona she rebelled against her. They fought, Demona got knocked unconscious. Then she asked Goliath "what am I going to do".

Well, Goliath said one of the most memorable things that he had in that series. "Do not wait, do not look for this catastrophe. Live in the moment. And tend to the petty jealousies in your heart. But most of all look to your love (which was his younger self) and remember your vows for they will surely save you." Then when they got back to the present...well Demona woke up just as angry and bitter as ever. It had seemed that she listened to his little speech "she never forgot it" and it did nothing.

Meaning she still set her betrayal in motion back in 994. Probably that little trip and the horrors she saw only spurred her to act for her clan's sake even more.

So you see in "Garoyles" time can't be fixed. Whatever happened, happened. And if you do try to change it the timeline will just go and "fix" whatever you've tried to change.

Kali 03-08-2005 11:40 AM

I've managed to divide time travel “rule sets” into three distinct groups.
  • Single, Immutable timeline. Like in Gargoyles, your cannot change time. If you go back in time, it's because history recorded that you were there.
  • Single, Mutable timeline. As seen in Back to the Future, if you go back in time, you are a new element, and therefore you change events just by being there. The Butterfly effect.
  • Forking/Multiple/Alternate timelines. Every choice creates a new timeline, therefore, if you go back in time and change something, you technically don't change your parent timeline, but create a brand new one, branching off on it's own path.

These rules can, of course, be mixed and matched to the writer’s whimsy. For example, it’s possible that travel via the Time Scepter does not alter the timeline (ala the Phoenix Gate from Gargoyles. I see both as being “made” from time itself). But, if Shredder happens to build a time machine, he may very well be able to alter the past as we know it.

Aska_Badoura 03-08-2005 12:29 PM

Quote:

Umm...no not quite. In the Gargoyles universe history is immutable meaning you can't change events in the past. Gargoyles timeline was never malleable so whatever happened there happened and there was no way to fix.
Yes, yes, I'm a good little student of Gargoyles, "Time is like a river; its course cannot be altered". :) I think I just didn't say it right. I meant, the way I see it, Goliath did change the past by bringing Gryph forward in time (as opposed to letting Gryph live (or die) through those years like any normal creature should), but in the present, he'd already done it in the past, so it's not like he was changing anything from the way it happened originally. It just defied the natural order of things. So did the Archmage's little stunt. That's what I meant. Did that make sense?

Quote:

Then when they got back to the present...well Demona woke up just as angry and bitter as ever. It had seemed that she listened to his little speech "she never forgot it" and it did nothing.
"It changed nothing," she said. "More's the pity," he said. *sigh*


I'm still struggling to put the Acorna series' system into words though. It's almost like time is only a timeline if you don't mess with time-travel. If you do, time is no longer restricted to a line; it's more like a jumble. You never know what the events in a specific point of time will be, because at any time, someone may do something different via time travel.

Looking at what Kali said, again:
Quote:

Forking/Multiple/Alternate timelines. Every choice creates a new timeline, therefore, if you go back in time and change something, you technically don't change your parent timeline, but create a brand new one, branching off on it's own path.
Maybe that's what they're using in TMNT here. It would explain how a time staff can change dimensions also. Ooh, this could be fun... :)

Whitewolf89 03-08-2005 12:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aska_Badoura
Hrm... I'm picking apart the HTML on the preview pop-up window to see what's in it, Wolf. It looks like a Windows Media Player ASF file. Do you have Windows? What version of Media Player do you have, do you know?

Yes, I have Windows (ME version, in fact; came on my comp when I got it), AND Windows Media Player, but I'm not sure WHICH version it is. I upgraded it to the lastest one (I THINK ), not long back, so it SHOULD work, I would think. Haven't tried to play it yet today, so I just don't know. I need to soon, to see what's up with it.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aska_Badoura
It should work for the newer versions, but if you have a really old version or something, it may act weird. Um, you can try saving this to your disk and try to play it from there, that might help. I dunno, see what you get.

Thanks for the link, Aska. I'll try it THIS way and see what happens, and I'll let you and Kazzy know afterwards. I'm gonna try it using the website first, though, see what happens. I'll let y'all know the result, either way.

Peace.

Doppleganger 03-08-2005 04:28 PM

Quote:

Yes, yes, I'm a good little student of Gargoyles, "Time is like a river; its course cannot be altered". I think I just didn't say it right. I meant, the way I see it, Goliath did change the past by bringing Gryph forward in time (as opposed to letting Gryph live (or die) through those years like any normal creature should), but in the present, he'd already done it in the past, so it's not like he was changing anything from the way it happened originally. It just defied the natural order of things. So did the Archmage's little stunt. That's what I meant. Did that make sense?
Griff was brought forward in time because it was meant to be. Goliath, Elisa, and the others didn't know who Leo and Una were because first Goliath had to travel back in time to meet them.

Kazari 03-08-2005 05:05 PM

Guys they didn't time travel so its okay if Mike's there. They did a dimensional travel..totally different spectrum. But the writers were wrong about Fluxing. Flux is only for time travel but Mikey was doing dimensional traveling.

Aska_Badoura 03-08-2005 07:16 PM

Quote:

Griff was brought forward in time because it was meant to be. Goliath, Elisa, and the others didn't know who Leo and Una were because first Goliath had to travel back in time to meet them.
o.0 We're just arguing semantics here, you know; we're telling each other what happened in the show, when we've both seen it. :goof: It's just the interpretation that's different. Technically, yes, the timeline was set in stone and nothing could be changed. It depends on how exactly you define 'changed'. The episodes are the evidence, and we both obviously know them pretty well. We're just getting off topic. :)

Quote:

Guys they didn't time travel so its okay if Mike's there. They did a dimensional travel..totally different spectrum. But the writers were wrong about Fluxing. Flux is only for time travel but Mikey was doing dimensional traveling.
But it had to be time travel of some kind, or the Time Scepter wouldn't have been able to bring him there...? I don't think it does dimensions. I dunno... :p

Kazari 03-08-2005 07:18 PM

Then another flaw LOL It is a Time Scepter...for time..not dimensions anyways LOL. but then we get with time AND space..different plains and stuff, but still that is dimensions...not going back to different time periods.

Doppleganger 03-08-2005 08:47 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aska_Badoura
o.0 We're just arguing semantics here, you know; we're telling each other what happened in the show, when we've both seen it. :goof: It's just the interpretation that's different. Technically, yes, the timeline was set in stone and nothing could be changed. It depends on how exactly you define 'changed'. The episodes are the evidence, and we both obviously know them pretty well. We're just getting off topic. :)

Fair enough I thought that too. It's just that I love that show. :) Gargoyles comes first (sorry TMNT fans) then TMNT. Maybe we should start a "Gargoyles" thread in the General discussion or something.

Anyways I get the feeling UD didn't intend to send them off to different dimensions like that. Remember what Lord Simultaneous said? Something about UD not being able to handle the time sceptor. So maybe he intended something different like warp them into the sun and got this instead.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:04 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.