The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Jim Lawson's art is a reflection and metaphor of the type of person he is (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=13430)

Space Lieutenant Josh 08-10-2005 04:29 PM

Jim Lawson's art is a reflection and metaphor of the type of person he is
 
I was thinking the other day about Jim Lawson's artwork. Say what you will about it-- I enjoy it and always have.

It's stylized, but do you ever think that maybe the stylization is a metaphor for the amount of pressure he's under to create? I mean, the man pencils a lot-- a LOT, and has for a number of years. As he's continued, more and more has poured on, and he's become faster and faster. The inks capture the pencils' raw energy, which is what they have basically become-- pure action, with less emphasis on correct anatomy--- just more and more movement.

I dunno, it's just a thought. The characters are always moving and alive, kinda like Lawson has to be to keep up with so many pencilling obligations. They complement each other, him and his art.

Any thoughts on that?

Weapon X 08-10-2005 04:33 PM

I liked Lawsons art in the early Vol. 1 days, "Return To New York" to be exact and his style did change alot from the begining to now, and I kinda agree with what people say about his art now, how the humans arent exactly well drawn and the TMNT look kinda not like Turtles, but Lawson is Lawson and that shouldn't change the story at all.

Tigerfog 08-11-2005 01:21 AM

Yeah, it takes an acquired taste to appreciate Jim Lawson's art. Most common comic/manga readers find it ugly (personal experience with my friends).
The characters' movements are quite flashy like you said, and it's actually what makes me keep reading TMNT even now. Otherwise, whenever there's a closeup on a human character's face, I unwillingly let out a little 'ugh'. I can't help it. The way he draws women just makes me uneasy.
Somehow... I can still appreciate his art for what it is. But I think it'd be better if another artist took over for the main TMNT VOL4 comics and Jim moved to the Tales of TMNT VOL2... that is, of course, once the current story arc is completed (for the sake of continuity).

raphael_is_cool 08-12-2005 01:35 PM

It's not that his art is completely terrible. The inking is just lazy and sucks.

DrSpengler 08-12-2005 02:39 PM

I just can't bring myself to like Lawson's art. I'm used to it, no doubt about that, I just don't like it.

However, I'd rather he stayed on vol 4 and didn't draw for Tales any longer, as Tales is the better of the two books, features guest artists and writers, and comes out more frequently. The less Lawson the better.

Dane E5R 08-12-2005 04:54 PM

What angers me the most about Lawson is the fact that I know he's capable of better. As mentioned, his Return to New York stuff is probably some of the best TMNT art ever printed. And while his City At War stuff wasn't quite as good as Return to New York, it was still very nice. But this stuff he's churning out for Vol. 4, it's just like.. Come on, man. Are you even trying? I simply do not, CAN NOT understand it.

twopinacoladas 08-12-2005 06:27 PM

I like his art he is good at what he does imo but I have to agree with the way he draws humans at times leaves more to be desired. I like the art in the issues of Tales of the TMNT vol 1 I have with him and Ryan Brown doing the inks I have not read any of those books in a while but I think its some very good work. Return to NY was the best imo but he worked from detailed layouts by Eastman and Laird also had them inking along with Eric Talbot(? cant remember the other artist?) City at war was also good imo. He has done a lot for the TMNT comics for Mirage more then any other artist more then Eastman and Laird for pencils anyway I still like those early issues way more then his stuff but he is basically the unofficial official TMNT artist lol.

I just ran through the thumbnails the on official site and refreshed on vol 4 his art is good but I wouldn't mind seeing another artist do vol 4 eventually but with the pace the comic comes out I dont think it would ever happen unless Laird decides to run it like 5-10 years longer.

Though with that in mind I am happy with having other artist doing tales vol2 I am liking this Leonardo story arc though when I first saw the cover I thought Rick Remender's heads for the turtles looked odd with the new boxier style head but I like it and its some very nice work. I also have to mention in issue 11 where Splinter had that two page spread and the page before that was awesome also its a little more like the style of the new show but I have been liking that series a lot.

Jaf 08-23-2005 02:40 AM

I hate Jim Davis. Garfield and Odie are ugly; I mean do they even look like a cat and a dog? Just two big bubble eyes with a distorted smile! And what's with Charles M. Schulz? His human's head's are larger than their bodies! And Snoopy looks like a whale, not a beagle. And Vaughn Bodé? Distorted lines, cheezy expressions, caricatural proportions, berk!!! We should take all these sickos and show their work in a new «Degenarated Art» exhibition, like they did in Germany in the '30s. They knew how to do it in those days...

:lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: ;)

Seriously, guys and gals, take a look at all the TMNT guest artists, take a look at Gobbledygook, Prime Slime Tales, Bade Biker, Grunts, Turtle Soup, Rockola, Plastron Cafe; take a look at the books Tundra Publishing published; take a look at the books Mirage is founding through its Xeric Foundation. Jim Lawson is doing turtles because his art IS the kind of thing that the Mirage crew has published and wants to publish. And the turtles, in the comic media, ARE vehicles for this kind of art. Always were, always will be as long as Mirage is in charge. Should they lose interest in comics, they'd license to another publisher, like they did with Image. But they aren't in the publishing biz to make the turtles popular (they have T.V., movies, toys, etc. to do this); they're in the biz to publish the kind of comix they like. And I can tell you that there is a heck of a lot of people who like their style as well.

Lawson's my man. I read TMNT because I like his (and other Mirage artists/guests) style. Those guys taught me to love comics, and completely changed my view of this form of art. Give me a Guzzi / Bade Biker crossover and I'll be camping in front of my comic shop.

Space Lieutenant Josh 08-23-2005 03:58 PM

I'm not sure if I communicated what I said clearly--- I was commenting on how Lawson's style has changed over the years as more and more work has piled on... Like, the figures are stretched thin (physically), just like Lawson (mentally, workload-wise).

I thought it was kinda interesting. I still like Lawson's art, but man, the stuff in Tales with Ryan Brown was fantastic. That's probably some of my favorite Turtle art there is.

Dane E5R 08-23-2005 04:55 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaf
I hate Jim Davis. Garfield and Odie are ugly; I mean do they even look like a cat and a dog? Just two big bubble eyes with a distorted smile! And what's with Charles M. Schulz? His human's head's are larger than their bodies! And Snoopy looks like a whale, not a beagle. And Vaughn Bodé? Distorted lines, cheezy expressions, caricatural proportions, berk!!! We should take all these sickos and show their work in a new «Degenarated Art» exhibition, like they did in Germany in the '30s. They knew how to do it in those days...

You see, the difference here is, those artists are cartoonists. They draw cartoons. Short, comical, not to be taken seriously cartoons. Jim Lawson, however, is drawing a mature, (supposed to be) action oriented comic book. There's a big difference. If you don't believe me, then answer me this: Could you imagine Jim Davis or Charles M. Schulz penciling an issue of X-Men? Hell no. Marvel would have laughed at them if they'd even applied using their respective styles. The point is, those artists are working with a different medium, with different standards.
And quite honestly, I believe that if it weren't for Laird, Lawson would have never made it in the comic book industry using the style he's using now.

Buslady 08-23-2005 05:31 PM

IMHO...I dont care for Lawson...I was reading my handful of V2 issues he did and they look good. I look at the new stuff, and doesnt seem as good as it was before. I dunno...I think his people look funny. HIs turtles are ok, I can go with his turtles but his people just look funny. His females do not look female...and he draws funny big lips on them!

KROW 08-23-2005 07:29 PM

Good observation, Josh. I also have noticed that his work has been less refined and a bit choppy since his earlier days.

I still think he's a good artist (his background work, especially), but the only thing I don't like, and haven't since I first laid eyes on his material, is the way he draws human hands. Other than that, I don't think he's that bad.

Jaf 08-23-2005 09:53 PM

mediums and standards...
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Elite5Raph
You see, the difference here is, those artists are cartoonists. They draw cartoons. Short, comical, not to be taken seriously cartoons.

Vaughn Bodé is a CARTOONIST?!?!?!? And do you seriously pretend that Schulz's Peanuts is not to be taken seriously?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Elite5Raph
Jim Lawson, however, is drawing a mature, (supposed to be) action oriented comic book. There's a big difference. If you don't believe me, then answer me this: Could you imagine Jim Davis or Charles M. Schulz penciling an issue of X-Men?

Well, lad, ain't no Mirage artist that would even WANT to draw X-Men!! Laird and Eastman plainly HATE Marvel because of what they did to Jack Kirby! They refused to work for Marvel back in the days the turtles were the «next big thnig»; in fact, they LAUGHED at those big Marvel executives when presented with their new working conditions : «That's all you can offer? Then let's forget it, dudes, it's all the way back to NoHo for us!»

And... wait a sec'... are you suggesting that X-Men and that kind of comics are «mature» and «to be taken seriously» opposed to Peanuts or Garfield? :ohwell:
Granted, the X-Men flick was great pro gay rights propaganda...

Quote:

Originally Posted by Elite5Raph
The point is, those artists are working with a different medium, with different standards.

You're right on that : there is cartoons, comics... and comix. Face it man, TMNT is NOT a mainstream comic franchise, because Mirage don't want it to be. When they tried to launch the Next sub-company back in the '90s, Mirage said it was their first take at one fun genre : the supehero comic. Meaning : they never considered anything they published before as «superhero» comics. X-Men can be great (or Batman, Avengers, Sup', name it), but it is undoubtebly a superhero comic. Mirage & TMNT = comix; different medium, different standard. They may be walking the thin line, but just look at the people they publish! It's clear where their hearts lie.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Elite5Raph
And quite honestly, I believe that if it weren't for Laird, Lawson would have never made it in the comic book industry using the style he's using now.

And the whole point, the «raison d'être», the goal of Mirage, Tundra, the Xeric or TMNT is to give some highly talented folks with a distinctive and unique style a publishing medium by which they are not bound by the industry's conservative standards.

«The Ninja Turtles comics were an enjoyable experience; there was absolute artistic and editorial freedom, and, flush with its success, the parent company was extremely generous with its money.» Milton Knight speaking. And no, Knight never did X-Men
No hard feelings, Elite5Raph, but this whole anti-Lawson vendetta is seriously starting to get frustrating by the thickness of its argumentation. People should read the stuff they like; I have a hard time understanding why people who don't like Mirage comics in general would continue to read it for some mysterious attachment to the basic concept of some of its characters. The big companies are full of other titles they could enjoy!

Dane E5R 08-24-2005 02:17 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaf
Vaughn Bodé is a CARTOONIST?!?!?!? And do you seriously pretend that Schulz's Peanuts is not to be taken seriously?!

I'll admit, I had no idea who Vaughn Bode was. And um.. who takes Peanuts seriously?!

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaf
Well, lad, ain't no Mirage artist that would even WANT to draw X-Men!! Laird and Eastman plainly HATE Marvel because of what they did to Jack Kirby! They refused to work for Marvel back in the days the turtles were the «next big thnig»; in fact, they LAUGHED at those big Marvel executives when presented with their new working conditions : «That's all you can offer? Then let's forget it, dudes, it's all the way back to NoHo for us!»!

X-Men was JUST an example, dude. My point was that Jim Lawson could not work for anyone other than Mirage using the style he currently uses, because it simply isn't up to the industry's standards.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaf
And... wait a sec'... are you suggesting that X-Men and that kind of comics are «mature» and «to be taken seriously» opposed to Peanuts or Garfield? :ohwell: !

Um. Dude? Do you realize that Garfield is a cartoon strip about an overweight cat with big ass eyes, who sleeps all day and eats lasagna? I doubt very seriously that Jim Davis created the strip with intentions beyond making the reader laugh, and although Schulz's work had some slight christian undertones, the same pretty much goes for him as well.


Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaf
You're right on that : there is cartoons, comics... and comix. Face it man, TMNT is NOT a mainstream comic franchise, because Mirage don't want it to be. When they tried to launch the Next sub-company back in the '90s, Mirage said it was their first take at one fun genre : the supehero comic. Meaning : they never considered anything they published before as «superhero» comics. X-Men can be great (or Batman, Avengers, Sup', name it), but it is undoubtebly a superhero comic. Mirage & TMNT = comix; different medium, different standard. They may be walking the thin line, but just look at the people they publish! It's clear where their hearts lie.!


I've never once seen Peter Laird tell anybody "Slag off! We don't make comics, here! We make COMIX! DOI! ANYBODY can tell the difference!" I myself have never really considered TMNT "SUPER" heroes, but they are heroes, albeit reluctant, that combat evil. That's damn close enough for me. "Just look at the people they publish?" You speak as though EVERYONE at Mirage draws on the same half assed level as Lawson. That couldn't be further from the truth. A.C. Farley, Dan Berger, Mike Dooney, Eric Talbot? Aces. Any one of them could easily get work else where. Hell, Lawson probably could too if he would pick his game back up. The people they've gotten to draw Tales thus far are also talented artists from within the industry. No one else with funky wonky boxy rush job looking styles like Lawson, which is why Tales is much more popular.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jaf
And the whole point, the «raison d'être», the goal of Mirage, Tundra, the Xeric or TMNT is to give some highly talented folks with a distinctive and unique style a publishing medium by which they are not bound by the industry's conservative standards.

«The Ninja Turtles comics were an enjoyable experience; there was absolute artistic and editorial freedom, and, flush with its success, the parent company was extremely generous with its money.» Milton Knight speaking. And no, Knight never did X-Men
No hard feelings, Elite5Raph, but this whole anti-Lawson vendetta is seriously starting to get frustrating by the thickness of its argumentation. People should read the stuff they like; I have a hard time understanding why people who don't like Mirage comics in general would continue to read it for some mysterious attachment to the basic concept of some of its characters. The big companies are full of other titles they could enjoy!

I actually haven't bought an issue of vol. 4 in quite some time. Too many seperate (and slow) storylines, not enough action, second rate art, my favorite character becoming a Gamera clone and many other factors being the cause of that. Honestly, I'm surprised I stuck with it for as long as I did. I just suppose like many others, I was just.. "waiting for it to get better." And it's not as though I don't like Mirage's TMNT comics, that this doesn't feel a THING like the TMNT I knew from issues 1-15, through Return to NY and to CAW. That's my problem, as it is with many other people. And Jim Lawson is a part of it.

Jaf 08-24-2005 09:53 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Elite5Raph
The people they've gotten to draw Tales thus far are also talented artists from within the industry. No one else with funky wonky boxy rush job looking styles like Lawson, which is why Tales is much more popular.

Two issues of Tales are sold out : n°5 and n°9, the Lawson solo gig.

To continue this argument is pointless. It's like the old debate about «Picasso can't draw».

Quote:

Originally Posted by Elite5Raph
My point was that Jim Lawson could not work for anyone other than Mirage using the style he currently uses, because it simply isn't up to the industry's standards

He worked for Empty Press, Antartic Press, Archie, City Cycle, ZeroMayo Studios.

When you work in the field of art, you may want to achieve fame, to work with the big established companies, to have your name on every lips, etc. Wish is honorable and admirable if you put enough talent and determination in it. Then again, maybe what you truly want is to have control over your destiny, to work the way you truly like and develop your own identity, to be true to yourself instead of yielding to the wishes of others. And it needs much more determination, because the results arent't automatic.

In 1988, a group of comic books creators, firmly believing in self-publishing, established The Creator's Bill of Rights, because they have had enough of the «industry's standard» and how it drained the talent of it's artists without any respect.

«The participants of the Bill’s creation included Scott McCloud, Dave Sim, Gerhard, Steve Bissette, Rick Veitch, Larry Marder, Kevin Eastman, Peter Laird, Mark Martin, Steve Murphy, Michael Zulli, Eric Talbot, Ken Mitchroney, Michael Dooney, Steve Lavigne, Craig Farley, Jim Lawson and Ryan Brown.»

You may think that I'm off topic, but we're only sctratching the surface of the question.

«For the survival and health of comics, we recognize that no single system of commerce and no single type of agreement between creator and publisher can or should be instituted. However, the rights and dignity of creators everywhere are equally vital.
Our rights, as we perceive them to be and intend to preserve them, are:
1.The right to full ownership of what we fully create.
2.The right to full control over the creative execution of that which we fully own.
3.The right of approval over the reproduction and format of our creative property.
4.The right of approval over the methods by which our creative property is distributed.
5.The right to free movement of ourselves and our creative property to and from publishers.
6.The right to employ legal counsel in any and all business transactions.
7.The right to offer a proposal to more than one publisher at a time.
8.The right to prompt payment of a fair and equitable share of profits derived from all of our creative work.
9.The right to full and accurate accounting of any and all income and disbursements relative to our work.
10.The right to prompt and complete return of our artwork in its original condition.
11.The right to full control over the licensing of our creative property.
12.The right to promote and the right of approval over any and all promotion of ourselves and our creative property.»

THIS is what those artists wanted. And THIS is what the industry's standards don't give them. Lawson, among thousand others, may never be offered to work on Captain America or Transformers. But for twenty years, he published the comics he wanted to draw, and earned a fairly good living with them. On the other hand, most of the folks hired by Dreamwave are now on the brink of bankrupcy because they worked for months on best-sellers without getting paid, and now they have no rigths on their creations because somebody else owns it.

The answer : self-publishing. «The Xeric Foundation is a private, nonprofit corporation established by Peter A. Laird, co-creator of the Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles and Planet Racers. The Foundation offers financial assistance to fully committed, self-publishing comic book creators and qualified charitable and nonprofit organizations.»

This is where your cash goes when you purchase a Mirage title or any TMNT product. And what kind of comic does Xeric wants? : «originality, literary and artistic merit, and a sense of commitment to the work. The content is open-ended.[...]It is the policy of the Xeric Foundation to prohibit discrimination based on race, color, national origin, gender, sexual orientation, or disability.»

Because you don't like somebody's work, it doesn't give you the right to call it «second rate art». Or dig out your PhD in Fine Arts and do some serious criticism.

While some fans are busy expressing their frustration, me and thousand others will just lay back and have a good time re-reading Bade Biker, Dino Island, Paleo, Planet Racers, Guzzi LeMans, and of course, TMNT.

Leo656 11-11-2005 07:58 PM

Everyone more or less knows my opinion. Bottom line: Lawson's art holds the book back from the success it deserves. I know plenty of people whose main argument why they don't buy TMNT even though they want to is, quote, "the art sucks". No, I don't think the artist should be the main deciding factor in a book's quality, but comics *are* a visual medium, and when people have been exposed to a wide variety of visual styles regarding the TMNT, like the old cartoon, the new toon, most of the later Archie TMNT series, video games, etc., they kind of expect a certain "look" to the TMNT and the associated characters, and Lawson's art on TMNT reminds me of Ron Lim's art on Sonic the Hedgehog: it looks as though he's never drawn any of these characters before and is half-assing his way through it, even though we all know he's done better.

I'm sorry, but when I see a close-up drawing of April, and she looks like a man with a broken nose and a Spaghetti-O for a mouth, I get mad. I "get" what some people call "style", I just think that it should be used in varying degrees depending on the tone of the work you're doing. Evan Dorkin's "Bill and Ted" comic for Marvel was wacky, goofy, and hysterical, and the realist-based yet over the top "wacky" artwork fit perfectly. TMNT is (as far as I know) supposed to be a somewhat-serious action/adventure/drama book, and Lawson's art is so distorted from reality that it sucks out quite a bit of the dramatic tension for me.

Maybe I'm just picky. I mean I got mad when Rags Morales made Lois Lane look Arabic in an issue of Identity Crisis, so whatever.

Aztec General 11-12-2005 04:24 PM

I love some of Lawson's work in Vol. 4. His GameRaph is awesome looking, the TMNT always look great, and that new devil looking dude is crazy looking.

His humans do leave quite a bit to be desired, but considering that most of the characters in this series are non-humans these days, that's not too big a deal.

cqb101 11-13-2005 07:55 AM

I'm also one of the "Lawson Haters". Ok, I don't hate him or his art, I just hate his new "style". His old art was superb, and some of the best ever printed in a TMNT comic. I don't buy the excuse that it refelcts how much pressure he's under. If penciling one issue every two months, plus various issues of tales is too much work, he needs to find a different profession. There are numerous comic artists that do more work than that, and have far better art. Example...

Mark Bagley. Artists on Ultimate Spider-man. The guy punches out atleast 14 issues a year, plus all the covers, plus covers on other books.

http://images.amazon.com/images/P/07...1.LZZZZZZZ.jpg

http://www.comictreadmill.com/images/pulse03-thumb.jpg

Salvador Larroca. Artists on X-Men. Also punches out 14+ books a year, plus covers, guest covers and penciled the five issue mini-series Spider-man: House of M.

http://www.dynamicforces.com/images/...Lithograph.jpg
http://www.silverbulletcomicbooks.co...03/xmen168.jpg
http://www.newsarama.com/marvelnew/S...HOM004_cov.jpg

Joh Romita Jr. Don't even get me started on all the work he does. Believe me, it's a lot.

http://www.hillcity-comics.com/poste...ine_20_big.jpg
http://www.x-men.pl/previews/wolverine_25.jpg
http://www.marvel.com/comics/onsale/...OLV030_COV.jpg

Benito 11-15-2005 01:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Weapon X
I liked Lawsons art in the early Vol. 1 days, "Return To New York" to be exact and his style did change alot from the begining to now, and I kinda agree with what people say about his art now, how the humans arent exactly well drawn and the TMNT look kinda not like Turtles, but Lawson is Lawson and that shouldn't change the story at all.

the humans would be better drawn if he learn't facial proportions


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:47 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.