The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   Why can't the use the current toon voices? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=17037)

TerranigmaFreak 09-18-2006 05:26 PM

Why can't they use the current toon voices?
 
One thing I never understood was why they didn't use the voices from the original toon when they made the movies. I remember when I first saw the very first movie, they all sounded really weird to me. Of course I got over it pretty quickly and it didn't ruin the movie in any way. Heck the voices really grew on me.

I'm pretty sure the current new movie doesn't use the current voice actors either, but really, why do they do that? What is wrong with using the same actors? I'm very curious about this. I mean, I can't say if I'll like the new voices, but hearing the same voices as the toon gives it a more of a feeling of continuity. For one thing, don't you think the current cast--who by now have really grown into their roles--could do a better job cause they've been doing it longer? I don't think the new cast would suck, cause I know nothing about them. I have no reason to dislike them, and from all the info we've gotten so far, the people involve really know what they're doing. I guess I'll have to adjust.

Still, I'm very thankful that they aren't using big name actors just for the heck of it. I mean, heavens forbid they should get Tom Cruise to voice one of the turtles just so they can attache a "big name" movie star to the movie. That would be like casting Jacky Chan into the role of Sun Ce...

Ecto Jedi 09-18-2006 06:11 PM

To be quite honest with you, I'm kind of glad that they're using different voices for the film. I have nothing against the current toon voice actors, quite the contrary; I think they do a heck of a job. But having different voices for the Turtles and Splinter will really help set the movie apart from any other incarnation of the TMNT, much like the first film way back in 1990.

TerranigmaFreak 09-18-2006 06:17 PM

I don't really mind the new voices, I'm just curious as to why they use new voices.

Mandi-chan 09-18-2006 07:20 PM

I love the new toon, but to be perfectly honest...the only two voices from that show that I think are good enough to do the movies are Donnie and Leo.

Raph, Mikey, and Splinter's actors just aren't good enough in my opinion to do the job. They're fine for the new toon, but they wouldn't cut it for the movies.

Ecto Jedi 09-18-2006 07:46 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Mandi-chan
I love the new toon, but to be perfectly honest...the only two voices from that show that I think are good enough to do the movies are Donnie and Leo.

Bah, I never really liked Donnie's voice in the new 'toon. It always sounded more like Donatello from TMNT II: Secret of the Ooze, rather than TMNT and TMNT III. Long live Corey Feldman!

ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael 09-18-2006 08:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ecto Jedi
Bah, I never really liked Donnie's voice in the new 'toon. It always sounded more like Donatello from TMNT II: Secret of the Ooze, rather than TMNT and TMNT III. Long live Corey Feldman!

Corey Feldman was meh. Don needs to have a geeky tone to his voice. That's why I think Sam Regal makes a great Don.

Jo Dawn 09-18-2006 09:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael
Corey Feldman was meh. Don needs to have a geeky tone to his voice. That's why I think Sam Regal makes a great Don.

Exactly! Don does NOT 'nyuck nyuck'. That horrified me when I heard it. I love Feldman, but he's NOT Don. Ugh.

Quote:

To be quite honest with you, I'm kind of glad that they're using different voices for the film. I have nothing against the current toon voice actors, quite the contrary; I think they do a heck of a job. But having different voices for the Turtles and Splinter will really help set the movie apart from any other incarnation of the TMNT, much like the first film way back in 1990.
I totally agree. I love the new toon voices, but I don't mind new voices to differentiate between the genres.

...As long as they're good. ;) :P

Spawn Guy 09-19-2006 02:22 AM

4Kids dosen't actually have anything to do with this, so why use their actors?

Spitfire 09-19-2006 06:06 AM

Because their voice actors for a TV series not movies. Their professionals but noton a Hollywood level. They can deliver good lines but they could find someone who is alot better at it. Their used to doing a cartoon for kids not a serious*Though still for kids* movie. It wouldn't have worked in my opinion. With the old movies espcially.

Katie 09-19-2006 06:44 PM

those VA guys are probably under contract...not produced by 4kids...no samey voice actors. I'm so interested to see the movie though *bounces up and down excitedly*

Ecto Jedi 09-19-2006 06:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jo Dawn
Exactly! Don does NOT 'nyuck nyuck'. That horrified me when I heard it. I love Feldman, but he's NOT Don. Ugh.

I'll pretend you didn't say that. :P

Space Lieutenant Josh 09-19-2006 07:13 PM

I liked Corey Feldman as Don. Correct me if I'm wrong, but it seems like of all the turtles, Don's had the least consistent voice anyway-- and also I'd say the most voice actors... although Raphael has had quite a few different voices himself, so I dunno for sure.

Vincent 09-20-2006 02:09 PM

Sure, Mike Sinterniklaas is a good Leo, 'cause he sounds just like Cam Clarke, but his acting just feels a bit forced sometimes. He sucks at being angry, for example. The "Angry Leo" voice in the first half of season 4 bothered me. As did the way he pronounced "Master Splinter" in the first episode. Don't get me wrong, I like Mike as Leo. He's got a good voice. It's just that his acting skills won't cut it in the big speakers. (Can't say "on the big screen", 'cause we won't actually see the actors.)

John "Frank Frankson" Campbell is better at being angry, but he just doesn't sound like a teenager. It's okay for the show, but he just won't pass for the movie.

Sam Riegel, I think, is an excellent Don. Probably the best one. He sounds both intelligent and nice, which is very important, because Don is nice. He cares, and he doesn't like to fight if he doesn't have to, and I think Sam does a very good job depicting that.

Wayne Grayson...what's not to love? He's perfect as Mikey, in my opinion. He sounds like a teenager, he embraces the feel of the character, and he does his own thing with the basic idea of the classic Mikey voice, without sounding like he's stuck in the past. And his acting skills aren't bad. I think he's got a great future ahead of him.

Darren Dunstan is pretty funny, and gives a good overall warm and fatherly feel to Splinter, which is great, but let's face it, he's no Mako. He doesn't even sound Japanese.

Veronica Taylor is great for the cartoon version of April O'Neal, she's a good cartoon voice actress, but I have a feeling the movie version of the character will be different, and Veronica's emotional range probably doesn't cut it for a movie anyway. Much like Sinterniklaas, she doesn't do "angry" very well (actually, she does great cartoon anger, but movie anger is probably out of her range). And she doesn't do chocked very well, either, as we all remember from the third episode. This leads me to believe that there is plenty of stuff she can't do well enough for the big speakers.

Marc Thompson is very funny as Casey Jones, but that's about it. He's a funny casey jones. He's pretty alright as a violent casey jones aswell (which is funny, 'cause Marc is apparently a minister), but mostly, he's just funny. He does give Casey a very distinctive voice, though, and I think that's a good reference for creating the movie version of Casey. They should get someone else for the movie, but they should take some inspiration from Marc's Casey voice, perhaps mix it a bit with some elements of Elias Koteas's version, and add something new. I like the idea of Casey having a thick New York accent.

Karen Neil is absolutely horrible as Karai. No offense to Karen, she may very well be quite talented, but her voice for Karai is just awful. She just sounds annoying. Karai should be an interesting character, but Karen just makes me wish she'd shut the shell up. She needs a cooler voice (in all senses of the word).

That said, I think a very good reason not to use any of these actors (including Sam and Wayne, who I personally think are pretty much perfect) in the film is because the movie is very much a separate thing from the series, and needs to sound as such.

Masked Ninja 09-20-2006 06:43 PM

^ That pretty much sums up my thoughts, too. I'd like Mikey with a bit smoother voice, but I think the new toon Don is one of the best. I like the old toon one too, but Wotsisbucket is just about dead on what I think our turtle in purple should sound like.

wyze2099 09-20-2006 07:24 PM

It made a lot of sense for the '90s movies to use different voice actors than the cartoon, because the movies depicted the characters in a noticeably different way than the cartoon. The movies were geared more toward the Mirage comic characterizations that the cartoon versions. I mean, as great as Townsend Coleman's Mikey voice was, it wouldn't quite have fit movie Mikey, who was less prone to insert "dude" and surfer Spanish into his sentences. And Rob Paulsen's Raphael performance just would not have worked with the angrier movie Raph. Cam Clarke's Leonardo might have fit movie Leo without too much difficulty, and I wouldn't have minded Barry Gordon voicing Donatello instead of Corey Feldman, but ultimately, the movie characters were noticeably different than the cartoon versions. And while it was jarring to me at first to see how different the movie versions were (I was 10 at the time), I think it ultimately would have been less confusing than if they'd used the cartoon voice actors but kept everything else different. There wouldn't have been enough of a cue that things were different.

Using the 4Kids cartoon actors in the new movie is not quite as clear-cut. From what I hear, Wayne Grayson tried out for Mikey (and/or other characters) but was unsuccessful. But the interesting thing is that the 4Kids versions of the Turtles are intentionally close to the Mirage and movie versions. In fact, the actors were actually shown the first movie as inspiration for their performances. I think it would have been great for the 4Kids cartoon actors to voice the characters in the CGI movie, but again, that might cause some people to assume that the movie is based on the cartoon version, when it's more based on the previous movies.

Personally, I think the voice actors from the previous movies should have had the right of first refusal for the CGI roles, but I don't know if that happened.

Jester 09-20-2006 09:06 PM

I have to agree with the argument that the change is good to get this it's own universe. The movie isn't the toon, so why not get new voices? I just wish we'd get some of the old movie voices back. I've never heard Mako, but I have heard Kevin Clash as Splinter, and he rocks. My biggest gripe with TMNT 3 is that he wasn't Splinter.
I do have one thing to say about Wayne as Mikey though and that's the "Show me the money, baby! Ya-hoo!" from Things Change....yarg. He's grown into the voice, as they all have, but that always makes me wince.

Buslady 09-20-2006 10:59 PM

well i was glad they didn't use the original toon voice for the movies they don't FIT those turtles, just the silly cartoony version they fit.


I kinda like the idea of them not using the 2k3 voices because the CGI movie is a little darker in tone than the toon, soooo...maybe they dont wanna have a connection to the cartoon and the movie.

I've heard tho, Raph's a mix of Josh Pais~Frank/John Campbell/Frankson,whatever his name is this week :P

Buslady 09-20-2006 11:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Space Lieutenant Josh
I liked Corey Feldman as Don. Correct me if I'm wrong, but it seems like of all the turtles, Don's had the least consistent voice anyway-- and also I'd say the most voice actors... although Raphael has had quite a few different voices himself, so I dunno for sure.

Josh Pais1, Laurie Faso2, Tim Kelleher3 to be exact.
I thought it was funny that Matt Hill was Raph in 3, then voiced him in Next Mistake...I mean Mutation...

Jo Dawn 09-20-2006 11:11 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vincent

Sam Riegel, I think, is an excellent Don. Probably the best one. He sounds both intelligent and nice, which is very important, because Don is nice. He cares, and he doesn't like to fight if he doesn't have to, and I think Sam does a very good job depicting that.

Yes!! Exactly. :)

Vincent 09-21-2006 01:35 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jo Dawn
Yes!! Exactly. :)

Oh, and he also sounds a bit um, affeminite, for lack of a better term, which I think is so great for the character. Not saying Don is gay or anything - they're all asexual - but it sort of gives Don this sort of warmth, which I think fits the character perfectly and is a good contrast to his somewhat menacing exterior. People look at the promo art and say "What? They've ruined the Turtles! They look so scary!" and I can just calmly say "Once you've actually seen the show, Raph will be the only scary one," because the voices are in such good contrast to the designs.

Anywho. If they'd keep one or two voices from the cartoon and change all the others, wouldn't that seem a bit weird? I just hope they find people who are just as good (or hey, even better than would be even better than just as good) as Sam and Wayne for Don and Mikey. Shell, I think I could pull off a pretty decent Mikey. Too bad I don't live anywhere near the US.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 12:41 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.