Quote:
Originally Posted by ThemanthatwouldbeRaphael
Why do you have it in for Master Splinter?
|
OK, i admit my words about Master Splinter were too harsh. I do believe he treasures family greatly & does not actually "have nobody". However I do believe there are faults to Master splinter that tend to be overlooked. For instance i know meditation is only a hobby, but I do think he spends a few too many hours of the day doing it, the same problem the turtles may have with their own hobbies. Splinter serves two role in the turtles lives, "father" & "sensei", and sometimes I think he is a little too absorbed in his role as a "sensei" and not enough absorbed in his role as a "father". The least he could do is try to have a few more "real" conversations with his sons, or ask them to join him in meditation more often. Also, when Splinter deals with his sons by whacking them with his stick or slapping them in the face ("Shredder Strikes Part 2") I do believe he is somewhat out of line. If you were in his position, when you deal with your mortal enemies, violence is usually the only way to resolve conflicts; BUT when it comes to your own family, you deal with your problems by talking things out (raise your voice if necessary) and try to come up with positive ways to resolve fights, avoid them in the future and put them behind you, what you DON'T do is start hitting them in the back of the head with your hand or your cane, like when he did to Michaelangelo in "Bishop's Gambit" for saying "Shell, we're good" (I thought to myself, "Now that was completely unnecessary!"). My belief is the turtles learned this from him and that is why they do it to each other (especially michaelangelo) when they get on each others' nerves, and this would be a major area where he "went wrong". I also believe maybe he chooses "physical assault" as a form of discipline as a way of lashing out on account of his bitter past, and while I do believe he deserves pity for seeing his master murdered right before his eyes, that's still no excuse to take it out on his present family.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sage Ninja
Because if nothing else Splinter is all about his family.
|
Well, maybe there is something else. If I remember the original comic book storyline correctly, the primary reason Master Splinter began training his sons in the first place was so one day they could avenge his master; yet in the new toon, Splinter clearly tells his sons in the flashbacks of them as kids that he never wants them "going topside", and when they're teenagers he still discourages it. Now I believe when a family wants to train their children at an extremely early age (in martial arts, to be a bodybuilder, etc.), they most definitely need some outrageously provacative type of motivation (and to do it simply to pass on a family tradition is not enough). When Splinter said in "Shredder strikes part 1" that he hoped the day his sons learned who the Shredder is would never come, I honestly didn't believe he was telling the whole truth. Now while I'm sure Master Splinter's intentions for his sons' lives are good, I believe his motives are somewhat foul.
When I said Splinter was "wrapped up in himself" I was thinking that maybe he was a little too concerned with his own life problems and not so much concerned with those of other innocent people. For instance, whenever a situation came up on the surface which involved Shredder, this was the only time I remember Splinter encouraging his sons to go topside and fight, he didn't at first but later on he did. Now while the shredder was indeed a crimelord in New York and taking him out would most likely do the whole city a favor, think about this: when the Triceraton invasion came along and all those innocent people were kidnapped (April and Casey included) and brought to central park, splinter discouraged his sons from leaving the lair to be of any help, but they made the noble decision and went anyway, and in this case ended up doing the whole world a favor, & if the fugitoid hadn't come back and triggered the crisis all over again, eventually leading to the turtles being held at knifepoint in Bishop's lab, Splinter would have never gotten himself involved and helped out.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sage Ninja
And your comment that he has a diisrespective sence of humour confuses me too. When has not shown respect for others?
|
How about in "Secret Origin part 1" when Michaelangelo was trying to grab the riceballs in vain and splinter said "There is a lesson to be learned here, but I'm enjoying this too much to think of what it is?" I know he loves his sons, but personally, I don't find it respectful to laugh at other people's expense, no matter how slight an expense it is. Also, in Fast Forward during the video game episode, when he lectured Cody about not adventuring when cody is very smart and he actually saved the turtles' lives that episode I thought to myself, "Geez Splinter, give him a f***ing break, he saved your sons' lives and he's not a careless, helpess fool, so don't f***ing treat him like one!"
Personally, if I were one of Splinter's sons, I sure wouldn't be proud to end up like him.