![]() |
What Do You Think Of Jim Lawson's Work
Now I know he's been working on the TMNT books for quite sometime but honestly I really don't like the way he draws the turtles sometimes. Certain angles he draws them in just doesn't look right. What do you think?
|
Do we really need to reopen this can of worms again? :roll:
|
Quote:
|
I like his work from Volume 1 (Return to New York, City at War, Tales of TMNT Vol.1).
But from what I've seen of Volume 4...well, I just don't like it. Part of it's the inking...they could put more effort into the inking...but his artwork now still comes off as lazy compared to his older art. The TMNT themselves still look fine, but everyone else (Splinter, and all humans) look horrible from what I've seen. |
Quote:
If you look at the work he's done on the tmnt comic strip and some of the issues he did for archie You will see his style is that of a cartoonish style. I've begun to wonder if infact his work would be even worse at this point if it wasn't for the inking style of Eric. It seems to me though that the two styles do no go very well and if I was going to keep using Jim Lawson as the person who is illustrating my story I would hire a differnt inker for his pencils. That's just my 2 cents. |
i love his work when he's drawing the turtles and environments and most stuff… but most of his humans look interchangable, that's the only thing i don't like.
|
In the early 80s, Lawson's art seemed to reflect what he was drawing for. Thus his art for the ocassional Archie book or comic strip was cartoony and his Return to New York and Tales Vol. 1 art was very similar to Eastman & Laird. The cartoony stuff never worked for me, but the RTNY and Tales art is excellent.
When he started the regular penciling gig with Shades of Grey & City at War his style became more settled and I believe more reflective of what his actual personal style is. This took a little getting used to, but ultimately worked rather well. The Vol. 2 art I think suffered because it was in color, but it was still decent. Vol. 4 & Tales Vol. 2, though... I hate to say it, but it's a bit embarassing even as a fan. It started out ok, but has only slid downhill. It looks rushed with very little effort given. Talbot has a very unique inking style (which I happen to love) that probably is not best suited for Lawson's pencils, but I really don't think a different inker would solve any of the problems with it. When/if the series comes out of hiatus, it would be refreshing to see someone new behind the pencils. There is *so* much available talent that could do a kickass job with the book, which would also likely increase its mainstream appeal and overall success. I just wish I could be optimistic that that would actually happen. |
I think he's a good artist. Granted, he's art style doesn't look as fancy as someone like Kevin Eastman, but he's definatley got all the fundimentals down.
I do think he's work would be better complemented in color though. |
Yeah it is a little cartoonish(and its a comic!) such as Casey. For the City at War I was disappointed that A.C. Farley wasn't doing the pencils because the covers were great
|
He sucks now, his glory days are over. And his humans look horrid.
|
They looked pretty damn good in Blind Sight... though they felt a little rushed in Tales #25
|
Jawson use to be one of my favorite artists when he was kicking ass with volume one....but now I cant even stand to pick up a TMNT comic because of his art (and the stories but thats a different topic all together)
What can I say? If I was a publisher and needed an artist for my book lawson would never even be a consideration, sure they claim he draws that way because its easier but I'm sorry when it comes to drawing comics you dont take the road thats easier, you take the one thats more work because in the end you get something thats far greater and more fun to work on. But then again its just an opinion, I believe most of us just hate his art now because we've been spoiled by his magnificent art in city at war and return to new york, it really sucks to know he can do that but he choices to take this lazy easy way. |
Quote:
|
There were some genuine "wow!" moments for me in the first issue of the mini (not the tales issue), particularly the expressions on people's faces.
|
Quote:
Personally, I love his work in volume one. Anything after that has been trash, as far as art goes. His turtle designs are decent now, but his humans are just freakin' ugly as hell. Laird could hire better. |
Quote:
|
I think it's obvious Laird could pick from a huge list of artists willing to do TMNT, but I think he goes with Lawson because they're friends and share interests other than the turtles (motorcycles, etc...).
I'm going to be honest, art is subjective, but when it comes to comic books you want someone that will sell the book. So while we may not have right to say his art is crap artistically speaking, we can definitely comment all we want as consumers. In this sense I'm glad Laird isn't trying to just pimp the turtles out to whatever demographic it would sell to the most. One could argue E+L have done that with the cartoons, and certainly I can't fault them for that or I wouldn't have known about turtles in the first place, but when it comes to comics I'm glad there's more a sense of integrity rather than greed. I may have said some bad stuff about Lawson in the past, but I take it all back, and I admit I was a dumbass for saying it. He's a good artist who delivers the book on time, and for those who don't like his style there's always Tales. |
Quote:
I'd bash it simply because I know Lawson can do better, and he's not even trying (or so it seems). I just don't understand how someone can illustrate some of the best arcs in volume one so skillfully, but then fall off as time progressed. |
Quote:
|
All of his earlier works were fine...V4 work...what happened?! *gags*
His turtles look like walking boxes with some pretty bad skin diseases, their snouts are squares. His women look like men on female hormones, and their lips look silly drawn the way they are. Dont get me started on the tails...*.* (the turtles, not the people hahaah) If I were to choose an new artist, Dooney's done some good work. |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:00 PM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.