The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   My story pitch for how they SHOULD have done the monster prologue: (SPOILERS!!) (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=19163)

Fledermaus 03-25-2007 12:40 PM

My story pitch for how they SHOULD have done the monster prologue: (SPOILERS!!)
 
I truly loved the TMNT movie – pretty much my favorite version of the turtles to date. But I couldn’t get past the fact that the opening monster prologue was one of the most outlandish, and over-the top clichéd ways for them to introduce us into the “reality” of the movie. It was so absurd, in fact, that it became one of the funniest scenes of the film. I mean, come on! “Every 3000 years, the stars align, unleashing an army of monsters…” And then there was that epic fight scene that was just teeming with obvious clichés! I’m amazed they didn’t take advantage of the fact that this was so ridiculous!! My sides were aching with laughter by the time Lawrence Fishburne had finished his narration.

If you ask me, this prologue could have been so much better. Skeptic? Well, hear me out first before you judge me.

If I had gotten to work with the story department, here’s what I would have pitched:

Go ahead and open the movie with a re-introduction to the turtles. I thought that segment was necessary to remind us that this, in fact, a ninja turtles movie. You can even have Lawrence Fishburne narrate that entire, ridiculous, HILARIOUSLY over-the-top monster prologue.

But I’m thinking… mutant turtles are one thing. When you have something this painfully cliché, you simply HAVE to acknowledge it in some way.

So instead of cutting directly from the narration to the village that is being raided by an impressive guerilla squad, the movie could have set up early on that this entire sequence is in fact a legend among a group of people in the jungles of… what was it? Central or South America?

Anyways, as the monster prologue ends, the narrator can say something that indicates the fact that he is an elder telling a kind of “urban legend” of his people. “This is why, blahblahblah…” He tries to add some kind of moral capstone to the end of his tale. This moral capstone should be perhaps the climax of the prologue’s cliché factor. But then, as the camera holds on a kind of imposing, heroic shot on some warrior – a shot that takes itself WAY too seriously, much like the entire prologue itself – it is rudely interrupted by a young voice:

“Yeah, right!” (or some basic equivalent). “That has got to be one of the biggest loads of donkey crap I’ve ever heard!” Cut to a scene by a campfire of a bunch of young children and an older man sitting. There is a stunned silence.

The boy then starts laughing and ridiculing the guy (who doesn’t have to old, just older – could even be an older brother, or maybe a father) because that story is, by far the most ridiculous thing he has ever heard. “Of all the dumb stories you’ve told me, this takes the prize!!” (He should probably say something a lot more scathing, however.)

“Well,” the storyteller grins sheepishly, “it is just a legend, anyway…”

“Man, that was even dumber than that one about the lame jungle ghost.” The young whippersnapper could then give us a few lines – not just exposition, but also his way of defending his viewpoint that all these things are a huge of waste of his time.

As the boy ridicules the older man, we see this campfire scene from the perspective of something watching from the nearby bushes. We do not see who or what the watcher is – ideally, I’m thinking it would be Leonardo.

“If it’s not real, then why are you telling us?” the boy continues. “It’s not helping us against those jerks who come here every week and take our stuff! Etc….”

The storyteller does not return the boy’s scathing criticisms. He only says something that kind of hints at the idea that stories become a part of how we define ourselves – they become part of our dreams and hopes”

“These stories, these dreams are the one thing they can’t steal from us.”

But they shouldn’t give too much attention to this, despite its truth – the man only hints at this, but does not actually spell it out. Still, it is meant to sound a little cliché: “Dreams can’t be stolen. When you lose everything else, it is the story, the history of existence – your existence which remains…” Something that, again, is sentimental and takes itself too seriously.

The boy, who is supposed to be the oldest child in the group, then says something like, “Oh my GOD, will you just quit it?? You know what? I’m leaving… I can find something better to do.”

“No, no. I’ll leave.” The old man gets up to go.

“Wait! I like your stories,” another kid says.

“No. Your friend is right. This is just a waste of your time. Besides, I’m old, I need to sleep more anyway,” he says in a voice of defeat and slight bitterness. “You boys have a good night.” Or he says some equivalent to this that gets the point across (in better dialog, because mine sux!! :D) He leaves and we see him enter his home.

The rest of the boys remain silent. They are disappointed that one of their few sources of entertainment has left them. They share looks of contempt for the complainer, who then says:

“Finally! Now we can really have some fun!” He pulls out a ball.

The angry looks disappear and are replaced by looks of excitement and interest.

Cut to the boys playing a game – soccer, perhaps? – in the small clearing between the village and the jungle. They are shouting, laughing. The eldest child mentions something that indicates why he thinks this sort of entertainment/playtime is more worthwhile, like: “pretend this is the head of one of those guerillas!” he yells while running. He kicks the ball high into the air.

“I got it!” Says one kid. But he trips as he runs after the ball, which bounces out of the clearing and into the jungle. He gasps and freezes. He gets up and just stares into the dark void of the foliage. (By the way, it is night time right now. The moon is fairly bright, though, allowing them to play soccer/football, whatever you call it.)

The other boys approach the one who missed the ball. They too stare into the forest. They are afraid.

“I thought you said you’d get the ball. Hey! What’s going on?” The eldest runs over to the group.

One of the boys points to the jungle.

“Um… maybe we can get it tomorrow,” says the one who lost the ball.

“You guys are such whimps!” the eldest says angrily.

He heads off into the darkness. “I’ll be back in a second.”

He disappears into the jungle. The boys stand silently and exchange worried looks.

The eldest looks around the foliage. He is unsuccessful and becomes frustrated. “This would be SO much easier if I had my flashlight! Too bad those guerillas stole it last week…” he mutters. At last, he spots the ball. “Weird. I swear it wasn’t there before,” he says (with or without actual dialog). He picks up the ball, but then gets a funny feeling that he’s being watched.

We cut to Leonardo’s perspective (it is implied that he put the ball there so that the boy wouldn’t stupidly risk his life by venturing deeper into the jungle.)

The boy suddenly looks in Leonardo’s direction. Then, BAM! Leonardo moves – we hardly see or hear it, but boy do we know it. We only know, because we hear a slight rustling of bushes and we see the boy’s reaction of surprise and bewilderment. Out of curiosity, he tries following what he thought he saw, but gives up after a few seconds of intense running through foliage, which becomes more and more brambled and slows him down. The thing he saw is gone.

He stands there, now on the road, for a few moments, briefly contemplating how strange this was… suddenly he perks up as he sees two lights in the distance. At first he is confused, but then the lights approach a little closer. They belong to a car. The eyes of the eldest child open widely in terror. He drops the ball and runs all the way back to the village. He has to warn them!

He gets back. The boys ask him what took him so long. “You didn’t even get the ball! What happened?” Then, seeing his distress they ask: “What’s wrong?”

“Did you see the jungle ghost?”

The others laugh in ridicule.

“Shut up!” the eldest says – he is still trying to catch his breath, he’s been running so fast. “I saw the headlights of a jeep. It’s the guerillas. They’re here early. We have to warn everyone. Go!”

At once they scatter to tell their families and neighbors. There is a deep sense of urgency right now which I’m certain that Kevin Munroe could convey convincingly.

The guerillas arrive. You could do something cliché, like show the jeep drive up, and then show the mean-looking guys with there guns hop off the jeep like they own the place. Then the right jeep door opens and we see nothing but the boots step out of the car and hit the ground with an imposing thud because their wearer is so heavy.

The camera pans up until at last we see the leader’s fat, grinning face.

The rest is just infill. The main leader of the guerillas says a few menacing lines to greet the oppressed villagers. He treats the women, again, like he owns them.

I won’t elaborate on how the guerillas assault the village, but they do. They aren’t done until it’s nearly daylight.

(CONTINUED IN THE NEXT POST)

Fledermaus 03-25-2007 12:41 PM

continued from above
 
This is where my pitch ends and the movie picks up the way it did in the movie – with an establishing shot of the forest in daylight and then a cut to the village, of the woman getting thrown down, having her necklace snatched, etc.

The rest plays out as it does so well in this wonderful scene of the guerillas getting attacked (and I think it is implied that they are killed, since we never see them again,) by Leonardo. That was the impression I got, anyway. He kills them. When I first saw that in the theater I was kind of freaked out. With the story I just told you, though, I think this makes Leonardo more justified, though still somewhat… scary… in how he dispensed justice.

The eldest child… or whoever managed to actually attempt to retrieve the ball, could be (but doesn’t have to be – could easily be another one of the boys, maybe the one who loses the ball) the same one who finds the jeep and whispers excitedly: “it’s him…” I don’t remember exactly what he said. But I think it would be a huge mistake for Leonardo to do something expected, like give the boy back his ball. The kid can obviously go find it again, since the bad guys are gone, but it’s not so important that we have to show it.


I think a short scene like this (no more than 2-3 minutes) could have done wonders for the movie. A lot of the harshest criticisms for TMNT stem from the fact that it does not show the audience that it is somewhat aware of how ridiculous the main plot is. I think that this added scene would show how the movie is not only aware of the outlandishness of the big-scale plot, but also nod its head (in a smart, not self-ridiculing way) to the urban legends aspect of the turtles AND make the story a little tighter. It also would generate stronger desire in the audience to WANT justice for the villagers. By the time the guerillas leave, we will hate them so much that we’ll cheer when we see Leonardo for the first time to “take care” of them.

The only problem I can think of with this approach is that the narrator who first reintroduces us to the turtles (and where we last left them, with Shredder presumably dead and everything) is the same narrator who tells us that ridiculous premise. This is a plot hole, because how would some random guy in Central America know about the intimate history of the turtles? But I’m sure something could be done to work out this small detail.

So… what do you think? :D

Katie 03-25-2007 02:21 PM

That's Awesome, Fled!!! (the tone kinda reminds me of another fave writer around here ;) )

My very biggest gripe about this movie was the super actiony first half of frantic back story/get Leo home/OMG monsters we gotta fight em. I had action scene after action scene thrown at me (don't get me wrong...pretty animation, good story, but...will people who don't know the turtles be willing to hang in there?) and just when I was thinking to myself Damn! Can we get some down time? The Max Winters fire scene came around and the frantic pace slowed a little.

I think an intro like this would have been good 8)

Rooish 03-25-2007 02:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fledermaus (Post 483448)
The rest plays out as it does so well in this wonderful scene of the guerillas getting attacked (and I think it is implied that they are killed, since we never see them again,) by Leonardo. That was the impression I got, anyway. He kills them. When I first saw that in the theater I was kind of freaked out. With the story I just told you, though, I think this makes Leonardo more justified, though still somewhat… scary… in how he dispensed justice.

I got that impression, too--that he killed at least the one guy. It was pretty intense.

Really cool intro; I agree that the breakneck pace of the movie was kinda overwhelming.

Fledermaus 03-25-2007 03:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Katie (Post 483559)
My very biggest gripe about this movie was the super actiony first half of frantic back story/get Leo home/OMG monsters we gotta fight em. I had action scene after action scene thrown at me (don't get me wrong...pretty animation, good story, but...will people who don't know the turtles be willing to hang in there?) and just when I was thinking to myself Damn! Can we get some down time? The Max Winters fire scene came around and the frantic pace slowed a little.

I think an intro like this would have been good 8)

Yeah. That's what I mean. It's really important to connect people to the movie. The opening monster narrative (without my added scene) is a huge WTF????? kick in the face. I asked myself, "My God.... is this seriously the premise of the movie???":lol: :lol: :lol:

And thanks, Rooish.

The point is, the way you start a film is extremely important in how it will make you feel about the film overall. Unfortunately, without the scene I just wrote, I swear the monster narrative makes it seem like this movie will be utter crap -- the kind that is so horribly "out there" it will be an unintended comedy. You've got to point out that it's extremely ridiculous and you know it is as the filmmaker, but you're telling the audience to hang in there, because this is going to be a fun movie.:) The point of a quick scene like this one would be to connect the monster prologue to the movie from the get go -- establish it has having a place in this world by making it a legend that you tell to scare little kids. That way, April's exposition in the middle of the film that the "every 3000 years" absurdity as well as her redundant statement: "so the legend is true. Every 3000 years, omg..." doesn't sound so out of place in the more fleshed out story of the turtles themselves.

Otherwise, my feeling from that scene was that April's insight basically comes out of nowhere, as we haven't enough connection to the culture/community that produced this legend. Establish that connection early on, and the unfolding of the plot will be a lot less jarring.

Raph's Girl 03-25-2007 03:37 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Rooish (Post 483562)
I got that impression, too--that he killed at least the one guy. It was pretty intense.

Yea... During that scene one of the kids in the audience at the theatre I was at wondered rather loudly. "Is he dead?"

Katie 03-25-2007 04:56 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fledermaus (Post 483621)
Yeah. That's what I mean. It's really important to connect people to the movie. The opening monster narrative (without my added scene) is a huge WTF????? kick in the face. I asked myself, "My God.... is this seriously the premise of the movie???":lol: :lol: :lol:


I was in WTF mode for the whole first half of the movie....then that giant soda I drank began distracting me :P

By the end I was like "Ok...Ok that worked..." But I was woried people who didn't know the Turtles story...or had not visited the franchise in a long time were left scratching their heads a bit. This movie will probably not create fans the way the first one did...but for most Turtles fans it was satisfying.

Now...they should hire you for the second installment if that comes to pass :D

Fledermaus 03-25-2007 08:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Katie (Post 483743)
I was in WTF mode for the whole first half of the movie....then that giant soda I drank began distracting me :P

By the end I was like "Ok...Ok that worked..." But I was woried people who didn't know the Turtles story...or had not visited the franchise in a long time were left scratching their heads a bit. This movie will probably not create fans the way the first one did...but for most Turtles fans it was satisfying.

Now...they should hire you for the second installment if that comes to pass :D

I can dream....

I dunno. I wonder if there was something cut out that would have helped the connection a bit. Oh well. If only...

Masked Ninja 03-25-2007 08:44 PM

I agree that opening it that way could have really helped. Part of the entire concept of the Turtles is its corniness. Even the comics... the first issue was a parody, and the ones that followed, while still being serious stories, still allowed you to look back and say "...ha! All this heavy stuff is happening to four NINJA TURTLES, of all things..."

I think the intro as-is sounded like it was taking the story way too seriously, and yeah... a bit of self-deprecation would have helped make the audience more OK with it. Not too much, though... this ain't Shrek.

wyze2099 03-25-2007 09:25 PM

I'd advise against phrasing it as, "how they SHOULD have done" it, because that's an opinion masquerading as fact. It's your opinion that they could have done a better job had they done it differently, but ultimately it sounds like an order to the filmmakers, and you're not in a position to give them orders. :) Maybe something more along the lines of, "this is how they think they could have done the monster prologue", which seems to be your intent anyway.

But yeah, I didn't particularly care for the expository dump in the opening narration. Not only did it outright tell us everything we needed to know about the Turtles instead of letting us discover it through the unfolding movie, the narration gave away the entire monster plot of the movie ... again, instead of letting us discover it for ourselves as the movie unfolded. Did they really have so little faith in kids' attention spans and reasoning skills?

One way I think they could have done it was given the narrator's lines (minus the description of the Turtles) to April for the scene when she talked about the myth. That way the heavy exposition would have been at a welcome time when the Turtles needed to know it, and I think it would have softened the cheesiness of it.

Spawn Guy 04-20-2007 02:23 PM

Pretty cool. But frankly, your dislike of the intro is coming off way more over the top than you say the intro was. But still, cool.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 06:28 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.