The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   4Kids TMNT Cartoon Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=11)
-   -   How much does 2k3 follow the comic? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=19429)

Colliwog 04-02-2007 10:17 AM

How much does 2k3 follow the comic?
 
Sorry if this has been posted somewhere before..
I was just wondering how much of the 2k3 series follows the original storyline of the Mirage comic?
I've only read a few of the issues online, and a few of the 2k3 episodes..
It bothers me that Splinter is gray instead of brown. :ohwell: I was watching a couple episodes from TLS yesterday on Youtube, and was reeeaally surprised to see the turtles turn into dragons..!! Did that really happen in the original comic?!

The Shelf 04-02-2007 10:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Colliwog (Post 489210)
Sorry if this has been posted somewhere before..
I was just wondering how much of the 2k3 series follows the original storyline of the Mirage comic?
I've only read a few of the issues online, and a few of the 2k3 episodes..
It bothers me that Splinter is gray instead of brown. :ohwell: I was watching a couple episodes from TLS yesterday on Youtube, and was reeeaally surprised to see the turtles turn into dragons..!! Did that really happen in the original comic?!

I haven't read all of the comics, but I think it's safe to say that nothing from the Battle Nexus Tournament on was in the comic books, although Leo recently went to the Battle Nexus (for the first time, I think) in the Volume 4 comics. This was after it happened in the cartoon, though. In any case, I don't think the turtles have ever turned in to dragons before TLS came around. I'm glad too because I think the whole idea is rather stupid, but that's just me. Most people seem to like TLS.

To answer your main question, though, the first two seasons were based very heavily on the original comics, but it added some extra stuff (for example, I don't think Garbageman was in the comics, but again, I could be wrong). After the second season, I think the cartoon began to pull away from the comics.

I haven't been following the 2k3 cartoon very closely, though, so maybe someone else can clear things up some more.

Tinuvielsdreams 04-02-2007 10:30 AM

yeah there is a lot of compare and contrast discussions mostly because yeah it does flow with the comics to a point. This is one of those things where I would love to pull out all my comics and all my DVDs and go on a huge tangent...
Actually the closer to comic episodes were the earlier seasons like
The turtles all have a comic book that went into the series... for example Tales of Leo (comic) and Shredder strikes back (2K3) The episode with Donny and Kirby...Raph meeting Casey Jones, Mikey and the Christmas episode (finding Klunk)

Some other storylines like....
Baxter Stockman and mousers,
The fugitoid and Tricerations...
City at war...

If you have access to it just read the first comic from 84 and watch the first 2003 episode "Things change" Some of the lines are exactly the same

Now these are just a few and they aren't mirror perfect from comic to series but if you read and watch you really make see all the connections

Talk about opening the flood gate...I guess a simple yes would have been sufficient...lol

CyberCubed 04-02-2007 11:54 AM

The 2k3 takes storylines from the comics but also changes them to fit their universe better.

If you expect 2k3 to be a faithful adaption of the comics...it is to an extent, but its also basically old stuff with new stuff.

After 6 seasons its officially its own animal now. There's a LOT of differences between the arcs in the show and the arcs in the comics.

Stephen 04-05-2007 01:27 PM

A lot of stuff from "Return Of Savanti" is apparently the same. Although they actually eat the fish before returning home. http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/sho...73&postcount=8

Coola Yagami 04-06-2007 12:53 AM

Or some elements are taken from the comics, like Rogue in the House had the TMNT use a brain-damaged Triceraton to fight on their side against the Foot, similar to how they did in the comic's version of Return of New York and such.

Characters like Renet, Nobody, Leatherhead, Rat King and such are from the comics and have similar episodes.

GK Punk 04-06-2007 01:03 AM

I think it's best to leave it at "It's loosely based on the mirage comics". Otherwise, it gets to confusing :lol:

CJStyles 04-06-2007 09:31 AM

Yeah its safe to say its loosely based because alot of the arcs are changed a bit to fit the "kid friendly" standards, for example City At War. Go read the comic and watch the show sort of the same premise but completely different when you factor in Casey isn't with another woman and April isn't in California with her sister.

LogicDonny 04-06-2007 11:43 AM

So I take it the Bishop character isn't in the comics.

Next to Shredder, I am starting to like Bishop more and more.

Spike Spiegel 04-06-2007 01:13 PM

I've read the first few issues of the first series, and the first season of 2k3 about sums them up...

soccerstud652 04-12-2007 07:09 PM

I just read the first 12 or so comics. The triceratons / fugitoid story is great, I couldn't stop reading. I haven't seen the new toons, so I hope they did a good job with it.

Coola Yagami 04-12-2007 08:18 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LogicDonny (Post 491642)
So I take it the Bishop character isn't in the comics.

Next to Shredder, I am starting to like Bishop more and more.

yeah, he's new to the TMNT2k3 series only.

Sparvid 04-13-2007 02:32 AM

Season 1:
Things Change, A Better Mousetrap, Attack of the Mousers - Vol. 1 #2-3
Meet Casey Jones - Raphael
The Shredder Strikes - Vol. 1 #1 (the rooftop fight part)
The King - Donatello
The Shredder Strikes Back, Part 1 - Leonardo
The Shredder Strikes Back, Part 2 - Vol. 1 #10
Return to New York - Vol. 1 #19-21

Season 2:
The Search for Splinter - Vol. 1 #4
Turtles in Space - Vol. 1 #5-6
Secret Origins - Vol. 1 #7 (except the virtual reality/Shredder part)
What a Croc - Vol. 1 #45
City at War - Vol. 1 #50-62 (kinda)
The Golden Puck - Vol. 1 #14 (kinda)
Return of the Justice Force - Vol. 1 #15

Season 3:
Hunted - Tales #6
Nobody's Fool - Tales #2
The Christmas Aliens - Michaelangelo
Time Travails - Vol. 1 #8 (minus Cerebus)

Season 4:
Cousin Sid - Tales #1
The People's Choice - Vol. 1 #13
Sons of the Silent Age - Vol. 1 #28
I, Monster - Tales #4
Still Nobody - back-up story in Tales TPB
All Hallows Thieves - Tales #3
Return of Savanti - Tales #7

(might've missed one here or there)


In short, the comics that haven't been adapted and are in Mirage continuity:

#9 - The Passing (although there has been other flashback stories focusing on the early years)
#11 - True Stories (although Tales of Leo was sorta similar)
#12 - Survivalists
#24-26 - The River (it's still in-continuity to me, dammit! :P )
#27 & Tales #5 (Radical & Complete Carnage! Where are they in the cartoon?)
#46-47 - Masks
#48-49 - Shades of Gray

And various short stories a la Still Nobody.

Risawn 04-13-2007 12:42 PM

Same as it Never Was is loosely based on the Image comics, which aren't considered canon and kind of an alternate reality anyway, from what I've heard.

VaughnMichael 04-13-2007 03:38 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Risawn (Post 498745)
Same as it Never Was is loosely based on the Image comics, which aren't considered canon and kind of an alternate reality anyway, from what I've heard.

This is Not true.

AquaParade 04-13-2007 03:41 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Putrescent (Post 498890)
This is Not true.

Dont really know why I'm quoting this :lol: It just came off as funny lol.

VaughnMichael 04-13-2007 03:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Underoath740 (Post 498895)
Dont really know why I'm quoting this :lol: It just came off as funny lol.

mmmk well I just didn't want any rumors being started that it was based on image comics tmnt. I'm sure it will none the less though cause any time I actully post anything of any value everyone ignores it...I post something they dissagree with I get flamed weeee. How's that for justice capin' america!
:lol:

Masked Ninja 04-13-2007 09:55 PM

There are some parallels that kinda remind you of some bits of the Image comics (Raph missing an eye, Don using an exosuit) but like Putrescent said, not an adaptation. One of my favorites, though. :)

Risawn 04-14-2007 10:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Putrescent (Post 498890)
This is Not true.

Ok, then why don't you tell that to Wiki?

Besides, I said it was based loosely on Volume 3. I didn't say it followed it word for word.

All of the cartoons where the turtles are sent by the Ultimate Draco are based on a comic in the mirage universe.

Raphael was sent to the planet racers(Across the Universe), Michelangelo met up with the Super Turtles (Reality Check), and Leonardo got sent to Usagi's world (The Real World Pt 1). Donatello was sent to an alternate future loosely based on the Volume 3 image comics (Same as it Never Was). No, they aren't complete adaptations, but it is obvious that they are inspired by what happened in those comics.

VaughnMichael 04-14-2007 11:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Risawn (Post 499884)
Ok, then why don't you tell that to Wiki?
Besides, I said it was based loosely on Volume 3. I didn't say it followed it word for word.

And I'm saying it's not even loosely based and as everyone knows Wiki is an easily edited piece of crap.
Let's see Raphs' worn an eye patch in Mirage, Archie, & Image.
Both Mirage And Archie had it happen in the future. Image had it happen in the current storyline Raph had the eye patch on for what 1 maybe 2 issues then he dawned Casey's hockey mask until he found shredders old outfits and became the new shredder.
Quote:

Originally Posted by Risawn (Post 499884)
All of the cartoons where the turtles are sent by the Ultimate Draco are based on a comic in the mirage universe.

Dude seriously No just No you are so missinformed none of that ever happened in any comic book the entire battle nexus story lines where made up for the 2k3 cartoon. The recent Vol. 4 of mirage is loosely basing some new story's on the new Toon if anything.
Quote:

Originally Posted by Risawn (Post 499884)
Raphael was sent to the planet racers (Across the Universe), Michaelangelos met up with the Super Turtles (Reality Check), and Leonardo got sent to Usagi's world (The Real World Pt 1). Donatello was sent to an alternate future loosely based on the Volume 3 image comics (Same as it Never Was). No, they aren't complete adaptations, but it is obvious that they are inspired by what happened in those comics.

Oi OK let's see here.
1.) Raphael nor any other character from anything in the Mirage or Turtle related universes have ever been a part of Planet Racers besides on the show Jim Lawsons Planet Racers is a comic book all in it's self because he and Peter are so close this got to be part of the new show.
2.) The Michaelangelo story also never happened in the comic book we see a Panel in Vol. 4 of the Mirage comics as well and we never see the characters again.
3.) Leonoardo and the turtles have met Usagi in both his own comics and the mirage comics but the episode for the 2k3 show is not based on any one comic book. Much like Planet Racers Usagi appears in allot of the Turtles incarnations because Peter Laird is very close to the creator of Usagi Yojimbo Stan Saki.
4.) The Future world in which the Utrom Shredder has control over is absolutely nothing like the Image comics series Name one thing that was even close to being like it?
The closest thing we've ever seen in this series that even remotely scraped the surface of the Image TMNT series was when in the episode "The Darkness Within" Raph sees his worst nightmare himself as the shredder.
I'm not trying to be an @sshole I just don't want anyone to be misslead.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:28 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.