![]() |
A Leo rant: "Maybe you should talk to Raphael"
Splinter of all people would know (more than Leo) how Raph felt. Splinter demanded they stay in hiding until Leo returned, and Raph resented Leo for coming back and going straight into order mode, basically pretending like the whole last year never happened. Leaving to train was one thing, but then to STAY there after the training was over and to not even acknowledge life back home is totally another.
Leo even admits to Splinter: "I was caught up in my own world, I forgot about everyone else." So how is his "Ghost of the Jungle" any different from Raph's "Nightwatcher"? They're ONE AND THE SAME. Which makes one wonder why Leo hated the Nightwatcher so much... I sure as heck don't understand it. Leo just didn't want to admit to Raph that he was WRONG. If Raph wanted an apology then jeez, step up to the task and be a leader, Leo. You're just as guilty of making a bad situation worse. Whoops, back to the subject of the post: Splinter knew if Leo talked to Raph it would have smoothed things over a lot more quickly. I mean, he raised them--and though he knows Don and Mikey would accept Leo back without question and while Splinter himself may understand why Leo stayed away so long, he knows Raph does not. Raph is the one brother who sees Leo's decision to stay and find himself as the other extreme--desertion. A leader doesn't forget about his troops. And Raph wouldn't admit that he wanted Leo there not only because he's his brother but because he knows that as a team they are all needed. Read: a leader is needed. If Leo refuses to come back and need them then Raph's going to be his OWN leader. And that's exactly what he did. Too bad so sad, Leo. True, Raph didn't necessarily want anything to do with Leo right away: "Leo's back, better go say hello before he leaves again"... but Leo didn't exactly start things out with a bam by dissing Nightwatcher almost immediately. I can't help but feel that if Leo had actually talked to Raph instead of being so stand-offish and I-don't-need-to-explain-myself-since-you're-the-only-one-who-has-a-problem-with-me, then things might have been different. Leo was TOLD that his brothers needed him by April and TOLD by Splinter his absence affected Raph the most. I'd stop and think "Wow... it does probably seem like I deserted them. Raph's obviously still mad at me, maybe I should tell him why I stayed down there--that I'm not perfect. That becoming a better leader was taking longer than I thought. That I just didn't feel like the leader I needed to be." Raph thinks Leo has this smug confidence like he's now perfect in every way... and when he was battling the Nightwatcher you could see that confidence. It was when he saw Raph his whole demeanor changed--like it's Raph who phases his confidence daily. Oh the irony. I love it. I do think Leo's "I'm BETTER than you" was completely uncalled for. Though I agree Leo should be the leader, he's not "better" than any of his brothers. Throughout the whole movie Leo disses Raph along with the Nightwatcher and thus OF COURSE that's why he's so willing to fight with him at every turn. I kind of resent the fact that Leo didn't even take into account his brother's feelings. Their fight needed to happen for several reasons--Leo needed to be humbled just as much as Raph's anger needed to be dealt with. After the fight you can clearly see that BOTH of these goals were accomplished. Which is why they forgave each other. Each brother saw his own faults, no words need be spoken. In a way Leo's lucky Raph isn't as proud as he is... or he would be dead right now. At least Raph admitted something very hard for himself to hear, and right in front of Leo *and* Splinter no less. Go Raph. I'm proud of ya. Comments? Thoughts? |
you might want to check some of the other threads--we've had huge debates about this in a bunch of them
|
Quote:
|
It's a case of the movie's script just not being good enough.
It was full of plot holes so obvious, that I just can't understand how they didn't correct or re-write parts of the story. |
I agree with you (although Leo was dissing up the Nightwatcher right away without knowing the Nightwatcher was Raph), but I think some parts of Raph being bitchy were cut out of the movie. In the novelization, when the Turtles first go up on the roof together, they play a game of Ninja Tag (Don and Mike pair up, and Leo and Raph pair up, and they try to race each other to a billboard).
I'm gonna quote it now (cutting out some rambly parts). The sixth rooftop posed a bit of a challenge as it sloped east at a thirty-degree angle. Flat out running wouldn't work here. Teamwork would. Leonardo and Raphael slammed onto this rooftop and began sliding down its slope. "Quick! Grab my hand!" Leonardo called out. "No. You grab mine," replied Raphael. Leonardo expected his brother to grab his hand, and when he didn't, Leonardo was forced to duck and roll--right into Raphael. Raphael crashed face-first into a duct. Leonardo bounded over the duct and onto a pipe. "You did that on purpose!" Raphael said accusingly. "It was an accident," said Leonardo. "Wouldn't have happened if you grabbed my hand." Raphael climbed on top of the duct and looked over at the next rooftop. "The only way we're going to get over there is if I cannonball you over and then allow the momentum of my throw to bounce off that flagpole and up onto the rooftop behind you." Leonardo considered this. "Sounds good except--" Before Leonardo could finish his thought, Raphael grabbed his arm, then spun him around before launching him into the air. "Whoaaaaaaa!" Leonardo shouted, as his shell skidded over the lip of the next rooftop, barely clearing it. "You did that on purpose," said Leonardo. They began to job toward the last rooftop. Raphael grinned. "No I didn't," he said. Leonardo looked intently at his brother. "What's up with you, Raph? Have you been avoiding me? I've barely seen you since I got home." "I've been busy." "I see," said Leonardo. "You're definitely not upset at me or anything, right?" "Why do you think that?" "Because when your brother gets to go on a worldwide training mission, and you have to stay home ... might upset me, too." Raphael glowered. "You trying to make me mad?" "I'm just saying, I'd understand if you were upset." "You wouldn't understand the first thing about me, daddy's boy!" See how petty Raph was being there? Leonardo was trying to get Raph to talk. Perhaps a little unsensitively, but still. Granted, this was cut out of the movie so it doesn't really matter, but I think that Leo's jerk-ness in the later scenes was written to follow this exchange. And right after this, Raph launches right in to fight the monster, even though both Splinter and Leo thought this would be a bad idea. |
While there were plot holes, I don't think Leo not talking to Raph is one of them. Yes, it would have been better if Leo had done that, but Leo isn't perfect, and I think this movie did a good job of showing that. Not having characters making ideal choices isn't a plot hole, it shows aspects of who they are. It would have been better if Han Solo had originally decided to stay for the Death Star fight, but he didn't.
Edit: Even though Leo attempting to talk to Raph is cut out from the movie (or something -- are novelizations based on the script?), just because it wasn't included doesn't create a hole. |
Quote:
|
Yeah, I didn't get it either.
Why was Leo so hellbent against the Nighwatcher? Because he was a vigilante? Well, that doesn't make sense....Casey's one, the TMNT as a team are, and Leo himself was one on his little trip to South America. Because of his methods? Again, that doesn't make sense since the Nighwatcher's methods were no different than Leo's. In fact, from what we saw in the movie, he didn't kill his enemy like Leo did... Because the guy was getting a lot of attention on the news? Maybe, but if we really do consider this movie a loose sequel to the original films then that doesn't add up either since the boys landed on the cover of a newspaper in the second movie... Besides, why should Leo care about how much media attention a complete stranger's getting? He didn't know who he was! The only reason I can come up with is that Leo was jealous of the attention the Nighwatcher got from his family. Mike respected the guy, and Raph (who was the person in question) defended him. But, that's a really stupid reason for Leo to be against the Nighwatcher. What really kills me is that Leo goes after the Nighwatcher and preaches to him about the error of his ways being a vigilante (totally glossing over the fact that he, his family, and a friend of his are ALL vigilante's themselves). His actions were completely hypocritical and senseless to me. I do get why he was so pissed when he discovered it was Raph though. Leo did act alone in South America, but it wasn't anywhere near as populated there...so the risk of being caught was low, especially since the people there were grateful for his actions. In NYC, the population is high, and vigilante's are more shunned than praised. The authorities want them arrested. While the TMNT do act as vigilante's, they're actions are done as a team. They can watch each other's backs, to prevent from getting caught. And Casey's a human, so it's no big deal if the cops catch him. I can see why Raph playing vigilante solo would bother Leo (especially with how heavily active he was and how much attention he was getting). However, before he learned who the Nightwatcher really was, I don't understand Leo's anti-Nightwatcher attitude. Besides maybe jealousy against him, why should he care? |
“Oh so this is my fault now Raph? I’m the only one that has to be responsible?”
I will admit I have not read every thread on this subject so if I repeat things that have already been said I apologize in advance. I have to preface what I am about to say by stating I don’t honestly find neither Leonardo nor Raphael at fault solely for there issues. I see them both as two very strong willed personalities that clash. It just tries me because I feel like since before this film was released Leo is getting the brunt of the blame. They are brothers, they are a family, and they fight. If the two of them can forgive each other and move on, I honestly wish the fandom could too. I am a diehard Leonardo fan and I have never once called Raphael out for the way he acted towards him, even if I didn’t agree with it. I understand Raphael had his own issues, he and Leo resolved there issues with each other I have absolutely no reason to tear apart and over analyze everything Raphael did. I will be frank, it is beginning to annoy me a little that EVERYTHING Leonardo did in this film is being put under a microscope it seems like. Raphamel no offence but your really looking at everything in a very one sided fashion. I am very happy that you are obvious such a strong supporting Raphael fan, I am the same way with Leonardo, but I feel with a lot of your arguments you are ignoring the fact that Leonardo is only a singular being himself, he can make mistakes. He is still young and yes he is the leader, but as the Ancient One himself says in the Leo prequel comic he is still a “baby ninja”. You go on and on about how Leo was so insulting to the Nightwatcher how he shouldn’t have said nasty things about him, how if he hadn’t he and Raphael wouldn’t have gotten off on the wrong foot. How was Leo supposed to know Raph was the Nightwatcher? Leonardo up until the point that he knocked the helmet off Raphael’s head though he was dealing with him vigilante lunatic. I am sorry Leonardo cannot read minds. Had it come right out to Leo in an unheated situation that Raphael was the Nightwatcher I think there could have been a much more understanding exchange between the Brothers’s. Yes what Leonardo does in the Jungle is very similar, he even says to the Nightwatcher before they fight that he has been down the same path as him and that it won’t help. Leonardo does not know if the Nightwatcher is actually doing what he does for good reasons or if he is just some nutcase who enjoys beating the living crap out of people. Had him and Raphael been able to sit down and have a conversation, had Raphael explained to Leonardo why he was making the choices he was I am certain Leonardo would have been more supportive. I still don’t imagine him being happy about it. Leo is very much one of those types of guys that has no issue with putting himself in danger but HATES to think of anyone in his family in danger. So who’s fault do I feel it is for this… both characters. Raphael is a big boy too and could have tried to talk to Leo just as much as Leo could have tired to talk to him. They both made bad choices that put them at odds with each other. They both learned and grew form them. That’s what’s important. Also I feel Leonardo was fearful of Raphael being caught either dead or alive in his Nightwatcher gear and it giving away his family’s secret. In Tales of Leonardo: Blindsight the Mirage Mini-series in the first issues it shows the grim imaginings of Leonardo. Of himself slipping and falling to his death, from finger prints on his shell from his brothers and the techs analyzing the type of soil clinging to his feet Police are able to find the lair and his family. I can see fears like this being very real for Leonardo everyday. Leo tends to see the big picture much more then Raph does and I think it was something like this that caused him to be angry at Raphael for putting the family in danger. And considering the “magic” men and women work in modern labs today I don’t see it being that far off form being possible. I have to admit I almost have to laugh at the fact you say Leo has a “smug confidence”. He spends almost the entire movie doubting himself. Not believing he is a good leader, believing he has failed his Master and his Brothers. The scene of his return of him begging Sensei for forgiveness for his failure breaks my heart. If this is a “smug” man maybe I need to look up what the word means again. Yes Leonardo is smug during the Nightwatcher battle, but that’s just his style when he fights. It’s a great way for him to unnerve his advisory and a great way for him to read just how controlled the man he is fighting is. Plus Leo was still furious from his fight with Raphael and he viewed his little bout with the Nightwatcher as a way to blow off some steam. I love his little smirk before he begins the chase. This is what Leo loves. Being out there, battling. How can you fault him for taking the same pleasure during battle that Raphael himself does? It reminds me of the opening scene with Raph “Looks like it’s just you and me shaky… don’t worry I won’t hurt ya….. much.” And you say Leo’s “I’m better than you” line was uncalled for… well so was Raphael’s tirade about how no one in the family needs Leo and how they were better off without him. Raph hit Leo’s most sensitive spot (his family is the most important thing to Leo) so Leonardo in his frustration hit right back in Raphael’s. They are two very close brother’s fighting of course they are going to say things that they KNOW will hurt one another. I think maybe you need to stop looking at Leo as being this all knowing being and realize his is just as capable as making mistakes as his brother is. You have so readily forgiven every mistake Raphael made in the film; it’s unfair to chastise Leonardo for every one of his. Is Leonardo prefect…. NO. Is Raphael prefect… NO. That’s what makes them the interesting characters that they are and that’s what makes there dynamic together so effective. Oh and Raphael as JUST as proud as Leo… don’t kid yourself and Leonardo is just as willing to admit when he is wrong as his brother is. (As long as neither is completely pissed off at which point neither will make the correct choice.) All I ask is for people to realize that both characters are at fault for there transgressions and for people to stop berating Leonardo for what happened. The Brother’s made up… I think its time for all of us to move on about it too. |
I agree, they were both at fault, neither are perfect, and yet the two of them are still dedicated warriors with noble intentions, as their brothers are. And in the end, everything was forgiven and forgotten and the family's issues were resolved, as it should have been.
Besides, I still blame Splinter for this whole thing anyway: it was his decison to separate them that further fueled the fire which was already between them, and led them to clash their personalities in an almost lethal battle. I know Splinter's not perfect either, but I still think he should've at least been given an ounce of blame for what happened. |
Yes Leo and Raph both acted strange. They acted like... teenagers. Wow what a concept. No one is perfect, especially young teenage "boys" who must live in a sewer and avoid human contact. Not to mention there are no female mutant turtles to... well you get the point.
Leo acts the way most teenagers act when everyone around him is telling him who great he is. "Your brothers need you." "You are the leader Leonardo." So on and so on. It's quite difficult for a young male to keep a small head when he constantly put under pressure and told his is the leader. After all that, it's only natural for a teenage boy to think "Maybe I am better than my brothers. Everyone else seems to think so." |
Quote:
In the Raph prequel comic, he says to Raph to leave man's problems(with things like muggings and theft) to the cops, while things like Utroms and Triceratons were they're business. But with the stuff in South America, I don't know if there was anyone else that could help these people, plus, he had misinterperted the last part of the 5-Fold Path, and thought helping the people in the village was a part of his journey. But with the stuff with the Nightwatcher, I guess he felt that he needs to leave all the stuff like theft and murder to the cops and stop before he goes to far. With Casey, they mellowed him, and since they're close friends, he doesn't look at Casey that way. But yeah, Leo was being a hypocrite, but the film does a good job at acknowledging that. I think Leo himself kinda realizes that at the end. |
I like how some folks are so quick to root for Raphael when he "one ups" somebody but should another character "one up" him, AW HELL NAW CAN'T HAVE THAT NOW RAPHAEL IS REBEL RAWWWWWWWWWWWWWR. HE SO MISUNDERSTOOD, NOBODY LIKE HIMMM.
...Seriously, folks... they're FAMILY. How many times has a family member made you so mad, you wouldn't even pee on them if they were on fire? Brothers argue, fight, call each other names, and all kinds of "serious business". In the end, they hug, punch each other on the arm, and the book is closed.. until next time when somebody's feathers or shells or whatever gets ruffled. If we're going to continue this "RAPHAEL SHOULD'VE SMACKED LEO TEN WAYS INTO SUNDAY", then we're totally missing the entire point of the series. Still, a nice conversation piece - if a bit being one-sided a lot. Then again, there are so many dimensions to the characters.. that's why we're all here discussing them. |
In the book Leo tells Nightwatcher during the scene where he is 'lecturing' him that he tried the vigilante path and that it doesn't work, acknowledging that they both did the same thing. In the film there is a brief amount of dialogue that is muffled while Leo 'lectures' Nightwatcher, the scene where Raph comments that he is being lectured too. I would not be surprised if the muffled dialogue is the i've tried this path part of his speech found in the book.
|
Quote:
|
Quote:
While it was a poignant scene, it was so amusing when Raph muttered if Leo was lecturing him XD; I'm sure he's thinking, "Geez, he lectures to ANYBODY!" I've got to buy those prequel comics. |
My first impression at the time was that Leo knew it was Raph. Once you realize Leo has no clue who Nightwatcher is, that scene is even better. That kind of double-take makes me forgive the ambiguity it starts out with.
|
Also in the novel, the fight between Nightwatcher and Leo was alot more extended. And that for a while, Nightwatcher was getting the upper hand. Mainly because everytime Leo would try a move, the Nightwatcher would easily block it, and Leo was starting to figure out how come the Nightwatcher was so good at counterattacking his blows. Then Leo decided to change his strategy completely to something he doesn't normally do, the uppercut.
In the book, I'm sure a red alarm was going off, but it does seem that Leo was rather distracted and not as observing as he should have been. |
plus going from his reaction the entire dressing up thing seemed like something he truly didn't think Raph would do. it didn't click because it didn't seem like his brother to him.
|
There are two sides to this coin. Leo should have talked to Raph. If he knew his brother at all he would know that Raphael's frosty reception of him and later antagonism was a clear indicator that he was hurt by him, but at the same time, Leo has been going through his own process - undergoing some spiritual growth and dealing with his fear of failure. Maybe he just came back and thought, I can't deal with Raphael right now. Maybe Raph's rejection of him on his return was just as hurtful to Leo as Leo's absence was for Raph. Leo was returning in a somewhat vulnerable state, feeling like he had failed.
Also, I don't think that Leo has ever considered the deepest cause to Raph's resentment of him (the whole Raph thinking Splinter loves Leo more thing) and still thinks that Raph's just got a big chip on his shoulder about the fact that Leo was appointed the leader. Leo is probably thinking: "Raph, get over it, it's been 4 years...(or however long)." Leo has been on the receiving end of Raphael's unrelenting antagnism for years and he may just have had enough. Of course, his not realising that Raphael's pain is so much deeper than that continues to damage Raph. I don't really have a point... I'm tired and rambling... either way, I agree with both Raphamel and Reira - you both raise some really good points. |
| All times are GMT -6. The time now is 02:06 AM. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.