I've heard this before, but I'm not convinced. While it's true that it was originally planned for MJ to compose the music, I don't think any of the music in the actual game was composed by him. Several interviews with Sega employees confirmed that his work was removed.
Quote:
Originally Posted by ThirdMarioBro
(Post 559219)
Supposedly, MJ (and his song writing staff) wrote the music for the majority of the game, but failed to complete the last 20% or so because Sega killed the deal after MJ's child molestation charges.
|
Not quite. Of the 28 tracks used in Sonic 3, people claim that MJ wrote only 9 (32%). And that's not including the Sonic & Knuckles tracks that were also included in Sonic 3, none of which people claim he wrote.
Quote:
Sega reps say the music was supposedly scrapped, but I call bullsh*t, because other Sega reps reported that he still got paid.
|
Source?
Quote:
In Sonic 3's credits, most of MJ's core song writing team is credited with his name mysteriously missing. Getting weird? Howard Drossin (Sonic Spinball, Comix Zone) was brought in to finish that last 20% or so of the soundtrack.
|
I don't doubt that some of the people who worked with MJ also worked on Sonic 3's music, but I don't think he wrote any of it himself. Besides, if MJ did compose any of the music, I don't think Sega would risk a lawsuit by removing his name from the credits (which most people probably don't even read).
Quote:
Play Sonic 3 & Knuckles (locked on) and read the credits. You'll find only Howard Drossin is credited for the soundtrack. Sega covered their tracks removing MJ's writing team completely.
|
Well, those credits are just copied over from Sonic & Knuckles, and since the people who worked with MJ didn't write any of the songs in S&K, there was no reason to credit them.
Quote:
Now, play the PC version of Sonic 3 & Knuckles. You'll find half the damn soundtrack is altered/replaced presumably for legalities.
|
Or, those tracks could have been replaced because they could not be reproduced using MIDI due to the sound samples used in them. Also, the original soundtrack in its entirety remained intact for Sonic Jam (which was recompiled from the original source and was released after S&KC) and all other releases of Sonic 3.
Quote:
Supposedly everything after Marble Garden Zone was written by MJ & team, plus the boss themes. Need proof? Play Sonic 3 without Sonic & Knuckles locked on. Get to the first mod-boss (the flame throwing mecha that sets the island on fire). Listen to the boss music. Occasionally you'll hear (though scratchy as hell) a trademark Michael Jackson "Whoo!" in the song at least three times.
|
Listen closer, and you can tell that it's not him, it's the same guy who says "Come on!" Speaking of that song, the Act 1 boss theme from S&K is in the game as well, and there's even a trick in Hydrocity where you can hear it in-game. If the Sonic 3 Act 1 boss theme was composed by MJ and they were trying to cover up his work, why wouldn't they use the perfectly good replacement from S&K so that they would have one less track to worry about?
Quote:
Need more proof? Here's the proof you can't argue with. Listen to this clip of Sonic 3's ending theme mixed over top of Michael Jackson's Stranger in Moscow.
Stranger in Moscow meets Sonic 3 ending.
THEY'RE THE SAME DAMN SONG.
|
They do sound similar, but the composers for Sonic 3 did work with MJ, so they could have unintentionally borrowed from his song. Besides, if he really did compose that track, wouldn't it kind of cheapen his other song by sounding so similar?
Quote:
Originally Posted by ThirdMarioBro
(Post 559221)
I've got another one mixed with Ice Cap when I can find it.
|
I saw the YouTube videos, and I think the Ice Cap comparison is pretty weak.