The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Are you happy the Mirage universe never had "retcons" like DC and Marvel (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=26253)

CyberCubed 01-30-2009 04:13 PM

Are you happy the Mirage universe never had "retcons" like DC and Marvel
 
In terms of Mirage continuity, I'm glad older continuity was not "retconned" the same way DC and Marvel restart their universes every so often.

Its true the Image series started off as a direct sequel to Mirage Vol. 1 and 2., and essentially you can say this series was retconned from Mirage continuity, but at least it was published by a different company and can be viewed as an "alternate universe" of sorts where the Turtles suffer mutilations and so forth. I actually appreciate the Image series more now that I view it as some "alternate reality" of the Mirage timeline.

And while some issues in Vol. 1 aren't considered canon, they at least do not destroy continuity in any way if you want to accept them.

Its great that the first issue from 1984 is still maintained with continuity now with the new comics in 2009. Mirage has been able to make a 25 year history with its comics, and I appreciate it.

Jester 01-30-2009 05:52 PM

True, but that's just it, Mirage is only 25. Marvel and DC are twice as old, with a plethora of other characters. It's a lot of continuity to wrap one's mind around. That and the original creators aren't still at the helm of say Spider-man, Batman, or Superman keeping the continuity tight.

If anything, it's a testimony to just how small Mirage is, yet it created characters that rival Superman, Batman and Spidey in popularity.

staypuftweepel 01-30-2009 06:06 PM

I'm exremely happy that they've never tried to pull that kind of marketing scheme. They really haven't had to either. Even though it's 25 years since they began there simply hasn't been that much history. I think when people retcon they do it so that they can pull in new readers by establishing a new beginning point. I hate when that happens. I don't read DC comics other than batman and the Green Lantern, so for me the only comic that's been retconed has been Spiderman. And that irritates the crap out of me.

Mirage would never have to do that because in their actual continuity there's only like 20 some issues from the first volume, 13 from the second, and 29 from the fourth that really make a difference. I would like some of the stories to be considered important like The River, but I think I've seen that he's dismissed that story as non continuity.

So if they really wanted to pull new readers into a new comic all they'd have to do is print like 3 trades for people to pick up.

Cipher 01-30-2009 06:54 PM

So, so happy. Universe shattering retcons has always been the stupidest aspect of the DC Universe.

If you want to reboot a series, I'm all for it. But if that's the case, you finish the current one, and then start a new, unrelated series with new origins. Like the old TMNT cartoon to the new TMNT cartoon.

The only reason I can see behind DC doing this sort of thing is that their characters all co-exist. It can make for some cool stories, but it presents a problem. You have to deal with keeping forty-year old characters fresh, explaining why they don't age, etc, so reboots are necessary. Unfortunately, since all the characters interact, you can't just reboot one series, you need to reformat the whole thing at once. Then the problem becomes once-a-decade cosmic crisises, but whatever.

OA 01-30-2009 08:26 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Jester (Post 667182)
created characters that rival Superman, Batman and Spidey in popularity.

I dunno if I'd go that far. It's true that alot of people know of the tmnt but no where near the numbers that know those 3 do or anywhere near as popular.

Andrew NDB 01-30-2009 08:29 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 667160)
Its true the Image series started off as a direct sequel to Mirage Vol. 1 and 2.

Started off as? It was a direct sequel to them the whole way through, and was touted as such by not only the Image crew but Mirage/Dan/Peter/and Kevin directly every step of the way before and during.

Quote:

and essentially you can say this series was retconned from Mirage continuity
Can and should. Which kind of neutralizes the question posed by the subject of this thread.

Quote:

but at least it was published by a different company and can be viewed as an "alternate universe" of sorts where the Turtles suffer mutilations and so forth.
It's pretty insulting to Gary's work to relegate Volume 3 to just "mutilations and so forth." We saw Michelangelo as a published writer and also getting his first girlfriend, Shadow growing up, Casey becoming a town hero, Casey and April really giving their relationship a go, etc. etc., and just a ton of character development all around... arguably more so than even seen so far in Vol. 4.

CyberCubed 01-30-2009 08:47 PM

Of course, but that series was published by Image and as far as I know, Pete and Kevin had no creative control over what happened in that book. Pete may have shelled out money of his own pocket to keep it going, but that's because it was the only thing Turtles being published at the time. It was either Image or bust, and they chose the former.

I have all the Image comics myself, and I know it had some well done stories like Shadow's father (?) being a mob boss and Raphael taking over the mantle of the Shredder and leading the new NYC branch of the Foot, but people tend to think of the mutilations when they think of Image more than anything else.

It may have been somewhat realistic to see the Turtles suffer serious injuries after all their battles, but it changed the dynamic of what the Turtles are. They kick ass and get knocked around, but at the end of the day they're still fine and ready to fight another day. I do remember Gary saying that eventually the Turtles would have turned back to normal if the comic progressed, going from memory didn't Leo get a replacement arm in the last few comics? I also believe Don was going to lose the cyborg parts and Raph's face was going to heal.

In any case it may have been a retcon, but since neither Mirage nor Peter Laird were at the helm of it, it can safely be put in an alternate universe, just like the Archie series.

Andrew NDB 01-30-2009 09:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 667236)
Of course, but that series was published by Image and as far as I know, Pete and Kevin had no creative control over what happened in that book.

Sure they did. I mean, the option was always there for Kevin, but I don't think he ever partook. Peter, however, was very heavily involved in the approval process of each and every issue, each and every plot point, and even made several creative suggestions (I seem to recall that both Kevin and Peter not only were OK with, but offered up the suggestion themselves: "Kill Splinter! Start it off with a bang!" but Gary didn't). You have to look no further than the lettercol of Vol. 3 to find this mentioned at least a few times.

Quote:

In any case it may have been a retcon, but since neither Mirage nor Peter Laird were at the helm of it, it can safely be put in an alternate universe, just like the Archie series.
Not quite comparing apples to apples there (the Archie Comics diverged intentionally from the cartoon fairly early on while the Image series was firmly written in the same universe/as a direct continuation of the old comics the entire whole run), but I admit it's a vaguely similar example in retrospect.

Coola Yagami 01-30-2009 09:28 PM

Yeah, the whole Image thing was a retcon. Volume 3 was set in the same Volume 1/2 universe and had the events follow those volumes and remember stuff from the past volumes. So Mirage making Volume 4 and saying Volume 3 never happened is retconning...


And well.... re-releasing the TMNT stories, the only ones that Peter considered canon (no more The River for example), and also erasing Cerebrus and such is kinda like retconning the original Volume 1 canon.

Cipher 01-30-2009 09:40 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Coola Yagami (Post 667241)
Yeah, the whole Image thing was a retcon. Volume 3 was set in the same Volume 1/2 universe and had the events follow those volumes and remember stuff from the past volumes. So Mirage making Volume 4 and saying Volume 3 never happened is retconning...

I suppose it kind of is. If it hadn't been done by another company it would be so, unquestionably.


Quote:

And well.... re-releasing the TMNT stories, the only ones that Peter considered canon (no more The River for example), and also erasing Cerebrus and such is kinda like retconning the original Volume 1 canon.
I have a question. Where was it ever firmly established that certain Volume 1 stories are no longer canon? Some of them may feature a very different take, but no more so than Tales Vol. 2. With the obvious exception of "Soul's Winter," is there any reason why they couldn't have occurred, even silly ones like "Spaced Out"?

TristanHuwJones 01-30-2009 09:49 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Coola Yagami (Post 667241)
Yeah, the whole Image thing was a retcon. Volume 3 was set in the same Volume 1/2 universe and had the events follow those volumes and remember stuff from the past volumes. So Mirage making Volume 4 and saying Volume 3 never happened is retconning...


And well.... re-releasing the TMNT stories, the only ones that Peter considered canon (no more The River for example), and also erasing Cerebrus and such is kinda like retconning the original Volume 1 canon.

I've said a few times that Cerebus is not being retconned. Nothing has truly been retconned. All it would take is one issue of Tales to make Vol.3 fit in. As it would with all the other stories. Those issues just haven't happened. They might not, they might. It's up to Pete. Retcons are things that happen in the continuity of the narrative to forcibly reshape that continuity/narrative. They fly in the face of what has come beforehand and make it work. Whether you like what is done is a matter of opinion, but so far, there hasn't been any retconning in the TMNT universe as far as I can recall. At least not in any sort of negative, history eraser-button fashion. Just because Peter chooses to leave certain stories out doesn't mean you have to.

Until the recent retelling of #8 hits (if it ever does), there's no real retconning.

Think about it. Vol.2 is canon right? Which means the reference made to the statue coming to life is as well, which means the Savage Dragon crossover is... dominoes. You can take them or leave them. It's like taking golden or silver age stories from Batman and putting them in with things post Frank Miller.

Coola Yagami 01-30-2009 09:52 PM

If I recall it was after the events of 'Return to New York' that E&L took a break and basically let whoever draw whatever, no matter how goofy or silly until they finally returned and started working on City At War.

DK2 01-30-2009 11:40 PM

I wished the Image series was in continuity. But it simply isn't at all by Peter Laird's vision. It was a great read overall. Truly a continuation of the previous Mirage runs. Some good story moments as well. Its something that I wished Vol. 4 had: more action at least. It certainly also helped fill a void when there was no TMNT comics. Next to TMNT V3 I'd never touched Image Comics since the horrible Youngblood mini.
I think Kevin and Peter just let Image go carte blanche with the TMNT. But I guess Peter was the one that monitored it, Kevin must've really gotten out of TMNT by then. I remember reading that they wanted the Image guys to kill Splinter, course they didn't do it. Near its end Kevin and Peter personally offered Image money to keep the comic afloat but Image just knew it wasn't worth it in the end. I originally was going to subscribe at the comics store for V3 but just kept not adding it to my list. But I was lucky enough to find all the issues and read it just as Vol.4 came along. If there was no Image TMNT run I guess TMNT vol. 3 would've been the Mirage Vol 4 run. For canon, its just skipping over the Image V3 series. The Tales series sometimes fills that gap between the Mirage runs. So Vol.4 really isn't a retconning. But like I said I really enjoyed V3. But at the time was really shocked that Image was doing a TMNT comic. Yet later on Erik Larson says he never read the TMNT. So what was all the hullabaloo from him that the TMNT are all his and its an honour to work on the property? Again I was surprised Mirage was gonna do another TMNT book. So I was thrilled. But between the two series, V4 is slower paced and too passive on the action.
I think canon Vol 1 series is more then just 20 issues. The initial 15 E&L books, E&L solo books, #19-21, #27 (?, wouldn't 24-26 count then?)), #48-62. This is as much I can think of. Am I wrong? Please someone else correct me. But Laird has stated that all the other stories by other people did happen but not yet or something. He also said that all those other peoples works just isn't Mirages or his vision of the TMNT.

Andrew NDB 01-31-2009 01:07 AM

Peter Laird responded once to a long missive from me in the lettercol of Vol. 4 about why Vol. 3 isn't in his personal canon of the Mirage TMNT.

"It didn't feel right to me."

Though, as Tristan also says, at the same time Peter also admitted that "it would be quite easy" to work Vol. 3 back into canon. If he decided so.

Which isn't unheard of. As Dan Berger himself would tell you, Dan's own Vol. 1 #45 wasn't in canon until only the last couple of years when Peter Laird kind of broke down and went, "All right, all right, it's canon."

Ninjinister 01-31-2009 01:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 667270)

Which isn't unheard of. As Dan Berger himself would tell you, Dan's own Vol. 1 #45 wasn't in canon until only the last couple of years when Peter Laird kind of broke down and went, "All right, all right, it's canon."

This is one of the ones that makes no sense. I could see Spaced Out and the Zulli trilogy, but why stuff like Leatherhead, Too and The River... why?

staypuftweepel 01-31-2009 09:32 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Ninjinister (Post 667274)
This is one of the ones that makes no sense. I could see Spaced Out and the Zulli trilogy, but why stuff like Leatherhead, Too and The River... why?

I agree. Why the heck wouldn't those books count. Especially since Dan is one of the Mirage crew. I would think that all of the Leatherhead stories would autimatically be canon. It's kind of crumby to think that Peter would keep a tight lid on the Turtles canon. I mean what's the point of having all of these stories if they're all just throw aways. If you don't count other peoples stories then the Turtles really haven't accomlished much in their 15 years of actual comic time. The issues I always hoped were canon even though Peter and Kevin weren't involved were issues 13, 17, 24-26, 27, 28, 29, 37, 42, 43, 44, 45, 46, and 47.

CyberCubed 01-31-2009 12:06 PM

To be fair what Pete considers canon or not doesn't make much of a difference. The issues won't magically disappear from existence.

It just means that the events in those comics won't be referenced in the future, essentially making them fillers.

The good thing about a lot of those Vol. 1 issues is that they don't disrupt continuity in any way if you choose to accept them. Likewise what about the TMNT specials? The one about the Haunted Pizza and such, they could fit in and aren't bothersome if they aren't.

RossMay 01-31-2009 12:24 PM

I'm with you Trist that Vol. 3 could actually be in continuity if there was just a bridge to Vol. 4. Gary Carlson said Don's mutant body was trying to reject the cyborg parts to him so he would be all-turtle again. Leo and Raph could also lose their disfigurements, even if it's a one-off regeneration. Just explain what happens to Pimiko and the Lady Shredder (cough, Karai, cough) and you're set up for the start of Volume 4.

I'm a firm believer that while creators can say whatever's "official," it's each individual fan who decides for him or herself. Some things for me...
-I don't care what jiggery pokery DC is doing, when I read my reprint of Action Comics #1 THAT'S the origin of Superman!
-Star Wars prequels? What, there were prequels?...
-Norman Osborn had love children with Gwen Stacy? Crazy talk!

Empower yourself and just accept the continuity that YOU like.

staypuftweepel 01-31-2009 04:04 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RossMay (Post 667324)
-Norman Osborn had love children with Gwen Stacy? Crazy talk!

Empower yourself and just accept the continuity that YOU like.


I liked some of Strazinski's run on Spiderman, but I really hated that storyline. I heard that when they recently rewrote Spidey's history they decided to leave that in. Why?

Andrew NDB 01-31-2009 04:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by RossMay (Post 667324)
-I don't care what jiggery pokery DC is doing, when I read my reprint of Action Comics #1 THAT'S the origin of Superman!

And that's never been retconned away. It's just... everything on that Earth -- including that Superman and Action Comics #1-- happened on Earth-2. That very same Superman (who had been trapped in a paradise dimension after he helped save the universe at the end of "Crisis on Infinite Earths" in the 80s) came to save the day in "Infinite Crisis" but was killed by Superboy-Prime from Earth-Prime.

That same Superman (from Action Comics #1) will be coming back in The Blackest Night this year with a black ring.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 10:50 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.