The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Comic Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=18)
-   -   Why was the middle of Vol. 1 so inconsistent? (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=26745)

CyberCubed 03-15-2009 10:57 PM

Why was the middle of Vol. 1 so inconsistent?
 
I'm talking about the issues after Return to New York but before #45 with Leatherhead.

Basically issues 24-44. 20 issues of inconsistency. While some of these issues I've really liked, some of the others are abysmal.

Why did Peter Laird/Eastman approve some of these stories back in the day? I can see why he doesn't want to include some of these in Mirage canon, some are just awful.

Same goes for a lot of those specials Mirage pumped out back in the day.

trustno1 03-15-2009 11:24 PM

you need to stop asking questions nobody here can answer, either that or rephrase it to start a discussion. the only answer you can get here is speculation. ask peter on his blog.

CyberCubed 03-15-2009 11:51 PM

Well I guess I'll ask it another way, which of those issues in the middle did you people enjoy and which did you not?

Andrew NDB 03-16-2009 12:02 AM

CyberCubed asks a valid question, really. But there's no easy answer.

Some combination of...

1) Kevin & Pete's falling out of good favor with one another.
2) Their wanting things to continue, with or without them working together.
3) With the blooming franchise with the toys and toddler stuff, their attentions had to be diverted elsewhere.
4) They enjoyed seeing new writers and artists take a crack at their universe.

junkboy 03-16-2009 02:36 PM

That is a question i ask myself a lot of times. Last week i took out my comic box having old TMNT issues and started to read vol.1 again.
Outside of 1-11 , Return to New York, Steve Bissette and Michael Zulli part and pre-City at War and City at War issues, i really do not like each and every issue and collected them for the sake of having all of vol.1
I do not feel that way for vol.2 and Image Comics part. I like vol.4 , too.
I guess the main thing that is annoying me is having those light-hearted , comedy oriented stories between cult TMNT story arcs such as Return to New York, City at War and the origin stories.
I like the present condition of TMNT comic book ( not the condition of Mirage but the book itself ) But whenever i read vol 1 non-canon stories i will always feel that uneasy feeling.

There may be lots of reasons as Andrew said. The most possible one may be : Cause that it is an indie book, Peter and Kevin wanted to give chances to lots of less known people in comic industry and cause of the rising popularity thanks to old cartoon ( which i truly hate at the moment ) and toy lines, they failed to keep or did not want to keep a tight grip on the comic series.

If those issues were printed as another series or some stand-alone one-shot-like issues , such as Maltese Turtle or Haunted Pizza or Special Times Pipeline, etc i would be a fan loving vol.1 much more.

Cipher 03-16-2009 04:09 PM

Yeah, it's inconsistent, but it still helped flesh out the universe, and it was cool that Eastman and Laird were willing to be experimental with their series. They didn't take it seriously at first, and who can blame them? If my independent homage comic spurred an merchandise empire, I'd be more than willing to let others have their fun with it while I surveyed more profitable endeavors.

And I disagree about the lack of quality during the run. While "City at War" and Volume 2 are the pinnacle of the series, there are a lot of guest artist issues I really enjoy. Like "Twilight of the Ring." Hell, I even got some laughs out of the "Spaced Out" trilogy, which I thought I'd hate.

oldmanwinters 03-16-2009 05:32 PM

Volume may be inconsistent largely do to the looseness and autonomous feeling of many of the stories, but I think it is still a great anthology of art and storytelling as a whole.

On a lighter note, internal evidence of Hedden & McWeeney's twisted #39 suggests that perhaps Eastman & Laird regretted some of their "loans" to outside creators:
http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3569/...f671d532_o.jpg

Peter and Kevin's editorial responded:
Quote:

P.S. We won't even talk about p. 27!!!
Some of my favorite issues were included in the "post-Return to New York/Pre-Leatherhead Too" run, including:
Rick Veitch's "The River"(24-26)
Dooney's "Dreams of Stone" [Radical & Carnage] #27
"Sons of the Silent Age"
Farley's "Men of Shadow #29
Veitch's "Sky Highway" (#30... AMAZING!)
Jan Strnad and Richard Corben- "Turtles Take Time" #33
Hedden & McWeeney "Toitle Anxiety" #34 (less zany than their later issues)
Rick Arthur's "The Violent Underground" #44

And don't forget Zulli's surreal trilogy and the legendary "Halls of Lost Legends"! I'd say outside of the unique styles of Zulli, Mark Martin, Hedden & McWeeney, and Matt Howarth (and maybe Mark Bode) all the books are fairly consistent with the tone of the main continuity.

Ninjinister 03-16-2009 05:41 PM

lol, I came across that issue this weekend and had the desire to use that as a sig, replacing their dialogue with their petty squabbling from recent events.

oldmanwinters 03-16-2009 05:48 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by The Ninjinister (Post 680084)
lol, I came across that issue this weekend and had the desire to use that as a sig, replacing their dialogue with their petty squabbling from recent events.

hehe, but if you're going to chronicle the break up of Eastman and Laird based on internal evidence, you HAVE to cite the day Kevin almost left Peter in the graveyard on the "Mid-Afternoon of the Living Dead"!
http://farm4.static.flickr.com/3538/...2e1a15f6_b.jpg

I was saving this scan for April Fool's Day, but it seems relevant now.

How was Peter supposed to know Kevin was running to the van in order to help him? Too bad, it didn't do either of them much good. I wonder how they survived that encounter... and when were they into meteorology? :-D

CyberCubed 04-04-2009 11:09 PM

Re-reading through these issues now, I can see they're better than I remembered.

I loved the Egyptian story, although April is a reporter at the end of that issue. I guess we can write that off as a one-time thing?

#33 is a fun story with the Turtles and Renet's time cube. I also LOVE #34 where the guy kills himself after seeing, "Toitles, Toitles...EVERYWHERE!"

There is some great stuff between RTNY and #45, some of the stories are also part of the main canon continuity too.

oldmanwinters 04-05-2009 05:23 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CyberCubed (Post 683932)
Re-reading through these issues now, I can see they're better than I remembered.

I loved the Egyptian story, although April is a reporter at the end of that issue. I guess we can write that off as a one-time thing?

#33 is a fun story with the Turtles and Renet's time cube. I also LOVE #34 where the guy kills himself after seeing, "Toitles, Toitles...EVERYWHERE!"

There is some great stuff between RTNY and #45, some of the stories are also part of the main canon continuity too.

:thyper::tthumbsu:

And, yeah, the "April as reporter" thing is a real surprise since Kevin Eastman himself worked on that issue with Bode. But it's all cool.

Mr._Mutant_Man 04-05-2009 05:45 PM

I think it's cool that other writers and artists got an opportunity to work on the Turtles comics. Considering the rising popularity of the franchise at the time, it was probably a pretty big opportunity in the comic world. Plus the variety of stories helps make the TMNT series that much more unique.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 11:09 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.