Quote:
Originally Posted by Peanut
(Post 694975)
I've got one for you, give me one reason why it isn't a dumb idea and I'll change my tune.
|
Somehow I doubt that, given the volatile nature of your reaction, but here goes! :lol:
Quote:
Originally Posted by Peanut
(Post 694975)
For what foreseeable reason would a change of ethnicity for the main character of a series be even remotely sensible?
|
Simply put, they're changing almost everything else -- they're getting rid of the supporting characters, etc. -- so I don't see why it would be
dumb to change one more thing. Without all of the background and depth that she developed with her friends and during various battles, Buffy isn't really a character but a premise: teenage girl who fights vampires. From that starting point, her ethnicity doesn't really make a whit of difference one way or another.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Peanut
(Post 694975)
What purpose would it serve?
|
Maybe none! But not serving a grand purpose doesn't make it dumb -- for that, it'd have to serve a dumb purpose and/or bring about a dumb result. It wouldn't necessarily do either of those things (though, as with anything else, there's always the possibility that they'd screw it up).
Quote:
Originally Posted by Peanut
(Post 694975)
Is making her black going to add some new layer of depth to the character? Doubtful. ... It's an arbitrary difference made for the sake of what? To appeal to a different demographic? To give it a nice coat of "ethnic diversity is awesome!" paint?
|
They'd have to change quite a bit more than Buffy's skin color to give depth to the character -- like I said, the character didn't really have a ton of depth to begin with (which is kinda why the movie and the 1st season of Buffy weren't all that great) -- but yeah, a change like that
could help to give this new Buffy some depth. And it could help to broaden the target audience and diversify the cast. I don't regard those as bad or dumb outcomes.
But in any case, I was just saying that it wouldn't be
dumb to turn "teenage white girl who fights vampires" into "teenage minority girl who fights vampires," since they're apparently changing everything else and there's nothing about the character/premise that requires her skin to be a specific color. If that's the dumbest thing you'd heard all day, I'd love to live in your world. :P