| The Big Bad |
07-27-2009 09:31 AM |
Question: Is page 65 duplicated for anybody else? My copy has that page twice, with the proper page 66 missing. It bugs.
Aside from that, I have to say I'm not terribly satisfied with the TPB; while it's definitively worth the $20.00 price tag, it all feels terribly bare-bones.
Random comments/complaints:
- Where's the covers for the original stories? I thought something like that would be a given.
- While I suppose it doesn't fit the collection's theme, I'm really sad that the TPB didn't include the April "The Angel of Times Square Story" that backed up "Dreamland", since its one of my favorite TMNT stories ever.
- In retrospect, I wouldn't have minded if they'd had cut the Mutanimal story and included the Black Stone of Mecca story instead--it has just as little relevance as the Mutanimal arc, and would probably fit the rest of the TPB better. Heck, better yet, why not include all of them? I'd have paid the extra coin.
- The Pin-ups/unused art, while nice, seem a bit random--as if they were included solely to fill in the pages. Why only one A.C. Farley pin-up, when there were originally five included with issue #62?
- I also really wish we'd seen something from Laird, Clarrain, or Allen about how these stories came about. Context is always nice.
All in all, it's a good buy for anyone who hasn't read the original stories. For anybody who has, not so much.
ETA: I just noticed that the blurb on the back states that the collection includes "9 complete issues originally published by Archie Comics!", which is just not true by any stretch of the imagination.
ETA2: Thanks, Will.
|