The Technodrome Forums

The Technodrome Forums (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/index.php)
-   TMNT Movie Discussion (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/forumdisplay.php?f=32)
-   -   The storyline (http://forums.thetechnodrome.com/showthread.php?t=28503)

CJStyles 09-25-2009 10:26 PM

The storyline
 
I know it's going to be an origin story. However, would you rather see a close to panel for panel adaptation of the first issue or a brand new story yet still having the revenge plot that everyone wants.

Personally, I'd like a fresh story to keep even us hardcore fans guessing. Add new characters, new twists to mythos, something fresh.

Andrew NDB 09-25-2009 10:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CJStyles (Post 722672)
would you rather see a close to panel for panel adaptation of the first issue

That would be a silly expectation.

Quote:

or a brand new story yet still having the revenge plot that everyone wants.
Something akin to that. With different storytelling and stronger juxtaposition of Saki's rise to power against the Turtles' own training and maturity under Splinter (make it like these are people destined to fight, their destinies cruelly intertwined like a train set on a track racing toward a singular destination)... all building up to their eventual crossing of paths. Which should be no-holds barred. No kid characters thrown in to draw away from that... I don't want to be taken out of things to worry about rubbish like, "Oh noes! Will Danny fall to the Dark Side and become a Foot?!" or "Will Keno be able to put aside his pizza delivery career to help the Turtles?!?!"

None of which is possible as a PG film.

CJStyles 09-25-2009 10:40 PM

Are they still gungho about having this movie PG yet "violent"

Andrew NDB 09-25-2009 11:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CJStyles (Post 722677)
Are they still gungho about having this movie PG yet "violent"

No idea, or even if they're truly being gung-ho about it at all. The only evidence that is concerning to that end was at Diego, when the producer seemed to be very quick to defend PG (not PG-13) as, "Well... look at what the latest Harry Potter movie got away with, and that was only PG!"

And maybe that means nothing. But I got a very bad feeling from it.

Dragon Turtle 09-26-2009 01:25 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by CJStyles (Post 722672)
I know it's going to be an origin story. However, would you rather see a close to panel for panel adaptation of the first issue or a brand new story yet still having the revenge plot that everyone wants.

Steve Murphy actually wrote a very close adaption of the first comic, originally meant for the defunct 25th anniversary CGI TMNT project, but even then it was considered way too short.

ToTheNines 09-26-2009 10:03 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 722684)
"Well... look at what the latest Harry Potter movie got away with, and that was only PG!"

Terrible example. Had he said Star Wars episodes I and II, I would have been more hopeful.

Cowabunga Carl 09-26-2009 01:08 PM

I am really hoping for something close to the first few issues. I think the first half of the movie should be them dealing with the Shredder with the climax in the middle the death of the Shredder. Then the second half of the movie be the mousers and Baxter. The end would be them going home to find Splinter missing.

Andrew NDB 09-26-2009 07:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Cowabunga Carl (Post 722767)
I am really hoping for something close to the first few issues. I think the first half of the movie should be them dealing with the Shredder with the climax in the middle the death of the Shredder. Then the second half of the movie be the mousers and Baxter. The end would be them going home to find Splinter missing.

That'd make for an uneven, perhaps random movie without a concise three acts. How would they shift gears from the death of the Shredder at the halfway point of the film onto Baxter and his mousers in a way that would seem organic?

If they must include Baxter and the Mousers, it ought to be only for a short few scenes as a way to introduce April in the early or middle parts of the film. He's quickly stopped, apprehended, and the movie carries on with April and the Turtles and the main plot with Shredder.

Think, the Scarecrow from Batman Begins... only with even less screen time.

OK, maybe, for a tease, toward/at the end of the movie we could see him doing the Vol. 2 thing where he is transferring his brain into a robotic body... cut to end credits. Though I don't know if Baxter -- with or without his mousers -- can carry a TMNT film.

Aztec General 09-26-2009 11:01 PM

I'm all about the origin story but I would certainly want some new twists and additions to keep it all fresh. I would certainly use Vol. 1 issues 1, 2, 3, and the Raphael one shot to provide the overall tale. I would also be interested in a Rat King cameo, especially if Baxter and the Mousers are to be involved.

I like Andrew's Shredder/TMNT character foil idea. IMHO though a true TMNT origin story cannot be told without the focus being on the cyclical nature of "revenge". The Mirage comics, at their best, are all about the never ending cycle of revenge between the TMNT and the Foot. This NEEDS to be part of the story. As others have mentioned before, this just cannot be properly done with a "PG" rating.

The Stryker 09-26-2009 11:08 PM

It never f*cking ends with you people! Jesus.

Andrew NDB 09-26-2009 11:30 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aztec General (Post 722839)
I would also be interested in a Rat King cameo, especially if Baxter and the Mousers are to be involved.

I was thinking the same, as long as it's the non-hammy Mirage Rat King... who's actually more of an ally than a nemesis. Somewhere combining Baxter, mousers, the Rat King, and armies of rats lies a story... my only worry is that it could too easily descend into camp. Much too easily.

And nowhere between Rat King, rats, or Baxter could we get satisfactory fights with the TMNT going all out. Them splattering rats or breaking mousers would get real old real fast, and neither Baxter or Rat King are fighters.

Quote:

This NEEDS to be part of the story. As others have mentioned before, this just cannot be properly done with a "PG" rating.
Can't be done with a PG rating, period.

Dragon Turtle 09-26-2009 11:45 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 722824)

OK, maybe, for a tease, toward/at the end of the movie we could see him doing the Vol. 2 thing where he is transferring his brain into a robotic body... cut to end credits. Though I don't know if Baxter -- with or without his mousers -- can carry a TMNT film.


Baxter could carry a film about as well as the Shredder, since he's a marginally more developed character then Shredder, and being a genius, he could come up with more then just mousers, in the end it all depends on the writer.

I still think an amalgam of the first three Mirage comics would make a good origin movie.

Andrew NDB 09-27-2009 02:21 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle (Post 722850)
Baxter could carry a film about as well as the Shredder

As long as we resign ourselves to not seeing much of the "ninja action" we haven't really gotten to see yet from the comics.

Aztec General 09-27-2009 12:01 PM

I envision the movie as a series of parallel storylines.

1) The rise the TMNT is contrasted by the rise of the Foot.
2) The TMNT's moral use of martial arts vs. the Foot's immoral use.
3) Baxter's attempt to eliminate the city's rat problem is contrasted by Rat King's desire to overrun the city with rats; of course with waking, talking rat Splinter caught in the middle.
4) April and Donatello's moral use of technology vs. Baxter's use for evil purposes.
5) Splinter as the caring father vs. Shredder as the uncaring father.
6) Casey as the troubled wildcard for good vs. Hun as the troubled wildcard for evil.
7) Revenge NEEDS to be the central theme of the movie. It is the central theme of the TMNT comics: Splinter/TMNT vs. Shredder/Foot, Baxter vs. April, Casey vs. Hun, Rat King vs. Baxter, etc. It can also lead to excellent sequel possibilities with Karai and Hun (should he survive the first film).
8 ) Finally the film should be about adolescents becoming adults. Isn't that an important message for a film about teenage warriors? Hopefully this will end the trend of the perennial child-like Mikey we've been getting in recent TMNT lore.

Thus the characters that I'd use in this film would be:
1) Leonardo
2) Donatello
3) Raphael
4) Michelangelo
5) Splinter
6) Casey Jones
7) April O'Neil
8 ) Shredder (w/Foot Ninja)
9) Hun
10) Baxter Stockman (w/Mousers)
11) Rat King

That's a lot of characters but it is completely doable if they allow the film to go to the 2 hour mark (maybe 2:15?); which unfortunately most TMNT films are not allowed to do for whatever reason. Besides it's really only adding 2 characters to the original 90 minute 1990 TMNT film (Tatsu played the same role as Hun really): Baxter Stockman & Rat King. I feel that if they are serious this time around about rebooting TMNT (which I don't feel they were with the 2K7 film) then they need to start fresh with a serious attempt at a comic book film, ala recent comic reboots/orign films: Batman Begins & Iron Man.

The characters and storylines above would provide a successful reboot if the producers allow a PG-13, action packed, just over 2 hour film, yet still fun filled, martial arts revenge film. It can be done, should they choose to do it.

Again it's all about how serious they plan on taking this film, and more importantly this franchise...

In fact, later on I'll write up a basic treatment of how I envision all of these characters and stories fitting together.

Warhorse 09-27-2009 12:16 PM

^Good comparison there between the good vs evil of the TMNT world. And that's not too many characters. X-Men, LOTR and HP all balanced out a great number of characters, there is no reason why TMNT can't.

Dragon Turtle 09-27-2009 10:13 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew NDB (Post 722863)
As long as we resign ourselves to not seeing much of the "ninja action" we haven't really gotten to see yet from the comics.

Perhaps not a lot ninja vs ninja action, but a wealthy Baxter Stockman is most likely going to have his own security force with a few particularly well trained individuals on his payroll, perhaps even the Foot themselves.

odupianist 09-28-2009 08:50 AM

If it has the "Rat King" in it, I don't want the OT version/Archie comics version of him. I want Mirage, thought provoking, mysterious "Rat King"

Aztec General 09-28-2009 10:28 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by odupianist (Post 723048)
If it has the "Rat King" in it, I don't want the OT version/Archie comics version of him. I want Mirage, thought provoking, mysterious "Rat King"

Naturally. I see the Rat King as a deranged version of The Riddler. I see him taunting, fighting, and potentially even helping the TMNT where necessary. He should not hold allegiance to anyone. I would have him as an extremely enigmatic and mysterious figure who appears almost randomly to taunt the protagonists.

Sort of like a crazy homeless guy, who actually has a master plan.

Andrew NDB 09-28-2009 12:33 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Dragon Turtle (Post 723002)
Perhaps not a lot ninja vs ninja action, but a wealthy Baxter Stockman is most likely going to have his own security force with a few particularly well trained individuals on his payroll, perhaps even the Foot themselves.

True, true. And I'm imaging a climax where, perhaps after suffering a loss from the Turtles, a frustrated Baxter puts his brain inside the robot body for the final battle with the TMNT at the end of the film. Think, Cain in RoboCop 2. But cooller.

This would need to be a sequel, though. The first movie needs to be down-to-Earth.

TMNTD 09-29-2009 12:05 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Aztec General (Post 722920)
I envision the movie as a series of parallel storylines.

1) The rise the TMNT is contrasted by the rise of the Foot.
2) The TMNT's moral use of martial arts vs. the Foot's immoral use.
3) Baxter's attempt to eliminate the city's rat problem is contrasted by Rat King's desire to overrun the city with rats; of course with waking, talking rat Splinter caught in the middle.
4) April and Donatello's moral use of technology vs. Baxter's use for evil purposes.
5) Splinter as the caring father vs. Shredder as the uncaring father.
6) Casey as the troubled wildcard for good vs. Hun as the troubled wildcard for evil.
7) Revenge NEEDS to be the central theme of the movie. It is the central theme of the TMNT comics: Splinter/TMNT vs. Shredder/Foot, Baxter vs. April, Casey vs. Hun, Rat King vs. Baxter, etc. It can also lead to excellent sequel possibilities with Karai and Hun (should he survive the first film).
8 ) Finally the film should be about adolescents becoming adults. Isn't that an important message for a film about teenage warriors? Hopefully this will end the trend of the perennial child-like Mikey we've been getting in recent TMNT lore.

Thus the characters that I'd use in this film would be:
1) Leonardo
2) Donatello
3) Raphael
4) Michelangelo
5) Splinter
6) Casey Jones
7) April O'Neil
8 ) Shredder (w/Foot Ninja)
9) Hun
10) Baxter Stockman (w/Mousers)
11) Rat King

That's a lot of characters but it is completely doable if they allow the film to go to the 2 hour mark (maybe 2:15?); which unfortunately most TMNT films are not allowed to do for whatever reason. Besides it's really only adding 2 characters to the original 90 minute 1990 TMNT film (Tatsu played the same role as Hun really): Baxter Stockman & Rat King. I feel that if they are serious this time around about rebooting TMNT (which I don't feel they were with the 2K7 film) then they need to start fresh with a serious attempt at a comic book film, ala recent comic reboots/orign films: Batman Begins & Iron Man.

The characters and storylines above would provide a successful reboot if the producers allow a PG-13, action packed, just over 2 hour film, yet still fun filled, martial arts revenge film. It can be done, should they choose to do it.

Again it's all about how serious they plan on taking this film, and more importantly this franchise...

In fact, later on I'll write up a basic treatment of how I envision all of these characters and stories fitting together.

I gotta give you props Aztec for posting this here and on SHH. Very well thought out. You should write the script because this is THE turtle movie that we've been waiting for.


All times are GMT -6. The time now is 01:43 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.7
Copyright ©2000 - 2026, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.